Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
This does not sound correct to me. Surely the Security Council make decisions on deployment of UN peacekeeping forces, and a deployment throughout the West Bank and Gaza would be possible if voted for.

ETA: The problems that I have heard with this suggestion is that nobody wants to deploy their own troops to be part of a UN mission and that no countries are trusted enough by either side to be considered neutral.

Kinda. http://www.un.org/en/peacekeeping/operations/newoperation.shtml

Basically the hurdle of the general assembly not supporting action would make the security council not even consider voting on forming a new operation, but it is the security council's call to actually form a new operation.

Yeah, who would comprise that force is but one hurdle. At any rate, it's nowhere near in Israel's power to do so. It wouldn't be a bad deal for them if it happened, but they aren't in any position to make it happen.
 
I think I understand where the OP is coming from. You have to admit, this kind of public display of hatred and intolerance is fairly alarming. What values do these people have that will permit them to write such atrocious things? I think it's the same kind of mentality that creates an atmosphere where these kinds of crimes against humanity can take place.
Absolutely. Far as I've understood it, dehumanizing your enemy, or forming a generalized picture of all the people in a group as evil or dangerous, is the first step towards justifying all kinds of atrocities against them. That, and the "them or us" mentality.

It's sobering that many of the posters responding here seem completely unfazed by it, just hand wave it away. I admit it's easy to become callous to vicious Internet rants...only isn't that kind of the point?
We've become desensitized, I guess. People like this reply to threads about terrorist acts, sexual abuse, self-injury, racial issues, you name it. No matter the topic, there will be all kinds of... individuals spouting bigotry, uncalled-for jokes, vicious comments in general and all sorts of trolling in addition to that.
 
There is already a UN presence in Palestine, though not a military one. Below I'm posting a brief excerpt from a paper written by James Dobbins. Dobbins is an American diplomat whose most recent assignment was U.S. Envoy to Afghanistan. He has also served as U. S. Ambassador to the EU. The excerpt is from a paper Dobbins wrote in 2010 but sadly I don't think much has changed.

Many non-military elements of an international state-building mission are already in place. U.S., European and UN personnel have been working for some time to improve the quality of Palestinian governance. But these efforts are taking place in the midst of an ongoing military occupation run by an Israeli government that is unsure about whether it truly wants the emergence of a competent Palestinian state [and] in the midst of an ongoing conflict among the Palestinians themselves...The UN itself is not a plausible candidate to lead this particular mission, however. Most UN members regard the Israeli occupation of the West Bank and Gaza to be, at best, unduly prolonged, and, at worst, illegitimate. Israel, by the same token, does not regard the United Nations as sufficiently impartial to undertake a mission so central to Israeli security. Link
 
+++You can add mine. Have you taken a look at the cartoons and children's programs? Pls do not attempt to tell me Palestian TV is not horribly racist and driven by propaganda. See Google.

Sadly not very far from reality, if it is at all.

I recommend you read the HAMAS charter as well as HAMAS speeches and documents. Then you can look into the things Palestinian children are indeed taught in Palestinian schools. It is very, very frightening.

Funny how some critics of Israel can't even spell it. Probably just trolling.

It is very sad to see such kind of comments after the murder of a teen in such an horrible way.
Hamas did many things wrong, but some people can not avoid engaging in "tu quoque" arguments all the time.
As even American news sites admit, this was very probably one crime of revenge after the murder of the 3 teens, so people should definitely stop to keep shouting "Hamas bad"", "Hamas bad" at least this time.
They are behaving like that guy that, during the commemorations of the Holocaust, said that Jews had done some bad things after all.
They can not avoid promoting their political agenda not even in front of the death of a teen.
Despisable!
 
Last edited:
First and foremost, if you're more concerned that some people who may or may not be Americans are saying nasty things online than about who and why a young man was burned alive, then your priorities are way off.

First and foremost, do not assume what I think

Secondly, there is the 'assumed to be American' flaw.

Well, all three site quoted are US news sites.
I assume the majority of the people writing comments do not write from Laos.

Third, based off the posters other posts the reason he or she is more interested in what some maybe Americans might be posting seems to just be a continuation of the America hate on. That last one is probably the least valid, but it's understandable that some are going to read it in that light.

So criticizing some outrageous comments (well, lots of them) on US news sites means to be a US hater?
This is totally illogical

Also, the idea that the outrageous things posted in comment sections are sincere or representative is not a useful one. An unknown but certain non-zero number of those posts are there to get a reaction, not to advance a view.

Nossir!!
People over 18 should be responsible for what they write and they do not look "parodies" to me at the least.
They really seem to mean that.
Moreover, you should not assume the motives for other people to do things
 
On a more serious note, why have you immediately changed the subject of your own thread from the murder of a Palestinian teenager to a discussion of what morons on the Internet will write?

I never changed the subject of the thread.
As you can read from my mispelled title, the thread OP is focused on US people reaction on the news.

I wondered about this, too. Why people, Americans or otherwise, write offensive things online is more of a sociology topic than a political one. Perhaps the thread should be moved, and the title changed?

Trying to censor what you can` t fight? :rolleyes:

Why doesn't Israel allow UN Peacekeepers into Palestine to keep the peace until a stable and proper Palestinian Government can be established?

Please note that this thread is not about the issues behind the Palestine/Israel situation, but about some comments in US news sites about the crimes against a teen
 
I certainly hope the perpetrators of this murder are found and prosecuted, and likewise the murderers of the Israeli teens for whom this murder appears to be considered "revenge".

From what I have read, the family of the teen are very concerned about the way this is being investigated by police who seem to be more interested in finding an inter-Palestinian motive (i.e that maybe he was killed by other Palestinians for either being part of a gang or for being gay, etc...).

And now this murder is being retaliated against with rockets being fired "in revenge" which will then likely make it inevitable that Israel will have to attack the source of the rockets.
I don't hold my breath. The Israeli state itself is morally co-responsible for such revenge actions on the part of its population (assuming this is one), by the way they conducted the investigation of the abduction of the three settler boys. Really, have you ever heard before of a criminal investigation in which 350 suspects were detained and 5 people were killed?

Why doesn't Israel allow UN Peacekeepers into Palestine to keep the peace until a stable and proper Palestinian Government can be established?
Why would Israel have to consent? The UN can authorize military force if it wants to, and doesn't need the consent of the country it's directed against. See, e.g., Afghanistan. And see Chapter VII of the UN Charter.

This does not sound correct to me. Surely the Security Council make decisions on deployment of UN peacekeeping forces, and a deployment throughout the West Bank and Gaza would be possible if voted for.
You're forgetting East Jerusalem and Golan. ;)

Theoretically, the UN could authorize deployment of a force to implement 242 and drive out the illegal (that is: all) settlements on the West Bank, and, with advance notice, turn Jerusalem into a glass crater. Of course, that will never happen, not even the first. I agree with the statement of Dobbins as quoted by newyorkguy, with the slight change that the Israeli government is not just "not sure" but is simply "not willing". I wouldn't be surprised if Dobbins really meant the latter, but if he'd written that, he'd be unemployable.

ETA: The problems that I have heard with this suggestion is that nobody wants to deploy their own troops to be part of a UN mission and that no countries are trusted enough by either side to be considered neutral.
No, the problem is a UN veto.
 
What happened when they left Gaza? Oh, right, the Palestinians turned it into a terrorist nest from where they treated the Israelis to missiles and suicide bombers and use the civilians and city infrastructures as shields should they come under attack.

I agree the Israelis should withdraw to more sensible borders when the conflict ends, and that building settlements on lands you occupy during an armed conflict is unacceptable. At the same time, though, it's not nearly as simple as that. Retreating now wouldn't be taken as a gesture of goodwill, it would be considered appeasement. It would only serve to give Israel's enemies more strength, resources and manpower, and absolutely nothing good would come out of that.


As for the investigation, I want to hear Israel's side of the story, though yes, it does seem altogether too brutal to me, too.
 
What happened when they left Gaza? Oh, right, the Palestinians turned it into a terrorist nest from where they treated the Israelis to missiles and suicide bombers and use the civilians and city infrastructures as shields should they come under attack.

"Tu quoque" argument and off-topic as well
We are not talking about such things here.

You keep talking about Palestinian committing acts of "terrorism" while the thread is about the US readers reactions to the news of the Palestinian teen killed
 
Last edited:
First and foremost, do not assume what I think

I didn't assume that. You said, "But I was even more interested in reading some horrifying comments by people..." If you meant something different you can clarify or retract, but you can't hold it against me for trusting you meant what your said.

Well, all three site quoted are US news sites.
I assume the majority of the people writing comments do not write from Laos.

I would assume that most were from people in the US too, but I wouldn't assume that any given posts were American and use that to assign blame to Americans rather than the specific posters who said such horrible things. Those posts can be problematic all on their own, and the utility of discussing how their comments are 'American' is more limited than I'd expect from the Non-USA and General Politics board. There could be productive discussions on the tendency of the citizens of the US to dismiss problems abroad (isolationism) and to be bias towards Israel and away from Palestinians or non-Israeli Middle-Easteners in general. I don't think the OP is conducive to such discussion.

So criticizing some outrageous comments (well, lots of them) on US news sites means to be a US hater?
This is totally illogical

That would be fairly weak evidence for that conclusion. I didn't use that reasoning however.

Nossir!!
People over 18 should be responsible for what they write and they do not look "parodies" to me at the least.
They really seem to mean that.
Moreover, you should not assume the motives for other people to do things

You can try to deny the existence of trolls, but it's a well document and very real phenomenon. There are possible alternate explanations for some of the comments and valid reason to not give the comment sections of internet news sites as much weight as some other forms of discourse. If you have reasons to believe otherwise, by all means present them.

Please note that this thread is not about the issues behind the Palestine/Israel situation, but about some comments in US news sites about the crimes against a teen

Thanks for clearing that up, because I thought it might also be about the actual important event as well.
 
...You keep talking about Palestinian committing acts of "terrorism" while the thread is about the US readers reactions to the news of the Palestinian teen killed

The problem is you can't separate out the brutal kidnapping and murder of three Israeli teenagers -- believed carried out by Hamas forces in June -- from the story or the reaction. This wasn't an isolated incident and it seems to me to be dishonest to pretend it is. The killing of the Palestinian boy is almost certainly revenge for those killings.

World leaders have been telling both sides for literally decades, they have to find a way to break the cycle of revenge and violence. Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas had publicly condemned the kidnapping, and Palestinian security forces helped the Israeli army search for the teens. However, Hamas took no responsibility for the killings and warned Israel not to retaliate. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu fanned the flames by publicly speaking about revenge on "human animals." He launched massive retaliation -- a series of air attacks -- on so-called terrorist targets in Gaza. Now Netanyahu is saying the murder of the Palestinian boy was “abominable” but without taking responsibility or even acknowledging his role in creating the climate in which such an act was possible.
 
I didn't assume that. You said, "But I was even more interested in reading some horrifying comments by people..." If you meant something different you can clarify or retract, but you can't hold it against me for trusting you meant what your said.

You are right on this.
I chose a bad wording, I would rather say I was even more surprised to read some of the comments in US news sites

I would assume that most were from people in the US too, but I wouldn't assume that any given posts were American and use that to assign blame to Americans rather than the specific posters who said such horrible things. Those posts can be problematic all on their own, and the utility of discussing how their comments are 'American' is more limited than I'd expect from the Non-USA and General Politics board. There could be productive discussions on the tendency of the citizens of the US to dismiss problems abroad (isolationism) and to be bias towards Israel and away from Palestinians or non-Israeli Middle-Easteners in general. I don't think the OP is conducive to such discussion.

??
Very complicated comment that I can not fully understand.
I did not specifically assume that any given post was from US citizen, but I assumed that most of the horrible comments I read were coming from US citizens
Please let me know if you think this may not be the case

That would be fairly weak evidence for that conclusion. I didn't use that reasoning however

You wrote "seems to just be a continuation of the America hate on.". Hate from whom, exactly?

You can try to deny the existence of trolls, but it's a well document and very real phenomenon. There are possible alternate explanations for some of the comments and valid reason to not give the comment sections of internet news sites as much weight as some other forms of discourse. If you have reasons to believe otherwise, by all means present them.

Usually, trolls are a few people in a site, here it seems there were quite a lot of people convinced that, well, the burning of the teen was more or less to be biased, uh, on Hamas
I did not see as a trolling behaviour
 
The problem is you can't separate out the brutal kidnapping and murder of three Israeli teenagers -- believed carried out by Hamas forces in June -- from the story or the reaction. This wasn't an isolated incident and it seems to me to be dishonest to pretend it is. The killing of the Palestinian boy is almost certainly revenge for those killings.

I think you can and definitely should separate the two things.
I am not 100% sure Hamas was behind the abduction and kidnapping of the teens, but even if, I do not think such revenge killing, assuming it had been done by some Israeli, could and should be discounted or whitewashed or ignored or .. whatever Hamas has done .
But this is exactly waht many people from the West are doing
 
Last edited:
The problem is you can't separate out the brutal kidnapping and murder of three Israeli teenagers -- believed carried out by Hamas forces in June -- from the story or the reaction. This wasn't an isolated incident and it seems to me to be dishonest to pretend it is. The killing of the Palestinian boy is almost certainly revenge for those killings.

World leaders have been telling both sides for literally decades, they have to find a way to break the cycle of revenge and violence. Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas had publicly condemned the kidnapping, and Palestinian security forces helped the Israeli army search for the teens. However, Hamas took no responsibility for the killings and warned Israel not to retaliate. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu fanned the flames by publicly speaking about revenge on "human animals." He launched massive retaliation -- a series of air attacks -- on so-called terrorist targets in Gaza. Now Netanyahu is saying the murder of the Palestinian boy was “abominable” but without taking responsibility or even acknowledging his role in creating the climate in which such an act was possible.

I have to say I've seen nothing to date that would suggest the kidnap and murder of the three teens was a political act; if it happened anywhere else in the world the police would be looking for a serial killer. it could even be that a certain type of sick mind locked on to 'politics' as an excuse for carrying out their warped desires.
 
I have to say I've seen nothing to date that would suggest the kidnap and murder of the three teens was a political act...

That report certainly didn't originate on this message board. Israel has stated from the start they hold Hamas responsible.

Israel's ambassador to Australia Shmuel Ben-Shmuel says there is no doubt Hamas is responsible for the kidnapping and murder of three Israeli teenagers. He also says the air strikes underway in Gaza are part of an ongoing attempt to weaken terrorist organisation Hamas. Link


They have even identified suspects. Earlier today the Israeli Army made an arrest in the case.

A Palestinian man has been arrested in connection with the kidnap and murder of three Israeli teenagers. The man was arrested by the army in the West Bank city of Hebron on Sunday, and his family have identified him as Hossam Dufesh, the Associated Press reports, though the army would not elaborate on the arrest...Israeli leaders have blamed Hamas for the deaths, and vowed to exact a "very heavy price" from the group at the joint funeral held for the teenagers this week Link
 
But I was even more interested in reading some horrifying comments by people (I believe, mostly American citizens) who seem to justify and whitewash this horrible crime

I'm not exactly sure what your point is. There is plenty of vitriol on all sides of this issue, seeing it in comments sections of some news articles isn't at all surprising.

However, it appears you cherry-picked the comments you presented. Let me show you some I found:

Israel and Israel-Firsters’
PR methods:

1. We haven't heard reports of deaths, will check into it

2. The people were killed, but by a faulty Palestinian rocket/bomb

3. Ok we killed them, but they were terrorists

4. Ok they were civilians, but they were being used as human shields

5. Ok there were no fighters in the area, so it was our mistake. But we kill
civilians by accident, they do it on purpose

6. Ok we kill far more civilians than they do, but look at how terrible other
countries are!

7. Why are you still talking about Israel ? Are you some kind of
anti-semite?

8. Repeat from step 1 (Test this against the next interview you hear or
watch.)"

767 likes.

all the Zionazi trolls are trying to spread their propaganda again.

You will hear
- There is no Palestine (Doesn't matter if Palestinians are 90% population there for 1000 years)
- Palestinians are not ready for peace (Doesn't matter if its Israel which is not stopping land theft for their settlements )
- They will all talk about Hamas (Doesn't matter their own 3 prime ministers were terrorists and were responsible for death of thousands of innocents in terror attacks)
- They will all talk about Palestinian rockets (doesn't matter if Israelis have been killing thousands of people with Jets and cluster bombs)
- They will all talk about Palestinian hate (Doesn't matter if Israelis have been demanding "Death to Arabs" in their mass protests)

615 likes.

Israel is a major terrorist state, even aside from the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, where it's been the major state terrorist actor, and yes if you read UN reports which are pretty consistent, Israel is pretty much described as a terrorist state, take the goldstone report for example done by Richard Goldstone who is Jewish by the way, after investigating and reporting both Hamas and Israeli war crimes, he concluded that Israeli actions were designed to "terrorize", well if you terrorize you're a terrorist, he was of course referring to Israel's use of white phosphorous on schools and the Gaza hospital among others. The funny thing is that these guys desperately climb on a racist batch...well these muslims or something or islamic terror or something which is real, although much smaller in comparison to the terror that originates from Washington. But let's give them the benefit of the doubt and say that only Islamic terror constitutes as terror, then they're arguments are still fraudulent. The US for example has very close ties to Saudi Arabia which has the worst human rights record in the name of Islam, it doesn't allow women to drive, there are public beheadings and under their version of Sharia Law rape is pretty much legal and it's more or less rape capital on the planet, not to mention it's actually illegal to build any kind of religious building aside from Islamic mosques unlike most other Islamic countries. Now if you take a look at the US media, you almost never hear about that kind of 'Islamic fundamentalism', the US media didn't bother to report anything when Saudi secret police arrested a family for attempting to celebrate christmas two years ago, but that's of course because the Saudis more or less allow US control of their oil resources and for decades actually the US government has what it called a 'Special relation', which means US protection for oil and that's almost explicit out of the mouths of US presidents. Interestingly even Israel is strengthening its ties with Saudi Arabia, Haaretz, Israel's largest newspaper for example not so long ago featured an article saying the two would be "best frenemies forever", that's because Israel wants to use Saudi Arabia as a base to strike Iran, no nobody says Israel and the US works with the Islamic fundamentalist state, but of course that's what happening. Believe whatever you want, you guys are just hysterical and easily manipulated and to be honest given the American media I can't blame you.

498 likes.

The enemy of my enemy is my friend.

words to live by if you are the Saudi gov't or Israel.

Both of these countries are based on radical fundamentalist principles and will turn on the US in the blink of an eye and can not be considered friends or allies.

4 likes.

the only diffrence between the two is that the muslims have 3 muslims judges in the supreme court and the muslims own the media in the US, the muslims control the money in the US which means they control the decision makers(more than 50 of congress on both sides are muslims, and the muslims uses the american army whith the american boys to break all the countries arround them in the middle east without a drop of their arian race blood.(watch brother nathaniel in you-tube)

Zero likes.

Unlike your quotes, these are not cherry-picked, these were the first 5 comments I saw on the CNN link you provided.

And on the Al Jazeera link you provided:

Bismillah, Anti-Christ Cult is evil, firmly believe the way both the Palestinian youth was kidnapped and killed was done by the same Cult who kidnapped the three Jewish youth. --anti-Christ Cult are sacrificing children on both sides to incite violence

15 likes.

Allah SWT grant our Muslim brother Jannah, he died as a Shaheed. ameen

5 likes.

Someone, or some people, are trying to delete 46nd2's comment. Here it is again:

46nd2 • 13 hrs

zi0nism is a mental illness.

It has 526 Ʌ up votes
8 likes.

Why is everyone a shaheed for you guys?
Would be he a shaheed if he was gay?

Are all the people who died in Shyria Shahids?
Are all the Hamas, PLO, Syrian, Lebanese , Iraqi, Libyan dead people Shaheeds?

What is it with Muslims and portraying every Muslim who dies as Shaheeds?

1 like.

it's just been said all over, that this boy been honor killed by his family

2 likes.

Those are the first 5. I'll throw in this one as a bonus, it was #8 when I looked at them.

It has been said all over that 6 million is a figure made up by Zionist propagandists.

Nice, huh? It has 7 likes at this moment.

My point is I don't think your cherry-picked comments mean anything. They're like any other anonymous internet commentary. Some will be reprehensible, some reasonable. Some will be amazingly ignorant, others will be well informed.
 
\Really, have you ever heard before of a criminal investigation in which 350 suspects were detained and 5 people were killed?

Can somebody please elaborate on this?
I have Googled it and found nothing
 
I'm not exactly sure what your point is. There is plenty of vitriol on all sides of this issue, seeing it in comments sections of some news articles isn't at all surprising.

I double checked your first comment and it dated back to 2012.
Apparently.

I am talking about the recent news of a dead teen here.
And yes, two bads do not make one good. :)
 
Last edited:
Can somebody please elaborate on this?
I have Googled it and found nothing

There is a long and rather disturbing article here from a left-wing Israeli, whose article provides some starting points on researching this:

Under cover of the great outcry “Bring Back Our Sons” the army started a widespread detention campaign, which had no direct connection with the kidnapping. Operation Brother’s Keeper was mainly directed against “the civilian infrastructure” of Hamas – starting with the Speaker of the Palestinian Legislature down to grassroots activists of Hamas-linked educational institutions and charity associations. It was clear that the people detained knew nothing about the kidnapping, and nobody expected them to know. But, as was noted with satisfaction by knowledgeable commentators such as Alex Fishman of Yediot Achronot, the kidnapping created “a rare window of opportunity” in which the world kept silent about a massive detention campaign which under different circumstances would have caused a wave of international protest. Nor was there much ado about the killing of several Palestinians, among them boys of the same age as the Israelis which the army supposedly was searching for.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom