Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
I think that stands to reason, No area C land = no Palestinian state, thats obvious from any map.
Well I couldn't ever see it being all or nothing because there is no way Israel would abandon all the settlements buffering Jerusalem and no way the Palestinians are going to accept a massive number of separate land fragments
Try reading that again. The official Israeli position is 2 states - Israel and Palestine. Area C is to be divided.

The Palestinians? They still want the whole enchilada, Israel must be destroyed. To date they haven't made a single concession, ever. If you dispute that do what your buddy a_u_p couldn't do a few pages back, list a concession the Palestinians have made.

I don't think there is a lot of value at times like this for attempting to proclaim what one sides position is going to be. I doubt Bibi is going to stick to the Likud charter either ( all that "no palestinian state" stuff...) This is a time for compromise.
We know what the Palestinian position is - a single Palestinian state after Israel is destroyed. That's not just the position of some in a political party - it's in their official state documents. To date they have made no concessions, made no counter-offers to Israeli proposals, in short they refuse to negotiate at all. There's always some reason that negotiations are inconvenient for them, always. Israel has made compromise after compromise, the Palestinians have yet to make a single compromise. Not a single one.

One side is the problem here, and it's not Israel.
 
Check this one out. They push their kids into the soldiers hoping they get lucky and the solder startles and shoots them.



This is the mentality that we're dealing with. They'd gladly get their kids killed for a headline at The Guardian.
 
French douchelomat to be expelled.

She and a number of other activists had been attempting to deliver tents and other equipment to Palestinian families whose homes were demolished several days earlier by court order for sitting on an IDF training ground.

No fair not letting people build tents on military training grounds. What gives?
 
Last edited:
Try reading that again. The official Israeli position is 2 states - Israel and Palestine. Area C is to be divided.

The Palestinians? They still want the whole enchilada, Israel must be destroyed. To date they haven't made a single concession, ever. If you dispute that do what your buddy a_u_p couldn't do a few pages back, list a concession the Palestinians have made.


We know what the Palestinian position is - a single Palestinian state after Israel is destroyed. That's not just the position of some in a political party - it's in their official state documents. To date they have made no concessions, made no counter-offers to Israeli proposals, in short they refuse to negotiate at all. There's always some reason that negotiations are inconvenient for them, always. Israel has made compromise after compromise, the Palestinians have yet to make a single compromise. Not a single one.

One side is the problem here, and it's not Israel.
If you could impose a solution what would it look like?
 
French douchelomat to be expelled.



No fair not letting people build tents on military training grounds. What gives?

Good Idea to get rid of her...

The trouble with the tent building on Military grounds is bought about by the problem of Area C. The Bedouin live there. Its made up of all the non builtup and low population areas. Thats where the Bedouin live.
 
"On Monday both Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu and Justice Minister Tzipi Livni who is in charge of the peace process, reaffirmed their commitment to a two-state solution, in which a portion of Area C would be given to the Palestinians."

Apparently Area C is to be split. They're not trying to claim the entire place like the Palestinians do. The "entire place" includes all of Israel per official Palestinian documents.
you really do have a rather elastic interpretation of what weight to put on old documents. The palestinians are required to rewrite them before you consider moving forward but documents like the Likud Charter are waved away without any requirements to be rewritten or even addressed. Do you think that if Netanyahu makes statements that are at odds with his party's charter he should at least amend the charter?


But anyway...what is the point of squabbling over these documents, things need to move on. or maybe not?
 
Check this one out. They push their kids into the soldiers hoping they get lucky and the solder startles and shoots them.



This is the mentality that we're dealing with. They'd gladly get their kids killed for a headline at The Guardian.

That is disgusting and sad.
 
If you could impose a solution what would it look like?
Whoosh goes the point right over your head. A solution cannot be imposed, it must come from negotiations, compromise, and mutual agreements. And right now only Israel has shown any interest in those things, the Palestinians refuse to follow through on even symbolic agreements, such as amending their Charter to remove the parts about destroying Israel and such.
 
you really do have a rather elastic interpretation of what weight to put on old documents. The palestinians are required to rewrite them before you consider moving forward but documents like the Likud Charter are waved away without any requirements to be rewritten or even addressed. Do you think that if Netanyahu makes statements that are at odds with his party's charter he should at least amend the charter?


But anyway...what is the point of squabbling over these documents, things need to move on. or maybe not?
The Likud Charter, quite unlike the PLO Charter, has no legal weight or bearing. It's a political party document, nothing more. The PLO Charter is the law of the land. And Netanyahu has already gone directly against the official Likud position.

You're the one who insists on squabbling over documents, since the Palestinians to date have refused to do anything concrete with regards to making peace with Israel.

Just like a_u_p, you have been completely unable to point to a single Palestinian concession or compromise, while Israel has a list of them a mile long. The Palestinians refuse to come to the table and negotiate, or make counter-offers to Israeli proposals. And you, like the majority of Israel-bashers, refuse to hold anyone on the Palestinian side responsible for any of the impasse. It's always "Israel did this, Israel did that, I'm outraged outraged outraged" while nary a syllable of criticism is directed at the Palestinians.
 
Good Idea to get rid of her...

The trouble with the tent building on Military grounds is bought about by the problem of Area C. The Bedouin live there. Its made up of all the non builtup and low population areas. Thats where the Bedouin live.

They don't live there exclusively, and they don't live everywhere in Area C. Can you define this "problem" more specifically?


you really do have a rather elastic interpretation of what weight to put on old documents. The palestinians are required to rewrite them before you consider moving forward but documents like the Likud Charter are waved away without any requirements to be rewritten or even addressed. Do you think that if Netanyahu makes statements that are at odds with his party's charter he should at least amend the charter?


But anyway...what is the point of squabbling over these documents, things need to move on. or maybe not?

First, the Likud party platform only applies to one political party, a party which has already demonstrated a willingness to change that one plank. Compare that the PLO charter, which defines their government, and they haven't demonstrated any willingness to go against it.

Second, Israel has a substantial liberal/leftist demographic. Most of these people vote conservative because they don't believe the Palestinians want peace. The moment the Palestinians begin acting like they want peace, these Israeli liberals will vote in a government that will make peace with them. You can talk all you want about these supposed "extremists" on the Israeli side that are blocking peace, but the truth is Israel is a democracy, and they don't have the numbers to make a difference against the majority if the Palestinians were willing to meet them part way.

Could not agree more.

But it doesn't seem to be enough to get you to look at what changes needs to be done from the Palestinian side to make peace, nor to get you to acknowledge how much of the negative press Israel gets is manufactured.
 
thats not what I asked....not even remotely close. I said you were wanting to compare a government using building permits to regulate building by its citizens within its borders with the situation being discussed. Regulating non citizens outside your borders. Please.....how much do I have to do to stop you from reading one thing and typing another? ?

You’re still trying to make your case by inference rather than just stating it. You think these people are different, they shouldn’t have to follow the rules. Why? Just tell us.

"the rest of the world" are not prevented by Israel from building...these people are. ?

Semantic BS. The rest of the world is prevented from building in that location. Remember all those non-Bedouin people in that video? Remember the French chick?

I was just curious if there is any reasons beyond it being illegal for it being illegal. ?

Then do some research.

Thats progress....possibly you are suggesting Israel is bulldozing these structures to change their traditional ways in response to modernity? Is that the case? ?

No.

Apparently you want me to put forth a guess…? I’m not going to do that. If you need a straw-man to knock down, build it yourself like you usually do. There are lots of possible reasons from this area being a military shooting range (the actual case in one of the previous discussions), to there being a water supply nearby that people don’t want sheep poop in. Many possibilities could be correct, but speculation by itself has no value.

And please stop repeating the "Bedouin in Israel" thing. This whole matter refers to Bedouin in the west bank. ?

Maybe. We still haven’t found it on a map, remember? The closest I’ve found is “Makhul”, which is in the Negev. Wouldn’t be the first time the press got something wrong.

Ok I was wrong that you had all the facts when you concluded they were tents....Have you have seen the pictures in the linked articles of the rubble? extruded metal section tents maybe?Anyway.... I assume you will want to continue to belittle the Bedouin structures so go ahead.... ?

It’s not about belittling Bedouin structures, but nice way to sneak in a little smear there. The fact remains that picking up a tent and placing it’s components into the back of a Bedouin truck so it can be reassembled later is somewhat less of a tragedy than having a suburban home with full electric, sewer, water hookups demolished by a bulldozer.


yes, confident enough to ignore photographs of the bulldozed structures ?

Wrong. I saw the pictures, they are not inconsistent with my descriptions.

sigh, I though maybe things had changed here. Your description of my posts in this thread is not supported by the reality of what anyone can read for themselves and frankly i just don't care and I won't be dragged into a slander match. Off topic personal garbage will simply be ignored. ?

Calling it “Neanderthalish” may have been a bit much, but I was under the influence of most of a pitcher of Margaritas so it seemed funnier at the time. Other than that it was still pretty accurate. You’ve basically declared that since you don’t know why the Bedouin can’t set their camp there that your default assumption is that Israel is just being mean to them for no reason. That’s your right, of course, but I think a more skeptical attitude is to first look for evidence.

Are you at all interested in discussing the situation these Bedouin are in?

Sure, but are you?

You only seem to be interested in discussing the situation these Bedouin are in when it leads to criticizing Israel. You dismiss discussing their housing, you dismiss discussing Bedouin in other countries, it never once occurred to you to ask what kind of housing options Israel is making available to them. I'm skeptical that you're willing to discuss them.
 
no...I see no evidence that these buildings caused any problems and I can not imagine any myself therefor I think its wrong to put a bulldozer through them. If anyone can give me a reason I may change my mind.

It turns out Virus's latest link holds a clue.


http://www.timesofisrael.com/french-diplomat-involved-in-scuffle-with-troops-to-be-expelled/

"She and a number of other activists had been attempting to deliver tents and other equipment to Palestinian families whose homes were demolished several days earlier by court order for sitting on an IDF training ground. The IDF said the group was attempting to rebuild the demolished structures."

Of course it's funny that even the Times of Israel, which one would think is pro-Israel, fails to mention that these "homes" were most likely temporarily placed tents, tin sheds and animal pens. Still, kudos to the only media outlet I've seen so far to give any mention as to why this happened.
 
The Likud Charter, quite unlike the PLO Charter, has no legal weight or bearing. It's a political party document, nothing more. The PLO Charter is the law of the land. And Netanyahu has already gone directly against the official Likud position.
wrong. sorry.The Plo charter is the charter of the PLO. The PLO are not the government of anything and thier charter is not law anywhere.

You're the one who insists on squabbling over documents, since the Palestinians to date have refused to do anything concrete with regards to making peace with Israel.

Just like a_u_p, you have been completely unable to point to a single Palestinian concession or compromise, while Israel has a list of them a mile long. The Palestinians refuse to come to the table and negotiate, or make counter-offers to Israeli proposals. And you, like the majority of Israel-bashers, refuse to hold anyone on the Palestinian side responsible for any of the impasse. It's always "Israel did this, Israel did that, I'm outraged outraged outraged" while nary a syllable of criticism is directed at the Palestinians.
suggestion....spend less time writing your own opposing views into sentences and putting them in quotes and arguing against them.
 
Last edited:
You’re still trying to make your case by inference rather than just stating it. You think these people are different, they shouldn’t have to follow the rules. Why? Just tell us.
No...you suggest that everyone in the world has to have a building permit and these people are just the same....This is not correct. They apparently need a building permit from a foreign country. Something nobody else in the world requires.


Semantic BS. The rest of the world is prevented from building in that location. Remember all those non-Bedouin people in that video? Remember the French chick?
Israeli settlers are not discouraged from building there..and thats not semantics.
 
It turns out Virus's latest link holds a clue.


http://www.timesofisrael.com/french-diplomat-involved-in-scuffle-with-troops-to-be-expelled/

"She and a number of other activists had been attempting to deliver tents and other equipment to Palestinian families whose homes were demolished several days earlier by court order for sitting on an IDF training ground. The IDF said the group was attempting to rebuild the demolished structures."

Of course it's funny that even the Times of Israel, which one would think is pro-Israel, fails to mention that these "homes" were most likely temporarily placed tents, tin sheds and animal pens. Still, kudos to the only media outlet I've seen so far to give any mention as to why this happened.
your continual placement of scare quotes around "homes" and describing tents, tin sheds and animal pens as in some way inferior is simply western arrogance directed at the way Bedouin live. get over it.
 
You only seem to be interested in discussing the situation these Bedouin are in when it leads to criticizing Israel. You dismiss discussing their housing, you dismiss discussing Bedouin in other countries, it never once occurred to you to ask what kind of housing options Israel is making available to them. I'm skeptical that you're willing to discuss them.
dismiss discussing thier housing??
I want to discuss it....why is it being bulldozed? I fully understand the reason Israel gives....Its in an area where they proclaim the right to do it. But what I would like to discuss is if it is the right thing to do. I don't think it is.


I can't see the relevance of bedouin in other countries, what point do you want to make?

You suggest Israel is offering housing options to them? what options? I think go somewhere else is the only option I know of.

My view is the Bedouins in area c are getting a really shabby deal and do not deserve it.
 
Last edited:
I am trying to divine anything original said in this second iteration of the I-P thread.

So far, not seeing it. The mental picture I have is of a gerbil sipping crack-laced water and tearing about on the exercise wheel in his cage.
 
Last edited:
wrong. sorry.The Plo charter is the charter of the PLO. The PLO are not the government of anything and thier charter is not law anywhere.
It's not? Then remind me who it is Israel is trying to negotiate with?

suggestion....spend less time writing your own opposing views into sentences and putting them in quotes and arguing against them.
Hey, I'm not the one making the ridiculous claim that the PLO isn't the official representatives of the Palestinian people.
 
It's not? Then remind me who it is Israel is trying to negotiate with?
please, do we have to go round and round before we can progress from a simple thing like who are the PNA?

Hey, I'm not the one making the ridiculous claim that the PLO isn't the official representatives of the Palestinian people.

are you serious? you asked who israel is negotiating with....



are you absolutely committed to avoiding the topic of Bedouin in area C? If so, let me know and I'll drop you out of the loop.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom