Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Which countries that let people build random crap wherever they want?

Basically comes back to this.
 
I think you should read back a few posts and get your bearings.
Since you never bothered to specify what the hell you're talking about (par for the course for you) I can only assume the Bedouins you refer to are the ones in the Negev, which is in Israel proper. If you're talking about some other Bedouins please post a link to whatever the hell it is you're referring to.
 
Since you never bothered to specify what the hell you're talking about (par for the course for you) I can only assume the Bedouins you refer to are the ones in the Negev, which is in Israel proper. If you're talking about some other Bedouins please post a link to whatever the hell it is you're referring to.

probably no need for the tantrum.

Virus posted the article maybe you should complain to him if it wasn't enough information to get you on track.
 
Anyway....

It seems to me that Bedouin have been doing pretty much the same thing in the same places for a long long time. Why is Israel now bulldozing stuff? I find this action against Bedouin a little difficult to understand as Bedouins and Israel have a long history, Many Bedouin Israeli citizens, many Bedouins serve in the IDF.

Bedouin culture is nomadic...or as Virus so eloquently sums it up " build random crap wherever they want". What harm to Isreal are they causing that deserves a bulldozer in response?
 
probably no need for the tantrum.

Virus posted the article maybe you should complain to him if it wasn't enough information to get you on track.
So where on the map did this occur? Any idea?
 
read the article and talk to virus if you are still confused. He posted it. From memory it was in area C west bank.
You don't even know? Then what makes you think it's not in land Israel annexed?
 
You don't even know? Then what makes you think it's not in land Israel annexed?
I don't believe Israel has annexed area c west bank....are you finished with this angle yet?

The issue I was asking about was what reason Israel has to bulldoze these peoples buildings. But you seem to want to take a little extra time to figure out where its all happening. After you have done that are you interested in posing any suggestions on what Israel is doing there and possibly why?
 
I don't believe Israel has annexed area c west bank....are you finished with this angle yet?
What makes you think this is "area c"?

The issue I was asking about was what reason Israel has to bulldoze these peoples buildings. But you seem to want to take a little extra time to figure out where its all happening. After you have done that are you interested in posing any suggestions on what Israel is doing there and possibly why?
I don't recall seeing any bulldozers, but it's been stated that thy had no permit to build there. Not even Australia lets people build without permits despite being formed when native Australians sailed to the UK and begged its inhabitants to settle there.
 
Like wildcat you want to compare a government regulating its own citizens inside its borders with this situation, can you not see any differences there?

See, this is where you're supposed to make your argument, but you don't. Can I see differences between myself and Bedouin nomads? Sure, hundreds of differences. If I took the time, perhaps even thousands, but I can't think of any that suggest why these people should be exempt from the same rules that govern everyone else on the planet.

Is it really so obvious to you? Then make your case. Pretend, for a moment, that Wildcat and I are stupid and explain it to us like we're a class of kindergartners. What's the basis of your special pleading? Then explain if your reasoning only applies to these Bedouin in Israel, and not the Bedouin of Egypt, Qatar, UAE, Saudi Arabia or any one of the many other countries where Bedouine are being forced to change their traditional ways in response to modernity.

you say you cannot form an opinion without all the facts...

I said I don't feel compelled to form an opinion without all the facts. That's very different from not being able to. I get it, your point here would have sounded silly against what I actually said, so you had to tweak it a bit. Problem is you still look silly after I correct you, so I wonder why you bothered. Next time respond to what I actually said, and we may be able to make progress.

..you conclude these were tents. You must have all the facts then?

Like any skeptic, my opinion is based on evidence. The evidence I'm using here is knowledge of Bedouin culture, recollection of very similar debates from the past, and that this "community" can't be found on any map I've looked at. It's not 100% certain, but I put the odds at about 95%. I'm pretty confident.

Here is the kicker...that opinion can change with new evidence. Got a picture of these "houses" that were destroyed? Great! Show 'em. I think at best you will find are some tents, maybe a cinder-block wall or two, and some tin sheds. Prove me wrong. I double-dirty-dog dare ya'.

Bulldozing Bedouins buildings is not good PR for Israel I think you may agree with that one.

I think it's weird that suddenly you want to talk about Israel and PR, where just a few posts ago you wanted to hand-wave it away. "...plenty of news sources spinning things one way and there are plenty spinning it the other way..." you said, apparently oblivious to the point that all the "spin" was going against Israel. Those were not cherry-picked news sources, they were the first page of a Google news search, in order.

I think given the media environment, Israel would be daft if they made any decision based on PR. They're only going to get bad PR anyway.

So you would think there has to be some good reason for it but damned if I can think of one. Can you?

Right, we get it. Without an answer to that question, you default to a Neanderthalish "Israel bad! Bad, bad Israel...!" You're posting it on a Skeptic's board, yet somehow you don't understand the value of withholding judgment for more information. Do you think that makes you skeptical?
 
What makes you think this is "area c"?
if you refuse to read the material being discussed its difficult for you to participate.

I don't recall seeing any bulldozers,
thats correct how could you see anything or become aware of anything if you don't look at what is being discussed.

but it's been stated that thy had no permit to build there. Not even Australia lets people build without permits despite being formed when native Australians sailed to the UK and begged its inhabitants to settle there.
Australia has no concerns with building permits for areas outside its borders....distraction fails again.

No opinions to express on topic? Or is it Israel says no, thats all I need to know?
 
See, this is where you're supposed to make your argument, but you don't. Can I see differences between myself and Bedouin nomads?
thats not what I asked....not even remotely close. I said you were wanting to compare a government using building permits to regulate building by its citizens within its borders with the situation being discussed. Regulating non citizens outside your borders. Please.....how much do I have to do to stop you from reading one thing and typing another?




but I can't think of any that suggest why these people should be exempt from the same rules that govern everyone else on the planet.
"the rest of the world" are not prevented by Israel from building...these people are.

Seriously, if Israel saying no is enough for you to go along with it without further question then fair enough thats up to you.

I was just curious if there is any reasons beyond it being illegal for it being illegal.


Is it really so obvious to you? Then make your case. Pretend, for a moment, that Wildcat and I are stupid and explain it to us like we're a class of kindergartners. What's the basis of your special pleading? Then explain if your reasoning only applies to these Bedouin in Israel, and not the Bedouin of Egypt, Qatar, UAE, Saudi Arabia or any one of the many other countries where Bedouin are being forced to change their traditional ways in response to modernity.
Thats progress....possibly you are suggesting Israel is bulldozing these structures to change their traditional ways in response to modernity? Is that the case?

And please stop repeating the "Bedouin in Israel" thing. This whole matter refers to Bedouin in the west bank.

I said I don't feel compelled to form an opinion without all the facts. That's very different from not being able to. I get it, your point here would have sounded silly against what I actually said, so you had to tweak it a bit. Problem is you still look silly after I correct you, so I wonder why you bothered. Next time respond to what I actually said, and we may be able to make progress.

Ok I was wrong that you had all the facts when you concluded they were tents....Have you have seen the pictures in the linked articles of the rubble? extruded metal section tents maybe?Anyway.... I assume you will want to continue to belittle the Bedouin structures so go ahead....



Like any skeptic, my opinion is based on evidence. The evidence I'm using here is knowledge of Bedouin culture, recollection of very similar debates from the past, and that this "community" can't be found on any map I've looked at. It's not 100% certain, but I put the odds at about 95%. I'm pretty confident.
yes, confident enough to ignore photographs of the bulldozed structures

Here is the kicker...that opinion can change with new evidence. Got a picture of these "houses" that were destroyed? Great! Show 'em. I think at best you will find are some tents, maybe a cinder-block wall or two, and some tin sheds. Prove me wrong. I double-dirty-dog dare ya'.
good grief is this an episode of the three little pigs? Are you at all interested in why these events are happening or are you more interested in being pedantic? There has been a number of links already provided in this discussion try clicking on them, if you think that Bedouin housing is inferior I don't really care and don't see how its relevant.

Right, we get it. Without an answer to that question, you default to a Neanderthalish "Israel bad! Bad, bad Israel...!" You're posting it on a Skeptic's board, yet somehow you don't understand the value of withholding judgment for more information. Do you think that makes you skeptical?

sigh, I though maybe things had changed here. Your description of my posts in this thread is not supported by the reality of what anyone can read for themselves and frankly i just don't care and I won't be dragged into a slander match. Off topic personal garbage will simply be ignored.

Are you at all interested in discussing the situation these Bedouin are in?
 
Last edited:
How is it you speak English in Australia, despite being located on the other side of the planet from England?

Are you at all interested in discussing the situation these Bedouin are in?
 
Last edited:
The whole scene seemed to me to be shrill protest arm waving drama-queen behavior. Pretty standard stuff and it doesn't really add or subtract from the basic issue which seems to me to be why or why not Bedouins can build stuff.

The basic issue concerning this particular incident- addressed by the videos, the french diplomat's claims, and the international tantrum thrown by the "outraged" journalists and European officials- is that Zionist thugs brutalized protesters and violated diplomatic immunity. Turns out it was all a sham, and my point is that this is a very common scenario.
 
The basic issue concerning this particular incident- addressed by the videos, the french diplomat's claims, and the international tantrum thrown by the "outraged" journalists and European officials- is that Zionist thugs brutalized protesters and violated diplomatic immunity. Turns out it was all a sham, and my point is that this is a very common scenario.

I agree that terms like "Brutalized" "Thugs" etc are just plain silly. It was a tense and potentially explosive situation and I thought the IDF handled it very well. I also agree that it is not the role of a diplomat to be rolling on the ground in a protest.

Unfortunately that can sometimes overshadow other things surrounding the incident. And that is the fate of many Bedouin in area C of the west bank. I sometimes get frustrated when these issues are crammed into this thread that frankly I think at times is disgraceful with its standard of behavior. Mea culpa to that too as I have at times been quick to put the boot into people.

Its a shame because these are important issues and its a shame that there is effectively nowhere on JREF to discuss them. This ongoing "thread with no topic" is a farce.
 
Part of the problem for these Bedouin is where they live. Its a place that a significant and influential group of Israelis believe should be part of Israel.

http://www.jpost.com/Diplomacy-and-Politics/LIVE-Settlers-conference-on-public-relations-316793

Sucks to live in area C eh?
"On Monday both Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu and Justice Minister Tzipi Livni who is in charge of the peace process, reaffirmed their commitment to a two-state solution, in which a portion of Area C would be given to the Palestinians."

Apparently Area C is to be split. They're not trying to claim the entire place like the Palestinians do. The "entire place" includes all of Israel per official Palestinian documents.
 
"On Monday both Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu and Justice Minister Tzipi Livni who is in charge of the peace process, reaffirmed their commitment to a two-state solution, in which a portion of Area C would be given to the Palestinians."
I think that stands to reason, No area C land = no Palestinian state, thats obvious from any map.
Apparently Area C is to be split.
Well I couldn't ever see it being all or nothing because there is no way Israel would abandon all the settlements buffering Jerusalem and no way the Palestinians are going to accept a massive number of separate land fragments


They're not trying to claim the entire place like the Palestinians do. The "entire place" includes all of Israel per official Palestinian documents.
I don't think there is a lot of value at times like this for attempting to proclaim what one sides position is going to be. I doubt Bibi is going to stick to the Likud charter either ( all that "no palestinian state" stuff...) This is a time for compromise.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom