Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
It's always deflection. "Look, over there". If Israel is serious about peace, let it demonstrate that it is negotiating in good faith.
It has. Numerous times. Merely giving up Gaza and offering up pretty much all of the West Bank in a peace offer speaks volumes in my book.
Again, I think you're placing way too much emphasis on the borders and settlements.

The problem here is that the situation is not static, Russia is not taking more space now, it has stopped.

As for the Fins, they were desperate enough to be allies of the Nazis during WWII. There are pictures of British hurricanes with a Swatztika on them.
Speaking of deflections...
 
It's always deflection. "Look, over there". If Israel is serious about peace, let it demonstrate that it is negotiating in good faith.
Israel has made numerous concessions over the years.

What have the Palestinians done? They can't even be bothered with amending their Charter to recognize Israel's right to exist. Instead, they keep in place claims to the entire state of Israel and state it's their right to fight to destroy it.

Hard to negotiate with "we call for your complete destruction" as the starting point.
 
It's always deflection. "Look, over there". If Israel is serious about peace, let it demonstrate that it is negotiating in good faith. Otherwise, there would be valid fears that Netanyahu is just lying again about peace, as he has been recorded boasting on video.

Israel just released 26 terrorists from prison as a condition to even start the talks. That will lead to dead Israelis in the future.

If that's not a concession, nothing is.

Speaking of nothing...what exactly are the Palestinians giving? Temporarily stopping rocket attacks doesn't count.
 
Israel just released 26 terrorists from prison as a condition to even start the talks. That will lead to dead Israelis in the future.

If that's not a concession, nothing is.

Speaking of nothing...what exactly are the Palestinians giving? Temporarily stopping rocket attacks doesn't count.

They have already conceded 90% of the territory that they wanted for a new state. That was a massive concession. The land that Israel now expects them to concede will break up the fraction left even more into disjointed pockets of population. The "East Jerusalem" expansion effectively breaks up the West Bank into two.
 
They have already conceded 90% of the territory that they wanted for a new state. That was a massive concession. The land that Israel now expects them to concede will break up the fraction left even more into disjointed pockets of population. The "East Jerusalem" expansion effectively breaks up the West Bank into two.

the setlement are illegal and enven the israeli government called many of them on "stolen" land.
 
It has. Numerous times. Merely giving up Gaza and offering up pretty much all of the West Bank in a peace offer speaks volumes in my book.
The West Bank and Gaza were not Israels to give up, they were quite clearly where Palestinians lived. The Palestinians have comrpomised far more in even accepting the 67 cease fire line. As for the West Bank, it is not going to be given up, this is made quite clear in the Likud Charter. What they proprose is a type of Apartheid. Perhaps talks will change this, but the hawks who effectively decide the policy in the current political situation have indicated with the settlements they are intent on expansion. This expansion is not just about taking land, but create strategic disjoints in the West Bank, isolating Palestinians into smaller "islands".

Small but continuous evictions are also carried out. For example.

http://www.poica.org/editor/case_studies/view.php?recordID=6532

Blocking a road.

http://www.poica.org/editor/case_studies/view.php?recordID=6428

Israeli Settlers destroy Palestinian crops.

http://www.poica.org/editor/case_studies/view.php?recordID=6431

Dividing the West Bank

http://www.nytimes.com/2012/12/02/w...sraeli-building-plan.html?pagewanted=all&_r=0

Jerusalem, which both Israel and the Palestinians see as their capital, is anything but united, with fierce fights over its development posing perhaps the greatest threat to the prospects of peace. And beyond the cornerstone, nothing has been erected since in this contentious 4.6-square-mile area, known as E1, where there are many more goats than people.
But Israel’s announcement on Friday that it was moving ahead with zoning and planning preparations for the area could change all that, and many fear that it could close the window on the chance for a two-state solution to the long-running Israeli-Palestinian conflict.
Construction in E1, in West Bank territory that Israel captured in the 1967 war, would connect the large Jewish settlement of Maale Adumim to Jerusalem and create a large block of Israeli settlements in the center of the West Bank. Access to the Palestinian cities of Ramallah and Bethlehem would be limited to narrow corridors far from the Old City and downtown Jerusalem. Critics see development of E1 as a threat to the meaningful contiguity of a Palestinian state, such as that endorsed by the United Nations last week, because it would leave some Palestinian areas connected to one another only by roads with few exits or by circuitous routes.






Again, I think you're placing way too much emphasis on the borders and settlements.

Speaking of deflections...

Since this is all about the land and who is going to live where, it's the major negotiating point and the reason for the start of the war.
 
They have already conceded 90% of the territory that they wanted for a new state.
They did? Evidence? AFAIK they still haven't given up their claim to all of Israel.

You will have to list them.
:rolleyes:

Several have already been listed - such as giving up Gaza and prisoner releases.

What have the Palestinians given up? Provide evidence for your answer please.
 
They have already conceded 90% of the territory that they wanted...
Considering they want the whole pie, yes, yes, they have.

The land that Israel now expects them to concede will break up the fraction left even more into disjointed pockets of population. The "East Jerusalem" expansion effectively breaks up the West Bank into two.
Not this * again. Things are cut in two when they're cut in two. Korea is cut in two. Germany prior to WWII was cut in two (the Danzig corridor). Norway, after much back-and-forth with Sweden, is only six kilometers at the narrowest and thus even more "effectively cut in two" than the West Bank is ever going to be, yet somehow we still make it through the day (amazing, I know).

A 15 kilometers wide corridor, by definition, doesn't cut anything in two. It's a particularly ridiculous statement when you consider that the area we're talking about is tiny. I'd have understood it if we were talking about a country the size of Germany or Brazil, but Israel? We have counties in Norway that are larger than the entire country.

To put things into perspective, Israel at her most narrow is... wait for it...

http://www.miff.no/site/wp-content/uploads/2012/12/big-update.jpg

15 kilometers:rolleyes:.

The West Bank and Gaza were not Israels to give up, they were quite clearly where Palestinians lived.
And thus it's not a sacrifice for Israel to give them up:confused:?

The Palestinians have comrpomised far more in even accepting the 67 cease fire line.
When did they accept it? last time I checked they don't even recognize Israel's right to exist?

As for the West Bank, it is not going to be given up
Then why did they, only a few years ago, propose its return to the Palestinians?

...this is made quite clear in the Likud Charter. What they proprose is a type of Apartheid.
Facepalm.
Don't use words without knowing their true meaning.

Oh, wait, you said "new type of". So you know it's not an Apartheid, but still you get to use the word. Just like you know the West Bank won't cut in two, but that doesn't matter because you can say it's "effectively" cut in two? Very clever.

Perhaps talks will change this, but the hawks who effectively decide the policy in the current political situation have indicated with the settlements they are intent on expansion.
:D.

Small but continuous evictions are also carried out.
All the more a reason for the Arabs to cut the **** and accept peace already.

It's like the Monty Python scene with the black knight.

the setlement are illegal and enven the israeli government called many of them on "stolen" land.
Do you have everyone but yourself on ignore or something:confused:?
 
i say let the Zionists keep israel and lwet the Arabs keep the West Bank "Arab Palestine".

They don't want a state on the West Bank. If they did they would have had one. They want to kill the Jews and push them into the sea. Not even before the Israeli left's popularity plummeted to single-digits could you get Israel to agree to that.
 
i say let the Zionists keep israel and lwet the Arabs keep the West Bank "Arab Palestine".
Which is pretty much what everyone here have been arguing (with the exception of the "wipe out Israel" crowd) since the beginning:confused:.
 
They don't want a state on the West Bank. If they did they would have had one. They want to kill the Jews and push them into the sea. Not even before the Israeli left's popularity plummeted to single-digits could you get Israel to agree to that.

this is funny becaue the only way "israel" can survive as a jewish state is if the Arabs get their own Palestine in the West Bank. If not Israel will not be a Jewish state for long/.
 
this is funny becaue the only way "israel" can survive as a jewish state is if the Arabs get their own Palestine in the West Bank. If not Israel will not be a Jewish state for long/.

Yeah, it's funny if you completely disregard the debate within Zionism itself, as well as mainstream Israel, whether Israel is a Jewish state, or a state of Jews. Please keep in mind that many Zionists and Israelis have a well established secular background.
 
They did? Evidence? AFAIK they still haven't given up their claim to all of Israel.


:rolleyes:

Several have already been listed - such as giving up Gaza and prisoner releases.

What have the Palestinians given up? Provide evidence for your answer please.

You have gone from numerous, to several, then can list two.

"Giving up Gaza" was debatable as a concession, as it was done largely out of the issue of population, there were far more Palestinians living there than Israelis, and nowhere to expand. There was no formal process of handing it over as a concession to the more moderate Palestinians, hence the radical HAMAS group was able to take the credit, legitimising violence as a way to deal with Israel.

The prisoner release is one concession. Apparently it is more desirable to let people who are being held on terrorism charges free than it is to stop illegal settlements.
 
Of course we could compile and post a whole list if you want to. It's not exactly the first time Israel has released prisoners, for example. I have a feeling you know more than you're letting on.

Also, what Virus said.
 
"Giving up Gaza" was debatable as a concession, as it was done largely out of the issue of population, there were far more Palestinians living there than Israelis, and nowhere to expand.

Sure is opinion in here. What do you base this on besides your own biased observation?

There was no formal process of handing it over as a concession to the more moderate Palestinians

Was that required?

hence the radical HAMAS group was able to take the credit, legitimising violence as a way to deal with Israel.

Hamas also took credit for a Cast Lead victory as well, IIRC. Logic, and reality, doesn't matter in this case - Hamas will find a way to legitimize violence against Israel in every situation - after all, the destruction of the state is their goal..
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom