Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Ah! Good, well then it is possible we are in agreement then, however, I would like to make the point that you are open to misinterpretation when you cite a quote that begins, "Pacifism is objectively pro-Fascist."

Perhaps. But I console myself in my failings that, as Karl Popper said, "It is impossible to speak in such a way that you cannot be misunderstood."
 
Perhaps. But I console myself in my failings that, as Karl Popper said, "It is impossible to speak in such a way that you cannot be misunderstood."

There's always one, isn't there.

I think Popper made an unfalsifiable claim, though, unless I misunderstood his falsifiability hypothesis.
 
Palestinian teen burned alive, his cousin beaten by Israeli forces-US people comment

In what looks like a crime of revenge, a Palestinian teen was apparently burned alive

http://www.cnn.com/2014/07/05/world/meast/mideast-tensions/
http://www.aljazeera.com/news/middl...nian-teen-burned-alive-20147512213466184.html

His cousin was severely beaten by soldiers wearing Israeli security forces uniforms

But I was even more interested in reading some horrifying comments by people (I believe, mostly American citizens) who seem to justify and whitewash this horrible crime

The news is not exactly the most quoted US news of the day, by far much less present than the killing of the 3 teens, but it does appear on some main US news sites.

On Yahoo!

"This will never end so long as there is a single follower of that POS pedophile still alive. Kill them all and let the rest of the civilize world live in peace!"
-> Got 7 "likes"

On CNN

"At this moment Hamas is hard at work brainwashing it's kids to hate Christians, Buddist and Jews instead of teaching them math, science and how to be successful in a modern world. all Palestinians kids should be treated like a terrorist threat."
-> Got 4 likes

"this kid is dead by hamas to stir up trouble"
-> Got 7 likes

"THE MUSLIMS ARE NOT HAPPY!
They're not happy in Gaza ..
They're not happy in Egypt ..
They're not happy in Libya ..
They're not happy in Morocco ..
They're not happy in Iran ..
They're not happy in Iraq ..
They're not happy in Yemen ..
They're not happy in Afghanistan. ..
They're not happy in Pakistan ..
They're not happy in Syria ..
They're not happy in Lebanon ..
SO, WHERE ARE THEY HAPPY?
They're happy in Australia .
They're happy in Canada .
They're happy in England ..
They're happy in France ..
They're happy in Italy ..
They're happy in Germany ..
They're happy in Sweden ..
They're happy in the USA ..
They're happy in Norway ..
They're happy in Holland .
They're happy in Denmark .
Basically, they're happy in every country that is not Muslim and unhappy in every country that is!
AND WHO DO THEY BLAME?
Not Islam.
Not their leadership.
Not themselves.
THEY BLAME THE COUNTRIES THEY ARE HAPPY IN!
AND THEN; They want to change those countries to be like.... THE COUNTRY THEY CAME FROM WHERE THEY WERE UNHAPPY!"
-> Got 30 likes

"It does serve a religious agenda though. Muslims can not tolerate an openly gay gay boy like Mohammed Abu Khedair. So, Palestinian Muslims killed him in the name of Islam."
-> Got 11 likes

"The Muslim gay teen was burned alive by Palestinians in honor killing. But they want to blame Israel."
-> Got 47 likes

"Yes, I am suspecting it is a honour killing, maybe this boy friendship with Israelis and I think the Hamas wants to increase the conflict with Israelis."
-> Got 23 likes

"Yeah? Look at how well all the other Muslim territories are doing. Sharia law, stonings, executions, underdeveloped for the most part, terrorist havens, etc.
And it's only the other way around because the Palestinians and Muslims are violent filth. Israel has nukes. Israel has heavy artillery. Yet, they don't use it indiscriminately like Hamas and Palestine would."
-> Got 8 likes

Comments from the Washington Post:

http://online.wsj.com/articles/arab...to-death-palestinian-official-says-1404564160

" It the Palestinians would give up on the Islamic religion, peace would ensue naturally."

"If you really believe Mahmoud Abbas' claim that Israelis murdered a Palestinian teenager, I have some beach front property in Antarctica to sell you. This war has been going on for a thousand years (west vs. muslim). It will not be resolved by "proportionate response". It can only be resolved by one side eliminating the other. That's reality, and I'm sick and tired of phony liberals' spouting "can't we all just get along" diplomacy."

"On the whole, I agree with you. However considering the Arab's culture of death, I must repeatable say that 'an eye for an eye' is the only language the Arabs understand."

I am just wondering why, in the so-called developed world, there are still people showing such a callous-disrespect for a teen murdered in such a horrible way..
 
In what looks like a crime of revenge, a Palestinian teen was apparently burned alive

I am still waiting for the evidence as to what happened. Are you?

"At this moment Hamas is hard at work brainwashing it's kids to hate Christians, Buddist and Jews instead of teaching them math, science and how to be successful in a modern world. all Palestinians kids should be treated like a terrorist threat."-> Got 4 likes.

+++You can add mine. Have you taken a look at the cartoons and children's programs? Pls do not attempt to tell me Palestian TV is not horribly racist and driven by propaganda. See Google.

I am just wondering why, in the so-called developed world, there are still people showing such a callous-disrespect for a teen murdered in such a horrible way...

No one should be murdered by any means.

The "so-called developed world" has a mix of all kinds of people, including those who make sweeping generalizations, apparently. It also has open internet forums that are not monitored by religious authorities, where even those who are against free speech may state their case. This (spotty, imperfect) respect for human rights is what makes the modern world modern, while the lack thereof makes the Muslim world medieval.
 
"At this moment Hamas is hard at work brainwashing it's kids to hate Christians, Buddist and Jews instead of teaching them math, science and how to be successful in a modern world. all Palestinians kids should be treated like a terrorist threat."-> Got 4 likes.
Sadly not very far from reality, if it is at all.

I recommend you read the HAMAS charter as well as HAMAS speeches and documents. Then you can look into the things Palestinian children are indeed taught in Palestinian schools. It is very, very frightening.

You have situations in Palestine/Israel that are as absurd as they are tragic, such as Palestinian kids being brought along to violent demonstrations and clashes with soldiers; children used as human shields; even little kids encouraged to put themselves in danger by throwing rocks at soldiers and armoured vehicles; and people, both Arab and Western, who cheer them on because in doing this they are somehow believed to be "defending their country".

If you watch "pro-Palestinian" documentaries like the propaganda flick Five Broken Cameras, you will see that even the Palestinians themselves are open about this. Children are apparently considered fighters to radical Palestinians, and they don't even try to hide this fact from the rest of the world.

I suppose experiencing all this violence and danger up close makes them easier to mold into martyrs or something, not to mention that it cements the propaganda image of the Desperate Palestinian throwing rocks at tanks in the streets because it's "all they have to fight with" :(.

Edit:
"The Muslim gay teen was burned alive by Palestinians in honor killing. But they want to blame Israel."
-> Got 47 likes

"Yes, I am suspecting it is a honour killing, maybe this boy friendship with Israelis and I think the Hamas wants to increase the conflict with Israelis."
-> Got 23 likes
This is what I have been hearing, too. Does it seem unlikely to you? Remember, Arabs are just as capable of such things as other ethnic groups, remember. Violence towards homosexuals is not exactly unheard of.
 
Last edited:
I am just wondering why, in the so-called developed world, there are still people showing such a callous-disrespect for a teen murdered in such a horrible way..
I'm not certain if I understand your question. Our part of the world consists of hundreds of millions of people. There are 350 million people in the US, I believe, and 800 million more in Europe, last time I checked. Of these people, some are, for various reasons, going to troll comment threads and Internet forums. Some do it for attention, some out of ignorance, some because of misguided ideologies or because they have been affected by various experiences.

Since people are different, each with their own lives, experiences and motivations, finding a "one size fits all" answer is very, very difficult, if not impossible.
 
What the Israelis don't really want is Peace - they want to steal whatever is left of the Palestinian's land. They just might succeed. Not all Jews want this, but a lot of them in Israel do - because they figure God gave then the land.

As a result, Israel must live like it's in a constant state of war, and if Israel slips up...if the Arabs by chance ever get the upper hand, then Israel will be demolished in the blink of an eye. On a long-enough timeline, I figure the Arabs will sooner or later get lucky...and Israel will get unlucky, and it will all be over for Israel. I figure the scene will be quite tragic if it happens - I figure it will make Auschwitz look like a backyard BBQ.

Of course, the Israelis will protest and feign innocence and tell us how those bad Arabs are so bloodthirsty - while neglecting to mention over 70 years of history - of mistreatment - that has so radicalized the Arabs and set the stage for Israel's downfall.
 
But I was even more interested in reading some horrifying comments by people (I believe, mostly American citizens)

Me too; I wonder who taught them such atrocious punctuation ("brainwashing it's kids", and "the Arab's culture of death"!).

On a more serious note, why have you immediately changed the subject of your own thread from the murder of a Palestinian teenager to a discussion of what morons on the Internet will write?

I certainly hope the perpetrators of this murder are found and prosecuted, and likewise the murderers of the Israeli teens for whom this murder appears to be considered "revenge".

From what I have read, the family of the teen are very concerned about the way this is being investigated by police who seem to be more interested in finding an inter-Palestinian motive (i.e that maybe he was killed by other Palestinians for either being part of a gang or for being gay, etc...).

And now this murder is being retaliated against with rockets being fired "in revenge" which will then likely make it inevitable that Israel will have to attack the source of the rockets.
 
On a more serious note, why have you immediately changed the subject of your own thread from the murder of a Palestinian teenager to a discussion of what morons on the Internet will write?
I wondered about this, too. Why people, Americans or otherwise, write offensive things online is more of a sociology topic than a political one. Perhaps the thread should be moved, and the title changed?
 
...But I was even more interested in reading some horrifying comments by people (I believe, mostly American citizens) who seem to justify and whitewash this horrible crime...

I think I understand where the OP is coming from. You have to admit, this kind of public display of hatred and intolerance is fairly alarming. What values do these people have that will permit them to write such atrocious things? I think it's the same kind of mentality that creates an atmosphere where these kinds of crimes against humanity can take place. It's sobering that many of the posters responding here seem completely unfazed by it, just hand wave it away. I admit it's easy to become callous to vicious Internet rants...only isn't that kind of the point?

It's troubling. :(
 
Why doesn't Israel allow UN Peacekeepers into Palestine to keep the peace until a stable and proper Palestinian Government can be established?
 
I think I understand where the OP is coming from. You have to admit, this kind of public display of hatred and intolerance is fairly alarming. What values do these people have that will permit them to write such atrocious things? I think it's the same kind of mentality that creates an atmosphere where these kinds of crimes against humanity can take place. It's sobering that many of the posters responding here seem completely unfazed by it, just hand wave it away. I admit it's easy to become callous to vicious Internet rants...only isn't that kind of the point?

It's troubling. :(

While the toxic things said online are troubling, it's not a hand wave to point out the flaws of the OP.

First and foremost, if you're more concerned that some people who may or may not be Americans are saying nasty things online than about who and why a young man was burned alive, then your priorities are way off. Secondly, there is the 'assumed to be American' flaw. Third, based off the posters other posts the reason he or she is more interested in what some maybe Americans might be posting seems to just be a continuation of the America hate on. That last one is probably the least valid, but it's understandable that some are going to read it in that light.

Also, the idea that the outrageous things posted in comment sections are sincere or representative is not a useful one. An unknown but certain non-zero number of those posts are there to get a reaction, not to advance a view. These are going to be the most outrageous things the poster can think of without clearly being parody. Of those that are sincere in their view, well, those are going to be squeaky wheels. Their hateful ideas on their pet subject are spewed at every chance, no matter how flimsy the connection. That last one seems very familiar...

So while I share your concern about the level of discourse being dragged down, and a bad mentality being advance by, these sorts of comments, I cannot fault other posters for not being phased by the trollish comments from news sites.
 
Yes it is. Israel enters and exits Palestinian territory as they wish. Israel calls all the shots over there. They can call this one, too.

No, they can't. You have an odd idea on how UN Peacekeepers work. They have to be agreed on by the general assembly (if I remember correctly), and it's not going to get any support from any of the local nations, any of them. Even if I'm not remembering that correctly, it's certainly not Israel's power to simply deploy them where ever they deem needed.
 
Why doesn't Israel allow UN Peacekeepers into Palestine to keep the peace until a stable and proper Palestinian Government can be established?

It's not Israel's call.

Yes it is. Israel enters and exits Palestinian territory as they wish. Israel calls all the shots over there. They can call this one, too.

No, they can't. You have an odd idea on how UN Peacekeepers work. They have to be agreed on by the general assembly (if I remember correctly), and it's not going to get any support from any of the local nations, any of them. Even if I'm not remembering that correctly, it's certainly not Israel's power to simply deploy them where ever they deem needed.

This does not sound correct to me. Surely the Security Council make decisions on deployment of UN peacekeeping forces, and a deployment throughout the West Bank and Gaza would be possible if voted for.

ETA: The problems that I have heard with this suggestion is that nobody wants to deploy their own troops to be part of a UN mission and that no countries are trusted enough by either side to be considered neutral.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom