I am wondering if we will get a show of hands for how many people think the settlements are illegal.
I think they are not illegal.
The reasons have already been discussed in this thread here,
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=9249485#post9249485
and here,
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=9421055#post9421055
And in many other places as this subject has come up time and time again in the ten years or so I've been following this topic on this forum.
In a larger sense, their legality can't be anything other than undetermined. One could make an argument one way or another, but the legal authority to rule on those arguments doesn't exist. If we were talking about some state law, there would be a court system in place to decide disputes and to make a final ruling. When the issue is the behavior of nations, and someone who understands international law better than I do is certainly free to correct me, but I don't believe there is any court that has jurisdiction unless all nations involved voluntarily grant it jurisdiction, which is something Israel won't do.
In another sense still, it doesn't matter. People use this issue as an excuse. The settlements are "illegal", therefore it's okay to hate Israel and blame them for the failure of the peace process. Or the settlements are "illegal", therefore you can't blame Palestinians for continued violence and non-participation in the peace process.
Both are wrong, regardless of the legality of the settlements.
Both Israelis and Palestinians need peace and security. Both Israelis and Palestinians are responsible for and need to do their part in making peace happen. In making peace, both Palestinians and Israelis will need to suck up some things they don't like. The problem with the "pro-Palestinian" side is they don't want the Palestinians to compromise, they want them to win, and they're willing to see them suffer for generation after generation to do it, because they hate Israel and Israelis that much.