Fair enough, but labels can sometimes lock people into categories they don't assoiate with. And who decides the name of the labels and what constitutes them? How about if we call one group ethno-nationalists and the other universalists?
How about we call those in favor of an independent, fully functional, well armed
Jewish nation in historic Israel
Zionists, since that's the current on-the-ground meaning of the word as it applies to international affairs and this thread? And how about we refer to people who oppose this concept as
anti-Zionists, since that's what they actually are?
Another reason I don't like the label "anti-zionist" is that it's a negation. I'm not a communist, but I don't go around and call myself anti-communist either.
Being a non-communist does not make you an
anti-communist. Actively (or even non-actively) supporting ideas, policies and tactics aimed at opposing communism makes you an anti-communist. What you like to call yourself is irrelevant. Your emotional reactions regarding "association" are irrelevant.
Neo-nazi types like David Duke and his ilk frequently call themself "anti-zionists". They use it as a code word for jews and I'm disgusted by it. Me, and many serious people in the Palestinian movement, don't want to be near these racists and antisemitic conspiracy nuts.
I appreciate your desire not to be identified with the David Dukes of the world. However, the fact that a small group of racist, Jewish-supremacist fanatics in Israel call themselves "Zionists" doesn't make me any less of one, no matter how disgusted I am by them.
Also, if it weren't for his name, David Duke would be a BDS superstar, regularly featured in
Counterpunch and
Mondoweiss.
I advocate the one man one vote system in the whole of Greater Israel. This falls back to the fact that green line-Israel will never give back the West Bank. I believe this fact haven't really filtered into the public discourse and peoples minds yet.
During, upon and following the establishment of modern Israel, the Arab world promised they would push the weak, cowardly Hebrews out of Judea and into the sea. They recycled Nazi imagery, and prepared themselves for the glorious triumph of Arab masculinity over their feminized, neurotic enemy.
What followed over the next 30 odd years was one of the most complete and thorough humiliations in modern times.
The one-State plan is an attempt to accomplish by political/demographic means, what could not be accomplished by force. I can't predict the future, so I don't know if this effort to eradicate Zionist Israel will be successful. I do know that many tough, resourceful people aim to stop that from happening, and I support that. I advocate a two-state peace plan based roughly on the 1967 borders, and I believe it is possible.
It's only "difficult" (euphemism for morally reprehensible) if you cling on to the 1900th century ideas about purity of peoples.
Drivel.
It is impossible for this microscopic ethnic group to achieve and maintain a small nation in which they are not ruled over by a dominant majority who often view them as a viral infection without some ethnic distinction. It is not "morally reprehensible", and has nothing at all to do with racial purity. It is a challenge for a modern, secular Zion to minimize those distinctions to the greatest extent possible, something Israel will continue to wrestle with.
Here I can agree with you. But there are many brands of zionism. We have the pious jewish pilgrims from the 1700-hundreds we have the Magnes zionists, the Martin Buber supporters; and we have the political zionism, divided into everything from soviet style communists to fascists.
Obviously, I'm aware of the many schools of Zionism. As far as the I/P conflict goes,
which is the subject of this thread, Zionism is the advocacy, support and defense of Jewish nationalism realized in the Jewish state of Israel. I don't think Palestine is particularly interested in the nuanced differences represented in the various subcurrents, nor should it be.
I think there is and always been a strong moral case for a jewish presence in Palestine. A zionism that works like a cultural center for judaism and the jewish people. But a violent ethno-nationalist crusader state like today? That clearly suppresses another, more open, secular and inclusive nationalism? No thank you.
Israeli Jews aren't interested in being reduced to a "presence' and a "cultural center". They are interested in self rule, self determination and self defense. I'm not convinced any boycott douchebaggery is going to change that anytime soon.