Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Sure. And then they can release them in exchange for Palestinians they kidnap.

It's only fair.

Fairness, Puppycow, is something that the Palestinians should dread. Because fairness means symmetry, it does not mean moral behavior, and it does not mean mercy.

The word "symmetry", I don't think it means what you think it means.
The situation is clearly asymmetrical here.

As far as that article you linked to goes, do you agree with all that? It's all over the place, but the common theme seems to be that "the White Man" (his words) is put upon by tyrannical liberals who want him to behave more civilized than his enemies. The same liberals don't care at all about the crimes committed by non-whites (in his version of reality). It's so unfair. Only "the White Man" and Jews get criticized for anything, and the others get a free pass.

I don't think it's true. Obama (and many others) condemned the murder of the three Jewish teenagers just as he condemned the murder of the Palestinian teen. I don't think he criticized the Israeli response either (the official one, not the unsanctioned revenge killing). So I'm just not seeing reality through the same lenses. Taken as a whole, it smacks of racial resentment, but not reality:

One of the former prerogatives of the liberal press was its ability to frame the narrative. In the past they could — and did — tell the public what to take seriously and who to laugh at. We were routinely told not to take the warning from Hamas that it will “open the gates of hell” seriously. Such threats — like the vow of ISIS to expand the Caliphate to include parts of Europe, or vows to behead infidels — were dismissed out of hand as either the posturing of simpletons or the justifiable wrath of the Poor and Downtrodden.

What was taken seriously in every case, however, was any sign of lawlessness by the White Man, including the Jews.

Who told the public "not to take the warning from Hamas that it will “open the gates of hell” seriously"? Who dismissed "the vow of ISIS to expand the Caliphate to include parts of Europe, or vows to behead infidels" as "the posturing of simpletons or the justifiable wrath of the Poor and Downtrodden"? Can we have some examples (from the mainstream "liberal media")?

The trouble is the American public may have had enough of these media narratives. Claudia Rossett noted that when the three Israeli teenagers were kidnapped everyone called for Israeli restraint. Now the situation is reversed the same voices are demanding no stone be left underturned to find the malefactors. For a long time things have gone in one direction only.

Again, this is simply asserted, but what was the reality? I went and looked, and the statements don't seem to be nearly as one-sided as they are portrayed to be here. Let's see this backed up by facts. I get the distinct sense that he means that we should not show any restraint. (Exactly how effective calls for restraint are anyway is another matter, but if words matter at all, it seems like the minimum responsible thing to do at times like these to call for restraint on all sides.) As far as the president's statement (about the Jewish teens) goes, it included a call for the perpetrators to be found and brought to justice.

Perhaps nowhere is this clearer than in the possibility that some Israeli settler might have killed a Palestinian teenager in revenge. Somebody snapped. It’s not that they didn’t know it was wrong, but possibly something worse: they didn’t care. This is suggestive of a breakdown of asymmetry. The game theoretic of the liberal establishment presumes asymmetric behavior; that for ever iteration the West will act in a civilized manner while their opponents will behave customarily. That’s the only way the game works for them. What they are not prepared for is the possibility of symmetry; that everyone will play by the same rules.

Shakespeare long ago warned that if you cut deep enough, every man looked the same. The problem with the left is that they assumed the contrary: that the White Man would always be different. Political correctness is based on this split level value system; it is ironically founded on the bedrock of racism.

Again with "the White Man". He just can't wait for the White Man to break his shackles of political correctness and stop acting "in a civilized manner", can he? A strange definition of "symmetry" if you ask me.




Anyway, enough about that. It appears that there has been a political development in Israel:

Israel: Avigdor Lieberman Dissolves Coalition Alliance with Benjamin Netanyahu's Likud over Gaza

Apparently he thinks Netanyahu's response hasn't been tough enough.
 
As a result of the Lebanon War of 2006, it was shown that the Israelis were not the great warriors so many people thought they were. You might also think that Israel learned a lesson or two, also - but they didn't. Israel still conducts the same 'ole policies of land-stealing and apartheid, and sooner or later it's going to get them in bigger trouble.

But now Israel has a force on thier Northern Border that is both Hostile and which they can not beat. Also, this force - this Hezbollah - is a proxy for Iran and as a Proxy, recieives a lot of effective arms. Also, Hezbollah is battle-tested and battle-hardened to a degree that is well beyond Israel's forces.

So far, Israel's good fortune is that Hezbollah is an effective Defensive Force but not an Offensive One. But...sooner or later, Iran is going to supply Hezbollah with OFFENSIVE weapons if this situation continues, and Israel will be in some real trouble.

But Israel doesn't see this. I guess Israel thinks their almighty God is going to protect them while they keep whipping arse on Palestinian Kids and taking land. Sure.
 
As a result of the Lebanon War of 2006, it was shown that the Israelis were not the great warriors so many people thought they were. You might also think that Israel learned a lesson or two, also - but they didn't. Israel still conducts the same 'ole policies of land-stealing and apartheid, and sooner or later it's going to get them in bigger trouble.

But now Israel has a force on thier Northern Border that is both Hostile and which they can not beat. Also, this force - this Hezbollah - is a proxy for Iran and as a Proxy, recieives a lot of effective arms. Also, Hezbollah is battle-tested and battle-hardened to a degree that is well beyond Israel's forces.

So far, Israel's good fortune is that Hezbollah is an effective Defensive Force but not an Offensive One. But...sooner or later, Iran is going to supply Hezbollah with OFFENSIVE weapons if this situation continues, and Israel will be in some real trouble.

But Israel doesn't see this. I guess Israel thinks their almighty God is going to protect them while they keep whipping arse on Palestinian Kids and taking land. Sure.

Agreed.
I think the Israeli and the American are on a power-trip not different (much) from the Nazis that believed God was on their side when they were exterminating Ukranian people.
Even if the number of people they kill is much lower.
What they do not see is that history is moving on with them, and they are losing their grip much fast.

https://www.aamlive.com/images/blog/percentage-of-world-gdp.png?sfvrsn=2

In my opinion, the state of Israel, as it is now, does not have more than 10 years to be.

And if your fantasy of Hizbollah and Hamas "freeing" Palestine ever occurs, then rainbows and unicorns will sprout from the hills and the skies?

No, we all know that the next step will be a bitter civil war between the two in which massacres will be perpetrated on just about any group still living there.
 
And if your fantasy of Hizbollah and Hamas "freeing" Palestine ever occurs, then rainbows and unicorns will sprout from the hills and the skies?

No, we all know that the next step will be a bitter civil war between the two in which massacres will be perpetrated on just about any group still living there.

1. I don't have a "Fantasy" about this subject. That's you talking.

2. If it came to pass that Israel was utterly defeated, then the revenge killing by the victors would probably be horrific. Like I said. the situation would "...make Aushwitz look like a backyard BBQ".

As a result of all the hate and the growing power of Israel's enemies, you might think that Israel would earnestly pursue a path of peace. But...they haven't. Instead, they keep kicking the 'ole Hornets nest year-after-year-after-year.
 
As a result of the Lebanon War of 2006, it was shown that the Israelis were not the great warriors so many people thought they were. You might also think that Israel learned a lesson or two, also - but they didn't. Israel still conducts the same 'ole policies of land-stealing and apartheid, and sooner or later it's going to get them in bigger trouble.

Yea, those faggy little Jews can't really fight.

Just keep telling yourself that.
 
Agreed.
In my opinion, the state of Israel, as it is now, does not have more than 10 years to be.

Or maybe Zionist Israel's greatest days are ahead of them, and 10 years from now you and the rest of the "anti-Zionist" flotsam will be muttering to yourselves about how Satanic Israel is down to its last 10 years.
 
Yea, those faggy little Jews can't really fight.

Just keep telling yourself that.

Well...Israel didn't acquit itself too well during the last war. They didn't even dent Hezbollah's strength. But...the Israelis did destroy a lot of property and leave a lot of people homeless, and this will probably make Hezbollah think twice before attacking Israel again. On the otherhand, Hezbollah showed that it could bring Northern Israel to a panic at will. Also, Hezbollah showed that it could neutralize Israel's Helicopter Gunships and Tanks.

Next...Hezbollah needs a Surface-to-Air Missile System - and some Cruise Missiles. The Israelis better start preparing for some bloody, in-your-face warfare if they want to neutralize Hezbollah.
 
In my opinion, the state of Israel, as it is now, does not have more than 10 years to be.

I think Israel will be around for a bit longer than 10 years, but I don't see a bright future for them if they continue their current path.

Israel has a great opportunity to start making peace...so why not?

I am under no illusion that a peace with the Palestinians would be perfect and without some strife, but why not try to reduce the overwhelming hatred if you have the opportunity to try? As far as the Palestinians are concerned, I don't expect much from them at this moment...they seem to have almost lost their minds - they have let their anger get the best of their judgement.
 
Well...Israel didn't acquit itself too well during the last war. They didn't even dent Hezbollah's strength. But...the Israelis did destroy a lot of property and leave a lot of people homeless, and this will probably make Hezbollah think twice before attacking Israel again. On the otherhand, Hezbollah showed that it could bring Northern Israel to a panic at will. Also, Hezbollah showed that it could neutralize Israel's Helicopter Gunships and Tanks.

Next...Hezbollah needs a Surface-to-Air Missile System - and some Cruise Missiles. The Israelis better start preparing for some bloody, in-your-face warfare if they want to neutralize Hezbollah.

Overwhelming success has degraded IDF fighting efficiency over the years, no question about that. That's to be expected. And Israeli command hasn't fully adjusted to fighting non uniformed guerrilla cells who's strategy is based on using civilian populations as cover- that's also true. But those unfortunate trends can be reversed very quickly...given the right circumstances.

You (and the like) aren't the first to heap contempt and scorn on the Jewish fighting spirit. You won't be the last.
 
And if your fantasy of Hizbollah and Hamas "freeing" Palestine ever occurs, then rainbows and unicorns will sprout from the hills and the skies?

Where did you buy that crystal ball from?

I think Israel will be around for a bit longer than 10 years, but I don't see a bright future for them if they continue their current path.
Gaddafi seemed invincible just a few months before his death.
In politics, such dramatic changes happen unexpectedly.

Overwhelming success has degraded IDF fighting efficiency over the years, no question about that.

Ahem..
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2006_Lebanon_War

I would like to see the IDF fighting against some hundreds of thousands of well armed Palestinains..
 
Last edited:
The word "symmetry", I don't think it means what you think it means.
The situation is clearly asymmetrical here.

I know exactly what it means. And yes, the situation is asymmetrical. But it may become symmetric (in a specific sense made clear in that link), and that is precisely the danger.

As far as that article you linked to goes, do you agree with all that? It's all over the place, but the common theme seems to be that "the White Man" (his words) is put upon by tyrannical liberals who want him to behave more civilized than his enemies. The same liberals don't care at all about the crimes committed by non-whites (in his version of reality). It's so unfair. Only "the White Man" and Jews get criticized for anything, and the others get a free pass.

Again, fairness is beside the point. The fact that we act more morally than our enemies may be a good thing, but it is also a luxury. And the thing about luxuries is that people discard them when it becomes difficult to afford them. The problem is not that liberals want us to act morally, the problem is that they don't seem to understand the conditions under which we can afford to do so, and that they are in many ways undermining those very conditions.
 
Again, fairness is beside the point. The fact that we act more morally than our enemies may be a good thing, but it is also a luxury.

Ahem..
I can foresee that sooner than later the Palestinian will start to act as morally as the Jews are doing now.
The guns will be reversed.
Operation Cast Lead 3 against Jews in Tel Aviv, 1000+ people killed.
Children as well.
Blockade against Jews people unable to buy basic stuff for self sufficiency.
Stopping posts for Jew people forced to stop by in order to move.
Assassinations at random of Jews youth.

Be careful what you wish for..
 
Last edited:
I have my doubts. The Jewish people have a habit of achieving outrageous success in the face of the scorn of idiots.

Definition of "success" may be debatable, but I would not qualify what happened in Germany between 1943 and 1945 as a success for the Jewish people :sdl: :sdl: :sdl: :sdl: :sdl:
 
Last edited:
Agreed.
I think the Israeli and the American are on a power-trip not different (much) from the Nazis that believed God was on their side when they were exterminating Ukranian people.
Even if the number of people they kill is much lower.
What they do not see is that history is moving on with them, and they are losing their grip much fast.

https://www.aamlive.com/images/blog/percentage-of-world-gdp.png?sfvrsn=2

In my opinion, the state of Israel, as it is now, does not have more than 10 years to be.

Fascinating graph. Funny thing, though: the US share of global GDP is staying pretty flat. It's western Europe that's in sharp decline. And how's the middle east doing in terms of economic growth? Oh, that's right: it's crap. Oil is almost the only thing the region exports. Well, except for Israel. They've got all sorts of fascinating high-tech industries going on there. But the rest of the middle east isn't producing jack ****.

Your fantasy of Israeli extermination (funny how often this fantasy is justified by calling them Nazis) isn't going to happen.
 
The Israelis better start preparing for some bloody, in-your-face warfare if they want to neutralize Hezbollah.

Israel found it tricky because it sent in troops and used target strikes in order to minimize civilian casualties. If they had fought a la Assad, they would have just leveled the place.

Hezbollah (and Hamas et al) are walking a fine line. They are attempting to be as much of a pain to Israel as possible, thinking (or at least claiming) that they will bring an end to Israel... but if they ever do become an existential threat to Israel then the gloves are likely to come off and Israel will probably go to total war (see WW2 area bombing and WMD's to see how that turns out). That Israel hasn't done this and has behaved more magnanimously towards the Palestinians than any neighboring government has done to fractious elements of their own populations, despite decades of terrorism is to Israel's credit. It does not mean that this forbearance is guaranteed to go on forever.
 
Hezbollah (and Hamas et al) are walking a fine line. They are attempting to be as much of a pain to Israel as possible, thinking (or at least claiming) that they will bring an end to Israel... but if they ever do become an existential threat to Israel then the gloves are likely to come off and Israel will probably go to total war (see WW2 area bombing and WMD's to see how that turns out). That Israel hasn't done this and has behaved more magnanimously towards the Palestinians than any neighboring government has done to fractious elements of their own populations, despite decades of terrorism is to Israel's credit. It does not mean that this forbearance is guaranteed to go on forever.

It is Israel waling the fine line.
They have 1 billions of Muslims around them who have nukes (Pakistan) or nuke capability (Iran).
Their area bombing wont work against the West bank, a bombing there would be like bombing themselves.
Gaza is same thing, defences of Gaza can be overrun even by a slight well-armed militia.
Israeli Arab soldiers may also turn against Tel Aviv
The IDF is simply not prepared and will never be capable to handle guerrilla warfare against hundreds of thousands of Palestinian or Muslim soldiers.
So far, they have killed mostly children or people using drones, when they tried to fight in 2006 Hezbollah, they got soundly beaten.
And Hezbollah is nothing compared with the forces that Israel may have to deal with pretty soon.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom