Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Tsk, tsk. "Antisemites" everywhere... :rolleyes:

Some people look at the enormity of all the UN resolutions passed against Israel as proof that Israel is a really awful place while others take a look at what is going on in the world and wonder why the UN is obsessed with criticizing Israel and seemingly oblivious to everything else. Anti-Semitism isn't the only explanation, but I think it would be absurd to assert that it is not a contributing factor.

Another contributing factor is the number of people influenced by marxist/communist ideologies. For reasons I don't quite understand, communists hate Israel.

If I were a communist, I'd look at Israeli Kibbutzes as one of the few successful and productive applications of communist ideologies. To me, that would trump any remaining cold-war era biases against Israel for being a US ally. But to do that one would have to be a thoughtful person who doesn't react in a knee-jerk way supporting any thug who happens to be anti-west.

Something you should ponder: Communism/Marxism are also western ideologies. Those from the non-Western world who struggle against western "imperialism" and "cultural hegemony" will struggle just as hard against you and your ideologies. Right now you're only tolerated in an "enemy of my enemy" sort of way.
 
Antisemitism is also found in all walks of life in Germany.

Anti-Semitism is the only form of bigotry I can think of where it's common to blame the victim for either being too sensitive, for causing it through their political activism, or for exploiting it for advantage.

Can you imagine in the United States if someone accused black people of exploiting slavery and racial discrimination for political advantage? The reaction would be swift and the person would carry the stigma of being a racist forever, but accuse Jews of exploiting the Holocaust? That would barely draw any reaction. Heck, it's been done in these very forums by educated people who are otherwise well respected.
 
Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu addressed the mishap on Sunday at a cabinet meeting. "I hope nothing happens to the translator as a result, but I can assure her of a job here in the State of Israel, should it come to that," he stated.

"Sometimes someone can rip away at the veil of hypocrisy that exists in the ever-present attacks against us, and this interpreter had the courage to do just that."

http://www.israelnationalnews.com/News/News.aspx/174098

Netanyahu rocks.
 
Israeli government split over joining prestigious EU science programme

The Guardian said:
[...] The roots of the row lie in guidelines published by the EU in July, prohibiting the funding by way of grants, scholarships or awards to Israeli institutions which have links to settlements. The move was met with furious condemnation by Netanyahu over "external diktats".

Horizon 2020 is the first serious test of the guidelines. The seven-year pan-European scientific research and development programme, which Israel was invited to join, would have a net financial worth to Israel of around €500m (£420m) as well as delivering valuable co-operation.

Israeli officials submitted a compromise proposal to Brussels which was rejected after two weeks. "We expected them to meet us halfway, but there was no attempt to do so. They just said: 'These are the rules, join or don't join'," said one official. "It looks like we're heading for a crash, but no final decision has been made." [...]


Aaaaaaantisemites!
 

Shouldn't the borders between Israel and "Palestine" be determined by negotiations between their representatives and not influenced by outside pressure?

It seems to me that such a move by the EU gives Palestinians less reason to negotiate and is more likely to prolong the conflict. In the long run, that seems to me to be much worse for the Palestinians and the Israelis.

Setting aside snarky comments on anti-Semitism, what's your actual opinion?
 
The elephant in the room.

Israel errs like all other nations: it is normal. What anti-Zionists find so obscene is that Israel is neither martyr nor saint. Their outrage refuses legitimacy to a people's national liberation movement. Israel's stubborn refusal to comply with the invitation to commit national suicide and thereby regain a supposedly lost moral ground draws condemnation. Jews now have the right to self-determination, and that is what the anti-semite dislikes so much.

Indeed.
 
A resolution recently passed in the UN condemning Israeli treatment of Syrians.

Israel treats Syrians in field hospitals, Assad bombs his own hospitals.

It's not even a joke anymore. 2014 was declared "Year of Solidarity with the Palestinian People.” The Palestinian Authority just scammed two billion dollars from the EU. Nobody knows where it is. Try Switzerland.

They can shove their solidarity.
 

He does a good job of articulating these ideas. I also think the preceding paragraph is especially good:

Zionism reversed Jewish historical passivity to persecution and asserted the Jewish right to self-determination and independent survival. This is why anti-Zionists see it as a perversion of Jewish humanism. Zionism entails the difficulty of dealing with sometimes impossible moral dilemmas, which traditional Jewish passivity in the wake of historical persecution had never faced. By negating Zionism, the anti-semite is arguing that the Jew must always be the victim, for victims do no wrong and deserve our sympathy and support.

This is so true. I can't tell you how many times I've seen someone deny any trace of anti-Semitism because they love Jews so much, but the Jews they love are always the passive, studious isolationists. They only hate the Jew that becomes an active participant in the world, and if he acts in the best interests of the Jewish community, they label him a racist.

I can't think of another ethnic group that gets that same treatment.
 
Apparently antisemites go around saying "Hey man. How's it going? I'm an antisemite." and don't try to couch their bigotry with rhetoric that's socially acceptable.
 
Please explain the polarization that is going on, with sources. Not that I don't believe you, but I feel it's weak to post a link and not comment further.
5. POLARIZATION: Extremists drive the groups apart. Hate groups broadcast polarizing propaganda. Laws may forbid intermarriage or social interaction. Extremist terrorism targets moderates, intimidating and silencing the center. Moderates from the perpetrators’ own group are most able to stop genocide, so are the first to be arrested and killed. Prevention may mean security protection for moderate leaders or assistance to human rights groups. Assets of extremists may be seized, and visas for international travel denied to them. Coups d’état by extremists should be opposed by international sanctions.

here
 
I see absolutely no evidence for a genocide occurring in Israel here. Do you have any actual evidence?

Are you claiming the Jews are committing genocide on the Palestinians or the other way around?

well it's slow.

according to their reports, both ways around. but yet only stage 5

like South africa
 
I've read Genocide watch for a while, and I've never seen any reasonable evidence of a systematic program of extermination (slow, fast or moderate) from either side offered. Not even close. Where is it?
 
PressTV interviews "expert" on Israel...

None other than neo-Nazi, Holocaust denier and antisemite David Duke. He's an "expert" on "Zionists" you see.

If you didn't know who he was, you could introduce him as a left-wing BDS Palestine Solidarity "peace activist" and you'd be none the wiser. The rhetoric is identical. He even knows replacing "Jew" with "Zionism" helps the toxic stew go down.

David Duke was also a guest of honour at Iran's Holocaust denier conference in 2006.

The Soviet Union pioneered the use of fake media to manipulate stupid westerners and taught the practice to their client states and proxies. Because a voting public holds sway over their government's foreign policy in a way that subjects of police state tyrannies do not.

Like the Palestinians, the Iranians try to keep the really crazy stuff out of their English-language media, but they often slip up and let some of it bleed through.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom