Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Few things to be noted:
1) Hamas rockets are now reaching distances longer than ever
No action taken by Israel so far has been proven useful to stop Hamas
http://www.reuters.com/article/2014/07/09/us-palestinians-israel-idUSKBN0FC0JP20140709
Now Hamas needs more precise rockets

2) Iran is looking to expand their enrichment capability ever further
Nothing the US has done so far has proven useful to stop their enrichment capability
http://www.theguardian.com/world/20...richment-capacity-supreme-leader-ali-khamenei
On nukes and Iran, it is game, set and match for Iran

3) Iraq is moving away from the US and moving towards Iran
http://edition.cnn.com/2014/07/07/opinion/harvey-pregent-iraq-iran/

4) And let` s not forget Hezbollah
https://news.yahoo.com/israel-hezbollah-now-stronger-arab-army-161239663.html

I would be surprised if Israel is still there in year 2024.
 
Debating this story right now with my highly biased Jewish orthodox friend.

Here's what I wrote in response to her post showing me this article.
http://www.foxnews.com/politics/201...alestinian-teen-will-not-be-hailed-as-heroes/


I'm saying you are biased in that you are glossing over the fact that 6 Jewish men did this to a boy. SIX. Not one guy who went off the rails. And it seems to me that whenever something happens on EITHER side of this issue, both the Palestinians and the Jews circles the wagons and start the spin master going in the media instead of stopping to pause right there in the moment and ask "how did we become so myopic that the only thing we're worried about right now is the way it affects US"

The fact that the title of this article is "Will not Be Hailed as Heroes" is disgusting beyond belief. The idea that in any way shape or form a group of men who burned a teenage boy alive would be regarded as "heroes" and that the public needs to reminded not to regard them as "heroes" is mind boggling in its cruelty. Unfortunately the truth is there are many Jews out there who will consider these men heroes. Just as there are many Palestinians who regard each and every suicide bombing as a heroic act.

Both sides have got to stop and to look at what they have allowed themselves to denigrate into in their reactions to the atrocities in this region. It's time to stop making it about sides and make it about the common human integrity of peace and respecting life.
 
Last edited:
Debating this story right now with my highly biased Jewish orthodox friend.

Here's what I wrote in response to her post showing me this article.
http://www.foxnews.com/politics/201...alestinian-teen-will-not-be-hailed-as-heroes/


I'm saying you are biased in that you are glossing over the fact that 6 Jewish men did this to a boy. SIX. Not one guy who went off the rails. And it seems to me that whenever something happens on EITHER side of this issue, both the Palestinians and the Jews circles the wagons and start the spin master going in the media instead of stopping to pause right there in the moment and ask "how did we become so myopic that the only thing we're worried about right now is the way it affects US"

The fact that the title of this article is "Will not Be Hailed as Heroes" is disgusting beyond belief. The idea that in any way shape or form a group of men who burned a teenage boy alive would be regarded as "heroes" and that the public needs to reminded not to regard them as "heroes" is mind boggling in its cruelty. Unfortunately the truth is there are many Jews out there who will consider these men heroes. Just as there are many Palestinians who regard each and every suicide bombing as a heroic act.

Both sides have got to stop and to look at what they have allowed themselves to denigrate into in their reactions to the atrocities in this region. It's time to stop making it about sides and make it about the

The relevance is that Palestinians have a track record of celebrating such killers as heroes while Israel doesn't. Which is important information.
 
That's a ******** reply. Jews celebrate just as much, only not as publicly. Arabs may dance in the street while Jews supplicate in gratitude before their god.
 
Both sides have got to stop and to look at what they have allowed themselves to denigrate into in their reactions to the atrocities in this region. It's time to stop making it about sides and make it about the common human integrity of peace and respecting life.

It would be great if that happened. But it won't. You can't get there from here. You cannot force people to respect life.
 
That's a ******** reply. Jews celebrate just as much, only not as publicly. Arabs may dance in the street while Jews supplicate in gratitude before their god.

You have no evidence of that. I thought from your previous post that you were merely a starry-eyed "let's all get along" naif, but you're not. You're looking for excuses to demonize the Jews.
 
Nope, I'm saying that the reaction to this has been the typical circiling of the wagons. (I guess you didn't read my previous post where I nailed the Palestinians for doing the same thing)

The reaction I'm seeing in the Jewish community is one of super defense mode and rationalizing it and moving it away from the atrocity to focus on how it's being "twisted to demonize the Jews"

How about you treat everyone the same and when one person does a horrific act you call it what it is instead of asking which side they were on first?
 
Definition of "success" may be debatable, but I would not qualify what happened in Germany between 1943 and 1945 as a success for the Jewish people :sdl: :sdl: :sdl: :sdl: :sdl:

LOL you do exactly what you where whining about in the OP. :rolleyes:
I guess you were only outraged because the disgusting posts were not against Israel...... very telling.
 
That's a ******** reply. Jews celebrate just as much, only not as publicly. Arabs may dance in the street while Jews supplicate in gratitude before their god.

got evidence for this claim?
 
Please re-read waht we were talking about

After taking a look back out of mild curiousity, you seem to 1) not actually have much of an argument of any kind in the first place, 2) not be paying any attention to the larger picture, and 3) not be paying attention to what you're actually presenting, given your responses. But then, any credibility you may have had on the topic was badly damaged when you started accusing others of needing glasses when they observed something true about what you had actually presented and continued on by presenting something significantly different.

I am curious, though. What part of the World's GDP continuing to rise while the USA has had a significant recession in recent years would make the USA's lower percentage of world GDP a surprise? What about it demonstrates that "What they do not see is that history is moving on with them, and they are losing their grip much fast?" What about it justifies basically calling the Israeli people and American people, as a whole, "Nazis?"
 
Last edited:
Few things to be noted:
1) Hamas rockets are now reaching distances longer than ever
No action taken by Israel so far has been proven useful to stop Hamas

That's because the IDF is taking a precise approach to neutralizing active rocket sites and killing individual commanders and their retinue when they poke their heads out. You're right though - this does nothing for the long term solution to Hamas. Perhaps the IDF should take a page or two from Russia's playbook on dealing with insurgents in urban areas. That would really get your engines revved up, I'm sure.

The rest of your post is just cheerleading for a war against Israel.
 
Nope, I'm saying that the reaction to this has been the typical circiling of the wagons. (I guess you didn't read my previous post where I nailed the Palestinians for doing the same thing)

Palestinians don't simply "circle the wagons". They celebrate. Your claim that the Jews are celebrating is a baseless accusation. It's just a milder version of the blood libel.

The reaction I'm seeing in the Jewish community is one of super defense mode

Gee, I wonder why.

How about you treat everyone the same and when one person does a horrific act you call it what it is instead of asking which side they were on first?

But we're not talking about how the perpetrators are being treated (they will go to jail for a long time, and that is fitting and proper), we're talking about how the societies are being treated. And they shouldn't be treated the same, because they're not acting the same.
 
That's a ******** reply. Jews celebrate just as much, only not as publicly. Arabs may dance in the street while Jews supplicate in gratitude before their god.

You have no idea what your talking about. None.

Especially about the parts you don't actually just make up.
 
The reaction I'm seeing in the Jewish community is one of super defense mode and rationalizing it and moving it away from the atrocity to focus on how it's being "twisted to demonize the Jews"

How about you treat everyone the same and when one person does a horrific act you call it what it is instead of asking which side they were on first?

Let's see all of your JREF posts right after the three Israeli kids were executed, calling it what it is.

And this "super defensive" reaction you're seeing; is that among all of your Jewish/Israeli "friends"?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom