Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
"a former member of the House of Representatives" - lol. He said "Zionist" in the first 10 seconds. It's so embarrassing that our telecom companies have this ******** and RT on cable and satellite television.
 
"a former member of the House of Representatives" - lol. He said "Zionist" in the first 10 seconds. It's so embarrassing that our telecom companies have this ******** and RT on cable and satellite television.


An expert on Zionism. Incredible.
 
This is a good thing, I hope they do more of it. It makes it all the more difficult to claim "anti-Zionism" isn't just a cover for anti-Semitism.

It's not unlike when Matt Giwer was a member here at the JREF, and it became embarrassingly clear how similar his arguments were to some of our regular "anti-Zionists" who, not so coincidentally, are no longer so regular.

They can't help but to expose themselves over time. The "mask is slipping", as Skeptic might have said.
 
Last edited:
Major US academic body backs boycott of Israeli educational institutions

The Guardian said:
A prestigious US academic body has joined a growing movement to boycott Israel in protest at its treatment of Palestinians, in a move both welcomed and condemned in a bitterly divisive international arena.

The American Studies Association (ASA), which has more than 5,000 members, is the most significant US academic organisation to back a boycott of Israeli educational institutions following a two-thirds majority vote. Around a quarter of members took part in the ballot.

The ASA resolution was "in solidarity with scholars and students deprived of their academic freedom", the organisation said in a statement. It cited "Israel's violation of international law and UN resolutions; the documented impact of the Israeli occupation on Palestinian scholars and students; [and] the extent to which Israeli institutions of higher education are a party to state policies that violate human rights."

The resolution bans "formal collaborations with Israeli academic institutions, or with scholars who are expressly serving as representatives or ambassadors of those institutions".

The vote came amid renewed calls in the aftermath of Nelson Mandela's death for an international boycott drive against Israel similar to the anti-apartheid campaign. [...]


AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAntisemites!
 
Wait, a virulently anti-Israeli organization passed a virulently anti-Israeli resolution?

Shocking! What's next, the KKK boycotting the NBA?
 
I have no doubt some of the fuel for the ASA Israel hatefest fire comes via the type of camouflaged racism currently so fashionable among the pompous "anti-imperialists". But, in this case, I think Peter Beinart has it pretty much right.

Why did the ASA ignore far worse abuses in Burma and Congo? For the same reason lefties rally endlessly against the economic policies of the World Bank and International Monetary Fund but not against the economic policies of North Korea. And for the same reason that in the 1970s and 1980s, academics across the globe boycotted apartheid South Africa while saying barely a word about post-colonial African tyrants like Sekou Toure, Macias Nguema and Paul Biya. Because for the global left, imperialism is the great sin of the modern world. And only Western governments and institutions—the United States, South Africa, the World Bank, IMF and now, Israel—can commit it. For institutions like the ASA, Israel’s real crime is not being a country where Jews rule non-Jews. It’s being a country where, in their view at least, whites rule non-whites. That’s empirically dubious and morally myopic. But not all political action fueled by moral myopia is wrong.

Of course, those of the Nazi-Left/Paultard persuasion are expected to beat their chests about these things. They're anti-Semites; that's what they do.
 
When's the boycott of China going to happen for occupying Tibet and brutally repressing dissent? When's the boycott of Russia for war crimes in Georgia, occupation of South Ossetia and "disappearances" of journalists? When's the boycott of Iran for supporting the bloody Assad regime, executing gays, persecuting the Bahai, sponsoring international terrorism and treating women as second class citizens?

I could go on all day.
 
It seems CE has run out of arguments and gone into "spam random disruptions" mode.

When's the boycott of China going to happen for occupying Tibet and brutally repressing dissent? When's the boycott of Russia for war crimes in Georgia, occupation of South Ossetia and "disappearances" of journalists? When's the boycott of Iran for supporting the bloody Assad regime, executing gays, persecuting the Bahai, sponsoring international terrorism and treating women as second class citizens?

I could go on all day.
"Well, you gotta start somewhere, don't you?".

Or, as I heard once, "none of those other countries are anywhere as bad as Israel!" :rolleyes: .
 
When's the boycott of China going to happen for occupying Tibet and brutally repressing dissent? When's the boycott of Russia for war crimes in Georgia, occupation of South Ossetia and "disappearances" of journalists? When's the boycott of Iran for supporting the bloody Assad regime, executing gays, persecuting the Bahai, sponsoring international terrorism and treating women as second class citizens?

I could go on all day.

Enough of that. Don't you know there are Jews kicking the shins of Palestinians?
 
When's the boycott of China going to happen for occupying Tibet and brutally repressing dissent? When's the boycott of Russia for war crimes in Georgia, occupation of South Ossetia and "disappearances" of journalists? When's the boycott of Iran for supporting the bloody Assad regime, executing gays, persecuting the Bahai, sponsoring international terrorism and treating women as second class citizens?

I could go on all day.

When is Israel going to stop pretending that it's problems are our problems and that the US should become involved?

I am not saying Israel doesn't have some bad neighbors (Israel certainly does have bad neighbors)...but I do contend that Israel creates a lot of their own problems with these neighbors - and this is especially apparent in the way they continuously steal land from the Palestinians and lie about it. If Israel wants to continue being a ******-little land stealer, then fine. Just keep us (the United States) out of it.

Oh yeah...and it's about time that the Israelis quit pretending to the Fundamentalists in this country that they are somehow "God's Chosen People" and, as a result, deserve the unqualified support of the US...and it's MONEY! I mean, for a country that is supposedly so successful, why the hell does Israel always need more money....from Us?!

Edited by LashL: 
Edited to properly mask profanity. Please see Rule 10.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
When is Israel going to stop pretending that it's problems are our problems and that the US should become involved?
Translation: I can't answer the question, so I'm gonna change the topic. Hey, let's talk about Israel!

To reply, to your post, though: The US has made Israel's problems their problems, and Israel might indeed be dependent on its allies for survival. That's not pretense, it's reality.

I am not saying Israel doesn't have some bad neighbors (Israel certainly does have bad neighbors)...but I do contend that Israel creates a lot of their own problems with these neighbors
I fully disagree. The Arab leaders have hated Israel since day one.

- and this is especially apparent in the way they continuously steal land from the Palestinians and lie about it.
You have a weird definition of "continuously". Is ceding Gaza, or Israel's other withdrawals, "stealing land"? What about the proposed peace treaty that offered most of the West Bank to the Palestinians? What do you mean with "continuously"?

If Israel wants to continue being a ******-little land stealer, then fine. Just keep us (the United States) out of it.
Israel doesn't want to be a "land stealer", in fact, as far as I know, most of its population would accept a peace treaty that involved ceding territory to the Arabs.

Oh yeah...and it's about time that the Israelis quit pretending to the Fundamentalists in this country that they are somehow "God's Chosen People"
Please explain the concept of "God's chosen people" with your own words.

and, as a result, deserve the unqualified support of the US...and it's MONEY!
Strawman.
 
Last edited:
Let me restate the question, though: when is the mass boycott of China starting, or of any other countries that treat people as badly, or worse, as people claim the Jews treat their neighbours? Considering that China occupies far more land and treats its citizens far worse than Israel would ever dream of, why isn't there a mass boycott in place for China?
 
When's the boycott of China going to happen for occupying Tibet and brutally repressing dissent? When's the boycott of Russia for war crimes in Georgia, occupation of South Ossetia and "disappearances" of journalists? When's the boycott of Iran for supporting the bloody Assad regime, executing gays, persecuting the Bahai, sponsoring international terrorism and treating women as second class citizens?

I could go on all day.

When is Israel going to stop pretending that it's problems are our problems and that the US should become involved?...

Could you please explain how the reply you posted relates to the comment you were replying to?
 
He probably won't return. My experience is that when they go into "quick! Look at Israel" mode, they don't have anything meaningful left to contribute to the discussion, if indeed they had anything in the first place. I'm part of a Norwegian "friends of Israel" Facebook site, and you wouldn't believe the amount of spam videos and pictures we get from random trolls who seem to drop by only to vent anger at the "Apartheid state", and refuse to engage in discussion when questioned, replying only with even more spam. They have taken a particularly strong liking to YouTube videos. The four-part map that supposedly shows Israel gradually taking over all of Palestine is spammed there several times a week, too.
 
Let me restate the question, though: when is the mass boycott of China starting, or of any other countries that treat people as badly, or worse, as people claim the Jews treat their neighbours? Considering that China occupies far more land and treats its citizens far worse than Israel would ever dream of, why isn't there a mass boycott in place for China?

What do you care? I mean, are we going to start boycotting Saudi Oil and Gas even though Saudi Arabia is the literal fountainhead of the world's terror? Naw....we got to drive. However, we could stop giving the Arabs weapons and supporting their dictatorships....and that's all I ask for is to do to Israel, too.

It is time for Israel to learn how to stand on it's own and get along with its neighbors. It's time for Israel to stop stealing Palestinian land. It's time for Israel to stop selling American Military secrets. It's time for Israel to stop asking us for an endless supply of money and weapons. It's time for Israel to stop asking us to get involved in their fights. It's time for Israel to grow up.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom