Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Then why is it Israel always seems to make the largest concessions only to have the Palestinians violate any agreements?

zionists violated the no mans land with Syria many times befoe the 1967 war and even invaded Jordan before 1967 war.
 
zionists violated the no mans land with Syria many times befoe the 1967 war and even invaded Jordan before 1967 war.
What do Jordan and Syria have to do with the question you quoted? Or were you waiting for me to ask,"Name two countries that have treated Palestinians worse than Israel?"?
 
What do Jordan and Syria have to do with the question you quoted? Or were you waiting for me to ask,"Name two countries that have treated Palestinians worse than Israel?"?

zionists violated agreemants and that is my point I am making.
 
So that has what to do with:
Then why is it Israel always seems to make the largest concessions only to have the Palestinians violate any agreements?
There is no mention of either Syria or Jordan in that question.
 
So it looks like Israel had already said new settlement housing would continue to go up, up front. And it looks like all these new announced settlements are on land that Israel expects to retain if a peace agreement is reached. That does put a different light on things.

I'm still inclined to say making this announcement at this time does not improve the chances for successful negotiations. Negotiations are about give and take. They could have said we are taking bids for new settlements, but none will be started for 90 days, to give the peace talks a chance. If in 90 days no progress has been made, we will start construction. Or something like that. It would have shown a commitment to the peace process, and cost little I would think.

I hope these scheduled talks are productive, but I have my doubts.

There are probably 3 Nobel Peace prizes waiting for the representatives from Israel and Palestine, and the negotiator that helps them reach an agreement for a lasting peace, not to mention the other benefits for all involved. It will be a great day if it ever comes.
 
all Jews who live in Israel are zioinists except for some of the crazy black hat guys.

and even the Israeli government has called many of the settlements "theft". When the zionists themselbves cal it stealing you know its stealing.

Again, what is a "zionist"? What political/religious/cultural markers are there that would allow us to differentiate between a zionist and an Israeli citizen?
 
The zionists fear peace more than war becaue they dont want to give up their precioius holy land given them by "God".
If the Israeli really were the bloodthirsty imperialists they frequently are portrayed as, there probably wouldn't even be a Palestine today. They'd have gone in and taken over all of the Palestinian territories a long time ago, and they would never have given up as much as a square inch of the land they had conquered.
 
the zionist settlements are illegal and stolen land, even the israeli government has said thuis!!

why did the the zionist lawyer for Isael say back in the 1960s that the settlemnts would be illegal? becuae he was a smart honest man who wasnt listened to by zionist extremists!!

even The USA called the West Bank "Arab Palestine", back in The 50s,.
 
the zionist settlements are illegal and stolen land, even the israeli government has said thuis!!
Israel is a democracy. This effectively means there will be a specter of opinions all across the scale, which in turn means saying that you'll probably find quotes fom the Israeli government that supports pretty much any stance.

even The USA called the West Bank "Arab Palestine", back in The 50s,.
"Even" the USA? The relationship between Israel and the United States in Israel's first years was lukewarm at best.

Oh, and for the third or fourth time,
please define "Zionist" with your own words.
​
 
Israel is a democracy. This effectively means there will be a specter of opinions all across the scale, which in turn means saying that you'll probably find quotes fom the Israeli government that supports pretty much any stance.

"Even" the USA? The relationship between Israel and the United States in Israel's first years was lukewarm at best.

Oh, and for the third or fourth time,
please define "Zionist" with your own words.
​

why do you keep asking me this silly question?

wil you define what a "doctor" and a "accountant" is after I define a zionist?
 
why do you keep asking me this silly question?
Because "zionist" is a "political word" that means different things to different people. Therefore I want to know how you would define it, especially after you make statements like "all Israelis are zionists".

wil you define what a "doctor" and a "accountant" is after I define a zionist?
"Doctor" and "accountant" are typical used to mean, well, doctor and accountant.
 
From Wikipedia:
Zionism (Hebrew: ציונות‎, Tsiyonut; Arabic: صهيونية‎, Șahyouniyyah) is a form of nationalism of Jews and Jewish culture that supports a Jewish nation state in the territory defined as the Land of Israel.[1] Zionism supports Jews upholding their Jewish identity, opposes the assimilation of Jews into other societies and has advocated the return of Jews to Israel as a means for Jews to be a majority in their own nation, and to be liberated from antisemitic discrimination, exclusion, and persecution that had historically occurred in the diaspora.
​
I don't think Hercules agrees with this definition. ETA: except, perhaps, if you take the "Land of Israel" part one hundred percent litterally.
 
Last edited:
So it looks like Israel had already said new settlement housing would continue to go up, up front. And it looks like all these new announced settlements are on land that Israel expects to retain if a peace agreement is reached. That does put a different light on things.

Not if that land is land the the Palestinians think they expect to retain if a peace agreement is reached. Such actions make a peace agreement pointless.

Washington agrees that they will not help negotiations.

“Certainly we find this unhelpful,” State Department spokeswoman Jen Psaki said of the building plans, which will see the recently authorized settlement of Bruchin expanded to 500 homes and Itamar grow to 675 units.

http://www.timesofisrael.com/washington-rebukes-israel-over-plans-to-build-new-settlement-homes/
 
Something that doesn't get much media attention (the significant stuff rarely does) is how Hamas basically work for Israel now.

What? That sounds like something a twoofer would say doesn't it? Hear me out.

Hamas now patrol the Gaza border shutting down rocket attacks into Israel and suppressing the even more radical terrorist groups. They do this because they don't want a repeat of the ass-kicking they got last time they started shooting rockets.

I've been reading Edward Luttwak's Grand Strategy of the Byzantine Empire and I think Israel's been taking notes. I'll lay it down for ya so listen up because this is going to be on the test. The only thing that really guarantees peace is a good, firm hand. Discipline your enemies with a good slap, draw a clear red line and they can be rendered tame. You don't always have to completely destroy your enemies, especially if it might create a vacuum for worse enemies to fill. Better to give them a slap, let them know you mean business, so you can bring them to heel and make them fight other enemies for you. That's what Hamas are doing.

Maybe Hamas will start shooting again. You never know. The strong rule the weak in Arab culture. Rival Palestinian terrorists try to prove how tough they are by killing Jews. Maybe Hamas will have to go back to shooting rockets to maintain their tough Muslim street-cred. Israel would then have to dispense more slaps to remind them of their place.

Right now, Israel enjoys excellent security and a booming economy. The Intifada was crushed, there hasn't been a suicide bombing in years, and Israel is the Silicon Valley of the Middle East. That pisses the millions of poor, angry Arabs off big-time because they tried to kill the Jews heaps of times and Israel's success is a bitter reminder of how pathetic and feeble they are.
 
Last edited:
[/INDENT]I don't think Hercules agrees with this definition. ETA: except, perhaps, if you take the "Land of Israel" part one hundred percent litterally.

He probably doesn't. "Zionist" isn't really a thing for these people, it's just a way to ply trade in the old anti-semitic tropes under a progressive, politically-correct veneer.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom