do you agree the Israelis receive a disproportionate amount of attention, while other parties are neglected, or do you not?
Not only do I agree, I gave three concrete exemples of it.
care to back up this statement?
I can't link untill I've done 10 postings but it's hardly disputed that there's been a peasant population in Palestine for well over a thousand years and that many of the cities are of this age or older. The crusaders praised the oranges of Jaffa, calling them 'the Gold of Palestine'. These oranges are today Israeli - stolen from the Palestinians in 1948. About 25,000 of them still lives, and can prove that they
personally owned the property (but aren't allowed back
because they can prove that they own(ed) the land)
Back up statement? Olive trees, that is now (as we speak) being burned down by settler thugs (with implicit support from the Israeli government), takes many years to grow and they get very old. The oldest olive tree is 3000 years (in Cyprus) and many of the trees in Palestine are 1500 years old. They are now being destroyed. It's very clever. Even if there would be a Palestinian state today, the livelihood of the peasants has already been destroyed (since it take many years for a tree to carry olives and it's not economically feasible to grow new trees).
You know, since you're so interested in good debate ethics, declaring your opponent's stance "indefensible" is not generally a wise way to start a good discussion.
You're misquoting me here. I meant
morally indefensible. For example, I consider death penalty morally indefensible. But I of course understand that there of arguments for it. Debating ethics: includes that one try to interpret the other sides arguments in as good light as possible. Specially in this topic (Israel/Palestine), where people love to misunderstand each other.
It's funny, though. I used to be like you. For a pretty long period I had a "Free Palestine!" and "boycott Israel!" signature, a Palestinian flag as my avatar, and an intense dislike for Israel's policies and occupation.
Oh, so now you know me? But I don't know you, even though I can study 7,555 postings and you can study all my
seven? (And I don't having any banners that you describe.)
Then, in part thanks to the people on this forum, who managed to present Israel's point of view in a rational way (as opposed to the strawmen I'd learned to dislike, and which are also presented by you in this thread, who defended Israel solely for religious reasons), I gradually turned to a far more nuanced view, for which I'm incredibly grateful today. I even became a paying member of a Norwegian secular organization called "With Israel For Peace" ("Med Israel for fred").
This is very interesting, since it's the other way around for me.
Maybe I can learn something here. Since your 'conversion' (figuratively speaking) to some part happended here in this forum, it would be very interesting to see the arguments that convinced you. If you could post a link or two to some key postings that would be great. Then we could all see your intellectual change, as it happened. And, since your profile says that you are a student, and you registered here 2007, may I assume that you are relatively young, when this happened? Anyhow, it will be interesting to see/study this change in you.
I'm also glad that you're a fellow secularist, and I assume atheist. You see, one of the problems I have with Israel (and
many other countries including some arab ones) is that it's not meant to be for all it's citizens (like USA or France). It's meant to be a jewish state. I have a problem with that, because it's a nationalism that ethnically/religiously is excluding some and including some. I don't think this is the way to go in the future. In this regard, Israel is a anomaly, created of the chauvinistic nationalistic ideas from an european 1900-th century filled with flag-waving bigotry. Though the the palestinian nationalism (and arab world at large) by no means lacks bigotry (including antisemitism), the palestinian nationalism, intrinsically includes jews and christian and muslims. You could be a palestinian jew, no problem. And there's been arab speaking jews living in Palestine since forever (and they were not zionists N.B.) But Israel, defined as a jewish state, is by it's very nature excluding citizens who live in that country.
Of course there are also things Israel does that I don't support. See, in reality I doubt there are anyone who "supports anything Israel does", just in case you didn't know.
Ok, but many hold Israel to such a high standard that they create a positive double bind. Because Israel have such a purity of arms, when 'she' is provoked it's all and well to attack. It's despicable, but I've seen defenses and 'explanations' for
everything Israel does. Do you support the the strangeling of the Palestinian economy? Do you support the creation of economically crippled palestinian enclaves that some years ago were planned to be a Palestinian state (what Rabin called 'something less than a state')? Do you support the systematic land theft, destruction of Palestinian homes and livelihood, the uprooting of olive trees (more than 800,000 trees and counting) jim crow style laws, military rule, martial laws against civilians, the daily harassments etc?
I feel I have good, rational reasons for supporting Israel on a lot of things, and at the very least understand the reasoning for many of its other decisions.
Well, I also
understand many actions, but i distingquishthem, as clearly as I can, from condoning them. Here you blend these two moral magnitudes together. I
understand how Eastern European jews were affected by the holocaust and the antisemitism and in what way that led them to wanting a state solely for jews. I also
understand the Black Panters reasoning when they wanted a state of their own. I really do. I see the underpinning knowledge, and how blacks have been suppressed and enlaved. But I still hold both ideas as bad ideas.