Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
It might just be that he found it the most convenient to take a single case and use it as an example, but if not, I would love to hear his reasoning.

I have to say I've seen nothing to date that would suggest the kidnap and murder of the three teens was a political act; if it happened anywhere else in the world the police would be looking for a serial killer. it could even be that a certain type of sick mind locked on to 'politics' as an excuse for carrying out their warped desires.
"Anywhere else in the world" I think is a massive overstatement. Israel and Palestine are a conflict zone where terrorist acts and violence in general is commonplace. In such areas, I suppose investigators have a lower treshold for suspecting political motives than they do in other areas, and they probably learn to spot signs and patterns, too.

Going out on a limb, I suppose that applies to all parts of the world: imagine how big a difference it'd probably make to the cops if the killings happened in a city ridden with gang-related violence and killings, or in a neighbourhood with lots of immigrants and a fair share of violent racists, or in a peaceful, upper middle class neighbourhood with next to no crime or violence at all.
 
I am just wondering why, in the so-called developed world, there are still people showing such a callous-disrespect for a teen murdered in such a horrible way..

You weren't aware that the comments section on practically all popular websites all over the world, contain evil, obscene material? That comment sections in general are notorious for ugly, cruel content? Really? I thought everyone already knew that.
 
The comments express:
- a recognition that Hamas is far worse, barbaric and supremacist than the Israelis
- That Palestinian factions celebrate murderers of families & children
- That the Palestinians have a long history of faking deaths in order to score PR points (the Jenin 'massacre", the Muhammad al-Durrah incident etc


In such circumstances, it's only natural (and sensible) for comments to reflect poorly and/or skeptically on the Palestinian narrative.
 
"Anywhere else in the world" I think is a massive overstatement. Israel and Palestine are a conflict zone where terrorist acts and violence in general is commonplace. In such areas, I suppose investigators have a lower treshold for suspecting political motives than they do in other areas, and they probably learn to spot signs and patterns, too.

This is no doubt true, but as the writer of the piece I quoted above says:

But at 4am on the same night two unknown persons came to the Shuafat Neighborhood in East Jerusalem and found there a 16 year old boy named Mohammed Abu Khdeir, who was studying to become an electrician and who was on his way to the neighborhood mosque because of Ramadan. These unknowns dragged the boy into a car and later on that morning his burnt body was found in a West Jerusalem park.

The authorities of the State of Israel, which were so clear and decisive about the responsibility of Hamas in the case of the previous kidnapping and murder showed themselves very hesitant in this case. Was it the act of people who were influenced by those very strong calls for revenge, looking for a Palestinian 16 year old boy? That certainly sounds plausible. But from the police came an alternative – i.e. that Mohammed Abu Khdeir was maybe a homosexual murdered by Palestinians and that just by coincidence this happened exactly on the night of the mob attacks on the streets of Jerusalem.

It appears that the Israeli police now do suspect a political motive for the murder, although (or perhaps, and therefore) Shin Bet have put a gag order on many of the details:

The Israel Police have arrested six suspects over the abduction and murder of a Palestinian teen and are leaning toward suspicion that the attack was carried out with nationalist motives, it was revealed on Sunday after a gag order was partially lifted.

Police increasingly believe that murder of 16-year-old Mohammed Abu Khdeir, whose body was found in the Jerusalem Forest on Wednesday, was carried out by Jewish extremists in revenge over the recent kidnap and murder of three Israeli teenagers in the West Bank, the Associated Press reported quoting an official.

Police are also investigating suspicions that the six were also linked to the attempted kidnapping of 9-year-old Mussa Zalum, less than a day before Abu Khdeir was abducted and killed. Complaints lodged with police following that attempted kidnap were disregarded, it emerged on Sunday.

Also a video of the beating of Tariq Abu Khdeir appears to have surfaced, though he cannot be completely identified as his head is covered.
 
The comments express:
- a recognition that Hamas is far worse, barbaric and supremacist than the Israelis
- That Palestinian factions celebrate murderers of families & children
- That the Palestinians have a long history of faking deaths in order to score PR points (the Jenin 'massacre", the Muhammad al-Durrah incident etc


In such circumstances, it's only natural (and sensible) for comments to reflect poorly and/or skeptically on the Palestinian narrative.

No, your characterization of the comments is incorrect.

This:

"This will never end so long as there is a single follower of that POS pedophile still alive. Kill them all and let the rest of the civilize world live in peace!"

does not "reflect poorly and/or skeptically on the Palestinian narrative." or express any of the things you said they do above.

There is also no excuse for this murder, and anyone trying to gloss it with political comments like the ones quoted in the OP is an apologist for murder.
 
No, your characterization of the comments is incorrect.

So, one of the comments was way out of line. The majority that were quoted express the reasonable frustration of civilized folks with Palestinian behavior. They may or may not be turn out to be accurate regarding this particular incident... but the majority of the comments are a pretty good summary of the usual I/P situation.

It's sad that the Palestinians have been 'the boy who cried wolf' (Jenin, Al-durah etc) so many times that people no longer believe them when perhaps this time they may finally be telling the truth.
 
So, one of the comments was way out of line. The majority that were quoted express the reasonable frustration of civilized folks with Palestinian behavior. They may or may not be turn out to be accurate regarding this particular incident... but the majority of the comments are a pretty good summary of the usual I/P situation.

It's sad that the Palestinians have been 'the boy who cried wolf' (Jenin, Al-durah etc) so many times that people no longer believe them when perhaps this time they may finally be telling the truth.

I think that the majority of Israelis and Palestinians want to live in peace, and that whenever someone from either side is murdered the murder should be investigated impartially and not with the assumption the seriousness with which a murder is investigated relies on a person's ethnicity. Your comments suggest you think otherwise and that it is perfectly fair to react to a murder such as this one by heaping ridicule and suspicion upon the victim's ethnic group.

Personally, I prefer this reaction:

Contact was established Sunday between the Israeli and Palestinian bereaved families formed on Sunday, during a condolence visit by Jerusalem Mayor Nir Barkat at the Nof Ayalon home of Naftali Fraenkel, one of the three Israeli teens kidnaped and murdered in the West Bank.

During the visit, Barkat called Hussein Abu Khdeir, the father of Mohammed Abu Khdeir, a 16-year-old Palestinian whose body was found in the Jerusalem Forest last week. Barkat offered his condolences, and at the end of the call asked Hussein Abu Khdeir and Yishai Fraenkel, Naftali Fraenkel’s uncle, if they wish to speak. Fraenkel Expressed his condolence, and added that he was horrified to learn that Khdeir’s murderers were Jews.

The two agreed that the families of the three Jewish victims would soon pay a condolences visit to Abu Khdeir’s family over the death of their son.

To this reaction:

This war has been going on for a thousand years (west vs. muslim). It will not be resolved by "proportionate response". It can only be resolved by one side eliminating the other. That's reality, and I'm sick and tired of phony liberals' spouting "can't we all just get along" diplomacy.
 
Edit:
"The Muslim gay teen was burned alive by Palestinians in honor killing. But they want to blame Israel."
-> Got 47 likes

"Yes, I am suspecting it is a honour killing, maybe this boy friendship with Israelis and I think the Hamas wants to increase the conflict with Israelis."
-> Got 23 likes
This is what I have been hearing, too. Does it seem unlikely to you? Remember, Arabs are just as capable of such things as other ethnic groups, remember. Violence towards homosexuals is not exactly unheard of.

Too bad you gave that credence. Did it seem unlikely to you that Jewish extremists were behind it?
With arrest of six Jews in Arab teen’s killing, Israel confronts its own extremists

The arrests shocked those on both sides of the Israeli-Palestinian divide — Palestinians because many had assumed Israel would never act against its own, and Israelis because there had been widespread doubt that Jews could have carried out such a heinous crime.
 
There is a long and rather disturbing article here from a left-wing Israeli, whose article provides some starting points on researching this:

I agree that the article is disturbing and I also admit I do not have the time to read it all with attention, but I could not find any reference to the five teens killed

You weren't aware that the comments section on practically all popular websites all over the world, contain evil, obscene material? That comment sections in general are notorious for ugly, cruel content? Really? I thought everyone already knew that.

I agree on this, but I am still massively surprised by the number of callous and insensitive comments that have been written on such a brutal murder.
Even here, in this very thread.
Take this one, for example.
Does not it show to you a complete lack of humanity?

The comments express:
- a recognition that Hamas is far worse, barbaric and supremacist than the Israelis
- That Palestinian factions celebrate murderers of families & children
- That the Palestinians have a long history of faking deaths in order to score PR points (the Jenin 'massacre", the Muhammad al-Durrah incident etc


In such circumstances, it's only natural (and sensible) for comments to reflect poorly and/or skeptically on the Palestinian narrative.

Now, what is the point *at all* to even start discussing the barbaric character of Hamas when a Palestinian teen was killed, very likely in a crime of revenge?
 
Too bad you gave that credence. Did it seem unlikely to you that Jewish extremists were behind it?
With arrest of six Jews in Arab teen’s killing, Israel confronts its own extremists

As to the quote (that does not come up when post is quoted)that the people didn't want to believe Jews could commit such a terrible crime, Bugsy Siegel. Jews are people, some people commit terrible crimes so, quite logically, some Jews will commit terrible crimes. The giant majority won't, but, of course, the giant majority of any group is unlikely to commit terrible crimes. Now, if each group would just remove asap it's members who do.................*






*or at least not protect/hide/defend those members.
 
I agree on this, but I am still massively surprised by the number of callous and insensitive comments that have been written on such a brutal murder.

Since high numbers of callous and insensitive comments appear in just about every comment section I have ever read, I'm surprised you're massively surprised. I'm massively disgusted and outraged by some of those comments, but not surprised in the least.
 
I think you can and definitely should separate the two things.
I am not 100% sure Hamas was behind the abduction and kidnapping of the teens, but even if, I do not think such revenge killing, assuming it had been done by some Israeli, could and should be discounted or whitewashed or ignored or .. whatever Hamas has done .
But this is exactly waht many people from the West are doing

I agree that two wrongs don't make a right. But the situation has long been asymmetric. Israel is held to a higher standard than the Palestinians. The problem isn't simply that this is unfair (though it is unfair). Of more practical significance is the fact that it's not stable. Asymmetries in conflicts frequently don't last.

Perhaps nowhere is this clearer than in the possibility that some Israeli settler might have killed a Palestinian teenager in revenge. Somebody snapped. It’s not that they didn’t know it was wrong, but possibly something worse: they didn’t care. This is suggestive of a breakdown of asymmetry. The game theoretic of the liberal establishment presumes asymmetric behavior; that for ever iteration the West will act in a civilized manner while their opponents will behave customarily. That’s the only way the game works for them. What they are not prepared for is the possibility of symmetry; that everyone will play by the same rules.
...
The people will accept the King’s fictions only while the King governs well. For more than ten years the West has worried what might happen in Muslim scientists privately decided to built a WMD to attack the Jews. What they really should get worked up about is what happens if Jewish scientists decide to do the same thing. Civilization depends on the King to provide justice in lieu of mob action. When the King goofs off or neglects to secure the realm, then at some point it’s every man for himself. And then there’ll be nothing to laugh at any more.

All the major players in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict have been operating under the assumption that Israelis will act with restraint, even if the Palestinians don't. That assumption may eventually break down. The Palestinians should dread that possibility, but they do not act as if they do. If that day comes, moral condemnation will mean nothing anymore.
 
I am just wondering why, in the so-called developed world, there are still people showing such a callous-disrespect for a teen murdered in such a horrible way..

Because it's the internet. Callous-disrespect isn't just an exception to the rule, it's POLICY
 
Will Israel treat Jewish Terrorists the same way they treat Arab terrorists, by destroying their homes?

http://www.slate.com/articles/news_...nment_destroyed_the_homes_of_palestinian.html

The government of Israel says it will treat the July 2 abduction and murder of Muhammad Abu Khdeir, a Palestinian boy, the same way it treats terrorism against Jews. The killers “will face the full weight of the law,” Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu pledged Sunday. “We do not differentiate between the terrorists.”

To this, Muhammad’s parents have issued a simple challenge: Prove it. Demolish the homes of the Jews who murdered him.

Demolition played a central role in the drama leading up to Khdeir’s death. According to Israeli officials, two West Bank Arabs, Marwan Qawasmeh and Amer Abu Aisha, kidnapped and murdered three Jewish boys on June 12. Israeli authorities haven’t found Qawasmen or Aisha, much less tried them. Nevertheless, on June 30, Israeli soldiers destroyed the suspects’ homes in Hebron. They broke windows, wrecked furniture, smashed sinks and toilets, and trashed kids’ bedrooms. Then they used explosives to blow out the ceilings and walls.

Twenty people were living in Aisha’s house. At Qawasmeh’s house, all the men had been arrested, so the only people still there were women and children.

Why did Israel destroy the homes of these children? Officially, the rationale is to “disincentivize” future terrorism. Unofficially, it’s ramped-up retribution. Israeli courts have accepted the government’s authority to do it, on the grounds that anyone considering violence “should know that his criminal acts will not only hurt him, but are apt to cause great suffering to his family.”

So Israel should "cause great suffering" not only to the suspects, but to the suspects' families, right? It's only fair.
 
Last edited:
Will Israel treat Jewish Terrorists the same way they treat Arab terrorists, by destroying their homes?

Sure. And then they can release them in exchange for Palestinians they kidnap.

It's only fair.

Fairness, Puppycow, is something that the Palestinians should dread. Because fairness means symmetry, it does not mean moral behavior, and it does not mean mercy.
 
Sure. And then they can release them in exchange for Palestinians they kidnap.

It's only fair.

Fairness, Puppycow, is something that the Palestinians should dread. Because fairness means symmetry, it does not mean moral behavior, and it does not mean mercy.


Yep. About time too ...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom