Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
I am trying to divine anything original said in this second iteration of the I-P thread.

So far, not seeing it. The mental picture I have is of a gerbil sipping crack-laced water and tearing about on the exercise wheel in his cage.
Maybe you could assist? By possibly commenting on what I am attempting to discuss. The situation of Bedouin in area C?
 
please, do we have to go round and round before we can progress from a simple thing like who are the PNA?



are you serious? you asked who israel is negotiating with....
Israel is negotiating with representatives of the PLO, who claim sole authority to represent the Palestinians and are recognized as such by pretty much everyone.

Now, would you still like to claim that the PLO Charter is no more than a political party document with no legal bearing in the PA? :rolleyes:

are you absolutely committed to avoiding the topic of Bedouin in area C? If so, let me know and I'll drop you out of the loop.
This is the "General Israel/Palestinian thread". Why don't you start a separate thread about the Bedouins who want to live on an Israeli training ground?
 
Israel is negotiating with representatives of the PLO, who claim sole authority to represent the Palestinians and are recognized as such by pretty much everyone.
good luck with that interpretation. Have you heard that Arafat died? And Israe is and has been dealing with the PA/PNA for quite some time.
Now, would you still like to claim that the PLO Charter is no more than a political party document with no legal bearing in the PA? :rolleyes:
Seriously...you habitually attempt to divert all discussion in this thrtead to your pet piss and moan about that charter. I am going to take your advice and make a separate thread. Lets see if it makes a scrap of difference.
 
No...you suggest that everyone in the world has to have a building permit and these people are just the same....This is not correct. They apparently need a building permit from a foreign country. Something nobody else in the world requires.

More semantic BS. Everyone in the world needs the permits of whatever legal authority governs the land where they want to build.


Israeli settlers are not discouraged from building there..and thats not semantics.

That's not semantics, but it is wrong. Settlers are not allowed to build on military training grounds. Even if they were, they would still need permits.

your continual placement of scare quotes around "homes" and describing tents, tin sheds and animal pens as in some way inferior is simply western arrogance directed at the way Bedouin live. get over it.


Has nothing to do with being "inferior", it has everything to do with accurately portraying the circumstances. The fact is that terms that imply permanent structures were destroyed are misleading. Some of these news stories don't even mention them being Bedouin, saying "Palestinian villages" were destroyed.

dismiss discussing thier housing??
I want to discuss it....why is it being bulldozed?

Re-asking questions that have already been answered is not "discussing". You don't want a discussion, you only want to lead people down your rabbit hole, and you're upset nobody wants to follow you.

I fully understand the reason Israel gives....Its in an area where they proclaim the right to do it.

More semantic BS. Yes, every governing authority everywhere proclaims their right to do whatever they do, but if you want to discuss the specifics of it, well, you gotta be more specific.

But what I would like to discuss is if it is the right thing to do. I don't think it is.

There you go, that's what you really want. You want to blow straight past all issues of accuracy, perspective, and facts you deem unnecessary, and get straight to the point. Israel is bad, and is behaving badly.

I can't see the relevance of bedouin in other countries, what point do you want to make?

You make my point for me. All over the Middle East Bedouin are being forced to change traditional ways because the world is no longer the same, but you're only interested when Israel can be faulted for it.

You suggest Israel is offering housing options to them? what options? I think go somewhere else is the only option I know of.

And that's the only option you're ever going to know of, because you're not interested in doing the research to find out.

My view is the Bedouins in area c are getting a really shabby deal and do not deserve it.

A view formed without any pesky "facts" to muddle it up.

please, do we have to go round and round before we can progress from a simple thing like who are the PNA?

A lot of the anti-Israel arguments depend on creating false-equivalencies. You should know by now that every time you make one, someone is going to object to it. If you don't want people distracted from the topic you want, then don't bait people with distractions you know they will react to.

False equivalency is false.
 
More semantic BS. Everyone in the world needs the permits of whatever legal authority governs the land where they want to build.




That's not semantics, but it is wrong. Settlers are not allowed to build on military training grounds. Even if they were, they would still need permits.




Has nothing to do with being "inferior", it has everything to do with accurately portraying the circumstances. The fact is that terms that imply permanent structures were destroyed are misleading. Some of these news stories don't even mention them being Bedouin, saying "Palestinian villages" were destroyed.



Re-asking questions that have already been answered is not "discussing". You don't want a discussion, you only want to lead people down your rabbit hole, and you're upset nobody wants to follow you.



More semantic BS. Yes, every governing authority everywhere proclaims their right to do whatever they do, but if you want to discuss the specifics of it, well, you gotta be more specific.



There you go, that's what you really want. You want to blow straight past all issues of accuracy, perspective, and facts you deem unnecessary, and get straight to the point. Israel is bad, and is behaving badly.



You make my point for me. All over the Middle East Bedouin are being forced to change traditional ways because the world is no longer the same, but you're only interested when Israel can be faulted for it.



And that's the only option you're ever going to know of, because you're not interested in doing the research to find out.



A view formed without any pesky "facts" to muddle it up.



A lot of the anti-Israel arguments depend on creating false-equivalencies. You should know by now that every time you make one, someone is going to object to it. If you don't want people distracted from the topic you want, then don't bait people with distractions you know they will react to.

False equivalency is false.
It appears attempts to lure you away from fixations about my motivations has failed. If you are at all interested in the Issue of Bedouin in area C you may wish to participate in a thread on that topic. Otherwise I am going to leave you to whatever you get out of this ridiculous topic free thread.
 
It appears attempts to lure you away from fixations about my motivations has failed.

My commentary is about your methods. Any observations about what you want to talk about or don't want to talk about are derived purely from observation.

If you are at all interested in the Issue of Bedouin in area C you may wish to participate in a thread on that topic.

I don't see you talking much about Bedouin in area C in that thread. The article you cite in your opening post only mentions them in one paragraph, and none of your subsequent posts mention them at all.

It's almost as though you weren't really interested in talking about them after all.

Otherwise I am going to leave you to whatever you get out of this ridiculous topic free thread.

Nice to see you visit again. Let us know if you change your mind and want to actually discuss something rather than try...whatever it was you were trying to do.
 
My commentary is about your methods. Any observations about what you want to talk about or don't want to talk about are derived purely from observation.



I don't see you talking much about Bedouin in area C in that thread. The article you cite in your opening post only mentions them in one paragraph, and none of your subsequent posts mention them at all.

It's almost as though you weren't really interested in talking about them after all.



Nice to see you visit again. Let us know if you change your mind and want to actually discuss something rather than try...whatever it was you were trying to do.

Once again. The topic is the Bedouin in area C. You are invited, if you have views on the topic. Its in its own thread. The specific proposal is that I think there should be a moratorium on bulldozing while the peace talks are underway. You may have an opinion on that you may like to add?
 
Last edited:
This morning:


Classic Pallywood. Kids throw rocks at soldiers. Soldiers disperse with with teargas. Activists stand around capturing it on tape and insert their own BS headline that you're supposed to believe at face value, without question.
 
Last edited:
Classic Pallywood. Kids throw rocks at soldiers. Soldiers disperse with with teargas. Activists stand around capturing it on tape and insert their own BS headline that you're supposed to believe at face value, without question.

No surprise, it was produced by one of the kids from the International Solidarity Movement.
 
Classic Pallywood. Kids throw rocks at soldiers. Soldiers disperse with with teargas. Activists stand around capturing it on tape and insert their own BS headline that you're supposed to believe at face value, without question.

I don't accept the headline without question, how about your description of the video. How are people expected to accept that either? Can you point out the rock throwing?
 
I don't accept the headline without question, how about your description of the video. How are people expected to accept that either? Can you point out the rock throwing?

They're not going to include the provocation in the footage. They want to make it look like the IDF goes around shooting tear gas at kids for no reason.

All of this stuff is fake as crap. That's just what Palestinians and leftist cults like the ISM do.
 
They're not going to include the provocation in the footage. They want to make it look like the IDF goes around shooting tear gas at kids for no reason.

All of this stuff is fake as crap. That's just what Palestinians and leftist cults like the ISM do.
Ok, so where did you see the rest of the video, have you got a link?
 
Ok, so where did you see the rest of the video, have you got a link?
Why don't you ask the ISM? It's their video. I can make a good guess as to why they don't post the entire thing, unedited.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom