Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
So far, they have killed mostly children or people using drones, when they tried to fight in 2006 Hezbollah, they got soundly beaten.

I'm curious why you think Hezbollah sat on the side lines during Cast Lead? If their victory was so complete over Israel in 2006, why wouldn't Nasrallah force open a second front in the North while the IDF is bogged down in Gaza?

Also, where is Nasrallah these days?
 
Last edited:
I'm curious why you think Hezbollah sat on the side lines during Cast Lead? If their victory was so complete over Israel in 2006, why wouldn't Nasrallah force open a second front in the North while the IDF is bogged down in Gaza?

Also, where is Nasrallah these days?

Well, Cast Lead did not last long, right?
Nor it lead Hamas into remission, as you can see from the news
 
Last edited:
Hezbollah are kinda busy in syria at the moment and in any case have largely atchived their primiary objective of removing Israel from Lebanon. They don't really have much to gain through engagement with Israel.
 
You don't have an answer, in other words?

My answer is above. Read it.
Now, I have some questions for you:
1) why despite all the drawings of ACME made by Nethanyahu at the UN, Iran still has nuclear plants and enrichment capability?
2) Why despite Cast Lead Hamas is still there, and still able to bite with more missiles than ever?
3) Why Hezbollah is still there and strong?
4) How will Israel end up with the IS, which is much more anti-US than Iraq?
 
Hezbollah are kinda busy in syria at the moment

They weren't actively engaged in Sryia in 2008.

and in any case have largely atchived their primiary objective of removing Israel from Lebanon.

Have they changed their stance on The Necessity for the Destruction of Israel, then?

http://books.google.com/books?id=iVJR9UZnTVAC&pg=PA425&hl=en#v=onepage&q&f=false

They don't really have much to gain through engagement with Israel.

This is self-evident.
 
I see a couple of our resident "Anti Zionists" are openly cheering for Hezbollah to launch a massive attack on Israel, and only sad Hezbollah does not have the weapons to do it with.
ANd the idea that Israel is on it's last legs and the Israelis cannot fight is pure idiocy.
 

Note that these are, in fact, two different quantities, and the PPP share is, in fact, decreasing only slowly.

But who is it decreasing in share to, KumarS? Is it decreasing in share to the middle east?
No, it is not.


And hey, want to see something really neat? It's video of some Hamas commandos in action! Look at them go! (boom, that is)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HL9s9paqinU
 
Definition of "success" may be debatable, but I would not qualify what happened in Germany between 1943 and 1945 as a success for the Jewish people :sdl: :sdl: :sdl: :sdl: :sdl:

This post is terribly ironic given the fact that this thread started as a way for the KumarS to heap scorn on "Westerners" for being inhuman in internet posts.

It's ironic, and not a little bit disgusting. Well done, KumarS. You completely ruined the point you created the thread to make.
 
Last edited:
...I was even more interested in reading some horrifying comments by people (I believe, mostly American citizens) who seem to justify and whitewash this horrible crime...

"This will never end so long as there is a single follower of that POS pedophile still alive. Kill them all and let the rest of the civilize world live in peace!"-> Got 7 "likes"

...

I am just wondering why, in the so-called developed world, there are still people showing such a callous-disrespect for a teen murdered in such a horrible way..

Definition of "success" may be debatable, but I would not qualify what happened in Germany between 1943 and 1945 as a success for the Jewish people :sdl: :sdl: :sdl: :sdl: :sdl:

How about the definition of "hypocrisy"?
 
Last edited:
Hezbollah are kinda busy in syria at the moment and in any case have largely atchived their primiary objective of removing Israel from Lebanon. They don't really have much to gain through engagement with Israel.

The removal of cancerous Zion from the world isn't much to gain?
 
I think there a certain amount of wishful thinking about Hamas and Hezbollah going on here. Neither one has a "secular Palestinian State" as a final goal. They both want theocracies...only difference is one is Sunni,one is Shia.
 
What the Israelis don't really want is Peace - they want to steal whatever is left of the Palestinian's land. They just might succeed. Not all Jews want this, but a lot of them in Israel do - because they figure God gave then the land.

As a result, Israel must live like it's in a constant state of war, and if Israel slips up...if the Arabs by chance ever get the upper hand, then Israel will be demolished in the blink of an eye. On a long-enough timeline, I figure the Arabs will sooner or later get lucky...and Israel will get unlucky, and it will all be over for Israel. I figure the scene will be quite tragic if it happens - I figure it will make Auschwitz look like a backyard BBQ.

Of course, the Israelis will protest and feign innocence and tell us how those bad Arabs are so bloodthirsty - while neglecting to mention over 70 years of history - of mistreatment - that has so radicalized the Arabs and set the stage for Israel's downfall.

If Israel is ever destroyed in a nuclear attack she has promised to launch a nuclear missile attack from their submarines destroying every capital in Europe and the US.

Israeli nuclear blackmail
 
It is very sad to see such kind of comments after the murder of a teen in such an horrible way.
Hamas did many things wrong, but some people can not avoid engaging in "tu quoque" arguments all the time.
As even American news sites admit, this was very probably one crime of revenge after the murder of the 3 teens, so people should definitely stop to keep shouting "Hamas bad"", "Hamas bad" at least this time.
They are behaving like that guy that, during the commemorations of the Holocaust, said that Jews had done some bad things after all.
They can not avoid promoting their political agenda not even in front of the death of a teen.
Despisable!

Where is the evidence Hamas was responsible for the murders of the three Jews?
 
If Israel is ever destroyed in a nuclear attack she has promised to launch a nuclear missile attack from their submarines destroying every capital in Europe and the US.

Israeli nuclear blackmail

I find this a little hard to believe. Do you have any links?
 
I suppose it might be appropriate to 'bump' this thread, now that HAMAS has managed to get Israel to start shooting again?
 
Note that these are, in fact, two different quantities, and the PPP share is, in fact, decreasing only slowly.

Slowly???????????

:sdl: :sdl:

From over 32% to 24% in real terms and from 24% to 20% in PPP terms in just ten years is what you define as slowly?

Three pair of glasses for the guy!

But who is it decreasing in share to, KumarS? Is it decreasing in share to the middle east?
No, it is not.

Strawman
 
Last edited:
I suppose it might be appropriate to 'bump' this thread, now that HAMAS has managed to get Israel to start shooting again?

I guess. The feeling here that this round of violence is something that Hamas has planned in advance. The longer range missiles, the attempt to send a unit to infiltrate through the sea, and the booby trapped tunnel into an Israeli Kibbutz. All used in the first day of conflict. The essentially force the hand of the Israeli government to respond in force, which is probably not what it wanted.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom