Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
You are aware that the NY Times review of history books that you cited is not that complimentary to Shlaim, claiming that his politics influence his history. Morris gets a much better evaluation.
Yes of course Im aware. But I think it's only fair to show that Avi Shlaim's views aren't The Truth. His politics influence his history, and NYT politcal views influence them.

But there is also a link in the NYT article to the first chapter in another book of Avi Shlaim, so that IDB87 can get an idea of his kind of wrighting.
 
Apparently in his [Eon's] eyes, such material magically loses its credibility once they are put on YouTube, thereby making people who seek them out "people who get information from YouTube instead of reading books". The two are apparently mutually exclusive, you see, if you watch YouTube videos you must also stop reading books.

No, you misunderstand me. Of course there's nothing wrong with using Youtube per se.

I was addressing Youtube clips, with sound bites, aimed to put your thoughts in a certain direction (propaganda). Often that of kind of clips are just preaching to the quire, they rarely change any fundamental viewpoints. Moreover, motion pictures are better to convey emotions, academic books not so much. This can be a virtue in heated topics where emotions fly high. Thats what I meant with "reading books".

For instance, this clip I can imagine many pro-palestinian folks would use:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M539PgDjbas

But what does this clip say? Not much. Still, it can be regarded as "primary sources" according to you. But think it has little value. Sure, it shows a Palestinian family saved by the ISM from the harassment of some drunk settler thugs. And if the family would have resisted, they would be beaten harshly by the IDF, sent there for "protection" of the settlers. This is ordinary life under military occupation, since 1967.

However, I think clips like this won't change anyones mind, and they will not contribute to more understanding of "the other". Au contraire, it just fuels hate and misunderstandings. Pro-israelis watch their stuff and the pro-palestinians watch theirs. And then they hurl clips at each other.

A little bit more enlightening can clips from newsreports be. Like this:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tW1-_JmXQt0

But it has a silly conspiratory title ("Video Israel Doesn't Want You to See") and if I was a newcomer to this conflict, I would have been suspicious (because of the title).

But sure, there are many Youtube channels that are very god and have high quality and where people can learn something,wether you agree with the content or not. For instance, this one hour long analysis of the conflict of Israel/Palestine in the near future:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_detailpage&v=yq9PsXRbAzM#t=136
 
No, you misunderstand me. Of course there's nothing wrong with using Youtube per se. I was addressing Youtube clips, with sound bites, aimed to put your thoughts in a certain direction (propaganda).
Sorry, but given I said nothing about propganda soundbites in my post, you misunderstood me, not the other way 'round.
 
Can you imagine how much more peaceful would be our foreign relations if we treated Israel just like any other state? And you imagine how fast Israel would seek peace and a fair land deal for the Palestinians?

They tried it heaps of times and it just makes the Palestinians more violent.

Lesson learned. Don't give them anything. You can't make peace with people who don't want it.

There's never been a Palestinian peace movement. Just rival terrorists fighting over turf and loot.
 
I'll see if I have time to research that later on, I don't have the book in front of me now. But I am open for the possibility that I'm wrong in this detail. But would be nice if you gave a source (for comparison).

You can find here a pdf with parts of a book by Karsh which was written to refute Shalim claims. For me, the personal argument between both historian is not important. However, you can find text of the reports of two of the Jewish officials present at the meeting on pages 86-88. You should be able to find those also in Shlaim's book.

Another report, by Golda Meir, which is not cited by Shaim, can be found on page 93-95. You can read those for yourself.




Secondly, the Yishuv was eager to get the partition plan (or any jurisdiction) quick, and put all diplomatic effort into it, since they had facts on the ground (a newly arrived population), but no official recognition anywhere. But there is little doubt that the Yishuv had plans for more. It seems clear to me, that they wanted an official foothold in Palestine, so that they could go on with the zionist conquest - building a homogeneous jewish state in Palestine. For instance, even though the Yishuv ended up controlling an area about 40 % larger than the partition plan, Abba Eban complained and called the new borders "Auschwitz-borders", meaning they were to small and that they should have conquered even more.

Third, likewise, it isn't hard to see why the Palestinians didn't accept the plan. They considered Palestine their homeland, and were expecting the british to fullfill their promises. Why would they accept it? If someone were to take over your home, then offering you a few rooms in a "fair compromise" you might not be overwhelmed by his generosity, even if he were homeless, destitute, and persecuted.

I strongly disagree with pretty much everything you wrote here. You gave no evidence that the Jewish leadership intended to violated the UN partition plan had it been signed by all sides. Instead you gave evidence that once hostilities started by the Arab side, the Jews thought it will be hard to the to defend whatever area they managed to get. This is still true today, just look at the map of Israel.

Secondly, you seem to think that the Palestinians were right not to compromise. (And lets be honest, at the time their beef was not about the amount of land allocated to a Jewish state. They objected to the existence of a Jewish state in any part of the land.) Are you implying they were also right to start a war? If so, what are you exactly complaining about? Which side won? What do you think should be done today?

This probably requires more discussion but I fear I am too busy to really engage in long discussion here. I wish I had more free time, but this is not going to happen soon.
 
They tried it heaps of times and it just makes the Palestinians more violent.


So...giving the Palestinians the land that is rightfully theres will just make them more violent so Israel keeps stealing land from the Palestinians because this makes them .....Peaceful?

Your God Damned Logic escapes me.
 
So...giving the Palestinians the land that is rightfully theres will just make them more violent
Correct.

so Israel keeps stealing land from the Palestinians because this makes them .....Peaceful?
Stop it with the strawmen already. You are the one who keeps claiming, in every third post, that Israel "steals land". Care to back this up with evidence anytime soon? Remember, it's your claim, your burden of proof. Don't just sit there talking about how we don't want to discuss it (we do) or how olive trees are chopped down, back up your claim that Israel contiuously steals land.

Your God Damned Logic escapes me.
Of course it does. Then again, that's the whole point of a strawman.
 
All of Israel is "stolen" according to the Palestinians. That's what they're taught in schools.

You can't deny the facts Jules. They gave the Palestinians autonomy, they got suicide bombers. They withdrew every settlement in Gaza, they got Hamas and rocket attacks.

Can't make peace with a bunch of terrorists fighting over turf and loot Jules. It's a futile endeavor.
 
You can find here a pdf with parts of a book by Karsh which was written to refute Shalim claims.

While Karsh hasn't fully gone over to the Dark Side yet, he's certainly an ideologue when it comes to this particular historical topic, and definitely a polemicist when it comes to anything to do with New Historians.

Fabricating Israeli History is not a source I would rely on for anything.
 
Yeah...Hezbollah got it's arse kicked, but they WON!

By what standard do you say this? Again, Hezbollah got it's arse kicked, Lebanon suffered terrible damage, Hezbollah lost hundreds by even the most conservative estimates...? How can this possibly be called a "win"?

Remember...Hezbollah was acting as the proxy for Iran and insofar as they achieved a victory for anyone in Lebanon....they didn't.

Damn straight, they didn't. You seem callously indifferent to the suffering of Lebanese people. No sacrifice is too great if it causes harm to Israel, right? Especially when it's the sacrifice of other people.

However, the people in Iran who funded Hezbollah got lots of mileage out of that war for Israel is now afraid to attack Iran because they know thousands upon thousands of missiles will be launched at them by Hezbollah if they do - and Israel doesn't have the stomach to do anything about it.

Those "thousands of missiles" really didn't do much damage, suggesting Israel is afraid of them is fantasy. Israel has shown it "has the stomach" to do an awful lot just for the sake of a few soldiers, it's quite absurd to suggest they wouldn't do as much, if not a lot more, for the sake of eliminating a nuclear threat. Your opinions really seem more like wishes than anything based in reality.
 
No they couldn't and no they didn't. Twelve days before the UN resolution, the Zionist leadership had offered a (then secret) deal to the Hashemite monarchy in Jordan, conceding it the West Bank in exchange for a free hand elsewhere, since both parties were determined to pre-empt any chance of a Palestinian state. Jordan was a client state of Britain, which gave the arrangement its nod.

According to the never-ending conspiracy theories and historical revisionism, virtually everything that ever happened was the result of some secret Zionist machinations, yet somehow after more than a full century of exercising this near God-like power and influence over world events, the Zionists still can't achieve their goals and are ultimately doomed to failure.

Or so the narrative goes.

Others have done a much better job of debunking this claim than I would have, but in general any claim of Zionist secret deals and influence always need to be taken with a huge grain of salt. It's almost always nothing more than grist for the conspiracy theorists.
 
While Karsh hasn't fully gone over to the Dark Side yet, he's certainly an ideologue when it comes to this particular historical topic, and definitely a polemicist when it comes to anything to do with New Historians.

Fabricating Israeli History is not a source I would rely on for anything.

What I asked him to read are the primary documents cited in the book, not Karsh's conclusions.
 
Fair enough, but labels can sometimes lock people into categories they don't assoiate with. And who decides the name of the labels and what constitutes them? How about if we call one group ethno-nationalists and the other universalists?
How about we call those in favor of an independent, fully functional, well armed Jewish nation in historic Israel Zionists, since that's the current on-the-ground meaning of the word as it applies to international affairs and this thread? And how about we refer to people who oppose this concept as anti-Zionists, since that's what they actually are?


Another reason I don't like the label "anti-zionist" is that it's a negation. I'm not a communist, but I don't go around and call myself anti-communist either.
Being a non-communist does not make you an anti-communist. Actively (or even non-actively) supporting ideas, policies and tactics aimed at opposing communism makes you an anti-communist. What you like to call yourself is irrelevant. Your emotional reactions regarding "association" are irrelevant.


Neo-nazi types like David Duke and his ilk frequently call themself "anti-zionists". They use it as a code word for jews and I'm disgusted by it. Me, and many serious people in the Palestinian movement, don't want to be near these racists and antisemitic conspiracy nuts.
I appreciate your desire not to be identified with the David Dukes of the world. However, the fact that a small group of racist, Jewish-supremacist fanatics in Israel call themselves "Zionists" doesn't make me any less of one, no matter how disgusted I am by them.

Also, if it weren't for his name, David Duke would be a BDS superstar, regularly featured in Counterpunch and Mondoweiss.


I advocate the one man one vote system in the whole of Greater Israel. This falls back to the fact that green line-Israel will never give back the West Bank. I believe this fact haven't really filtered into the public discourse and peoples minds yet.
During, upon and following the establishment of modern Israel, the Arab world promised they would push the weak, cowardly Hebrews out of Judea and into the sea. They recycled Nazi imagery, and prepared themselves for the glorious triumph of Arab masculinity over their feminized, neurotic enemy.
What followed over the next 30 odd years was one of the most complete and thorough humiliations in modern times.

The one-State plan is an attempt to accomplish by political/demographic means, what could not be accomplished by force. I can't predict the future, so I don't know if this effort to eradicate Zionist Israel will be successful. I do know that many tough, resourceful people aim to stop that from happening, and I support that. I advocate a two-state peace plan based roughly on the 1967 borders, and I believe it is possible.


It's only "difficult" (euphemism for morally reprehensible) if you cling on to the 1900th century ideas about purity of peoples.
Drivel.

It is impossible for this microscopic ethnic group to achieve and maintain a small nation in which they are not ruled over by a dominant majority who often view them as a viral infection without some ethnic distinction. It is not "morally reprehensible", and has nothing at all to do with racial purity. It is a challenge for a modern, secular Zion to minimize those distinctions to the greatest extent possible, something Israel will continue to wrestle with.


Here I can agree with you. But there are many brands of zionism. We have the pious jewish pilgrims from the 1700-hundreds we have the Magnes zionists, the Martin Buber supporters; and we have the political zionism, divided into everything from soviet style communists to fascists.
Obviously, I'm aware of the many schools of Zionism. As far as the I/P conflict goes, which is the subject of this thread, Zionism is the advocacy, support and defense of Jewish nationalism realized in the Jewish state of Israel. I don't think Palestine is particularly interested in the nuanced differences represented in the various subcurrents, nor should it be.


I think there is and always been a strong moral case for a jewish presence in Palestine. A zionism that works like a cultural center for judaism and the jewish people. But a violent ethno-nationalist crusader state like today? That clearly suppresses another, more open, secular and inclusive nationalism? No thank you.
Israeli Jews aren't interested in being reduced to a "presence' and a "cultural center". They are interested in self rule, self determination and self defense. I'm not convinced any boycott douchebaggery is going to change that anytime soon.
 
I think there is and always been a strong moral case for a jewish presence in Palestine. A zionism that works like a cultural center for judaism and the jewish people.

To add to what TBV just said;

I'm sure you feel you're being generous in acknowledging a "strong moral case for a Jewish presence in Palestine", but you're not. Quite the opposite.

There is no argument to be made, the "Jewish presence" is already there and has always been. It's there in the form of millions of people, a thriving culture that includes a written and spoken living language, and a Jewish nation. The time for "making a case" for its existence is long past.

Stating that a "strong case" can be made for what already exists suggests that, at least in your mind, the default assumption should be the removal of the "Jewish presence", which evokes images of genocide and/or ethnic cleansing.

Think about it. If someone quite seriously told you that a "strong case" could be made for your continued existence, would you think that person was being fair-minded and generous towards you? Or would you find that statement ominous and threatening?
 
It is impossible for this microscopic ethnic group to achieve and maintain a small nation in which they are not ruled over by a dominant majority who often view them as a viral infection without some ethnic distinction. It is not "morally reprehensible", and has nothing at all to do with racial purity. It is a challenge for a modern, secular Zion to minimize those distinctions to the greatest extent possible, something Israel will continue to wrestle with.
This is a common thing among minorities with a degree of autonomy, actually. The Sami minority in Norway works much the same way. They have their own parliament, which is only open to Samis, and many Samis are open about how they will only engage in relationships with other Samis, preferrably reindeer herders.

Is this because the Norwegian Samis think they are better than us, because they want an apartheid state where the dáža (non-Sami Norwegians) are not allowed? No, it's because they're a small minority, spread all over the Scandinavian peninsula, and have already had much of their culture and mythology erased by organized efforts by Scandinavian rulers. It's not a "Sami Supremacist" philosophy, it's a survival strategy.
 
Neo-nazi types like David Duke and his ilk frequently call themself "anti-zionists". They use it as a code word for jews and I'm disgusted by it. Me, and many serious people in the Palestinian movement, don't want to be near these racists and antisemitic conspiracy nuts.


Too late.


It appears no one told the American Studies Association that when attempting to fend off accusations of bigotry, it’s best not to cite a bigot.

In a sign that the organization is feeling the heat from outside opprobrium, the ASA’s Caucus on Academic and Community Activism has posted a defense of its Israel boycott. The statement offers tacit acknowledgment of the fact that over 40 universities–including almost the entire Ivy League–have condemned the ASA’s action. In response, the ASA Caucus lists other academics who have endorsed the boycott and calls for supporters to renew their membership or join the ASA. Unfortunately for those attempting to exonerate the ASA from charges of prejudicial treatment of the Jewish state, one of the six scholars the ASA Caucus cites is Richard Falk, a known 9/11 truther and promoter of anti-Semitism.
 
The statement offers tacit acknowledgment of the fact that over 40 universities–including almost the entire Ivy League–have condemned the ASA’s action.
<childlike_empress>Anti-anti-Semiteeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeees!!!!111</childlike_empress>
 
Neo-nazi types like David Duke and his ilk frequently call themself "anti-zionists". They use it as a code word for jews and I'm disgusted by it. Me, and many serious people in the Palestinian movement, don't want to be near these racists and antisemitic conspiracy nuts.

The Palestinians are a bunch of David Dukes.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom