Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Israel offered up the West Bank in a peace proposal in (I believe) 2009. The Arabs couldn't even be assed to come up with a reply, nor did they respond with any kind of suitable reciprocity when the IDF pulled out of Gaza. Sorry, but I don't think the Israelis are the problem here.
People make these sort of vague statements a lot here....who "offered up" what and when?? Are you talking about Olmert's plan? If so this proposal was hardly "Israel offered up".


as for who is the problem well let me make a short abbreviated list.

1. Everyone involved.
 
http://www.jpost.com/National-News/...ns-of-food-medicine-to-Syrian-refugees-325579

In my opinion, the epitome of charitable work. Anonymous, thankless, and delivered to people who might consider you an enemy.
from your link...

"In light of the situation in Syria, the volunteers have been working in full cooperation with democratic secular Syrian groups that have significant presence on the ground and deliver the organization’s aid to specific places according to an agreed-on distribution map."


excellent work. Co=operation between ordinary rational thinking citizens from both Nations.

More please....
 
alternately, do you believe they are happy to remain in control of a large population of stateless people.....in an ongoing festering limbo?

They are exceedingly unhappy with the ongoing festering limbo. The current state of mind in Israel is "damned if we do, damned if we don't".
 
They are exceedingly unhappy with the ongoing festering limbo. The current state of mind in Israel is "damned if we do, damned if we don't".

Isreal can't control stateless populations forever without being seen as an oppressor state which is very much not what they want...

Its time, I think they all realize this.
 
People make these sort of vague statements a lot here....who "offered up" what and when?? Are you talking about Olmert's plan? If so this proposal was hardly "Israel offered up".


as for who is the problem well let me make a short abbreviated list.

1. Everyone involved.

Awesome! Only eleven years and we have made some progress!

Welcome back. :)
 
Awesome! Only eleven years and we have made some progress!

Welcome back. :)
don't remember ever holding a different opinion?... But for the extremists on all sides who are actually a functional minority when it gets down to it....I think there would be a Palestinian state today.
 
Some idiot French diplomat took part in a stunt designed to make Israel look bad. You know the drill. Stir up some trouble that's captured on multiple cameras, pretend to be hurt, pretend to be traumatized. She even punched an IDF soldier in the face.

http://bbcwatch.org/2013/09/22/bbc-...ort-of-incident-involving-european-diplomats/

You can see on the videos that they're standing around laughing and smiling when they're not pretending to be hurt. Stupid retard.
 
This is the kind of thing that happens all the time in thezionistentity. If you can't get cooperation from the IDF in your ridiculous attempt at street cred, you
can always just fake the whole thing.
 
Some idiot French diplomat took part in a stunt designed to make Israel look bad. You know the drill. Stir up some trouble that's captured on multiple cameras, pretend to be hurt, pretend to be traumatized. She even punched an IDF soldier in the face.

http://bbcwatch.org/2013/09/22/bbc-...ort-of-incident-involving-european-diplomats/

You can see on the videos that they're standing around laughing and smiling when they're not pretending to be hurt. Stupid retard.
I think you probably should use occums razor rather than a conspiracy theory. Looks to me like Bedouins getting stroppy because they are being prevented from building rather than a band of conspirators setting the whole thing up as a process to give Israel bad publicity.... Its hardly bad publicity for Israel, the Video shows the IDF behaving impeccably.


also...beware of any site who's name ends in "watch" generally they have a particular agenda and you may not want to be so quick to stand in line and salute their article like you appear to be doing....
 
Last edited:
She even punched an IDF soldier in the face.
I have reviewed the video again and there is a still frame grab elsewhere in the article claimed to be her punching someone but its not in the video at the time mark claimed or any other time. The still frame could be a punch or quite a few other things but you seem to have just accepted what you are told by bbcwatch.


You can see on the videos that they're standing around laughing and smiling when they're not pretending to be hurt. Stupid retard.

actually I can't see anyone laughing or smiling in the whole video....you did watch it didn't you?....did you just accept what you are told and are repeating it on JREF?


Why do you post on a skeptic forum? Do you consider yourself a skeptic?


Sorry to get all grumpy but you seem to enjoy jumping on this thread and having a little hissy, maybe you should confirm the details first?
 
This is the kind of thing that happens all the time in thezionistentity. If you can't get cooperation from the IDF in your ridiculous attempt at street cred, you
can always just fake the whole thing.
What was the "whole thing" that was faked?
 
French diplomat Marion Fesneau-Castaing being "man-handled" by Israeli security forces. It's the subject of the article posted by Virus.

Man handled is a bit emotive from what I saw, from what I saw on the video they grabbed her and pulled her out of the front seat and she ended up on the ground but I saw no sign of Israeli troops knocking or pushing her to the ground. I think on the balance of probability she did the "protestors flop". The IDF appeared to use the minimum force reasonably needed to get people off/out of the truck

whole thing seemed like a good old fairly non violent protest...People simply wanting to create enough fuss so that media would show that Israel was intercepting this truck and its contents.


The original BBC article seemed like a reasonable presentation of what happened. But I have to say the "BBCwatch" article is a bit of a propaganda rave.....
 
Last edited:
Man handled is a bit emotive from what I saw, from what I saw on the video they grabbed her and pulled her out of the front seat and she ended up on the ground but I saw no sign of Israeli troops knocking or pushing her to the ground. I think on the balance of probability she did the "protestors flop". The IDF appeared to use the minimum force reasonably needed to get people off/out of the truck

whole thing seemed like a good old fairly non violent protest...People simply wanting to create enough fuss so that media would show that Israel was intercepting this truck and its contents.

A bit emotive?

It's a complete charade. She refused to leave the vehicle, so the officer pulled her a bit, just enough to start her moving. She went limp, so the officer held her up to keep her from falling, which is what she wanted to produce for the cameras- to make it appear that she had been ripped out of the truck onto the ground. In fact, it was just the opposite; security exerted force to keep her from falling out of the truck and onto the ground. Security then gently lowered her "limp" body to the ground where she lay on her back as if harmed. The truth is she was barely touched at all.

My favorite part occurs at approx 5:07. The heavy set, dark skinned fellow throws himself to the ground, gets up and starts screaming at the soldiers for abusing him. Priceless.
 
A bit emotive?

It's a complete charade. She refused to leave the vehicle, so the officer pulled her a bit, just enough to start her moving. She went limp, so the officer held her up to keep her from falling, which is what she wanted to produce for the cameras- to make it appear that she had been ripped out of the truck onto the ground. In fact, it was just the opposite; security exerted force to keep her from falling out of the truck and onto the ground. Security then gently lowered her "limp" body to the ground where she lay on her back as if harmed. The truth is she was barely touched at all.

My favorite part occurs at approx 5:07. The heavy set, dark skinned fellow throws himself to the ground, gets up and starts screaming at the soldiers for abusing him. Priceless.
Fair enough but who are you upset with? Who has described the incident unfairly?

She said she was pushed to the ground I haven't seen any evidence to establish that but people do tend to get all indignant if a hand is put on them.

As I said they seemed to want to create a scene to highlight that Israeli Authorities were intercepting this truck which they were describing as "aid"

Why can't Bedoin build homes? Any Idea?
 
I have reviewed the video again and there is a still frame grab elsewhere in the article claimed to be her punching someone but its not in the video at the time mark claimed or any other time. The still frame could be a punch or quite a few other things but you seem to have just accepted what you are told by bbcwatch.




actually I can't see anyone laughing or smiling in the whole video....you did watch it didn't you?....did you just accept what you are told and are repeating it on JREF?


Why do you post on a skeptic forum? Do you consider yourself a skeptic?


Sorry to get all grumpy but you seem to enjoy jumping on this thread and having a little hissy, maybe you should confirm the details first?

Grinning idiots all over this close-up video.



You're acting like you're unfamiliar with the manufactured media stunts the Palestinians and their left-tard enablers are constantly pulling.

Here's an introduction:

 
Grinning idiots all over this close-up video.


you also said
You can see on the videos that they're standing around laughing and smiling when they're not pretending to be hurt. Stupid retard.

I have to say that the videos don't match your words. I can see the diplomat smile when she is back among her supporters. That seems normal to me. The only other person I saw smile once was a journalist being pushed away by the IDF. Thats not many out of the full crowd and not one of them was one of the Bedoins......maybe you can find a grin on someone in there but I certainly can't. In the original video linked in your article I can't see a single grin. Certainly not groups of people laughing and smiling....just not there sorry.

I put it to you that you are misrepresenting this as much as the people you complain about.
You're acting like you're unfamiliar with the manufactured media stunts the Palestinians and their left-tard enablers are constantly pulling.

Here's an introduction:

I'm more than happy to discuss other events if you like but I would rather stick with the event you were describing at first.

Do you think there are plenty of people trying to put spin on this that likely includes you?

Why can't Bedouin build homes? Any Idea?
 
Last edited:
Why are Western diplomats travelling to Israel to pull media stunts with political activists?

That's the question that should be asked.
 
Last edited:
Why are Western diplomats travelling to Israel to pull media stunts with political activists?

That's the question that should be asked.
well lets ask that question then.

My view is that your question contains a premise or two that you have yet to establish.

That this is in Israel. Is it?

That this truckload of supplies was a media stunt. Is all Aid supplied or attempted to be supplied a media stunt....or just some of It? How do you tell which is which?


and again, why can't these people build a house?
 
Last edited:
and again, why can't these people build a house?

The phrasing of your question presumes that someone has a problem with Bedouin people having houses, and I see no evidence for that. As far as I know they have the same rights to build a house that you and I do. If you have any evidence to the contrary, I'd be happy if you presented it.

A better phrasing of the question may have been, "Why were the homes demolished to begin with?", but that question was answered directly in the BBC article; "The homes in Khirbet al-Makhul were knocked down on Monday after Israel's High Court ruled that they had been built without the correct permits."

Having been involved in these Israeli discussions for many years, it's been my experience that quite often the rulings of the ISC (Israeli Supreme Court) go against the interests of the government. Not always, but often enough that I believe a reasonable person would conclude that the ISC's judgements are based on the rule of law, attempt to be fair, and that the ISC is not an organization of Zionist extremists willing to rubber-stamp anything that furthers the Zionist agenda. If you disagree and would like to dispute that, well, it's been a while since we've had a real discussion in this thread.

My personal opinion, and this is formed from similar discussions involving previously demolished Bedouin structures, is to question exactly what is meant by the word "homes" used to describe what Israel destroyed. On previous occasions the "homes" turned out to be temporary structures involving tarp roofs set against earthen embankments with a cinder-block wall to qualify it as a "permanent structure." In this case, my suspicion is raised in part by my inability to find Khirbet al-Makhul on any map. Perhaps one of the Israeli readers of this thread will be better able to find information on that.

Edited to add: I did find one map that places Khirbet Makhul a bit to the North East of Amman Jordan, but I'm pretty sure that's not the location under discussion here.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom