Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
It's amazing. I mean, Hezbollah - as small as they are - frightens Israel and intimidates the IDF. Seriously...did Israel think that some Arabs wouldn't eventually learn how to wage a real war? Did Israel think they'd be fighting dumb Syrians and Egyptians forever - that sooner or later they wouldn't face an "A Team"?

Nasrallah is the one that's been living in a bunker for eight years.
 
By what standard could you consider Hezbollah an "A-Team" who "waged a real war"? They inflicted no substantial damage on Israel, absorbed huge damage in Lebanese infrastructure in return, lost hundreds of fighters...the only goal they accomplished was not being obliterated.

Yeah...Hezbollah got it's arse kicked, but they WON! Remember...Hezbollah was acting as the proxy for Iran and insofar as they achieved a victory for anyone in Lebanon....they didn't. However, the people in Iran who funded Hezbollah got lots of mileage out of that war for Israel is now afraid to attack Iran because they know thousands upon thousands of missiles will be launched at them by Hezbollah if they do - and Israel doesn't have the stomach to do anything about it.

Not all wars have clear winners and losers, and sometimes it's the people who don't fight who are the wons who actually win. I mean, consider the last war the US fought in Iraq. Did the US win anything, or did Iran have their worst enemy (Saddam) taken out and an Iran-friendly Shiite Government installed? Thus, Iran gained a friendly neighboring state, and the United States wasted a half-Tillion dollars and still are hated in Iraq.
 
Sure. Meanwhile, the world is waiting for the Mighty IDF to take out all those bad, bad Hezbollahs. :D

Hezbollah have been disciplined. Nasrallah admitted he wouldn't have started the 2006 war if he knew how badly they would get hammered.

Remember when Hezbollah said they would join Hamas in a two-pronged attack if Hamas was ever attacked?

They punked out.
 
Last edited:
Hezbollah was disciplined. Nasrallah admitted he wouldn't have started the 2006 war if he knew how badly they would get hammered.

Remember when Hezbollah said they would join Hamas in a two-pronged attack if Hamas was ever attacked?

They punked out.

You are right, Hezbollah got hammered and Nasrallah declared his regrets - but don't deceive yourself into thinking they wouldn't attack Israel if their benefactors (Iran) were attacked. And Israel know this!

Meanwhile, Israel is sitting back and gleefully watching Hezbollah lose a lot of guys in the Syrian Civil War. Of course, the Syrian Civil War may have an effect that Israel had not intended - it may forge the Hezbollah into a really hard-core force for there are plenty of recruits to fill the slots. We'll have to wait and see.

Meanwhile, Israel keeps stealing land from the Palestinians and wages perpetual against them. And day by day, the Palestinians grow more numerous and murderously psychotic. In years to come, when the Palestinians are even more numerous and even crazier, Israel will have hell to contend with if the Palestinians ever escape the West Bank and Gaza Asylums. If it were up to the Palestinians, I'm sure they would to do to the Israelis what would make Hitler's Holocaust look like a Backyard BBQ.

Do we really want this level of hate to exist when it can easily be avoided?
 
I get you're the kinda free spirit who doesn't get all hung up on labels, but when posting in the Israel/Palestine discussion thread, it's probably a good idea to have well defined, accurate meanings for the terms Zionist and anti-Zionist.
Fair enough, but labels can sometimes lock people into categories they don't assoiate with. And who decides the name of the labels and what constitutes them? How about if we call one group ethno-nationalists and the other universalists?

Another reason I don't like the label "anti-zionist" is that it's a negation. I'm not a communist, but I don't go around and call myself anti-communist either. During the cold war many fascist dictatorships called themself "anti-communist" to gain legitimacy, which leads us to my third reason:

Neo-nazi types like David Duke and his ilk frequently call themself "anti-zionists". They use it as a code word for jews and I'm disgusted by it. Me, and many serious people in the Palestinian movement, don't want to be near these racists and antisemitic conspiracy nuts.

I advocate the one man one vote system in the whole of Greater Israel. This falls back to the fact that green line-Israel will never give back the West Bank. I believe this fact haven't really filtered into the public discourse and peoples minds yet.

Which is one of the core anti-Zionist arguments. It's a valid, difficult issue to deal with for Zionist Israel, and will continue to be so going forward.
It's only "difficult" (euphemism for morally reprehensible) if you cling on to the 1900th century ideas about purity of peoples.


After the last in a long line of ruthless slaughters (that last one being the most ambitious, systematic, continent wide attempted extermination in history) some Jews decided it might be a good idea to establish self rule, self determination and self defense instead of continuously depending on the "tolerance" and good will of the massive host populations. We call those people (and their sympathizers) Zionists. I'm one of them. They were met with smaller, but still significant, opposition from some Jews who thought that would be a bad idea. My great grandfather, a very influential Rabbi in the Flatbush section of Brooklyn, reluctantly took that view. We call those people anti-Zionists. You're one of those. There are strong arguments available to both sides.
Here I can agree with you. But there are many brands of zionism. We have the pious jewish pilgrims from the 1700-hundreds we have the Magnes zionists, the Martin Buber supporters; and we have the political zionism, divided into everything from soviet style communists to fascists.

I think there is and always been a strong moral case for a jewish presence in Palestine. A zionism that works like a cultural center for judaism and the jewish people. But a violent ethno-nationalist crusader state like today? That clearly suppresses another, more open, secular and inclusive nationalism? No thank you.
 
You are right, Hezbollah got hammered and Nasrallah declared his regrets - but don't deceive yourself into thinking they wouldn't attack Israel if their benefactors (Iran) were attacked. And Israel know this!

So you admit Iran sponsors terrorism. Or do you still want it both ways?
 
But if there are three starving families in your neighbourhood, neither of which you have ties to, and you and all your friends all group together to give one of them an almost disprportionate amount of help of all kinds, while neglecting the other three:rolleyes:...?
The other 3 are Jews, they have Jew gold hidden away!
 
Back up statement? Olive trees, that is now (as we speak) being burned down by settler thugs (with implicit support from the Israeli government), takes many years to grow and they get very old. The oldest olive tree is 3000 years (in Cyprus) and many of the trees in Palestine are 1500 years old. They are now being destroyed. It's very clever. Even if there would be a Palestinian state today, the livelihood of the peasants has already been destroyed (since it take many years for a tree to carry olives and it's not economically feasible to grow new trees).
:boggled:

Depending on cultivar, olive trees bear fruit within 3-12 years. Roughly the same amount of time it takes for apple, plum, peach, and pear trees.

The Palestinians could have had a state a long time ago (in fact they did, but they wanted all of Israel too) if they weren't raging anti-semites who could not bear the thought of Jews controlling a tiny sliver of marginal land and sought to finish off what the Nazis started. In fact, to this very day the Hamas Charter calls for the genocide of the Jews and the "moderate" PLO (Fatah) calls for the destruction of Israel. That's quite an obstacle for any peace deal, don't you think? "Leave us alone in our own state until we are strong enough to kill/destroy you" is hardly the basis for a long lasting peace agreement.
 
I'm also glad that you're a fellow secularist, and I assume atheist. You see, one of the problems I have with Israel (and many other countries including some arab ones) is that it's not meant to be for all it's citizens (like USA or France). It's meant to be a jewish state. I have a problem with that, because it's a nationalism that ethnically/religiously is excluding some and including some. I don't think this is the way to go in the future.
So which Palestinian secular, non-ethnicity based group do you think will hold power once your dream of destroying Israel is realized? Do you even know of any, or are they hidden in the wilderness along with sasquatch and chupacabras and Elvis?
 
Where? Not in the US, that's for sure. On the opposite, younger american jews are more disconnected to Israel than their parents generation. They just can't think that the current deal with Iran isn't a good thing. But the wrightwing governement i Israel needs enemies. Just look at Netanyahu's latest paranoid (and laughable) ramblings about Iran.
I see you now have no issues whatsoever with a society based on religion and ruled by religious hardliners according to religious laws.

It's just Jews that concern you, yes?
 
It's interesting how someone can be so up in arms about perceived Israeli injustices, but then rush to the defense of terrorist groups like Hizbollah. I suppose it's a kind of "enemy of my enemy" thing, but seriously, is it that difficult to just say, "yes, they're horrible people and I do not at all support what they're doing"? Can't you support the Palestinians' case (as many friends of Israel are also doing) without making excuses for, or outright supporting, murderous thugs like HAMAS or in your case Hizbollah?

Palestinian rulers treating Palestinians terribly: tumbleweeds.
Egyptians and other Arabs treat Palestinians terribly: you can hear a needle drop.
Arabs treating Arabs terribly: yawn.
Israelis lift a finger against Arabs: outrage, cries of boycott.


I suppose pointing this out will either get you guys to change the subject again, or get me told off for posting another another "evasion", but still, why?

I think there is and always been a strong moral case for a jewish presence in Palestine. A zionism that works like a cultural center for judaism and the jewish people. But a violent ethno-nationalist crusader state like today? That clearly suppresses another, more open, secular and inclusive nationalism? No thank you.
Pray tell, what is this moe open, secular and inclusive nationalism being openly suppressed?

Maybe I can learn something here. Since your 'conversion' (figuratively speaking) to some part happended here in this forum, it would be very interesting to see the arguments that convinced you.
As I've already told you, it wasn't as much individual arguments as it was simply learning the nuances and facts about the conflict, seeing the other side as it were. Anyone who describes Israel as "contiuously stealing land" and praises Hizbollah for being an A-Team army... has a way to go there.
 
Last edited:
Meanwhile, Israel keeps stealing land from the Palestinians and wages perpetual against them. And day by day, the Palestinians grow more numerous and murderously psychotic. In years to come, when the Palestinians are even more numerous and even crazier, Israel will have hell to contend with if the Palestinians ever escape the West Bank and Gaza Asylums. If it were up to the Palestinians, I'm sure they would to do to the Israelis what would make Hitler's Holocaust look like a Backyard BBQ.

Do we really want this level of hate to exist when it can easily be avoided?
Again, please educate yourself.
 
Of course he doesn't.

International_Law_Flowchart.jpg
 
The point was of course that no one in "the public discourse" make excuses for China's behavior in Tibet, Russia, North Korea etc.
Don't be stupid, of course they do.

At this point, pro-israel debaters, often sneary, refers to Israel as being a democracy. And that is just the point the BDS movement is making; it's just because Israel is a democracy that we should boycott, disinvest and delegitimize. Because in this international conflict, public opinion matter.
Public opinion and sanctions, from both the public, government, and organizations such as the United Nations, matter in every international conflict. Don't pretend otherwise.

It wouldn't make a bit of difference if there's a public opinion against China, Burma or North Korea, cause the the ruling clique are indifferent to public opinion, especially in their own country. Israel isn't (or shouldn't).
Yeah. We Norsemen discovered just how indifferent the Chinese Communist party is to criticism when we handed the Nobel peace price to one of their dissidents:rolleyes:.

But pray tell, what difference is the public opinion of Israel making? Other than "sending a (highly redundant) message" that you don't like what the country is doing?
 
Safe-Keeper,

In post #581 you attributed two (2) quotes to me that I have never made. Change them or I will alert the Admins or Mods.
 
Last edited:
The Palestinians could have had a state a long time ago (in fact they did, but they wanted all of Israel too)...

No they couldn't and no they didn't. Twelve days before the UN resolution, the Zionist leadership had offered a (then secret) deal to the Hashemite monarchy in Jordan, conceding it the West Bank in exchange for a free hand elsewhere, since both parties were determined to pre-empt any chance of a Palestinian state. Jordan was a client state of Britain, which gave the arrangement its nod.

The Palestinians resisted that European jews were to take over their land, a land they had the aspirations of creating an independent Palestine. Shouldn't they resist? You say that " they wanted all of Israel" and that says a lot about your bias: your null hypothesis is that there should be a jewish state in Palestine, like as if that was some kind of self-evident linear and political phenomenon.

...if they weren't raging anti-semites who could not bear the thought of Jews controlling a tiny sliver of marginal land and sought to finish off what the Nazis started.
I'm sure you can find antisemitism among Palestinians. But it has never been a driving force, more a sad and illegitimate respons to Zionist aggression. After all, it was the nationalistic Easter European Jews to travelled to Palestine, not Palestinians colonizing Eastern Europe. But most of all they were anti-zionist meaning they were against jewish mass immigration in order to take over what they considered their land. They were anti-zionists and who can blame them? The Palestinians of the 40s are not the same as 2013. Most have excepted Israel today as a reality. But it's difficult to blame the Palestinians of the 40s for not wanting a new state filled with newcomers from overseas. At the year of the Balfour Declaration 1917 there were only 10 % jews in mandatory Palestine, and most of those 10 % had newly arrived.

Making the peasants of Palestine into nazis is just ludicrous. There's been jews living there since forever. It was the zionist view of exclusiveness they were fighting.


In fact, to this very day the Hamas Charter calls for the genocide of the Jews and the "moderate" PLO (Fatah) calls for the destruction of Israel. That's quite an obstacle for any peace deal, don't you think? "Leave us alone in our own state until we are strong enough to kill/destroy you" is hardly the basis for a long lasting peace agreement.
If Hamas came to power in Gaza 2006. If Hamas is the problem, then why wasn't the conflict solved long before? It's not like they've been around forever. Everybody with the slightest knowledge knows the answer: Hamas is the result of the lost peace from early 1990s. Israel wanted peace, sure. But they wanted The Land more.
 
So you admit Iran sponsors terrorism. Or do you still want it both ways?

An incredible Non-Sequiter on you part. I think you are highly confused. :D

So....when are you going to insist that Israel stop stealing land? Why has Israel developed a policy that looks a lot like "Lebensraum?"
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom