Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
It is time for Israel to learn how to stand on it's own and get along with its neighbors. It's time for Israel to stop stealing Palestinian land. It's time for Israel to stop selling American Military secrets. It's time for Israel to stop asking us for an endless supply of money and weapons. It's time for Israel to stop asking us to get involved in their fights. It's time for Israel to grow up.
Already addressed most of this, so I don't see why you're re-posting it as if no one answered you:confused:.
 
Demanding Equality: Interview with Steven Salaita on the ASA Academic Boycott

Jadaliyya said:
Noura Erakat: So, there's a lot of exciting news in the air. We just found out that the American Studies Association membership has endorsed the National Council's resolution for the academic boycott of Israel by sixty-six percent, which is a supermajority. Obviously, this is a big deal, though the way that it has been framed is a bit curious, because it is not the first academic association in the United States to endorse an academic boycott--that was the Asian American Studies Association. It certainly is not the first globally as we know. For example, the University of Johannesburg cut all of its ties with Ben-Gurion University in 2011. Yet, it has been framed as a game-changer. You have been significantly involved in leading this effort for years and through this last stretch. Can you tell us a little bit about why it is such a game-changer?

Steven Salaita: I think there are a few things going on. The size of the ASA as compared to the Asian American Studies Association (AASA) is significant. This association has more of a national and international profile. Also, there was a level of opposition within the ASA that was loud and ended up getting a lot of media involved and created interest. So, I think that with the AASA, it passed unanimously and it passed rather quietly. They faced a good amount of backlash and criticism but in the weeks leading up to their adoption of a boycott there wasn't this media brouhaha that the ASA was subject to. So, with the interest of a lot of outside media, with a lot of the international profile and stature of a lot of the scholars that were helping to organize the resolution, all of those things created a tremendous amount of interest. In the United States, the very notion of isolating Israel or singling out Israel or targeting Jews and these sorts of nonsensical narratives that are coming from the other side carry a lot of weight in people's imaginations. So, a lot of curiosity got evoked around the idea of “why are people doing this to Israel?” This has been great, because it has given us an opportunity to explain what the boycott is about and to explain what it does and does not do.

[...]
 
What do you care? I mean, are we going to start boycotting Saudi Oil and Gas even though Saudi Arabia is the literal fountainhead of the world's terror? Naw....we got to drive. However, we could stop giving the Arabs weapons and supporting their dictatorships....and that's all I ask for is to do to Israel, too.

It is time for Israel to learn how to stand on it's own and get along with its neighbors. It's time for Israel to stop stealing Palestinian land. It's time for Israel to stop selling American Military secrets. It's time for Israel to stop asking us for an endless supply of money and weapons. It's time for Israel to stop asking us to get involved in their fights. It's time for Israel to grow up.

Is this your way of telling us you know even less about I/P than you do about global warming?
 
It also does not answer the rhetorical question, which is: why is Israel singled out for boycotts when there are other regimes that are far, far worse -- such as Russia and China?

I'm not even going to get into how a "boycott" of Israel is ridiculous anyhow, what with all the innovations and electronic gizmos we import from them. When you buy a phone or computer, chances are parts within it come from Israelis.
 
Still no answer on why there's no China/Russia/Iran/Burma et al. boycott.
 
Still no answer on why there's no China/Russia/Iran/Burma et al. boycott.

China lends us money. Russia sells natural gas and Oil to the west. Iran Provides Oil. Burma....doesn't really do anything for us.

Israel takes our money. Israel sells our Military Secrets. Israel insists that we become involved in her fights. Israel steals land from the Arabs - and many Arabs hate us because we support Israel when they do this.

I mean, when was the last time a some maniac flew a Jetliner into one of our buildings because he did not like our Chinese Policy? When has Burma ever taken our money? When has China or Russia ever pretended that they did not steal our Secrets? When has Iran ever insisted we go to war on their behalf?

Nevertheless, I would not Boycott Israel. But...I would refuse to give them more money. And, if they want to buy our weapons...fine, just pay the going rate.
 
You do realize a large part of our electronics and scientific innovations come from Israel, right? We wouldn't have had USBs had it not been for them.

http://blogs.timesofisrael.com/bds-this-10-israeli-exports-you-already-love/

Edit:
Israel takes our money. Israel sells our Military Secrets. Israel insists that we become involved in her fights. Israel steals land from the Arabs - and many Arabs hate us because we support Israel when they do this.
Just curious, do you have some sort of quota on how many times you're going to repeat this claim? We heard you the first time.
 
Last edited:
I mean, when was the last time a some maniac flew a Jetliner into one of our buildings because he did not like our Chinese Policy?
The peoples in and around China seem to not have adopted the fanatical "kill innocent civilians whenever somebody ticks you off" approach to diplomacy. Certain people love to use the occupation as an excuse for everything from dictators ruling Arabs to wars of aggression against Israel to terrorism, but you will notice there seems to be precious few Tibetan suicide bombers, even though China treats the Tibetans far more harshly than the Israelis have ever treated the Palestinians.

Similarly, Russia occupies large areas of Finland, but somehow this doesn't cause the Finns to elect a part of murderous genocidal maniacs into power, and for some inexplicable reason the number of suicide bombings and rocket attacks on Russian civilians from Finland seems to remain at a constant zero.
 
Still no answer on why there's no China/Russia/Iran/Burma et al. boycott.

That's not a good argument against boycott. When defending Israels oppression of the Palestinians, the best media strategy is probably tech washing and pink washing. Not going on about endless comparizons with other conflicts

2006 we where hearing: "but what about Darfur?"
2008 we where hearing: "but what about Sri Lanka?"
2011 we where hearing: "but what about Syria?"

Thousands of hasbara trolls, mouthing the exact same phrase of the day, all day, on thousands av social platforms.

There will always be somewhere where the oppression, for the moment or temporarily, is worse than for the crushed and downtrodden Palestinians.

This line of argument completely misses the point. Well of course there are worse conflicts etc, but why people engage in the Israel/Palestine conflict isn't because they think it's the worst. It can be many other things that makes one react. It can be that they have relatives there, they have travelled there, and seen that the reality doesn't match with what they've read on the internet, etc. And if I decide I want to belp some needy in my neighborhood, I don't want to answer smirking questions about why I don't help starving africans, who are much worse off. It's really a riddle why hasbara trolls can't see this. It's just preaching to the quire.

I for one had a much more sympathy for Israeli perspectives before I went and lived there. And the Israeli narrative is not only much more easy accessible, it's in many ways part of our (christian) culture at large. Todays brand of Zionism go long back. Among those who advocated or prophesied the recovery of the land of Israel by the Jews were Milton, Locke, Newton, Priestley, Fichte, Browning, as well as the better known case of George Eliot. Among politicians could be numbered Shaftesbury, Palmerston, Milner, Lloyd George. In the Enlightenment tradition, there was Napoleon’s call to the Jews to reconquer their patrimony, during the Syrian campaign of 1799.

The Nakba, and the indigenous palestinian narrative is not at all like that. But the oppression of the Palestinians are a reality. About a million olive trees have been uprooted of the agricultural land in the oPt and the ethnic persecution and harassment by the well armed settlers, sponsored by the state.
 
One of the quickest routes to make anyone stop taking you seriously is to start tossing around the "hasbara" label when talking about people you're trying to argue with on message boards.
 
The peoples in and around China seem to not have adopted the fanatical "kill innocent civilians whenever somebody ticks you off" approach to diplomacy. Certain people love to use the occupation as an excuse for everything from dictators ruling Arabs to wars of aggression against Israel to terrorism, but you will notice there seems to be precious few Tibetan suicide bombers, even though China treats the Tibetans far more harshly than the Israelis have ever treated the Palestinians.

Similarly, Russia occupies large areas of Finland, but somehow this doesn't cause the Finns to elect a part of murderous genocidal maniacs into power, and for some inexplicable reason the number of suicide bombings and rocket attacks on Russian civilians from Finland seems to remain at a constant zero.

But but Edward Said and otherness and and. ..
 
One of the quickest routes to make anyone stop taking you seriously is to start tossing around the "hasbara" label when talking about people you're trying to argue with on message boards.


Utter nonsense. HasbaraWP is a self-chosen term and the accurate word to describe the set of sad old talking points trying to defend the indefensible. "Hasbara trolls" isn't very fitting though, because those people don't try to enrage people with this preposterous litany, they are defensive. For those who do so out of ignorance, my term "hasbara parrots" seems quite appropriate. Those who do it against better knowledge are racist and/or religious extremist nutjobs.
 
One of the quickest routes to make anyone stop taking you seriously is to start tossing around the "hasbara" label when talking about people you're trying to argue with on message boards.

Yes, you are right in that labels can be confusing. If it isn't put in to a how and why context, which I clearly did. To a large extent the conflict is about different narratives.
 
Last edited:
That's not a good argument against boycott.
It's not meant to be one. It's still a perfectly valid observation.

There will always be somewhere where the oppression, for the moment or temporarily, is worse than for the crushed and downtrodden Palestinians.
Yup. Which means that one would think those other people who have it far worse, and their oppressors, would receive at least a little attention from the UN, or a bit of charity or pointed fingers from the relevant organizations.

This line of argument completely misses the point. Well of course there are worse conflicts etc, but why people engage in the Israel/Palestine conflict isn't because they think it's the worst.
Exactly.

And if I decide I want to belp some needy in my neighborhood, I don't want to answer smirking questions about why I don't help starving africans, who are much worse off.
But if there are three starving families in your neighbourhood, neither of which you have ties to, and you and all your friends all group together to give one of them an almost disprportionate amount of help of all kinds, while neglecting the other three:rolleyes:...?
 
It's not meant to be one. It's still a perfectly valid observation.
Here's another perfectly valid distraction observation: Carrots are more healthy than french fries.

Yup. Which means that one would think those other people who have it far worse, and their oppressors, would receive at least a little attention from the UN, or a bit of charity or pointed fingers from the relevant organizations.

Who do you think I represent? The UN? That's just another distraction. Nobody in this thread has mentioned the UN other than as a source of information. Some countries drives the question in the UN for their own reasons. It may be their own security issues, justice for the palestinians, or as a mean to distract from their own failures. Or all at once. But it has precious little to do with engaged citizens and/or the BDS movement. What drives me and many others is the oppression of the Palestinians, the manufacturing of false history and most of all the fact that people like you defend these indefensible acts (land theft, destruction of homes and livelihood, jim crow style laws, military (martial) laws against civilians, the daily harassment designated to drive this poor peasant population who might have lived there for a thousand years out of there, slowly but surely).

You see, there's no hordes of people on message boards and other social platforms, vigorously, staunchly, and certainly not fanatically, defending Chinas policy in Tibet or Belarus' hideous oppression of political opponents. Hence there's no debate about it, we all agree. But for great many people, Israel, with all its religious and historical connotations, the issue means a lot. So much that they can't see clearly.
 
That's not a good argument against boycott.
It's an argument against rank hypocrisy. A damn good one.

Thousands of hasbara trolls, mouthing the exact same phrase of the day, all day, on thousands av social platforms.

Right. Because anyone who dares to take issue with the rabid demonization of Israel and Jews played out 24hrs/day on the intertubes must be a "Hasbara troll". No way they could sincerely disagree. Hasbara!!!

There will always be somewhere where the oppression, for the moment or temporarily, is worse than for the crushed and downtrodden Palestinians.

The anti Israeli-mania has almost nothing to do with the oppression of the Palestinians. They are a convenience for bigots and activists looking for street cred.

This line of argument completely misses the point. Well of course there are worse conflicts etc, but why people engage in the Israel/Palestine conflict isn't because they think it's the worst. It can be many other things that makes one react. It can be that they have relatives there, they have travelled there, and seen that the reality doesn't match with what they've read on the internet, etc.

Nope. The obsessive focus on thelittlesatan is because the "oppressors" happen to be members of the most despised ethic group on the planet, and the conflict is viewed as light skinned Euro vs dark skinned tribal people.

I for one had a much more sympathy for Israeli perspectives before I went and lived there.

Christ, if I had a nickel for every time this tired old internet meme gets trotted out. I doubt you've ever set foot in Israel.

The Nakba, and the indigenous Palestinian narrative is not at all like that. But the oppression of the Palestinians are a reality.

Had Israel originally been an anti-American Soviet ally, this current crop of "activists" would either ignore the conflict or be enthusiastic Zionists.

Yes, the Nakba and the oppression of the Palestinians are realities. Which the boycotters and other assorted "anti-imperialists" don't really care about. What they do care about is getting rid of Israel; that's what all of this is really about.
 
It's an argument against rank hypocrisy. A damn good one.
No it's not and I've explained why at length above.



Because anyone who dares to take issue with the rabid demonization of Israel...
It is not demonization to point out the systematic land theft, destruction of Palestinian homes and livelihood, jim crow style laws, military rule for decades, martial laws against civilians, the daily harassment designated to drive this poor peasant population who might have lived there for a thousand years out of there - it happens as we speak.



The anti Israeli-mania has almost nothing to do with the oppression of the Palestinians. They are a convenience for bigots and activists looking for street cred.

It is not anti Israeli-mania to point out the systematic land theft, destruction of Palestinian homes and livelihood, jim crow style laws, military rule for decades, martial laws against civilians, the daily harassment designated to drive this poor peasant population who might have lived there for a thousand years out of there - it happens as we speak.

And, Sigmund, ease down on the psychologization of people who happen to disagree with you, ok?


The obsessive focus on thelittlesatan is because the "oppressors" happen to be members of the most despised ethic group on the planet, and the conflict is viewed as light skinned Euro vs dark skinned tribal people.

As I said, Sigmund, ease down on the psychologization of people who happen to disagree with you, ok? If you want people to listen to you, listen to others. You don't decide the reasons for other people.

Yes, the Nakba and the oppression of the Palestinians are realities. Which the boycotters and other assorted "anti-imperialists" don't really care about. What they do care about is getting rid of Israel; that's what all of this is really about.

Folks that "really" know what other peoples incentives are, even if they vehemently denies it, can generally be divined into either political propagandists or conspiracy theorists.

If you still feel you have to cling on to this line of argument men in order to defend Israels (morally) indefencible policies, rethink your premises.
 
Last edited:
Here's another perfectly valid distraction observation: Carrots are more healthy than french fries.
Who do you think I represent? The UN? That's just another distraction... :words:
...what:confused:?

Okay, nice and simple, when you're done dodging: do you agree the Israelis receive a disproportionate amount of attention, while other parties are neglected, or do you not?

No one intends this as a distraction. If there is one thing that has been made very clear by this thread, and the previous thread, and the other threads on Israel, it is that people here are very eager and able to rationally discuss Israel's policies.

What drives me and many others is the oppression of the Palestinians, the manufacturing of false history and most of all the fact that people like you defend these indefensible acts (land theft, destruction of homes and livelihood, jim crow style laws, military (martial) laws against civilians, the daily harassment designated to drive this poor peasant population who might have lived there for a thousand years out of there, slowly but surely).
I don't believe it's your place to tell me what I defend or believe, what with you having spent only a very short time on these forums and clearly do not know me.

You see, there's no hordes of people on message boards and other social platforms, vigorously, staunchly, and certainly not fanatically, defending Chinas policy in Tibet or Belarus' hideous oppression of political opponents. Hence there's no debate about it, we all agree.
So... there was no discussion or dislike towards Israel at all, but then some peopel started defending it out of nowhere on Internet forums, and now there's animosity and debate. That's certainly a new one:rolleyes:.

But for great many people, Israel, with all its religious and historical connotations, the issue means a lot. So much that they can't see clearly.
Again, please don't do that. See poisoning the well and straw man arguments.

No it's not and I've explained why at length above.

It is not demonization to point out the systematic land theft, destruction of Palestinian homes and livelihood, jim crow style laws, military rule for decades, martial laws against civilians, the daily harassment designated to drive this poor peasant population who might have lived there for a thousand years out of there - it happens as we speak.
Speaking of history revisioning... care to back up this statement? While you gather your sources, here is a nice visual presentation on "historical Palestine" for you:


​

It is not anti Israeli-mania to point out...
It's not Israel mania to point things out, no. No one said it was. No one is saying you can't. Please try to take this seriously.

And, Sigmund, ease down on the psychologization of people who happen to disagree with you, ok?

As I said, Sigmund, ease down on the psychologization of people who happen to disagree with you, ok? If you want people to listen to you, listen to others. You don't decide the reasons for other people.

Folks that "really" know what other peoples incentives are, even if they vehemently denies it, can generally be divined into either political propagandists or conspiracy theorists.
Oh. Good. You're learning:).

If you still feel you have to cling on to this line of argument men in order to defend Israels (morally) indefencible policies, rethink your premises.
You know, since you're so interested in good debate ethics, declaring your opponent's stance "indefensible" is not generally a wise way to start a good discussion.


It's funny, though. I used to be like you. For a pretty long period I had a "Free Palestine!" and "boycott Israel!" signature, a Palestinian flag as my avatar, and an intense dislike for Israel's policies and occupation.

Then, in part thanks to the people on this forum, who managed to present Israel's point of view in a rational way (as opposed to the strawmen I'd learned to dislike, and which are also presented by you in this thread, who defended Israel solely for religious reasons), I gradually turned to a far more nuanced view, for which I'm incredibly grateful today. I even became a paying member of a Norwegian secular organization called "With Israel For Peace" ("Med Israel for fred").

Of course there are also things Israel does that I don't support. See, in reality I doubt there are anyone who "supports anything Israel does", just in case you didn't know. Israel does things it shouldn't. Norway does things it shouldn't. The USA does things it shouldn't. But as a whole, I feel I have good, rational reasons for supporting Israel on a lot of things, and at the very least understand the reasoning for many of its other decisions.
 
Last edited:
do you agree the Israelis receive a disproportionate amount of attention, while other parties are neglected, or do you not?
Not only do I agree, I gave three concrete exemples of it.

care to back up this statement?
I can't link untill I've done 10 postings but it's hardly disputed that there's been a peasant population in Palestine for well over a thousand years and that many of the cities are of this age or older. The crusaders praised the oranges of Jaffa, calling them 'the Gold of Palestine'. These oranges are today Israeli - stolen from the Palestinians in 1948. About 25,000 of them still lives, and can prove that they personally owned the property (but aren't allowed back because they can prove that they own(ed) the land)

Back up statement? Olive trees, that is now (as we speak) being burned down by settler thugs (with implicit support from the Israeli government), takes many years to grow and they get very old. The oldest olive tree is 3000 years (in Cyprus) and many of the trees in Palestine are 1500 years old. They are now being destroyed. It's very clever. Even if there would be a Palestinian state today, the livelihood of the peasants has already been destroyed (since it take many years for a tree to carry olives and it's not economically feasible to grow new trees).

You know, since you're so interested in good debate ethics, declaring your opponent's stance "indefensible" is not generally a wise way to start a good discussion.

You're misquoting me here. I meant morally indefensible. For example, I consider death penalty morally indefensible. But I of course understand that there of arguments for it. Debating ethics: includes that one try to interpret the other sides arguments in as good light as possible. Specially in this topic (Israel/Palestine), where people love to misunderstand each other.

It's funny, though. I used to be like you. For a pretty long period I had a "Free Palestine!" and "boycott Israel!" signature, a Palestinian flag as my avatar, and an intense dislike for Israel's policies and occupation.

Oh, so now you know me? But I don't know you, even though I can study 7,555 postings and you can study all my seven? (And I don't having any banners that you describe.)

Then, in part thanks to the people on this forum, who managed to present Israel's point of view in a rational way (as opposed to the strawmen I'd learned to dislike, and which are also presented by you in this thread, who defended Israel solely for religious reasons), I gradually turned to a far more nuanced view, for which I'm incredibly grateful today. I even became a paying member of a Norwegian secular organization called "With Israel For Peace" ("Med Israel for fred").

This is very interesting, since it's the other way around for me.

Maybe I can learn something here. Since your 'conversion' (figuratively speaking) to some part happended here in this forum, it would be very interesting to see the arguments that convinced you. If you could post a link or two to some key postings that would be great. Then we could all see your intellectual change, as it happened. And, since your profile says that you are a student, and you registered here 2007, may I assume that you are relatively young, when this happened? Anyhow, it will be interesting to see/study this change in you.

I'm also glad that you're a fellow secularist, and I assume atheist. You see, one of the problems I have with Israel (and many other countries including some arab ones) is that it's not meant to be for all it's citizens (like USA or France). It's meant to be a jewish state. I have a problem with that, because it's a nationalism that ethnically/religiously is excluding some and including some. I don't think this is the way to go in the future. In this regard, Israel is a anomaly, created of the chauvinistic nationalistic ideas from an european 1900-th century filled with flag-waving bigotry. Though the the palestinian nationalism (and arab world at large) by no means lacks bigotry (including antisemitism), the palestinian nationalism, intrinsically includes jews and christian and muslims. You could be a palestinian jew, no problem. And there's been arab speaking jews living in Palestine since forever (and they were not zionists N.B.) But Israel, defined as a jewish state, is by it's very nature excluding citizens who live in that country.

Of course there are also things Israel does that I don't support. See, in reality I doubt there are anyone who "supports anything Israel does", just in case you didn't know.
Ok, but many hold Israel to such a high standard that they create a positive double bind. Because Israel have such a purity of arms, when 'she' is provoked it's all and well to attack. It's despicable, but I've seen defenses and 'explanations' for everything Israel does. Do you support the the strangeling of the Palestinian economy? Do you support the creation of economically crippled palestinian enclaves that some years ago were planned to be a Palestinian state (what Rabin called 'something less than a state')? Do you support the systematic land theft, destruction of Palestinian homes and livelihood, the uprooting of olive trees (more than 800,000 trees and counting) jim crow style laws, military rule, martial laws against civilians, the daily harassments etc?


I feel I have good, rational reasons for supporting Israel on a lot of things, and at the very least understand the reasoning for many of its other decisions.

Well, I also understand many actions, but i distingquishthem, as clearly as I can, from condoning them. Here you blend these two moral magnitudes together. I understand how Eastern European jews were affected by the holocaust and the antisemitism and in what way that led them to wanting a state solely for jews. I also understand the Black Panters reasoning when they wanted a state of their own. I really do. I see the underpinning knowledge, and how blacks have been suppressed and enlaved. But I still hold both ideas as bad ideas.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom