Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
No it's not and I've explained why at length above.
It's blatant hypocrisy, despite the usual limp "explanations".

It is not demonization to point out the systematic land theft, destruction of Palestinian homes and livelihood, jim crow style laws, military rule for decades, martial laws against civilians, the daily harassment designated to drive this poor peasant population who might have lived there for a thousand years out of there - it happens as we speak.

The so called "anti-Zionist" campaign is designed to demonize Israel and Jews.
Jewish "anti-Zionists" are finally beginning to realize that. The oppressive crimes of Israel, often wildly exaggerated, are a smokescreen.


And, Sigmund, ease down on the psychologization of people who happen to disagree with you, ok?

So the guy who throws around "Hasbara trolls" gets his panties in a bunch when someone dares to tell the truth about Israel Obsessive Disease? Remember what I said about blatant hypocrisy? Double it. OK?

As I said, Sigmund, ease down on the psychologization of people who happen to disagree with you, ok?

I try to avoid taking advice from the hopelessly pompous, ok?


If you still feel you have to cling on to this line of argument men in order to defend Israels (morally) indefencible policies, rethink your premises.

My characterizations concerning anti-Israel gasbags are accurate. Your error-filled ramblings support them.
 
Last edited:
Not much substance in that posting. Sharpen up please.

It's blatant hypocrisy, despite the usual limp "explanations".
So why are you arguing about this? There must be more important issues than arguing about this. You're a hypocrite, by your own standards (not mine).



The so called "anti-Zionist" campaign is designed to demonize Israel and Jews.

"So called" by whom? I've never called myself something idiotic like that. On the contrary, I clearly said that I completely understand the zionist claims (though I disagree).

Jewish "anti-Zionists" are finally beginning to realize that.

Where? Not in the US, that's for sure. On the opposite, younger american jews are more disconnected to Israel than their parents generation. They just can't think that the current deal with Iran isn't a good thing. But the wrightwing governement i Israel needs enemies. Just look at Netanyahu's latest paranoid (and laughable) ramblings about Iran.
 
But the wrightwing governement i Israel needs enemies. Just look at Netanyahu's latest paranoid (and laughable) ramblings about Iran.

Iran is the one that needs enemies. Jews.

That's why they're pumping billions into terrorist organizations while their people suffer food shortages.
 
Not much substance in that posting.
My weekly Hasbara mailing is late.

Sharpen up please.
Maybe if I mangle my grammar and spelling badly enough, I can achieve your degree of sharpness.

So why are you arguing about this? There must be more important issues than arguing about this. You're a hypocrite, by your own standards (not mine).
Because these are the issues currently being discussed in this thread?

So called" by whom? I've never called myself something idiotic like that. On the contrary, I clearly said that I completely understand the zionist claims (though I disagree).
In this context, Zionism is Jewish nationalism, realized as the Jewish state of Israel. Since you are opposed to this concept, that would make you an "anti-Zionist". Doesn't matter what you call yourself. And anti-Zionism isn't "idiotic"; it's just something I strongly disagree with. The fact that anti-Zionist thought is now so thoroughly saturated with racists, self-serving political bigots, bumbling hypocrites, outright frauds and assorted conspiracy morons is why I use quote marks and and the prefix "so called".

Where? Not in the US, that's for sure. On the opposite, younger american jews are more disconnected to Israel than their parents generation.
My comment had nothing to do with how connected or disconnected younger American Jews feel towards Israel:

The so called "anti-Zionist" campaign is designed to demonize Israel and Jews.
Jewish "anti-Zionists" are finally beginning to realize that.

I've noticed several prominent anti-Zionist Jews (along with prominent Zionist Jews highly critical of Israel) publicly acknowledging this demonization campaign during the last few years. It's about time, and I hope that trend continues.
 
In this context, Zionism is Jewish nationalism, realized as the Jewish state of Israel. Since you are opposed to this concept, that would make you an "anti-Zionist". Doesn't matter what you call yourself. And anti-Zionism isn't "idiotic"; it's just something I strongly disagree with. The fact that anti-Zionist thought is now so thoroughly saturated with racists, self-serving political bigots, bumbling hypocrites, outright frauds and assorted conspiracy morons is why I use quote marks and and the prefix "so called".

I'm not so interested in labels as you seem to be. I'm against nation-state models that excludes people on racial, ethnic and religious grounds. There's a big difference between say American and French nationalism (inclusive in nature) and ethnic nationalisms. Some nationalisms is more offensive than others. One reason is that they try to build their nation on top of another nation/population. Like the Boer nationalism of Transvaal or zionists whose views are that jews have an exclusive right to Palestine.

In both these cases we have a religious group ("a people") that has been persecuted (The story of how the Boer traveled across the river Vaal ("Transvaal") is very much a exodus story). But this gives them no moral right to develop an ideology that says that they have a right to the land they for whatever reason decide to settle in.

The same goes for the Black Panthers who wanted to separate themselfs from the rest of the society. No matter how much blacks have suffered in the past, they can't demand a state of their own. I can't see why jews would be and exception. Inserting a 1900th century style nationalistic idea like an exclusive nation-state was clearly a mistake. It was guaranteed to be an injustice to the people who lived there.
 
Iran is the one that needs enemies. Jews.

That's why they're pumping billions into terrorist organizations while their people suffer food shortages.

Iran may do most things wrong....but they don't support terrorists.

The same Sunni Fundamentalists and Wahabbi Terrorists that want to harm us would not hesitate to kill an Iranian Shiite Muslim.
 
Iran may do most things wrong....but they don't support terrorists.

They absolutely do support terrorists and are the biggest supporters of terrorism in the world.

The same Sunni Fundamentalists and Wahabbi Terrorists that want to harm us would not hesitate to kill an Iranian Shiite Muslim.

Big deal. People that hate each cut deals all the time. The world's more complex than the box you try to fit it in.
 
Last edited:
Iran may do most things wrong....but they don't support terrorists.

yukistare_zps64b059d5.jpg
 
Oh, so now you know me? But I don't know you, even though I can study 7,555 postings and you can study all my seven? (And I don't having any banners that you describe.)
Sorry, but I think you know what I mean.

Ok, but many hold Israel to such a high standard that they create a positive double bind. Because Israel have such a purity of arms, when 'she' is provoked it's all and well to attack.
I do believe that Israel, like every other country on earth, has the right to defend itself, includig with military force, when neccessary. Case in point, the recent Gaza offensive following 2000+ missiles fired at civilian targets within Israel. Again, this isn't a black-and-white picture, but yes, in many cases the country's actions were more than justified.

It's despicable, but I've seen defenses and 'explanations' for everything Israel does.
I've seen defenses and explanations for each individual thing the Norwegian state does. Such is the nature of public discourse: every policy and action has supporters and opponents -- but it does not follow from this that there are individuals who support every policy and action.

Do you support the the strangeling of the Palestinian economy?
I'm not sure if I agree with you that there's a strangling of Palestinian economy. The constant flood of aid into the Palestinian ares, for one thing, doesn't quite fit that picture.

Do you support the creation of economically crippled palestinian enclaves that some years ago were planned to be a Palestinian state (what Rabin called 'something less than a state')?
I support a fair two-state solution, as do many Israel supporters and, for that matter, a majority of Israelis.

Do you support the systematic land theft
I don't see how settlement freezes in settlement construction, the Gaza and Sinai withdrawals, the Olmert peace proposal, and various other "land for peace" initiatives fit in this image of "systematic land theft". Face it, if Israel's objective really was to conquer Palestine, they would have done so decades ago.

destruction of Palestinian homes and livelihood, the uprooting of olive trees (more than 800,000 trees and counting)
Nope. I can't imagine anyone but extremists would.

jim crow style laws, military rule, martial laws against civilians, the daily harassments etc?
To big a subject to cover in a single reply.

Well, I also understand many actions, but i distingquishthem, as clearly as I can, from condoning them. Here you blend these two moral magnitudes together.
Nope, never said such a thing.
 
I'm not so interested in labels as you seem to be.
I get you're the kinda free spirit who doesn't get all hung up on labels, but when posting in the Israel/Palestine discussion thread, it's probably a good idea to have well defined, accurate meanings for the terms Zionist and anti-Zionist.

I'm against nation-state models that excludes people on racial, ethnic and religious grounds.
Which is one of the core anti-Zionist arguments. It's a valid, difficult issue to deal with for Zionist Israel, and will continue to be so going forward.

The same goes for the Black Panthers who wanted to separate themselfs from the rest of the society. No matter how much blacks have suffered in the past, they can't demand a state of their own. I can't see why jews would be and exception.
After the last in a long line of ruthless slaughters (that last one being the most ambitious, systematic, continent wide attempted extermination in history) some Jews decided it might be a good idea to establish self rule, self determination and self defense instead of continuously depending on the "tolerance" and good will of the massive host populations. We call those people (and their sympathizers) Zionists. I'm one of them. They were met with smaller, but still significant, opposition from some Jews who thought that would be a bad idea. My great grandfather, a very influential Rabbi in the Flatbush section of Brooklyn, reluctantly took that view. We call those people anti-Zionists. You're one of those. There are strong arguments available to both sides.
 
China lends us money. Russia sells natural gas and Oil to the west. Iran Provides Oil. Burma....doesn't really do anything for us.

These are all very good reasons for our governments to look the other way, but what about our anarchist, marxist, activist demographic? These don't seem like issues that would deter them.

Israel takes our money. Israel sells our Military Secrets. Israel insists that we become involved in her fights. Israel steals land from the Arabs - and many Arabs hate us because we support Israel when they do this.

These are all doubtful assertions.
 
Utter nonsense. HasbaraWP is a self-chosen term and the accurate word to describe the set of sad old talking points trying to defend the indefensible. "Hasbara trolls" isn't very fitting though, because those people don't try to enrage people with this preposterous litany, they are defensive. For those who do so out of ignorance, my term "hasbara parrots" seems quite appropriate. Those who do it against better knowledge are racist and/or religious extremist nutjobs.

The reason tossing around the "Hasbara label" could add to people not taking you seriously is because in the darker corners of the internet where the slimes and molds of bigotry, paranoia and hatred thrive, are conspiracy theories where Israel or the shadowy "International Zionist Conspiracy" actually pay people to defend Israel online. Crazy? I think so, and for the sake of argument I'll assume you think so too, which makes one wonder why anyone would use the term when there are other options available which don't require any explanation and don't have the potential of tagging you as a conspiracy kook.

I think "hasbara parrots" is an ironic term coming from you, whose main tactic is to post articles without comment, then refuse to address questions about them. You quite literally "parrot" other people's words without offering any of your own ideas.
 
They absolutely do support terrorists and are the biggest supporters of terrorism in the world.

Sure...and just how many Chemical Weapons did the US find in Iraq?

You keep believing that hype about Iran if you will, but it doesn't make it true - just like the hype of Chemical weapons in Iraq turned out to be a lie. After 9/11, if the US had any proof Iran supported terrorists the place would have been flattened a long time ago.

Anyways...back to Israel. The Israelis need to stop stealing land from the Palestinians. The Israelis need to pull their illegal settlements out of the West Bank. Most importantly, the Israelis need to quit asking for us to get involved in their wars.
 
Anyways...back to Israel. The Israelis need to stop stealing land from the Palestinians.
Okay, now you're just obviously trolling.

Edit: had the Bush administration been our only source for the claim that Iran supports terror, I too would've been very sceptical to the claim. It isn't, however, so whatever happened in Iraq is completely irrelevant.
 
Last edited:
Folks, let me tell you why Israel is so afraid of Iran and they constantly push for us to go to war with them.

You see, way back before Benjamin Netanyahu became Prime Minister of Israel, he used to give numerous talks to conservative American Forums - and anyone else who would listen - about how ISrael was going to open up a "Can of Whoop Arse" on Iran if he became Prome Minister and solve that problem once and for all.

Then, the 2006 Lebanon/Israel War happened and the Lebanon's tiny Hezbollah Militia embarrassed the Legendary Israeli Defense Forces - knocked dout crap loads of the fearsome Merkava Tank and rendered Israel's Apache Helicopter fleet useless. Also, they shot thousands of unguided rockets into Israel and Israel was helpless to stop it - and it made life mighty uncomfortable for millions of Israelis.

In return, Israel turned Southern Lebanon into a wasteland and made Hezbollah regret the day they started that war. Even the spiritual leader of Hezbollah expressed his regret.

Anyways, this fighting went on for a couple of months until both sides just had enough and quit fighting. In the end, both Israel and Hezbollah lost the war, but their was one winner: Iran. You see, Iran had both trained and armed the Hezbollah and they did a damned good job of it - they are small, but good. In fact, if it were not for Hezbollah helping Syria's Assad, then Assad might be in big trouble right now. But...Hezbollah is destroying Syria's rebels quite nicely.

Anyways....Hezbollah is small, but they are a force to be reckoned with and Israel doesn't like them and they don't have the courage to deal with them. Israel knows that if they attack Iran, then the Hezbollah - as small as they are - will make life misberable for Israelis and there is nothing their fearsome IDF can do about it. So, Israel is trying to get the United States to bomb Iran and Invade it so they don't have to fight the Hezbollah - and they also don't have to make peace with anyone and stop stealing land from the Palestinians.

So...don't fall for the crap that the US should fight Iran - this is a cause that is heavily press-agented by Israel so they can keep stealing Palestinian Land and not have to deal with the Hezbollah. Really...ask the mighty Israeli Prime Minister Bejamin Netanyahu why he won't send troops to Lebanon to finish off Hezbollah - or bomb Iran's Nuclear Facilities like he promised for so many tears.

I smell chicken. I smell lies.

Americans should not die in order to support Israeli Theft and Cowardice.
 
Last edited:
I've seen defenses and explanations for each individual thing the Norwegian state does. Such is the nature of public discourse: every policy and action has supporters and opponents -- but it does not follow from this that there are individuals who support every policy and action.
The point was of course that no one in "the public discourse" make excuses for China's behavior in Tibet, Russia, North Korea etc. At this point, pro-israel debaters, often sneary, refers to Israel as being a democracy. And that is just the point the BDS movement is making; it's just because Israel is a democracy that we should boycott, disinvest and delegitimize. Because in this international conflict, public opinion matter. It wouldn't make a bit of difference if there's a public opinion against China, Burma or North Korea, cause the the ruling clique are indifferent to public opinion, especially in their own country. Israel isn't (or shouldn't).

I'm not sure if I agree with you that there's a strangling of Palestinian economy. The constant flood of aid into the Palestinian ares, for one thing, doesn't quite fit that picture.
When Israel conquered the WB they closed down all banks. How do you have a non-stone age economy without banks? Banks are somewhat allowed now, but Israel controls all major aspects of it, including foreign aid money. And Israel can bloc it whenever they choose to do so, including Palestinian taxes. That is the very definition of "stranglehold".


I support a fair two-state solution, as do many Israel supporters and, for that matter, a majority of Israelis.

Yes, some are serious about it, some just pay lip service to the idea.

In reality, we now know, that there won't be a two-state solution, and certainly not "a fair" one. Some say (like John Kerry, other European ministers and liberal pundits) that "the window for a two-state solution is closing…". I think they're fooling themselves. They're just frantically repeating the mantra (of so many decades) because they don't know what else to say. Forget it. There's not going to be a two-state solution. Current israeli regime aren't interrested in one. In fact, Netanyahu was elected on a platform that there will be no two-state solution. And his governement is filled with people who detest the very idea of a Palestinian state. Heck, even Rabin never accepted it, he called it "something less than a state".

I don't see how settlement freezes in settlement construction, the Gaza and Sinai withdrawals, the Olmert peace proposal, and various other "land for peace" initiatives fit in this image of "systematic land theft".
How do you think the settlers get their land (no, dont belive the lying of buying)? A start would be to google the truly kafkaesque phrase "The present absentees" and work your way forward.

Face it, if Israel's objective really was to conquer Palestine, they would have done so decades ago

Face it. Israel have already conquered Palestine decades ago.

Nope. I can't imagine anyone but extremists would.
Who do you think cut down allmost a million olive trees? A small group of extremists? Hint: the word security can be used in very creative ways. Especially in a highly militariesed society like Israel. And public discourse in the West allways buys it.

To big a subject to cover in a single reply. .

Yeah, but it's sort of the subject if this thread. And please don't forget this:


Then, in part thanks to the people on this forum, who managed to present Israel's point of view in a rational way (as opposed to the strawmen I'd learned to dislike, and which are also presented by you in this thread, who defended Israel solely for religious reasons), I gradually turned to a far more nuanced view, for which I'm incredibly grateful today. I even became a paying member of a Norwegian secular organization called "With Israel For Peace" ("Med Israel for fred").
This is very interesting, since it's the other way around for me.

Maybe I can learn something here. Since your 'conversion' (figuratively speaking) to some part happended here in this forum, it would be very interesting to see the arguments that convinced you. If you could post a link or two to some key postings that would be great. Then we could all see your intellectual change, as it happened. And, since your profile says that you are a student, and you registered here 2007, may I assume that you are relatively young, when this happened? Anyhow, it will be interesting to see/study this change in you.

I'm also glad that you're a fellow secularist, and I assume atheist. You see, one of the problems I have with Israel (and many other countries including some arab ones) is that it's not meant to be for all it's citizens (like USA or France). It's meant to be a jewish state. I have a problem with that, because it's a nationalism that ethnically/religiously is excluding some and including some. I don't think this is the way to go in the future. In this regard, Israel is a anomaly, created of the chauvinistic nationalistic ideas from an european 1900-th century filled with flag-waving bigotry. Though the the palestinian nationalism (and arab world at large) by no means lacks bigotry (including antisemitism), the palestinian nationalism, intrinsically includes jews and christian and muslims. You could be a palestinian jew, no problem. And there's been arab speaking jews living in Palestine since forever (and they were not zionists N.B.) But Israel, defined as a jewish state, is by it's very nature excluding citizens who live in that country.
 
In reality, we now know, that there won't be a two-state solution, and certainly not "a fair" one. Some say (like John Kerry, other European ministers and liberal pundits) that "the window for a two-state solution is closing…". I think they're fooling themselves. They're just frantically repeating the mantra (of so many decades) because they don't know what else to say. Forget it. There's not going to be a two-state solution. Current israeli regime aren't interrested in one. In fact, Netanyahu was elected on a platform that there will be no two-state solution. And his governement is filled with people who detest the very idea of a Palestinian state. Heck, even Rabin never accepted it, he called it "something less than a state".
[/SPOILER]

Unfortunately, I think you are right. Netanyahu doesn't want a two-state solution even though he mouthed such words in the distant past to American Audiences. It's a pattern: Netenyahu tells Americans he is for peace and two states in order to get American money, and then indulges in everlasting war and land theft back in Israel.

Netenyahu had me fooled. At one time I was really impressed with the guy. Gawd...how ignorant I was!
 
You keep believing that hype about Iran if you will, but it doesn't make it true - just like the hype of Chemical weapons in Iraq turned out to be a lie. After 9/11, if the US had any proof Iran supported terrorists the place would have been flattened a long time ago.

You see, Iran had both trained and armed the Hezbollah and they did a damned good job of it

T1zr7.gif
 
[qimg]http://i479.photobucket.com/albums/rr157/antpogo/T1zr7.gif[/qimg]


Nice smear A'isha.

Now...tell me why the mighty Israeli Defense Forces are so afraid to take on a bunch of what they call "Terrorists". Could it be that Hezbollah isn't a bunch of stupid Jihadi Terrorists but actually a pretty-darned good army that embarrassed the IDF and is doing a good job of fighting real Jihadi Terrorists in Syria?

It's amazing. I mean, Hezbollah - as small as they are - frightens Israel and intimidates the IDF. Seriously...did Israel think that some Arabs wouldn't eventually learn how to wage a real war? Did Israel think they'd be fighting dumb Syrians and Egyptians forever - that sooner or later they wouldn't face an "A Team"?

Meanwhile...Israel keeps stealing land and claiming to always be the victim. Israel keeps figuritively "poking the Palestinians in the eye" and, as a result have driven them barking mad. And Israel doesn't think there will be a price to pay for driving the Palestinians bloody insane?

Happy dreams.
 
Nice smear A'isha.

I really don't think A'isha is trying to smear you as much as point out that it's absurd for you to acknowledge how Iran supports Hezbollah while denying that Iran supports terrorism.

Now...tell me why the mighty Israeli Defense Forces are so afraid to take on a bunch of what they call "Terrorists". Could it be that Hezbollah isn't a bunch of stupid Jihadi Terrorists but actually a pretty-darned good army that embarrassed the IDF and is doing a good job of fighting real Jihadi Terrorists in Syria?

It's amazing. I mean, Hezbollah - as small as they are - frightens Israel and intimidates the IDF. Seriously...did Israel think that some Arabs wouldn't eventually learn how to wage a real war? Did Israel think they'd be fighting dumb Syrians and Egyptians forever - that sooner or later they wouldn't face an "A Team"?

By what standard could you consider Hezbollah an "A-Team" who "waged a real war"? They inflicted no substantial damage on Israel, absorbed huge damage in Lebanese infrastructure in return, lost hundreds of fighters...the only goal they accomplished was not being obliterated.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom