Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
I already replied to this in another thread. I consider it bad form to ignore replies and then just post the same argument in a different thread.
Edit: Christ, not even in a different thread.
 
Last edited:
how xdoes it make you all feel that even the israeli giovernment has admitted that many of the settlements are on stolen land?
 
I don't even know why he is so stuck at the legality of settlements in the first place. No one here have said they were legal, I think the closest you'll get is me pointing out to him that the case is more complicated than just "teh zionists stole land lol", and advising him to read up on international law and relevant UN resolutions, for example Security Council Resolution 242. I think it was this outrageous claim that the world is not as black-and-white as he thought that set him off for some reason.

How does it feel to not be able to define the terms you use?
This, too. Hercules, care to define "Zionist" any time soon? We'll all define "doctor" and "accountant" for you, I promise!
 
Today the USA secretery of state said that "all settlements are illegitimate".

He is right and finally the USA is doimg the right things and sayign the right things about Palestine.
 
So it looks like Israel had already said new settlement housing would continue to go up, up front. And it looks like all these new announced settlements are on land that Israel expects to retain if a peace agreement is reached. That does put a different light on things.

Agreed, but if you think that puts a different light on things, consider this: Why couldn't Jewish residents of these communities become citizens of the new state of "Palestine"?

Anywhere else in the world if two nations negotiate a new border, they don't ask the people living there to get up and move, those people just become citizens of the new nation that takes over. Why is is different there? Israel's population is about 20% Muslim, so why couldn't some of "Palestine's" population be Jewish? For some reason it's believed that Jews living in the West Bank somehow make a Palestinian state there problematic, but why is that? What exactly are the unspoken beliefs that underlie this assumption?

I think anywhere else in the world if we were discussing any other peoples, the default assumption would be that if some or all of these communities became "Palestinian", they would become an important asset to the Palestinian economy as well as an important tax base for the Palestinian government.

I'm still inclined to say making this announcement at this time does not improve the chances for successful negotiations. Negotiations are about give and take. They could have said we are taking bids for new settlements, but none will be started for 90 days, to give the peace talks a chance. If in 90 days no progress has been made, we will start construction. Or something like that. It would have shown a commitment to the peace process, and cost little I would think.

I think this is a perfectly reasonable statement. The problem is both the Israelis and Palestinians have been on this merry-go-round before, and they know how it goes. Israel captured these lands back in '67, and it's been more than four decades of failed negotiations, betrayals, achingly slow progress, misunderstandings and set-backs.

I hope these scheduled talks are productive, but I have my doubts.

Me too. I hate being a pessimist, but I've been following it too long to be anything else.

There are probably 3 Nobel Peace prizes waiting for the representatives from Israel and Palestine, and the negotiator that helps them reach an agreement for a lasting peace, not to mention the other benefits for all involved. It will be a great day if it ever comes.

I think every US administration dreams of being the one two bring these people together in Peace, but everyone since Carter has failed to make significant progress. Arguably Clinton came closest, but couldn't bring them that last step. Bush's Road Map never got off the ground, now Obama is going to take his shot. I wish him luck, but have no illusions about the difficulty of the challenge.
 
yes we all now that the Americans will try to convince the Palestinians to accept leting Isael keep some of the settlemrnts near jerusalem and the green line even though they are all illegal so says international laws.

I think what Kerry is saying is that if a lasting peace is reached, Israel will no longer need "settlements" to act as buffers of defense against a possible invasion from Jordan, Syria, or Egypt. Indeed I would guess that some posters here would share that view.

The bottom line is Israelis need to be secure, and Palestinians require a state of their own.
 
Mycroft - I have to wonder if the settlement announcement isn't meant to show the hard core conservatives that there is no intention of giving up and going soft. And I consider it possible that it is intended to remind the PA that if an agreement isn't reached there will be even more settlements built in the future.

Hopefully the prisoner releases will offset any negative effects from the settlement announcement, and these talks will go as planned, and with a lot of luck even be productive. Guess it will be late tonight or early tomorrow before most of hear how the start went.

I'm not superstitious, but I may cross a couple fingers anyway :)
 
Let's hear what people think, then.

I think they are illegal, and as such are an impediment to any peace settlement.
So if they had been legal, they would not have been an impediment to a peace deal?

-eta-
What I personally think is that it's a bit of a tempest in a teacup. Lots of nations in history have borders that should probably have run somewhere else. The Finns lost considerable areas to unprovoked Soviet Union aggression in the fourties -- you'll notice there's no suicide bombings or rocket attacks on those areas from the Finnish government today. Lots of Norwegians once lived on the Kola peninsula east of the Norwegian-Russian border -- all were evicted by Stalin, never to return. Yet unsurprisingly, we let those people move on with their lives rather than throw them in camps and let them rot there for decades, and you never see anyone take to the streets to burn Russian flags and chant "free Kola!".

Lots of people wish the Israeli-Palestinian borders would run elsewhere, legal or illegal as they may be (and let me remind that that it is legal to keep land you won in a defensive war) but seriously, to many of the people acting as if the 1967 borders are the end of the world, I worry it's just an excuse to dislike Israel. There's certainly a tendency among certain Palestine supporters to derail any valid point on, say, terror attacks on Israel with "but, but occupation!!!".
 
Last edited:
Why couldn't Jewish residents of these communities become citizens of the new state of "Palestine"?

You're asking why the settlers of Israel, mostly extremely religious nationalists, couldn't become citizens of a new Palestine? I think their national and religious identity would preclude that choice for them.

Anywhere else in the world if two nations negotiate a new border, they don't ask the people living there to get up and move, those people just become citizens of the new nation that takes over.

Do you have a modern example of this actually happening outside of a war?
 
Best example I can think of would be how Finland doesn't really want their lost areas back because their Russians population would be a burden on Finland's welfare system.

As for why Israelis can't become Palestinians, I think Mycroft is referring more to how Arabs are systematically expelling Jews from their countries;). Best illustration I could find:

http://www.barenakedislam.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/01/image001-vi.png
 
Last edited:
quoted from This Guy http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=9427046&postcount=160
I have to wonder if the settlement announcement isn't meant to show the hard core conservatives that there is no intention of giving up and going soft. And I consider it possible that it is intended to remind the PA that if an agreement isn't reached there will be even more settlements built in the future.

The settlements have nothing to do with the palestinians in that sense. They are there because that is where greater Israel is supposed to be. The only role for the Palestinians in that scenario is to not be there. Which is what is happening, the expansions are for Jewish Israelis only.
 
Last edited:
So if they had been legal, they would not have been an impediment to a peace deal?

It would be very difficult to argue against them if that was the case. Since they are widely acknoweldged to be illegal, then there is a strong case for the Palestinians to demand that they be stopped, which is exactly what they are doing. In this aspect of the issue, they have the backing Israel's strongest ally, the USA.

I don't see anyone here saying they are legal or illegal, it seems to be a topic that most people don't want to make a statement about.
 
The settlements have nothing to do with the palestinians in that sense. They are there because that is where greater Israel is supposed to be. The only role for the Palestinians in that scenario is to not be there. Which is what is happening, the expansions are for Jewish Israelis only.
So there's no standing offer for Arab residents of Jerusalem for full Israeli citizenship?

And let me know when the Palestinians give up their claims to the entire country of Israel, that's a bit of an issue, don't you think?
 
So there's no standing offer for Arab residents of Jerusalem for full Israeli citizenship?

And let me know when the Palestinians give up their claims to the entire country of Israel, that's a bit of an issue, don't you think?

It's always deflection. "Look, over there". If Israel is serious about peace, let it demonstrate that it is negotiating in good faith. Otherwise, there would be valid fears that Netanyahu is just lying again about peace, as he has been recorded boasting on video.

Rabin seemed to be honest about it, as were the majority of Israelis, as far as I can tell. Those allied with Netanyahu were never going to accept that deal.

The Palestinians do have to accept a peaceful settlement, and two states, also. I have never thought otherwise. If the Palestinians were such a real risk to the Israelis, though, you would think that Israel would be doing everything it can to not antagonise the situation, such as by continually expanding and taking land the Palestinians see as their own, and live on.
 
Best example I can think of would be how Finland doesn't really want their lost areas back because their Russians population would be a burden on Finland's welfare system.
http://www.barenakedislam.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/01/image001-vi.png

The problem here is that the situation is not static, Russia is not taking more space now, it has stopped.

As for the Fins, they were desperate enough to be allies of the Nazis during WWII. There are pictures of British hurricanes with a Swatztika on them.

There are still tensions simmering among the Croats, Serbs, Macedonians, Greeks and Bosnians, after a very recent and very bloody period of war and acts of genocide. Europeans are not some superior race.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom