Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
The phrasing of your question presumes that someone has a problem with Bedouin people having houses, and I see no evidence for that. As far as I know they have the same rights to build a house that you and I do. If you have any evidence to the contrary, I'd be happy if you presented it.
They are being prevented from building and existing buildings demolished. This was what the video was about.

A better phrasing of the question may have been, "Why were the homes demolished to begin with?", but that question was answered directly in the BBC article; "The homes in Khirbet al-Makhul were knocked down on Monday after Israel's High Court ruled that they had been built without the correct permits."
yes...does anyone know why? Why do they need permits?

Having been involved in these Israeli discussions for many years, it's been my experience that quite often the rulings of the ISC (Israeli Supreme Court) go against the interests of the government. Not always, but often enough that I believe a reasonable person would conclude that the ISC's judgements are based on the rule of law, attempt to be fair, and that the ISC is not an organization of Zionist extremists willing to rubber-stamp anything that furthers the Zionist agenda. If you disagree and would like to dispute that, well, it's been a while since we've had a real discussion in this thread.

My personal opinion, and this is formed from similar discussions involving previously demolished Bedouin structures, is to question exactly what is meant by the word "homes" used to describe what Israel destroyed. On previous occasions the "homes" turned out to be temporary structures involving tarp roofs set against earthen embankments with a cinder-block wall to qualify it as a "permanent structure." In this case, my suspicion is raised in part by my inability to find Khirbet al-Makhul on any map. Perhaps one of the Israeli readers of this thread will be better able to find information on that.

Edited to add: I did find one map that places Khirbet Makhul a bit to the North East of Amman Jordan, but I'm pretty sure that's not the location under discussion here.

what I can't understand is what interest Israel has in what Bedouins do. Why do they seek to regulate what they do with bricks? It just seems to set them up for accusations of picking on people.
 
Last edited:
My favorite part occurs at approx 5:07. The heavy set, dark skinned fellow throws himself to the ground, gets up and starts screaming at the soldiers for abusing him. Priceless.
That's just what it looks like. In reality the Jews are using their secret invisible Jew-rays to throw him on the ground.
 
They are being prevented from building and existing buildings demolished. This was what the video was about.


yes...does anyone know why? Why do they need permits?



what I can't understand is what interest Israel has in what Bedouins do. Why do they seek to regulate what they do with bricks? It just seems to set them up for accusations of picking on people.
So in Australia you can just start building whatever you want wherever you want however you want, no permits necessary?
 
So in Australia you can just start building whatever you want wherever you want however you want, no permits necessary?
You need local planning approval provided by the Australian Government who regulates Australian Citizens inside Australian borders. What similarity do you see here?
 
Last edited:
Fair enough but who are you upset with?

"Diplomats" who participate in pathetic charades performed for the cameras in order to accrue activist-cred.

She said she was pushed to the ground I haven't seen any evidence to establish that but people do tend to get all indignant if a hand is put on them.

She lied about being abused after flopping around like a flounder in order to make it appear as if her band of heroes were attacked by the IDF. Unfortunately, some of the camera angles exposed the truth.

As I said they seemed to want to create a scene to highlight that Israeli Authorities were intercepting this truck which they were describing as "aid"

They wanted to provoke Israeli security forces into using excessive force, partly to serve their political agenda and partly to serve their vanity.This time the Israeli detachment was able to maintain outstanding discipline, and the effort failed. So they threw themselves around and lied down as if injured, hoping the cameras would show a scene of Zionist brutality. It didn't work.

I've seen, first hand, situations where the IDF abused, even brutalized, Palestinian activists. I've also seen a whole lot of buffoonish fakery like this.

Why can't Bedoin build homes? Any Idea?

It's certainly possible that I would agree with the "activists" concerning the rights of the Bedouins in this case. I'll have to do some reading on it because I'm not familiar with this particular situation. Israel has lots of oppressive, sometimes racist, code designed to discourage Arab populations. Protesting those regulations isn't what I have a problem with.
 
You need local planning approval provided by the Australian Government who regulates Australian Citizens inside Australian borders. What similarity do you see here?
The Negev is no longer in Israel? :confused:

When did this happen?
 
Last edited:
So what threw that guy to the ground? Palestinians never stage stuff for useful idiots in foreign lands, do they?

Maybe it was the death rays you propose? do us all a favor eh.


start a new thread for silly games.
 
"Diplomats" who participate in pathetic charades performed for the cameras in order to accrue activist-cred.



She lied about being abused after flopping around like a flounder in order to make it appear as if her band of heroes were attacked by the IDF. Unfortunately, some of the camera angles exposed the truth.



They wanted to provoke Israeli security forces into using excessive force, partly to serve their political agenda and partly to serve their vanity.This time the Israeli detachment was able to maintain outstanding discipline, and the effort failed. So they threw themselves around and lied down as if injured, hoping the cameras would show a scene of Zionist brutality. It didn't work.

I've seen, first hand, situations where the IDF abused, even brutalized, Palestinian activists. I've also seen a whole lot of buffoonish fakery like this.



It's certainly possible that I would agree with the "activists" concerning the rights of the Bedouins in this case. I'll have to do some reading on it because I'm not familiar with this particular situation. Israel has lots of oppressive, sometimes racist, code designed to discourage Arab populations. Protesting those regulations isn't what I have a problem with.

The whole scene seemed to me to be shrill protest arm waving drama-queen behavior. Pretty standard stuff and it doesn't really add or subtract from the basic issue which seems to me to be why or why not Bedouins can build stuff.
 
.... Its hardly bad publicity for Israel, the Video shows the IDF behaving impeccably.

Awesome. Let's start with that. I want to take a look at the contrast between reality and what's portrayed in the media in regard to the Israel/Palestinian conflict.

In searching for Khirbet al Makhul in Google News, the entire first page was composed of news critical of Israel. Let's look at the entries:

Something called "Aletho News" which is Greek, I presume, describes "an incident where IDF servicemen attacked a EU humanitarian convoy". On the same page, an article from a writer for "The Palestine Chronicle" denies a Jewish connection to Palestine.

http://alethonews.wordpress.com/tag/khirbet-al-makhul/

RT dot com (Yeah, I know what it is) sports the headline, "EU diplomats manhandled by Israeli troops in West Bank". The first paragraph claims Israel demolished a Palestinian village without even hinting that the "village" was more likely a grazing spot for Bedouin herdsmen.

http://rt.com/news/eu-diplomats-manhandled-israeli-147/

A blogger for something called hungeree dot com posts the same video that you describe as showing the behavior of Israel soldiers as behaving impeccably, but claims that these diplomats were "assaulted by Israeli paramilitary border police."

http://hungeree.com/society/strife-in-khirbet-al-makhul/

Fire dog lake dot com headlines, "Israel Threatens to Ban French Diplomat Who Reacted to Armed Thugs"

http://firedoglake.com/tag/khirbet-al-makhul/

Haretz is mixed, the headline is all about the EU protesting Israeli action, but at least the body of the article explains the Israeli point of view. Still no mention that what was demolished was likely temporary structures for a short-term stay while the Bedouin grazed sheep.

http://www.haaretz.com/news/diplomacy-defense/1.548107

The BBC article focuses almost exclusively on how angry EU representatives are. Clearly they didn't share your opinion that the IDF was behaving impeccably. It would be cool if you sent them a letter to the editor saying so.

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-middle-east-24184105

Voice of America. One would think this source would be pro-Israel, but not so much from the article. The headline reads, "Israeli Forces Manhandle EU Diplomats, Seize West Bank Aid".

Interesting quote from this article:

"This is how international law is being respected here," she said, covered with dust.

Lots of sources quote this snippet from French diplomat Marion Castaing. So far only VOA editorialized by adding "covered with dust." Interestingly, it's not even true. Every picture of her laying on the very dusty ground shows her as amazingly clean with a blindingly white shirt and very well groomed dust-free long hair. Frankly, I don't know how she stayed so clean getting on the ground.

Of course the canard of Israel breaking international law is ever present. Someone says it, every reporter quotes it, and it's just a part of the normal media narrative regarding Israel. Whatever Israel does regarding Palestinians violates international law, regardless of whether it actually does.

http://www.voanews.com/content/reu-...-seize-west-bank-aid-tents-truck/1753722.html

The New York Times. This one probalby has the most neutral headline, "Israeli Soldiers Quarrel With Diplomats", it's the body of the article that describes the IDF as manhandling and yanking diplomats. Of course, it also describes Khirbet al-Makhul as a "community in the occupied West Bank" rather than as a spot where Bedouin come to graze their sheep.

http://www.nytimes.com/2013/09/21/w...-israeli-soldiers-quarrel-with-diplomats.html

Finally, not the last by any means, but where I'm going to end, Electronic Intifada. You expect these guys to be anti-Israel, that is their purpose, but mostly they just quote what Reuters put out, adding only the headline. " French aid convoy diplomat dragged on ground by Israeli soldiers". Who claimed she was dragged on the ground? Nobody but EI, as far as I can tell. Oddly, the picture really shows how sparkly white her shirt is, and how tidy her hair, even if they chose a shot that looked like a soldier might be pointing a gun at her forehead. They should have cropped his feet, that would have made the illusion better.

Interestingly, further down on the page is a "shocking" video of the IDF "demolishing tents with people still inside"!!!1!

The video does show the IDF removing tents while people are still in them, but they're not being demolished. It's pretty clear these soldiers understand that even if these tents are not supposed to be where they are, they are to be re-assembled again somewhere else. They're moved, but pretty carefully.

Although it's not claimed to be Khirbet al Makhul, it's probably a pretty good example of the type of place we're talking about. While I'm sure in their minds it's every bit as shocking and awful as they claim, they probably forgot for a moment that the typical BBC viewer is imagining an actual community with real homes and paved streets, and not a collection of tents that can be moved pretty easily.

http://electronicintifada.net/blogs...nvoy-diplomat-dragged-ground-israeli-soldiers
 
They are being prevented from building and existing buildings demolished. This was what the video was about.

In this specific place. A place the ISC ruled was illegal for them to build. I see no evidence they cannot build elsewhere.

yes...does anyone know why? Why do they need permits?

Same reason you and I do? Does there need to be another reason?

what I can't understand is what interest Israel has in what Bedouins do. Why do they seek to regulate what they do with bricks? It just seems to set them up for accusations of picking on people.

Argument from ignorance? You don't understand why something happens, therefore it's wrong?

http://www.haaretz.com/weekend/twilight-zone/.premium-1.548008

Its in the northern Jordan Valley in area "C" of the occupied territories.


Great, but that covers a lot of land. Can you point it out on a map?
 
Awesome. Let's start with that. I want to take a look at the contrast between reality and what's portrayed in the media in regard to the Israel/Palestinian conflict.

In searching for Khirbet al Makhul in Google News, the entire first page was composed of news critical of Israel. Let's look at the entries:

Something called "Aletho News" which is Greek, I presume, describes "an incident where IDF servicemen attacked a EU humanitarian convoy". On the same page, an article from a writer for "The Palestine Chronicle" denies a Jewish connection to Palestine.

http://alethonews.wordpress.com/tag/khirbet-al-makhul/

RT dot com (Yeah, I know what it is) sports the headline, "EU diplomats manhandled by Israeli troops in West Bank". The first paragraph claims Israel demolished a Palestinian village without even hinting that the "village" was more likely a grazing spot for Bedouin herdsmen.

http://rt.com/news/eu-diplomats-manhandled-israeli-147/

A blogger for something called hungeree dot com posts the same video that you describe as showing the behavior of Israel soldiers as behaving impeccably, but claims that these diplomats were "assaulted by Israeli paramilitary border police."

http://hungeree.com/society/strife-in-khirbet-al-makhul/

Fire dog lake dot com headlines, "Israel Threatens to Ban French Diplomat Who Reacted to Armed Thugs"

http://firedoglake.com/tag/khirbet-al-makhul/

Haretz is mixed, the headline is all about the EU protesting Israeli action, but at least the body of the article explains the Israeli point of view. Still no mention that what was demolished was likely temporary structures for a short-term stay while the Bedouin grazed sheep.

http://www.haaretz.com/news/diplomacy-defense/1.548107

The BBC article focuses almost exclusively on how angry EU representatives are. Clearly they didn't share your opinion that the IDF was behaving impeccably. It would be cool if you sent them a letter to the editor saying so.

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-middle-east-24184105

Voice of America. One would think this source would be pro-Israel, but not so much from the article. The headline reads, "Israeli Forces Manhandle EU Diplomats, Seize West Bank Aid".

Interesting quote from this article:



Lots of sources quote this snippet from French diplomat Marion Castaing. So far only VOA editorialized by adding "covered with dust." Interestingly, it's not even true. Every picture of her laying on the very dusty ground shows her as amazingly clean with a blindingly white shirt and very well groomed dust-free long hair. Frankly, I don't know how she stayed so clean getting on the ground.

Of course the canard of Israel breaking international law is ever present. Someone says it, every reporter quotes it, and it's just a part of the normal media narrative regarding Israel. Whatever Israel does regarding Palestinians violates international law, regardless of whether it actually does.

http://www.voanews.com/content/reu-...-seize-west-bank-aid-tents-truck/1753722.html

The New York Times. This one probalby has the most neutral headline, "Israeli Soldiers Quarrel With Diplomats", it's the body of the article that describes the IDF as manhandling and yanking diplomats. Of course, it also describes Khirbet al-Makhul as a "community in the occupied West Bank" rather than as a spot where Bedouin come to graze their sheep.

http://www.nytimes.com/2013/09/21/w...-israeli-soldiers-quarrel-with-diplomats.html

Finally, not the last by any means, but where I'm going to end, Electronic Intifada. You expect these guys to be anti-Israel, that is their purpose, but mostly they just quote what Reuters put out, adding only the headline. " French aid convoy diplomat dragged on ground by Israeli soldiers". Who claimed she was dragged on the ground? Nobody but EI, as far as I can tell. Oddly, the picture really shows how sparkly white her shirt is, and how tidy her hair, even if they chose a shot that looked like a soldier might be pointing a gun at her forehead. They should have cropped his feet, that would have made the illusion better.

Interestingly, further down on the page is a "shocking" video of the IDF "demolishing tents with people still inside"!!!1!

The video does show the IDF removing tents while people are still in them, but they're not being demolished. It's pretty clear these soldiers understand that even if these tents are not supposed to be where they are, they are to be re-assembled again somewhere else. They're moved, but pretty carefully.

Although it's not claimed to be Khirbet al Makhul, it's probably a pretty good example of the type of place we're talking about. While I'm sure in their minds it's every bit as shocking and awful as they claim, they probably forgot for a moment that the typical BBC viewer is imagining an actual community with real homes and paved streets, and not a collection of tents that can be moved pretty easily.

http://electronicintifada.net/blogs...nvoy-diplomat-dragged-ground-israeli-soldiers
yes there are plenty of news sources spinning things one way and there are plenty spinning it the other way. I've just gone through an election where one mainstream paper cut out our Prime Ministers head and put it on a Nazi uniform. Can you imagine an American newspaper putting a Nazi uniform on your president?


As for if these were real homes or "just tents"....the article I linked to would indicate they were Homes..

What good reason is there for bulldozing these things? Can you think of any?
 
Argument from ignorance? You don't understand why something happens, therefore it's wrong?
no...I see no evidence that these buildings caused any problems and I can not imagine any myself therefor I think its wrong to put a bulldozer through them. If anyone can give me a reason I may change my mind.
 
yes there are plenty of news sources spinning things one way and there are plenty spinning it the other way. I've just gone through an election where one mainstream paper cut out our Prime Ministers head and put it on a Nazi uniform. Can you imagine an American newspaper putting a Nazi uniform on your president?

On this issue, the spin all seems to be going the same way.

As for if these were real homes or "just tents"....the article I linked to would indicate they were Homes..

They were described as homes, but this "town" can't be found on a map, and it's also described as a place where Bedouins come to graze their sheep. I think these "homes" were tents.

Keep in mind that these "homes" were described as such by the same people who described impeccable behavior using the minimum force necessary as "attacking", "manhandling" and "assaulting". It's much less of a stretch to describe Bedouin tents as homes, which is technically correct but giving westerners a much different impression than the reality.

What good reason is there for bulldozing these things? Can you think of any?

Asked and answered, fool. "The homes in Khirbet al-Makhul were knocked down on Monday after Israel's High Court ruled that they had been built without the correct permits."

I need a permit to build a home, you need a permit to build a home. If we built them without permits, the government might come around and knock them down. If that happened, asking why wouldn't change anything. Next time build where you got a permit to build.
 
no...I see no evidence that these buildings caused any problems and I can not imagine any myself therefor I think its wrong to put a bulldozer through them. If anyone can give me a reason I may change my mind.

The difference between you and I is I don't feel compelled to come to a judgement in a situation where I clearly don't have all the facts. If you do, fine. It's not a good use of my time to try to bring you around to my point of view.

Carry on.
 
Awesome. Let's start with that. I want to take a look at the contrast between reality and what's portrayed in the media in regard to the Israel/Palestinian conflict.

In searching for Khirbet al Makhul in Google News, the entire first page was composed of news critical of Israel. Let's look at the entries:

Something called "Aletho News" which is Greek, I presume, describes "an incident where IDF servicemen attacked a EU humanitarian convoy". On the same page, an article from a writer for "The Palestine Chronicle" denies a Jewish connection to Palestine.

http://alethonews.wordpress.com/tag/khirbet-al-makhul/

RT dot com (Yeah, I know what it is) sports the headline, "EU diplomats manhandled by Israeli troops in West Bank". The first paragraph claims Israel demolished a Palestinian village without even hinting that the "village" was more likely a grazing spot for Bedouin herdsmen.

http://rt.com/news/eu-diplomats-manhandled-israeli-147/

A blogger for something called hungeree dot com posts the same video that you describe as showing the behavior of Israel soldiers as behaving impeccably, but claims that these diplomats were "assaulted by Israeli paramilitary border police."

http://hungeree.com/society/strife-in-khirbet-al-makhul/

Fire dog lake dot com headlines, "Israel Threatens to Ban French Diplomat Who Reacted to Armed Thugs"

http://firedoglake.com/tag/khirbet-al-makhul/

Haretz is mixed, the headline is all about the EU protesting Israeli action, but at least the body of the article explains the Israeli point of view. Still no mention that what was demolished was likely temporary structures for a short-term stay while the Bedouin grazed sheep.

http://www.haaretz.com/news/diplomacy-defense/1.548107

The BBC article focuses almost exclusively on how angry EU representatives are. Clearly they didn't share your opinion that the IDF was behaving impeccably. It would be cool if you sent them a letter to the editor saying so.

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-middle-east-24184105

Voice of America. One would think this source would be pro-Israel, but not so much from the article. The headline reads, "Israeli Forces Manhandle EU Diplomats, Seize West Bank Aid".

Interesting quote from this article:



Lots of sources quote this snippet from French diplomat Marion Castaing. So far only VOA editorialized by adding "covered with dust." Interestingly, it's not even true. Every picture of her laying on the very dusty ground shows her as amazingly clean with a blindingly white shirt and very well groomed dust-free long hair. Frankly, I don't know how she stayed so clean getting on the ground.

Of course the canard of Israel breaking international law is ever present. Someone says it, every reporter quotes it, and it's just a part of the normal media narrative regarding Israel. Whatever Israel does regarding Palestinians violates international law, regardless of whether it actually does.

http://www.voanews.com/content/reu-...-seize-west-bank-aid-tents-truck/1753722.html

The New York Times. This one probalby has the most neutral headline, "Israeli Soldiers Quarrel With Diplomats", it's the body of the article that describes the IDF as manhandling and yanking diplomats. Of course, it also describes Khirbet al-Makhul as a "community in the occupied West Bank" rather than as a spot where Bedouin come to graze their sheep.

http://www.nytimes.com/2013/09/21/w...-israeli-soldiers-quarrel-with-diplomats.html

Finally, not the last by any means, but where I'm going to end, Electronic Intifada. You expect these guys to be anti-Israel, that is their purpose, but mostly they just quote what Reuters put out, adding only the headline. " French aid convoy diplomat dragged on ground by Israeli soldiers". Who claimed she was dragged on the ground? Nobody but EI, as far as I can tell. Oddly, the picture really shows how sparkly white her shirt is, and how tidy her hair, even if they chose a shot that looked like a soldier might be pointing a gun at her forehead. They should have cropped his feet, that would have made the illusion better.

Interestingly, further down on the page is a "shocking" video of the IDF "demolishing tents with people still inside"!!!1!

The video does show the IDF removing tents while people are still in them, but they're not being demolished. It's pretty clear these soldiers understand that even if these tents are not supposed to be where they are, they are to be re-assembled again somewhere else. They're moved, but pretty carefully.

Although it's not claimed to be Khirbet al Makhul, it's probably a pretty good example of the type of place we're talking about. While I'm sure in their minds it's every bit as shocking and awful as they claim, they probably forgot for a moment that the typical BBC viewer is imagining an actual community with real homes and paved streets, and not a collection of tents that can be moved pretty easily.

http://electronicintifada.net/blogs...nvoy-diplomat-dragged-ground-israeli-soldiers

Great work.
 
On this issue, the spin all seems to be going the same way.



They were described as homes, but this "town" can't be found on a map, and it's also described as a place where Bedouins come to graze their sheep. I think these "homes" were tents.

Keep in mind that these "homes" were described as such by the same people who described impeccable behavior using the minimum force necessary as "attacking", "manhandling" and "assaulting". It's much less of a stretch to describe Bedouin tents as homes, which is technically correct but giving westerners a much different impression than the reality.



Asked and answered, fool. "The homes in Khirbet al-Makhul were knocked down on Monday after Israel's High Court ruled that they had been built without the correct permits."

I need a permit to build a home, you need a permit to build a home. If we built them without permits, the government might come around and knock them down. If that happened, asking why wouldn't change anything. Next time build where you got a permit to build.

Like wildcat you want to compare a government regulating its own citizens inside its borders with this situation, can you not see any differences there?


you say you cannot form an opinion without all the facts.....you conclude these were tents. You must have all the facts then?

Bulldozing Bedouins buildings is not good PR for Israel I think you may agree with that one.

So you would think there has to be some good reason for it but damned if I can think of one. Can you?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom