Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
I think probably the best way* to get a democracy is to start with a dictatorship that establishes strong social institutions: rule of law, minority rights, etc., and then abdicates in favor of the citizens governing those institutions themselves through democratic means.

I think that, by it's very nature (needing to rule by fear or force or whipped up hysteria), a dictatorship is likely to erode rather than strengthen the civic and social institutions and ethos that makes democracy work.

The most certain way is probably a gentle evolution towards freedom and democracy (i.e. the Anglosphere model).
 
No one here is prepared to say what they think. You will have to withdraw your claim.

About the legality of the West Bank settlements according to international law as determined by the UN security council and other accredited international bodies? The settlements are illegal. They violate the fourth Geneva convention, as determined by the both the UN and the ICOJ.

There is a dirty covert, and sometimes overt, state of war between Israel and its enemies, with all participants using blatantly illegal tactics. Kidnapping, missile attacks on civilian targets, bus bombing, settlement expansion, assassination, conducting combat operations out of uniform and more.

So now you can stop whining about no one having the guts to answer this irrelevant question.
 
Nothing but the sound of crickets chirping from a_u_p.

The latest I readwas that Abass was prepared too accept borders based on the original Oslo accords that Israel as a nation had already sign up to. Hence his pre conditions . The number of Acts of violence from the west bank was considerably less than fromGaza,
Crickets chirping over the illegal settlements ,
 
Last edited:
What, is every single person in the thread required to answer you now :confused: ?
I have replied, as has trustbutverify, so I don't really see what you're doing, to be honest.
 
The latest I readwas that Abass was prepared too accept borders based on the original Oslo accords that Israel as a nation had already sign up to. Hence his pre conditions . The number of Acts of violence from the west bank was considerably less than fromGaza,
Crickets chirping over the illegal settlements ,
Ah, so you can't find a single example of any Palestinian concession ever, just something you read that Abbas might consider a concession of some sort at some time in the future if certain conditons are met.

So I guess it's official that you admit that the Palestinians have never made any concessions?
 
I am wondering if we will get a show of hands for how many people think the settlements are illegal.


I think they are not illegal.

The reasons have already been discussed in this thread here,

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=9249485#post9249485

and here,

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=9421055#post9421055

And in many other places as this subject has come up time and time again in the ten years or so I've been following this topic on this forum.

In a larger sense, their legality can't be anything other than undetermined. One could make an argument one way or another, but the legal authority to rule on those arguments doesn't exist. If we were talking about some state law, there would be a court system in place to decide disputes and to make a final ruling. When the issue is the behavior of nations, and someone who understands international law better than I do is certainly free to correct me, but I don't believe there is any court that has jurisdiction unless all nations involved voluntarily grant it jurisdiction, which is something Israel won't do.

In another sense still, it doesn't matter. People use this issue as an excuse. The settlements are "illegal", therefore it's okay to hate Israel and blame them for the failure of the peace process. Or the settlements are "illegal", therefore you can't blame Palestinians for continued violence and non-participation in the peace process.

Both are wrong, regardless of the legality of the settlements.

Both Israelis and Palestinians need peace and security. Both Israelis and Palestinians are responsible for and need to do their part in making peace happen. In making peace, both Palestinians and Israelis will need to suck up some things they don't like. The problem with the "pro-Palestinian" side is they don't want the Palestinians to compromise, they want them to win, and they're willing to see them suffer for generation after generation to do it, because they hate Israel and Israelis that much.
 
I have always thought that HAMAS was a dead end for the Palestinians.

That's a start. Now just recognize that Fatah isn't any better, and you will have some progress.

I don't know anyone who want's anything like it to be erased from the pages of time.

Really?! Not even anyone of the Iranian persuasion?

I have always been in favour of a two state solution.

As opposed to what, exactly?

To suggest that it is " facing down .... a planet which would like nothing better than to erase it from the pages of time." is sheer paranoia. The UN voted for the existence of Israel.

What's the UN voting record been like since? Do you think it's been fair, recognizing Israel's right to self-defense?

That those already living in the region had other plans for where Israel now exists is hardly surprising.

What were these plans? Can you show some documentation for them?

The push for more settlements never stops, and is backed by the highly influential Yesha political group.


http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-3810852,00.html

First, the article you quote is from 2009. Second, your assertion isn't true. Israel has closed and pulled back many settlements, and for many years now the only "new" settlements you hear of are just new buildings in existing communities.

Check out these West Bank settlements that have been closed.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sa-Nur

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homesh

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ganim

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kadim


The Likud Charter says...

Yet somehow it's the head of Likud, Netanyahu, who approved the release of violent Palestinian prisoners to bring the PA back to the negotiation table. How do you reconcile that apparent contradiction?

How do you explain Netanyahu endorsing the creation of a Palestinian State in his Bar-Ilan Speech in 2009?

Ghandi/MLK are very rare people.

They were pioneers.

Once an idea has been pioneered, copying it isn't a big deal.

Most of what they had wanted for their own state.


Evidence? I'd like a time and date for when this "concession" was made.
 
There's little hostility at the moment. Only one Israeli soldier has been killed this year which probably makes it the most peaceful year since Israel became independent.

We shouldn't ruin this with a peace process.
 
A democracy accepts the need for compromise and does not chase a futile zero sum game that only leads to more and more piles of corpses

Try compromising with a side that idolises the Nazis and calls for your nation's utter destruction.
 
What goes on in UNRWA's summer camps for Palestinian "refugees".

Indoctrination into "right of return" BS, victimhood and violence.



If the UN was honest, they'd teach these kids that their ancestors ran away from a war they started and were then sold out by their cynical, opportunistic leaders after they got their asses kicked.
 
Last edited:
Apparently the key to ending Palestinian/Israeli hostility is Psy's "Gangnam Style".

That's a great video. :)

Not according to this freedom fighter. He mad.

A story about Hebron made it to international news outlets again this week: a group of Israeli soldiers from the Givati Infrantry Brigade were filmed dancing at a Palestinian wedding. One soldier was carried around on the shoulders of various wedding attendees. Why were they there? Most likely, they were simply on patrol, heard familiar music, and "asked" to come in and dance. Because no Palestinian says "no" to a soldier in Hebron. It's pretty much impossible.

But the power dynamic is no different: fear permeates the lives of Palestinians in Hebron, and this fear is used to control them. When you rule at gunpoint, your subjects will always do what you say. It doesn't mean they like you. It doesn't mean they consent.
 
Not according to this freedom fighter. He mad.
A story about Hebron made it to international news outlets again this week: a group of Israeli soldiers from the Givati Infrantry Brigade were filmed dancing at a Palestinian wedding. One soldier was carried around on the shoulders of various wedding attendees. Why were they there? Most likely, they were simply on patrol, heard familiar music, and "asked" to come in and dance. Because no Palestinian says "no" to a soldier in Hebron. It's pretty much impossible.
Hilited the words which show the author is just making stuff up and has no first hand knowledge.
 
He's from a hard-left Israeli organization that goes around collecting second or third-hand anecdotes from soldiers to make the IDF look bad.

They get funding by some European governments. I found out that you can make a lot of money as an "NGO" feeding the narrative.
 
Last edited:
Hilited the words which show the author is just making stuff up and has no first hand knowledge.

He's from a hard-left Israeli organization that goes around collecting second or third-hand anecdotes from soldiers to make the IDF look bad.

They get funding by some European governments. I found out that you can make a lot of money as an "NGO" feeding the narrative.

You Zionists are so gullible. Clearly, the Hebron wedding party was forced at gunpoint to hoist the Jewish storm-troopers on their shoulders and sing and dance with them while taking scores of pictures and videos.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom