Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
I don't know anyone who want's anything like it to be erased from the pages of time. I have always been in favour of a two state solution. To suggest that it is " facing down .... a planet which would like nothing better than to erase it from the pages of time." is sheer paranoia. The UN voted for the existence of Israel. That those already living in the region had other plans for where Israel now exists is hardly surprising. It was two thousand years since a formal state of Israel had existed, a lot of time for other history to be happening there.

It's not paranoia. Every Palestinian party advocates the destruction of Israel. Anything else is unelectable. Not that they have elections anymore but whatever.

Iran is trying to build a nuke and has repeatedly called for wiping Israel off the map and is the world's biggest state sponsor of terrorism, most of it targeting Israel.

All of the Arab countries would love to destroy Israel. The only thing stopping them is Israel's deterrence and the knowledge that their armies are incompetent in a real fight and are there for show.

If the Arab leaders are bad, the populations they rule over are worse. With precious few exceptions they hate Israel so much they can't even think straight. The Arabic translation of Mein Kampf is a bestseller over there.

There's a host of demagogues and communist dinosaurs allied with the anti-Israel bloc and any two-bit thug that runs a decrepit economy can get some Saudi oil money thrown their way if they stand up in the UN and denounce Israel.

On top of that there's the Western left who are allied with these idiots. The Western media that runs Palestinian propaganda and calls it "news". Increasingly sympathetic Western governments that fund anti-Israel NGOs. (there's a good place to cut spending).

Of course the duped Western leftists don't want to "destroy Israel". Oh God no. That would be antisemitic. They just don't want them defending themselves or anything, which is like, a war crime or something.
 
Last edited:
It's not paranoia. Every Palestinian party advocates the destruction of Israel. Anything else is unelectable. Not that they have elections anymore but whatever.

Iran is trying to build a nuke and has repeatedly called for wiping Israel off the map and is the world's biggest state sponsor of terrorism, most of it targeting Israel.

All of the Arab countries would love to destroy Israel. The only thing stopping them is Israel's deterrence and the knowledge that their armies are incompetent in a real fight and are there for show.

If the Arab leaders are bad, the populations they rule over are worse. With precious few exceptions they hate Israel so much they can't even think straight. The Arabic translation of Mein Kampf is a bestseller over there.

There's a host of demagogues and communist dinosaurs allied with the anti-Israel bloc and any two-bit thug that runs a decrepit economy can get some Saudi oil money thrown their way if they stand up in the UN and denounce Israel.

On top of that there's the Western left who are allied with these idiots. The Western media that runs Palestinian propaganda and calls it "news". Increasingly sympathetic Western governments that fund anti-Israel NGOs. (there's a good place to cut spending).

Of course the duped Western leftists don't want to "destroy Israel". Oh God no. That would be antisemitic. They just don't want them defending themselves or anything, which is like, a war crime or something.

A pile of straw so high it is impossible to respond. Israel has numerous allies around the world, it has been a member of the UN since about the time the UN started. You seem to post in the Australian time zone. Australia has long provided bi-partisan support of Israel.

The specific claim was that the whole world wants Israel gone. Nothing could be farther from the truth.
 
Last edited:
It's easy to preach on what a democracy should be when you have none of its responsibilities or risks.
An well thought out observation. I am trying to use it in a discussion elsewhere regarding what American politicians are demanding of Egypt. :cool:
It's not paranoia. Every Palestinian party advocates the destruction of Israel. Anything else is unelectable.
At the moment, this state of play seems to be part of why the various political efforts at a workable deal are uphill battles.

I will make one further note: this thread, and its previous version, reminds me of a hamster wheel. :p
 
An well thought out observation. I am trying to use it in a discussion elsewhere regarding what American politicians are demanding of Egypt. :cool:

At the moment, this state of play seems to be part of why the various political efforts at a workable deal are uphill battles.

I will make one further note: this thread, and its previous version, reminds me of a hamster wheel. :p

The push for more settlements never stops, and is backed by the highly influential Yesha political group.

"The Netanyahu government was elected based on its promise to promote settlement activity in the West Bank, but immediately after it was established this government began to constrain the settlement enterprise. The cabinet ministers are obligated to prevent this," he said.
'Prevent another Sharon trauma'

MK Hotovely told Ynet, "We are calling on the PM to return to the principles of the Likud party. The party's charter does not make a distinction between the status of the West Bank and east Jerusalem – that is Kadima's charter.

"We must not adopt the Left's policy after the Israeli public voted Right. We'll continue building in the West Bank," she said, adding, "No one in Israel actually believes this move will jumpstart the (peace) negotiations."
MK Danon aid, "We were elected to bolster the settlement enterprise, not freeze construction. The freeze constitutes a statement that the settlements are an obstacle to peace, while up until this point Likud has backed the concept that the settlers guarantee Israel's security.
http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-3810852,00.html

The Israeli political system has been on a continuous move to the right for years. Can there be a two state solution when the most powerful political groups in the Israel are working as hard and as fast as they can that a second state cannot exist.

The Likud Charter says.

"The Jewish communities in Judea, Samaria and Gaza are the realization of Zionist values. Settlement of the land is a clear expression of the unassailable right of the Jewish people to the Land of Israel and constitutes an important asset in the defense of the vital interests of the State of Israel. The Likud will continue to strengthen and develop these communities and will prevent their uprooting."[16]
Similarly, they claim the Jordan River as the permanent eastern border to Israel and it also claims Jerusalem as belonging to Israel.

  • The 'Peace & Security' chapter of the 1999 Likud Party platform rejects a Palestinian state.
"The Government of Israel flatly rejects the establishment of a Palestinian Arab state west of the Jordan river. The Palestinians can run their lives freely in the framework of self-rule, but not as an independent and sovereign state. Thus, for example, in matters of foreign affairs, security, immigration and ecology, their activity shall be limited in accordance with imperatives of Israel’s existence, security and national needs."[16]


So what's worse, destroy a state, or preventing one from being formed in an act of self determination.



* that is if Fatah is intent on destroying Israel. From what I have seen, the Oslo peace talks were held in good faith by both sides, they were destroyed by extremists on both sides who did not want peace, such as Likud under Netanyahu. Abbass has set clear conditions he expects to be met if he is to hold talks. None of them involved the destruction of Israel.


Anyone wanting to put their hands up to say that the settlelemtens are legal or illegal. Safe Keeper was of the opinion that no one here thinks they are legal. I would like to see that clarified.
 
preventing one from being formed in an act of self determination.

I'd have sympathy, except that they mostly seem to want a state so that it's easier to wipe out their neighbours.

It's a bit rich to accuse Israel of being security conscious when all of it's neighbours have attacked it and the main Palestinian groups all want it destroyed. If the neighbours tried playing nice, I imagine that Israel would be far more accommodating (after all, things like the security fence were only built in reaction to terrorist attacks). If the Palestinians were to try Gandhian/MLK tactics their lot would improve tremendously... but they are wedded to genocidal antisemitism, nihilistic violence, and an honor-shame culture that does not recognise "moving on" "getting over it" or "everybody wins" outcomes.
 
The Israeli political system has been on a continuous move to the right for years. Can there be a two state solution when the most powerful political groups in the Israel are working as hard and as fast as they can that a second state cannot exist.
Very likely, if

a. the Arabs lay down their arms and agree on a peace treaty that returns the occupied areas, or
b. the Arabs realize you can't win them all and move the **** on already.
 
I'd have sympathy, except that they mostly seem to want a state so that it's easier to wipe out their neighbours.

It's a bit rich to accuse Israel of being security conscious when all of it's neighbours have attacked it and the main Palestinian groups all want it destroyed. If the neighbours tried playing nice, I imagine that Israel would be far more accommodating (after all, things like the security fence were only built in reaction to terrorist attacks). If the Palestinians were to try Gandhian/MLK tactics their lot would improve tremendously... but they are wedded to genocidal antisemitism, nihilistic violence, and an honor-shame culture that does not recognise "moving on" "getting over it" or "everybody wins" outcomes.

Can anyone respond to what I say here? I have talked about the Palestinian/Israeli peace talks. I have advocated Gandhi/MLK myself, I believe it would be far more effective. Ghandi/MLK are very rare people. Maybe one will turn up, Israel had one, but they shot him. The Palestinians have no ability at all to threaten the existence of Israel. From what I have read, there have been many peaceful protests, you don' hear about them.
 
Last edited:
Very likely, if

a. the Arabs lay down their arms and agree on a peace treaty that returns the occupied areas, or
b. the Arabs realize you can't win them all and move the **** on already.

You are assuming that occupied areas will be returned. It's not just Palestinians that have the die hard extremists. Netahyahu is on film boasting how he helped sabotage previous peace efforts.

No one willing to put their hands up to say the settlements are illegal or not? Last chance. Looks like it's not just Hercules who can't answer a question.
 
Palestinian Authority TV praises the Arab translator of the Protocols.



People who want peace are often praise Nazi literature.
 
Tell that to the Fogels.

I didn't say that people aren't being killed, on both sides for that matter. Can you please respond to statements I do make, and not ones you invent that I said.\

Maybe you should see what Netanhahu thinks

Netanyahu: Indeed, Hebron hurts. It hurts. It's the thing that hurts. One of the famous rabbis, whom I very much respect, a rabbi of Eretz Yisrael, he said to me: "What would your father say?" I went to my father. Do you know a little about my father's position?

...He's not exactly a lily-white dove, as they say. So my father heard the question and said: "Tell the rabbi that your grandfather, Rabbi Natan Milikowski, was a smart Jew. Tell him it would be better to give two percent than to give a hundred percent. And that's the choice here. You gave two percent and in that way you stopped the withdrawal. Instead of a hundred percent." The trick is not to be there and be broken. The trick is to be there and pay a minimal price."

He's quite happy to pay a minimal price, that is, he thinks a few dead Israeli's don't matter.
 
Last edited:
A democracy accepts the need for compromise and does not chase a futile zero sum game that only leads to more and more piles of corpses

Wrong.

A democracy simply puts the responsibility for bad governance on the citizens themselves.

If the citizens themselves do not accept the need for compromise; if the citizens themselves would chase a futile zero sum game that only leads to more and more piles of corpses; then their democracy will surely reflect these things.

Democracy is not some magical System for a Better Tomorrow. It is only as good as its citizens, and only as good as their social institutions.

I think probably the best way* to get a democracy is to start with a dictatorship that establishes strong social institutions: rule of law, minority rights, etc., and then abdicates in favor of the citizens governing those institutions themselves through democratic means.

I think... but I'm probably wrong. This is essentially what Tito tried to do in the Balkans, with the creation of the Yugoslavian state. And we saw what a mess that turned into, the moment the dictatorship was removed.













*Other than the way the American colonies did it, of course (lol j/k :P)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom