Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
You Zionists are so gullible. Clearly, the Hebron wedding party was forced at gunpoint to hoist the Jewish storm-troopers on their shoulders and sing and dance with them while taking scores of pictures and videos.
The real wedding party was hauled off and killed, then replaced by Mossad agents. The whole video is a Zionist hoax, like 9/11.
 
All that aside, it's touching to see reminders that it's not all hatred and war down there:). We all know that already, of course, but it's good to have concrete examples now and again, lest we grow too cynical.
 
All that aside, it's touching to see reminders that it's not all hatred and war down there:). We all know that already, of course, but it's good to have concrete examples now and again, lest we grow too cynical.

I lived in Jerusalem for about a year and was in H2 (sometimes H1) much of that time. Considering the circumstances, I was stunned at how Jews and Palestinians still managed to interact fairly well; occasionally very well. I expected IDF patrols to be particularly hated, but it wasn't that way at all, at least during times of relative calm.

Strange as it might sound, as opposed to the Indian/Pakistani situation, there's the potential for excellent relations between the two sides, if the right moves are made.
 
Welcome back to the madhouse, TF.

The loony bin is getting worse all the time. Can't have any thread or discussion without some twoofer, neo-Nazi, Gallowayite Holocaust denier crapping it up with articles from Globaltardsearch.com about how Iran and Assad are saving the world from the Holohoaxing global Jewry.
 
Last edited:
In other news, a right-wing party is in power in Norway, replacing Labour, following our most recent election. An anticipated effect of this is more friendly Norwegian-Israeli relations;).
 
Why do you think this?

Also, welcome to the forums :) !

Thank you.

I find it incredible that people still think that there will be anything like a two-state-solution. Israel is never going to leav the West Bank. Ian Lustick in NYT sums it up. And what is he summing up? What allmost all of academia have known for a decade now. There won't be any Palestinian state, at least not a viable state.
 
Thank you.

I find it incredible that people still think that there will be anything like a two-state-solution. Israel is never going to leav the West Bank. Ian Lustick in NYT sums it up. And what is he summing up? What allmost all of academia have known for a decade now. There won't be any Palestinian state, at least not a viable state.

They can start their own state any time they want to. What you mean is that there will never be a state where they get everything they want in the land dispute. That would require compromise, something they refuse.
 
Israel offered up the West Bank in a peace proposal in (I believe) 2009. The Arabs couldn't even be assed to come up with a reply, nor did they respond with any kind of suitable reciprocity when the IDF pulled out of Gaza. Sorry, but I don't think the Israelis are the problem here.
 
Thank you.

I find it incredible that people still think that there will be anything like a two-state-solution. Israel is never going to leav the West Bank. Ian Lustick in NYT sums it up. And what is he summing up? What allmost all of academia have known for a decade now. There won't be any Palestinian state, at least not a viable state.

I read that article, but didn't find it particularly insightful.

Excerpt:

...Israel will face the stark challenge of controlling economic and political activity and all land and water resources from the Jordan River to the Mediterranean Sea. The stage will be set for ruthless oppression, mass mobilization, riots, brutality, terror, Jewish and Arab emigration and rising tides of international condemnation of Israel. And faced with growing outrage, America will no longer be able to offer unconditional support for Israel. Once the illusion of a neat and palatable solution to the conflict disappears, Israeli leaders may then begin to see, as South Africa’s white leaders saw in the late 1980s, that their behavior is producing isolation, emigration and hopelessness.

So his idea boils down to abandoning the idea of a two-state solution, and then Israel will get down to the brutal oppression it secretly wants, leading to world condemnation and isolation. It seems to me there is just no end of Palestinian suffering anti-Israel types are willing to accept if it leads to an end of Israel.

Then his formula for peace?

Fresh thinking could then begin about Israel’s place in a rapidly changing region. There could be generous compensation for lost property. Negotiating with Arabs and Palestinians based on satisfying their key political requirements, rather than on maximizing Israeli prerogatives, might yield more security and legitimacy. Perhaps publicly acknowledging Israeli mistakes and responsibility for the suffering of Palestinians would enable the Arab side to accept less than what it imagines as full justice. And perhaps Israel’s potent but essentially unusable nuclear weapons arsenal could be sacrificed for a verified and strictly enforced W.M.D.-free zone in the Middle East.


Composed entirely of Israeli concessions, Israeli apologies, and then Israel neutering itself militarily. Then maybe the Arab side will be willing to accept something less than what it feels is full justice.

I'll say again what I've been saying for years. Israel can't create peace all by itself. In order for there to be peace between the Israelis and Palestinians, both Israelis and Palestinians need to play a role in making it happen. Those who can't imagine what Palestinians might do to help, have no rational ideas to contribute. Those who are willing to see Palestinian suffering continue until Israel is properly punished or eliminated don't really have Palestinian interests at heart.

A link to the article, if anyone wants to read it.

http://www.nytimes.com/2013/09/15/o...illusion.html?pagewanted=1&_r=1&smid=tw-share
 
Thank you.

I find it incredible that people still think that there will be anything like a two-state-solution. Israel is never going to leav the West Bank. Ian Lustick in NYT sums it up. And what is he summing up? What allmost all of academia have known for a decade now. There won't be any Palestinian state, at least not a viable state.

The Israeli public won't get behind the idea of a truly viable, mostly contiguous Palestinian state until they are convinced it won't be used as a programmed stage in an effort to accomplish politically what they failed to accomplish militarily.

I don't blame them.
 
Israeli organization delivers hundreds of tons of food, medicine to Syrian refugees

"Nobody asks permission to kill. We do not ask permission to save lives," says NGO’s founder.

Seventy tons of sanitation items, 670 tons of food, 120 tons of basic home items and 20 tons of medication are just a sample of the aid one Israeli NGO has delivered to Syrian refugees amid the current crisis.

The mission of the nonprofit organization, which has been operating since the early 2000s, is to provide lifesaving aid to communities affected by natural disasters or human conflicts, exclusively in countries that lack diplomatic relations with Israel and places where the regime prevents the entry of conventional international humanitarian organizations.

http://www.jpost.com/National-News/...ns-of-food-medicine-to-Syrian-refugees-325579

In my opinion, the epitome of charitable work. Anonymous, thankless, and delivered to people who might consider you an enemy.
 
They can start their own state any time they want to. What you mean is that there will never be a state where they get everything they want in the land dispute. That would require compromise, something they refuse.

They can start thier own state anytime they want??
And here is us all thinking that this was a difficult Issue.

Seems to me Israel has two basic choices, Attempt to run a "jewish state" where the Majority of people living in areas it controls are not Jewish.....or.... proclaim the final borders of Israel and get on with their lives and allow the stateless people in the occupied territories to establish their own nation.

Either way, lets get on with it eh?
 
The Israeli public won't get behind the idea of a truly viable, mostly contiguous Palestinian state until they are convinced it won't be used as a programmed stage in an effort to accomplish politically what they failed to accomplish militarily.

I don't blame them.
alternately, do you believe they are happy to remain in control of a large population of stateless people.....in an ongoing festering limbo?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom