Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
So which Palestinian secular, non-ethnicity based group do you think will hold power once your dream of destroying Israel is realized?

I think there eventually (15-20 years from now) will be one state over all of the present territory. It will be some sort of bi-national state, with weaker and weaker differences between Jews and Palestinians. It will be one vote per person.
 
Eon said:
Where? Not in the US, that's for sure. On the opposite, younger american jews are more disconnected to Israel than their parents generation. They just can't think that the current deal with Iran isn't a good thing. But the right-wing government i Israel needs enemies. Just look at Netanyahu's latest paranoid (and laughable) ramblings about Iran.

I see you now have no issues whatsoever with a society based on religion and ruled by religious hardliners according to religious laws.

How do you see that? Iran is a misogynic fascistic society with a despicable record on human rights. However, the iranian leaders are realists, they are not crazed fanatics. The current leadership in Israel, including the vast intelligence and security apparatus, knows this full well. That's why Netanyahu's ramblings are so laughable. Everybody with slightest insight knows that he's lying.

Remember the Iran Contras-scandal? US shipping weapons to Iran with the support and aid of Israel. And that was during a time when official contacts were even frostier than today.

It's just Jews that concern you, yes?
Ah, implying antisemitism for no reason other than that the topic contains jews... and as almost always, a sign of weakness.
 
Safe-Keeper, in post #581 you attributed two (2) quotes to me that I have never made. Change them or I will alert the Admins or Mods.
My mistake.

No they couldn't and no they didn't.
Yes, they could, and yes, they did.

Again, educate yourself. Read the HAMAS charter, listen to speeches made by Palestinian leaders on YouTube, heck, just read history. The Palestinian leaders want a "one party solution". They want to drive the Jews "into the sea". They speak openly of genocide. You can try to handwave all this as a result of eebil joowish zionism all you want, but it remains a reality, and it always has.

The Palestinians resisted that European jews were to take over their land, a land they had the aspirations of creating an independent Palestine. Shouldn't they resist?
They received an independent Palestine. Mission accomplished.

You say that " they wanted all of Israel" and that says a lot about your bias:
No, it doesn't. It says he has educated himself on the subject, whereas you haven't.

your null hypothesis is that there should be a jewish state in Palestine, like as if that was some kind of self-evident linear and political phenomenon.
Given that it's the area of land that the Jews historically and culturally belong to, and if history has shown us anything, it is that the Jews need a place to call their home, in which they can feel safe. It's also not the first time in history that a territory has been split up to accomodate different ethnic groups.

Of course none of this is self-evident, most nothing in life is, but the overwhelming yes vote in the UN for creating an Israeli state tells me that it wasn't just Jewish Zionists who were in support of the idea;).'

I'm sure you can find antisemitism among Palestinians. But it has never been a driving force, more a sad and illegitimate respons to Zionist aggression.
[Citation needed]
If Hamas came to power in Gaza 2006. If Hamas is the problem, then why wasn't the conflict solved long before?
Yes, because what we've been saying is that HAMAS is the only problem in play here.

It's not like they've been around forever. Everybody with the slightest knowledge knows the answer: Hamas is the result of the lost peace from early 1990s. Israel wanted peace, sure. But they wanted The Land more.
[Citation needed]
An incredible Non-Sequiter on you part. I think you are highly confused. :D
How is that a non-sequiter:confused:? Except perhaps if you for some reason deny that Hizbollah is a terrorist organization? In which case I would actually you rather read and replied to this thread.

[quoteSo....when are you going to insist that Israel stop stealing land?[/quote]When will you stop beating your wife:confused:?

Why has Israel developed a policy that looks a lot like "Lebensraum?"
[Citation needed]
 
Folks, don't be fooled by Israel and it's land-stealing tactics. The last thing Israel and it's supporters want to talk about is Israel's non-stop theft of land. Instead. they want to talk about Hamas, Hezbollah, Iran and how bad all these guys are. But Again: Israel Refuses to discuss their ongoing land theft and the relegation of Palestinians into smaller and smaller ghettos.

Also, Israel says they are for Arabs and Jews just because they have a few Arab Citizens. Don't believe it. The Star of David on their flag says everything - Israel is first and foremost about the Jews who inhabit Israel. Hell...Israel doesn't even have a written Constitution - for if they did they would have to document their nasty principals.

Imagine a Religiously-Fundamental Alabama of the 1950s with military power: this is Israel. When is all comes down to it, Israel is nothing but a state run by a bunch of hateful rednecks. What's worse is that all of Israel's neighbors are a bunch of Rednecks, too - so you know that it is inevitable that these Rednecks will always fight as Rednecks are won't to do.

Furthermore, don't ever believe that Israel wants peace - Israel does not want peace. For the day that Israel has peace, they will no longer have an excuse to steal land. No...Israel wants perpetual war so that they can justify the land they are stealing form the Palestinians, Syrians and Lebanese.

So why should we - Americans - get involved in the Israeli-Arab Cesspool that has no end?
 
Last edited:
Folks, don't get fooled by Jules. He doesn't want to talk about beating his wife. Instead, he wants to talk about Israel an...


eta
Also, Israel says they are for Arabs and Jews just because they have a few Arab Citizens. Don't believe it. The Star of David on their flag says everything
Uh-oh. Hope he doesn't check out the Scandinavian flags :covereyes.
 
Last edited:
Safe-keeper,

You are just rehashing old long outdated talking points, like "drive into the see", haven't seen that one in years.

You hardly address my central points, which is that the there will be no two-state solution because the the peace process is a charade. Israel have no intention of leaving the West Bank.

And no, they did never receive anything like a state. As I said: Ben Gurion made a deal with king Abdullah in Jordan, conceding it the West Bank in exchange for a free hand elsewhere, since both parties were determined to pre-empt any chance of a Palestinian state. Do you understand what this means?

For further reading see Avi Shlaim’s account, in his book Collusion Across the Jordan: King Abdullah, the Zionist Movement and the Partition of Palestine, New York 1988, pp. 110–16.

I agree that culturally and historically there's a connection between the Jewish People and Israel/Palestine. But there is a connection between this land and the Palestinians too. And it's the palestinians that's been ethnically cleansed. Jews surely have "a right" to live in Israel/Palestine. But it's not an exclusive right. Get it? Jews have lived there since forever. The conflict started 1897 in Basel when WZO was founded and set a goal to create a homogenous ethno-nationalistic state in a densely populated multicultural area (jews, christians, muslims and other minorities have lived there for centuries). Both the Palestinians and the israeli jews are trapped in mythology about their own history.

For further reading, Robert Bowker, Palestinian Refugees: Mythology, Identity, and the Search for Peace First and second chapter.

About the UN-voting: to a large extent it made possible because there were so few states members in the newly founded organization. Stalin, who easily could have stopped it with a veto, misjudged the situation (due to the fact that he thought Israel was going to be socialistic in nature).

But chief architect behind the vote's outcome was of course the convinced Christian Zionist Harry Truman. Resistance to the plan, widespread among smaller nations in the UN, was overpowered by American bribes and blackmail, to secure the necessary two-thirds vote in the General Assembly. For instance, Liberia - in origin another settler state created at US initiative - was told that it would be brought to its knees by a rubber embargo if it dared to vote against the UN plan. Cuba was paid $75,000 for its vote. Truman called himself, with every right, the modern Cyrus.

For further reading, see Michael Cohen, Palestine and the Great Powers 1945–1948, Princeton 1982, pp. 294–9.

Furthermore, speaking about knowledge and history, let me just calmly recommend that you, being a student, read books, instead of Youtube-clips, - as much to my suprise - you openly admit is one of your sources of information. You see clips, for instance of some arab/palestinian saying some incriminating soundbite, are there for a reason. Someone put it there, and it's a part of the war ideas, and the constant battle of trying to make "the other" look bad. And, as I said in an earlier post, this is a subject where people love to misunderstand each other.

A good place to start is to read about the discussion among the so called "New Historians" of Israel. They are less ideological, and they have in many ways confirmed the narrative of the Palestinians.
 
Furthermore, speaking about knowledge and history, let me just calmly recommend that you, being a student, read books, instead of Youtube-clips, - as much to my suprise - you openly admit is one of your sources of information.
Being patronizing and attacking person instead of the subject at hand will get you nowhere here. Stop it already. You're on a sceptic's forum.
 
Being patronizing and attacking person instead of the subject at hand will get you nowhere here. Stop it already. You're on a sceptic's forum.


Or...instead of acting all offended, you could reply to the content of EON's post.

Oh yeah...you still haven't edited the post #581 to remove the quote you misattributed to me. I'm not waiting much longer. So do it.
 
Last edited:
Folks, don't be fooled by Israel and it's land-stealing tactics. The last thing Israel and it's supporters want to talk about is Israel's non-stop theft of land. Instead. they want to talk about Hamas, Hezbollah, Iran and how bad all these guys are. But Again: Israel Refuses to discuss their ongoing land theft and the relegation of Palestinians into smaller and smaller ghettos.

Also, Israel says they are for Arabs and Jews just because they have a few Arab Citizens. Don't believe it. The Star of David on their flag says everything - Israel is first and foremost about the Jews who inhabit Israel. Hell...Israel doesn't even have a written Constitution - for if they did they would have to document their nasty principals.

Imagine a Religiously-Fundamental Alabama of the 1950s with military power: this is Israel. When is all comes down to it, Israel is nothing but a state run by a bunch of hateful rednecks. What's worse is that all of Israel's neighbors are a bunch of Rednecks, too - so you know that it is inevitable that these Rednecks will always fight as Rednecks are won't to do.

Furthermore, don't ever believe that Israel wants peace - Israel does not want peace. For the day that Israel has peace, they will no longer have an excuse to steal land. No...Israel wants perpetual war so that they can justify the land they are stealing form the Palestinians, Syrians and Lebanese.

So why should we - Americans - get involved in the Israeli-Arab Cesspool that has no end?

Preaching when you get called on your arguments again?
 
No they couldn't and no they didn't. Twelve days before the UN resolution, the Zionist leadership had offered a (then secret) deal to the Hashemite monarchy in Jordan, conceding it the West Bank in exchange for a free hand elsewhere, since both parties were determined to pre-empt any chance of a Palestinian state. Jordan was a client state of Britain, which gave the arrangement its nod.
Yes, they did. As the saying goes, you're entitled to your own opinions but not your own facts.

The Palestinians resisted that European jews were to take over their land, a land they had the aspirations of creating an independent Palestine. Shouldn't they resist? You say that " they wanted all of Israel" and that says a lot about your bias: your null hypothesis is that there should be a jewish state in Palestine, like as if that was some kind of self-evident linear and political phenomenon.
It was quite clear at the time, in fact there were hundreds of thousands of Jews living there already, many of whom fled Europe in the previous half century. And they didn't "take over", they immigrated and bought land. Would you make the same argument in support of a group that killed immigrants to the USA?

I'm sure you can find antisemitism among Palestinians. But it has never been a driving force, more a sad and illegitimate respons to Zionist aggression. After all, it was the nationalistic Easter European Jews to travelled to Palestine, not Palestinians colonizing Eastern Europe. But most of all they were anti-zionist meaning they were against jewish mass immigration in order to take over what they considered their land. They were anti-zionists and who can blame them? The Palestinians of the 40s are not the same as 2013. Most have excepted Israel today as a reality. But it's difficult to blame the Palestinians of the 40s for not wanting a new state filled with newcomers from overseas. At the year of the Balfour Declaration 1917 there were only 10 % jews in mandatory Palestine, and most of those 10 % had newly arrived.
Ah, more anti-immigrant sentiments and also complete denial of the Palestinians siding with Nazi Germany in WWII.

Making the peasants of Palestine into nazis is just ludicrous. There's been jews living there since forever. It was the zionist view of exclusiveness they were fighting.
Yeah, sure Sparky. That's why there's a million Muslim Arab citizens oi Israel today, while the surrounding Arab states have how many Jews living there as full citizens? :rolleyes:

If Hamas came to power in Gaza 2006. If Hamas is the problem, then why wasn't the conflict solved long before? It's not like they've been around forever. Everybody with the slightest knowledge knows the answer: Hamas is the result of the lost peace from early 1990s. Israel wanted peace, sure. But they wanted The Land more.
If "ifs" and "buts" were cake and nuts, what a happy Christmas it would be!

This may come as a shock to you, but Hamas is just one of many rabidly anti-Semitic groups of Palestinians. Show me a Palestinian "political party" (in scare quotes because they all have armed "militant wings") that has measurable support that doesn't call for either genocide of Jews or the destruction of Israel.
 
Last edited:
No they couldn't and no they didn't. Twelve days before the UN resolution, the Zionist leadership had offered a (then secret) deal to the Hashemite monarchy in Jordan, conceding it the West Bank in exchange for a free hand elsewhere, since both parties were determined to pre-empt any chance of a Palestinian state. Jordan was a client state of Britain, which gave the arrangement its nod.

Where did you get this from? So many wrong details, but in a revealing way. It has been a while since I looked at this story, but here is what I remember.

There was a meeting between the Jordanian king and emissaries of the 'Yeshuv'. In this Jordanian king first tried to convince the Jews that their best option is to have an autonomy in his kingdom. Then he offered that they would avoid fighting if hostilities break, and the Jews would let him take over the area meant for the Palestinians. Note two things here, the one offering was the Jordanian king, and the area in question was quite larger than the west bank. In fact, the Jewish side would have got precisely the same area allocated to in under the partition plan. I point that you wrongly suggested that it was the 'Yeshuv' who has suggested the deal. Why?

In any case, there was never a deal. You can find some historians which claim a deal, but I find their argument to be very weak. In the first meeting the Jewish emissaries did not promise anything to King Abdullah. They returned for consultations. BTW, we know about this from notes from a meeting of Jewish leader which is our only source. The notes make it clear that the Jewish leaders were not enthusiastic about the suggestion because they did not want to violate the UN plan. (The Yeshuv used all its diplomatic power to encourage the UN to pass the partition plan.)

There was no contact between the sides that we know of for months after that meeting. Only much later Jewish emissaries met Abdullah again. This was after the UN plan has passed and a civil war broke out, in which the Jewish side was first on the defensive, but later (April 1948) managed to win and gain territory. In the second meeting Abdullah made it clear that in the political climate of the time no deal of any kind was possible. By the way, the first thing Abdullah ordered his legion to do was to enter Jerusalem, which was not part of the area allocated to the Palestinians under the UN plan, and was furthermore Holy site for Jews, with a large Jewish population. Are you claiming that the Jewish leadership made a deal giving up Jerusalem?

There is no evidence that I know of covering other meeting between the sides. No evidence of coordination between the armies. (Which was needed to determine who takes which area.) And no evidence of British knowledge of a deal. The only evidence are reports made by the Jewish emissaries an a discussion following the second meeting, and this report includes also the detailed of the second meeting described above, in which it was clear that no cooperation or cease fire between the sides was possible.

My point is that you got your facts wrong here. More than that, they were rearranged in a way which put the agency in Jewish hands. (I do not claim that you did this, mind.) My observation is that in discussion on the middle east some people forget that both sides have agency.
 
Where did you get this from?

In my post above #594, I give three different sources to back up my facts:

Avi Shlaim, Collusion Across the Jordan: King Abdullah, the Zionist Movement and the Partition of Palestine, New York 1988, pp. 110–16.

It seems credible and I don't really see why it shouldn't be like Shlaim describes it. My point being that the palestinians never stood a chance of getting a state. And as a fact Israel emerged from the war in possession of a much larger territory than granted it by the UN, while Jordan annexed the West Bank.

Are you claiming that the Jewish leadership made a deal giving up Jerusalem?
No, Jerusalem was a prime goal. But if necessary they would regroup and take it later on.

There were two waves of fighting between November 1947 and March 1949. Most of the other areas where ethnically cleansed principally during the first. Over half the Arab population was driven out of Palestine by Jewish attacks - some 700,000 persons. But in Jerusalem it wasn't as notable (well it was notable for the Palestinians who were expelled) as it already had a large jewish population.
 
It seems credible and I don't really see why it shouldn't be like Shlaim describes it.

On what do you base this credibility? Do you merely find it plausible? Doctor Evil gave a pretty solid refutation of its credibility.

No, Jerusalem was a prime goal. But if necessary they would regroup and take it later on.

Are you privy to declassified Israeli battle plans? It seems like you're speculating.
 
Or...instead of acting all offended, you could reply to the content of EON's post.
I'm not obligated to respond to anything posted here. Pardon me, but when I check the forums late at night, condescending people who prowl other peoples' profiles for things to attack them for aren't exactly my cup of tea. Perhaps if Eon wants replies, he can treat his fellow debaters with respect, and understand how facts, logic and debates work.

edit: The fact that he found it "shocking" that I refer to primary sources is especially jarring. Apparently in his eyes, such material magically loses its credibility once they are put on YouTube, thereby making people who seek them out "people who get information from YouTube instead of reading books". The two are apparently mutually exclusive, you see, if you watch YouTube videos you must also stop reading books.

Oh yeah...you still haven't edited the post #581 to remove the quote you misattributed to me. I'm not waiting much longer. So do it.
Or...instead of acting all offended, you could put it behind you already, especially since posts cannot be edited after a certain time:rolleyes:.
 
Last edited:
On what do you base this credibility? Do you merely find it plausible? Doctor Evil gave a pretty solid refutation of its credibility.
Yes, I find it plausible. Of course I can be wrong in this detail. But the story is straight forward told and carries an inner logic. Besides, Shlaim is a professor of International Relations at the university of Oxford and a fellow of the British Academy, so we can expect at least some academic rigor.


Are you privy to declassified Israeli battle plans?

You can read the history here: Benny Morris, The Birth of the Palestinian Refugee Problem, 1947–1949, Cambridge University Press, 1988

It's a well sourced book, and among many sources, it contains declassified battleplans. There's a revisited edition that I haven't read though.

If you are a man of few words you can read shorter versions here:

http://www.nytimes.com/books/99/11/14/reviews/991114.14bronjt.html

http://www.palestine-studies.org/files/correct_BM.pdf
 
In my post above #594, I give three different sources to back up my facts:

Avi Shlaim, Collusion Across the Jordan: King Abdullah, the Zionist Movement and the Partition of Palestine, New York 1988, pp. 110–16.

It seems credible and I don't really see why it shouldn't be like Shlaim describes it. My point being that the palestinians never stood a chance of getting a state. And as a fact Israel emerged from the war in possession of a much larger territory than granted it by the UN, while Jordan annexed the West Bank.

It seems credible to you. I thought otherwise, and gave specific reasons why in my post above. Moreover, as far as I remember even Shlaim agree that it was Abdullah who make the offer. In your post you ascribed the initiative to the wrong side, hence my comment about not giving agency to the Arab side.

IMO, Shalim made his thesis by over-interpreting one document, well beyond what it contained. He then uses the relative small number of engagements between the Legion and the IDF to support his thesis, even though it can more simply be explained by each side preferring relatively easy and safe war goals.

Finally, your point about the Palestinians not having a chance for a state is rubbish. They would have gotten one had they supported the UN partition plan. They may even have gotten one by opposing the plan, but then accepting the result. It was threatening violence if the UN votes for the plan, and then starting a civil war which lead to the events that eliminated the possibility of a state.

No, Jerusalem was a prime goal. But if necessary they would regroup and take it later on.

There were two waves of fighting between November 1947 and March 1949. Most of the other areas where ethnically cleansed principally during the first. Over half the Arab population was driven out of Palestine by Jewish attacks - some 700,000 persons. But in Jerusalem it wasn't as notable (well it was notable for the Palestinians who were expelled) as it already had a large jewish population.

This makes no sense. You seem to be claiming simultaneously that the Jewish leadership made a deal that would give Jordan Jerusalem, and at the same time having controlling Jerusalem as a prime goal.

Regarding your point about Jerusalem, you should refresh yourself with the facts. It was the Jewish residents of the old city who were expelled from Jerusalem in 1948. This is not meant to say that Palestinians were not driven from other places, just to demonstrate you that there is more to the story that you are aware of.
 
You can read the history here: Benny Morris, The Birth of the Palestinian Refugee Problem, 1947–1949, Cambridge University Press, 1988

It's a well sourced book, and among many sources, it contains declassified battleplans. There's a revisited edition that I haven't read though.

If you are a man of few words you can read shorter versions here:

http://www.nytimes.com/books/99/11/14/reviews/991114.14bronjt.html

http://www.palestine-studies.org/files/correct_BM.pdf

You are aware that the NY Times review of history books that you cited is not that complimentary to Shlaim, claiming that his politics influence his history. Morris gets a much better evaluation.
 
You are aware that the NY Times review of history books that you cited is not that complimentary to Shlaim, claiming that his politics influence his history. Morris gets a much better evaluation.


While you cited nothing at all to back up the narrative you are trying to sell us. Quite interesting. :rolleyes:
 
If it wasn't for the support of the United States, Israel would be nothing. Israel is a pig on our teet that won't let go. The US feeds Israel Money, Arms and Diplomatic Influence and Israel steals land from Arabs and creates enemies in the process. Also, Israel steals American Military Secrets and sell them to the Enemies of the US. For example, take a look at the J-10 Fighter Aircraft from China that Israel helped China Develop from the plans of the F-16.

Can you imagine how much more peaceful would be our foreign relations if we treated Israel just like any other state? And you imagine how fast Israel would seek peace and a fair land deal for the Palestinians?

Israel is a "pain in the arse" so-to-speak that we only support because the Religious Fundies in this country are convinced that if we do not support "God's Chosen People" (i.e., Israel) then Jesus will smack our arses down when he returns. In effect, America is involved in religious warfare! How silly is that?
 
...as far as I remember even Shlaim agree that it was Abdullah who make the offer. In your post you ascribed the initiative to the wrong side, hence my comment about not giving agency to the Arab side.

I'll see if I have time to research that later on, I don't have the book in front of me now. But I am open for the possibility that I'm wrong in this detail. But would be nice if you gave a source (for comparison).

Finally, your point about the Palestinians not having a chance for a state is rubbish. They would have gotten one had they supported the UN partition plan. They may even have gotten one by opposing the plan, but then accepting the result.
First, I think the Palestinians lost their state the years before, during the Arab Revolt of 1936-1939. Here the British broke the back of the emerging Palestinian society in a way that it could not rise again (and it hasn't since). Hence, in my opinion, there's too much focus on the specific details of the war of 1948.

Secondly, the Yishuv was eager to get the partition plan (or any jurisdiction) quick, and put all diplomatic effort into it, since they had facts on the ground (a newly arrived population), but no official recognition anywhere. But there is little doubt that the Yishuv had plans for more. It seems clear to me, that they wanted an official foothold in Palestine, so that they could go on with the zionist conquest - building a homogeneous jewish state in Palestine. For instance, even though the Yishuv ended up controlling an area about 40 % larger than the partition plan, Abba Eban complained and called the new borders "Auschwitz-borders", meaning they were to small and that they should have conquered even more.

Third, likewise, it isn't hard to see why the Palestinians didn't accept the plan. They considered Palestine their homeland, and were expecting the british to fullfill their promises. Why would they accept it? If someone were to take over your home, then offering you a few rooms in a "fair compromise" you might not be overwhelmed by his generosity, even if he were homeless, destitute, and persecuted.

Regarding your point about Jerusalem, you should refresh yourself with the facts. It was the Jewish residents of the old city who were expelled from Jerusalem in 1948. This is not meant to say that Palestinians were not driven from other places, just to demonstrate you that there is more to the story that you are aware of.
I am aware of it. I just didn't wright about it. Maybe I should've.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom