Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Best example I can think of would be how Finland doesn't really want their lost areas back because their Russians population would be a burden on Finland's welfare system.

As for why Israelis can't become Palestinians, I think Mycroft is referring more to how Arabs are systematically expelling Jews from their countries;). Best illustration I could find:

http://www.barenakedislam.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/01/image001-vi.png

And there are very,very few Finns left in Karelia anyway.
 
In saying that the settlements are illegal, I am agreeing with Washington.

I've got a vague memory of you saying something along the lines of:

They have already conceded 90% of the territory that they wanted for a new state. That was a massive concession.


And who said that exactly? Hamas, who advocate the destruction of Israel or Fatah who advocate the destruction of Israel in stages?
 
I've got a vague memory of you saying something along the lines of:




And who said that exactly? Hamas, who advocate the destruction of Israel or Fatah who advocate the destruction of Israel in stages?

I guess that's why there are peace talks in progress. I personally can't see an existential threat for Israel from Palestinians. From what I read, the majority of Palestinians just want an end to all this, as do the majority of Israelis, and that has in fact been the case for many years now. That is what I look forward to in the region. Israel is going nowhere, the Palestians likewise, inevetibably there will be some sort of peaceful resolution, the sooner the better.

Lets compare their armed forces.

Israel Number of Jet Fighters and bombers, number of nukes, number of tanks, number of other armoured vehicles, size of armed forces, level of equipemnt of armed forces, naval ships, radar installations, anti-missile defences, command and control systems, airborne intelligence systems, drones. Not sure of the numbers of all of them, but the Palestinians all score zero or close to it for all the expensive, and militarily effective, hardware.

I am wondering if we will get a show of hands for how many people think the settlements are illegal.
 
I guess that's why there are peace talks in progress. I personally can't see an existential threat for Israel from Palestinians. From what I read, the majority of Palestinians just want an end to all this, as do the majority of Israelis, and that has in fact been the case for many years now. That is what I look forward to in the region. Israel is going nowhere, the Palestians likewise, inevetibably there will be some sort of peaceful resolution, the sooner the better.

Lets compare their armed forces.

Israel Number of Jet Fighters and bombers, number of nukes, number of tanks, number of other armoured vehicles, size of armed forces, level of equipemnt of armed forces, naval ships, radar installations, anti-missile defences, command and control systems, airborne intelligence systems, drones. Not sure of the numbers of all of them, but the Palestinians all score zero or close to it for all the expensive, and militarily effective, hardware.

I am wondering if we will get a show of hands for how many people think the settlements are illegal.
So you're admitting that the Palestinians are claiming all of Israel as theirs, but it doesn't matter because they aren't actually capable of destroying Israel? And therefore Israel should just shrug their shoulders and accept terrorist attacks, missiles and artillery shot into Israel, etc etc?

And, of course, just because the Palestinians have never made any concessions whatsoever doesn't mean they aren't serious about making peace with Israel!
 
I guess that's why there are peace talks in progress. I personally can't see an existential threat for Israel from Palestinians.
No one ever claimed Palestine's rulers posed an existential threa to anyone except, perhaps, themselves.

Lets compare their armed forces.
Yeah, let's.

One is a modern force formed by the government of a modern democratic nation. They abide by rules of egagement, kill fewer civilians per combatant than NATO, and has as its chief role the protection of Israel's border and population.

The other spits in the face of international law, uses its own civilians as human shields, has no scrouples against the use of children as scouts or even fighters and martyrs, and carries out suicide bombings and rocket attacks on civilians -- and has as its goal the destruction of Israel and the Israeli people.

Of course Palestine's "armies" do not post a threat to Israel's existence. I would argue, however, that does present a major obstacle to a fair and lasting peace. You can yell about settlements and occupation 'till the cows come home, but the reality is that as long as the Palestinians seem dead set against peace, there's never going to be one. As long as you're fighting an enemy that has as its stated goal the destruction of your country and people, there's absolutely no reason to lay down your arms and give concessions. Giving back Gaza certainly didn't give the Israelis anything except, of course, more rocket attacks.

As I said in my last post, the fact that Palestine is fighting a hopeless fight, while Israel occupies lands and has active settlements is a reason for calming down and accepting peace. As you yourself just said, the Palestinians can't win. They pose no threat against Israel. In fact, I'm not sure if the entire Arab world combined would present a threat, what with Israel's nuclear arsenal and strong allies. Certainly they've tried ganging up on the Jews before, and what came of that? Dead young men and enemy settlements on Arab lands.
 
A democracy accepts the need for compromise and does not chase a futile zero sum game that only leads to more and more piles of corpses
 
A democracy accepts the need for compromise and does not chase a futile zero sum game that only leads to more and more piles of corpses

Sums up the difference between Israel and Hamas nicely.
 
A democracy accepts the need for compromise and does not chase a futile zero sum game that only leads to more and more piles of corpses

What characteristic of a democracy would directly imply accepting the need for compromise and not chasing zero sum games?

Israel is a flawed, militaristic democracy which, for it's entire existence, has been facing down a region and a planet which would like nothing better than to erase it from the pages of time. It has so far wildly succeeded against all reasonable odds at the cost of obsessive vigilance and the willingness to be, at times, as brutal as its dark-aged enemies.

It's easy to preach on what a democracy should be when you have none of its responsibilities or risks.
 
What characteristic of a democracy would directly imply accepting the need for compromise and not chasing zero sum games?

Israel is a flawed, militaristic democracy which, for it's entire existence, has been facing down a region and a planet which would like nothing better than to erase it from the pages of time. It has so far wildly succeeded against all reasonable odds at the cost of obsessive vigilance and the willingness to be, at times, as brutal as its dark-aged enemies.

It's easy to preach on what a democracy should be when you have none of its responsibilities or risks.

I don't know anyone who want's anything like it to be erased from the pages of time. I have always been in favour of a two state solution. To suggest that it is " facing down .... a planet which would like nothing better than to erase it from the pages of time." is sheer paranoia. The UN voted for the existence of Israel. That those already living in the region had other plans for where Israel now exists is hardly surprising. It was two thousand years since a formal state of Israel had existed, a lot of time for other history to be happening there.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom