Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
You don't need citations for accepted facts. It would be like citing your sources for stating two plus two equals four.
 
Israel-Gaza conflict: The myth of Hamas’s human shields
Independent said:
Some Gazans have admitted that they were afraid of criticizing Hamas, but none have said they had been forced by the organisation to stay in places of danger and become unwilling human-shields. The Bani Sobeila area, near Khan Younis, where the Abu Jamaa deaths took place received leaflets dropped from the air last week warning them to leave.

But almost all stayed. One reason for that was many of the houses belonged to the Abu Jamaa clan who felt there was safety in staying together. Another reason was given by a neighbour, Abdullah al-Daweish: “Where do we go to? Some people moved from the outer edge of Khan Younis to Khan Younis centre after Israelis told them to, then the centre got bombed. People have moved from this area to Gaza City, and Gaza City has been bombed. It’s not Hamas who is ordering us in this, it’s the Israelis.”

"accepted facts" in fantasy land still require evidence in the real world.
 
What claim would I need to back up? That Hamas lobs rockets? That Israel responds by trying to target the rockets? That Hamas purposely places rocket launchers near or amongst civilians? All are absolutely irrefutable facts. Please keep up.
 
Each one you made in post 3480, you can start with this one
welcoming their deaths for some disgusting PR campaign.

For reference, witness statements already provided talk of Israel dropping leaflets ordering civilians into certain areas and then bombing those areas, hence civilians later not responding to Israeli orders anymore.
 
By my count, about a million Palestinians (or "Arabs" as you call them) lost land via war. Can you show how many of these "gambled with military force repeatedly"?

Irrelevant. War isn't about individuals. That you keep trying to treat it as if it was is :rolleyes:.

If you think the map progression can be invalidated solely because it's possible to not consider Palestine a country (as a few members of the international community do), then why did you have no problem going along with the obvious interpretation that the word "occupying" in "occupying someone else's country" was the relevant one rather than "country"? You did argue against it on that basis, after all.

Well, you've got an interesting bit of cherry-picking going on. Especially given that as I repeatedly stated, my main issues with the progression had little to do with the specifics of how accurate it was. Rather, they had to do with how the reasons for the changes were completely ignored in the picture, the inconsistency of the map criteria, and, most especially, how you tried to use the progression. I could easily add the convenient way it neglects the time before Israel pulled out of the Gaza Strip, too, as an example of the ways that it's quite misleading, for that matter. In other words, it's not and never was that the map progression is invalid, in and of itself. It's that the situations where it can be used it as a honest and valid resource are extremely limited. Your usage, for example, was quite invalid. It may be that it could have been used validly as some support for an argument, but you tried to let it stand alone to try to counter points that it simply could not.

:rolleyes: ->


People have memories you know.

Indeed they do and even if they didn't, the posts in question are still there, after all. You used it as a standalone counter to -

No they aren't. The West Bank previously belonged to Jordan, Gaza previously belonged to Egypt, but neither of those countries want that land back. Israel proper used to belong to the Ottoman Empire, which no longer even exists. And there is no country of Palestine. You can pretend all you want to, but it's still just make believe.

As has been noted before, the progression might have a chance at validly supporting your point, if you had additionally demonstrated that the land pointed out was, in fact, being occupied via unsavory means. The progression does not and, by it's nature, cannot demonstrate anything of direct relevance to your original claim, though, so it cannot be used as standalone support for the original point. Nor does it counter anything that Ziggurat said there, at all.

Of course, if we're going back to your remarkably twisted interpretation of Ziggurat's reasons for why the US should support Israel, it's worth noting that you were rather undeniably trolling there, which leads again to the very real question about what, exactly, you're fighting so hard to argue about. Seriously, when looking at the whole picture, you're still fighting to defend your attempt to basically claim that if Ziggurat actually meant that the US should support Israel because they occupy land, put people in camps, break international law, and have institutional segregation, that was totally fine, but that the actual reasons that he'd listed in the past for why the US should support Israel weren't really valid reasons... because totally unstated reasons.
 
Last edited:
Israel-Gaza conflict: The myth of Hamas’s human shields


"accepted facts" in fantasy land still require evidence in the real world.

You do realize that using "human shields" is when people, especially innocents/civilians, are used as an attempted deterrent to counterattacks, right, not limited to directly forcing them at gunpoint? Given that Hamas was launching weapons from residential areas, turning hospitals and schools into military targets, and failing to differentiate their military forces significantly from civilians, they have definitely been using "human shields."
 
Last edited:
Irrelevant. War isn't about individuals. That you keep trying to treat it as if it was is :rolleyes:

On the contrary, international law makes a clear distinction between combatants and civilians. Your persistent attempts at using the vague term "Arabs" to muddy the distinction is quite transparent and obvious. Again, you claimed the "Arabs" (ie the Palestinian civilian population) lost their land because they repeatedly used military force. No wonder you refuse to support such ridiculous notions.

The progression does not and, by it's nature, cannot demonstrate anything of direct relevance to your original claim

It demonstrated quite well the original claim.

Seriously, when looking at the whole picture, you're still fighting to defend your attempt to basically claim that if Ziggurat actually meant that the US should support Israel because they occupy land, put people in camps, break international law, and have institutional segregation

He said that it is because they have the same values as the US, I presented some obvious values that correspond well between the US and Israel.
 
You do realize that using "human shields" is when people, especially innocents/civilians, are used as an attempted deterrent to counterattacks, right, not limited to directly forcing them at gunpoint?

You do realize that was not the claim made? I even quoted the claim again just a couple of posts ago, it shouldn't be that hard to find. It is just the usual copy-pasting of long-debunked Israeli propaganda that you get from people who refuse to fact check claims.

Given that Hamas was launching weapons from residential areas

About that, could you show, on a map of the Gaza strip, where you think it should be done instead? Let's not forget that the Gaza strip is one of the regions with the highest population density in the world - 5000/km^2 - just behind Hong Kong (and without the high-rise buildings).
 
About that, could you show, on a map of the Gaza strip, where you think it should be done instead? Let's not forget that the Gaza strip is one of the regions with the highest population density in the world - 5000/km^2 - just behind Hong Kong (and without the high-rise buildings).

I suppose your thought process is that Hamas has no choice but to launch rockets? One argument that is routinely made is that Israel overreacts against these rockets because they are so, so ineffective at doing anything. Why then launch the ineffective rockets? There is a logic that is missing from this point of view.
 
Last edited:
I suppose your thought process is that Hamas has no choice but to launch rockets?

:rolleyes:

I'd just like to see the non-residential areas where Aridas thinks they should return fire from instead.

One argument that is routinely made is that Israel overreacts against these rockets because they are so, so ineffective at doing anything.

Not my argument, my argument is that Israel isn't reacting against these rockets at all, more like making sure enough of them come their way regularly enough.

Could you show that Israel reacts against these rockets? For instance that decreases in rockets lead to decreases in Israeli attacks, not say that decreases in rockets lead to increases in Israeli attacks then leading to increases in rockets.

Why then launch the ineffective rockets?

As has been abundantly shown already:
1. Hamas hadn't launched any rockets at Israel for over a year before the Israeli assault on Gaza.
2. All of Hamas' rockets were launched as a direct response to the Israeli assault on Gaza.

If you mean homemade rockets launched by individuals not affiliated with Hamas (aka the elected government of Gaza, which was party to the earlier ceasefire agreement), then consider the following. If someone in the US launches a rocket, you could either arrest this person or go bomb his neighborhood, what option is usually taken?

There is a logic that is missing from this point of view.

What is mostly lacking is any resemblance to factual reality.
 
:rolleyes:

I'd just like to see the non-residential areas where Aridas thinks they should return fire from instead.

I am interested in why you think they should be firing rockets in the first place, considering:

caveman1917 said:
Let's not forget that the Gaza strip is one of the regions with the highest population density in the world - 5000/km^2 - just behind Hong Kong (and without the high-rise buildings).

Your implication here is that there aren't many places that Hamas could launch rockets from that wouldn't endanger civilians. This is a "gotcha" game you're playing, and it's showing.

Not my argument, my argument is that Israel isn't reacting against these rockets at all, more like making sure enough of them come their way regularly enough.

Maybe. Maybe it's both - Israel wants Hamas to keep dicking around with rockets, and Hamas wants Israel to keep firing back. Both sides churn out the rhetoric, galvanizing their base, and move closer to whatever it is they want.

Could you show that Israel reacts against these rockets? For instance that decreases in rockets lead to decreases in Israeli attacks, not say that decreases in rockets lead to increases in Israeli attacks then leading to increases in rockets.

No. I think Israel cannot do anything militarily to decrease the rocket attacks short of leveling Gaza. That is the world they live in. As far as other approaches are concerned, that is dependent on Hamas and the Knesset. I frankly don't trust either parties to be mature enough at this point. Maybe the next generation of leaders.

As has been abundantly shown already:
1. Hamas hadn't launched any rockets at Israel for over a year before the Israeli assault on Gaza.
2. All of Hamas' rockets were launched as a direct response to the Israeli assault on Gaza.

1: There were sporadic rockets throughout the year, but nothing indicating an organized attack across the strip. Agreed.
2: While this may be true, the events that led up to the Israeli assault on Gaza did not only include rocket attacks.

If you mean homemade rockets launched by individuals not affiliated with Hamas (aka the elected government of Gaza, which was party to the earlier ceasefire agreement), then consider the following. If someone in the US launches a rocket, you could either arrest this person or go bomb his neighborhood, what option is usually taken?

I think you understand why the IDF doesn't routinely make trips into Gaza, on foot, to apprehend people firing rockets into Israel.
 
Last edited:
I am interested in why you think they should be firing rockets in the first place

I never said that, did I?

Your implication here is that there aren't many places that Hamas could launch rockets from that wouldn't endanger civilians.

The implication is that it's silly to point out that rockets are being fired near residential areas when all of the Gaza strip is "near residential areas".

No. I think Israel cannot do anything to decrease the rocket attacks short of leveling Gaza.

What you think is irrelevant, what is relevant is what you can show evidence for.

That is the world they live in.

No, that is the world you live in. The rest just goes ahead and counts the rockets and "retaliations" to find out what world they live in. Here is what it looks like week by week from the ceasefire agreement in november 2012 up to january 2014 (source).

1: There were sporadic rockets throughout the year, but nothing indicating an organized attack across the strip. Agreed.

No, Hamas had launched zero (zilch) rockets at Israel for over a year before the Israeli assault on Gaza.

2: While this may be true, the events that led up to the Israeli assault on Gaza did not only include rocket attacks.

So it wasn't reacting to rocket attacks after all?

I think you understand why the IDF doesn't routinely make trips into Gaza, on foot, to apprehend people firing rockets into Israel.

Not the IDF, Hamas was doing this before the Israeli assault.
 
And the dynamics of the first few weeks of the latest ceasefire (26 august 2014 - 18 september 2014)
On 26 August a ceasefire between Israel and Hamas was agreed, bringing a fragile end to a war that killed 2150 Palestinians (mostly civilians) and 73 Israelis (mostly soldiers). Since then Hamas has not fired a single rocket, attacked an Israeli target, or done anything to break the terms of the ceasefire. Israel has done the following:

Annexed another 1500 acres of West Bank land
Seized $56 million of PA tax revenue
Not lifted the illegal blockade (as required by the ceasefire)
Broken the ceasefire by firing at fishermen on four separate occasions
Detained six fishermen
Killed a 22-year-old, Issa al Qatari, a week before his wedding
Killed 16-year-old Mohammed Sinokrot with a rubber bullet to the head
Tortured a prisoner to the point of hospitalisation
Refused 13 members of the European Parliament entry into Gaza
Detained at least 127 people across the West Bank, including a seven-year-old boy in Hebron and two children, aged seven and eight, taken from the courtyard of their house in Silwad – and tear-gassed their mother
Continued to hold 33 members of the Palestinian Legislative Council in prison
Continued to hold 500 prisoners in administrative detention without charge or trial
Destroyed Bedouin homes in Khan al Ahmar, near Jerusalem, leaving 14 people homeless, and unveiled a plan to forcibly move thousands of Bedouin away from Jerusalem into two purpose-built townships
Destroyed a dairy factory in Hebron whose profits supported an orphanage
Destroyed a family home in Silwan, making five children homeless
Destroyed a house in Jerusalem where aid supplies en route to Gaza were being stored
Destroyed a well near Hebron
Set fire to an olive grove near Hebron
Raided a health centre and a nursery school in Nablus, causing extensive damage
Destroyed a swathe of farmland in Rafah by driving tanks over it
Ordered the dismantling of a small monument in Jerusalem to Mohamed Abu Khdeir, murdered in July by an Israeli lynch mob
Continued building a vast tunnel network under Jerusalem
Stormed the al Aqsa mosque compound with a group of far right settlers
Assisted hundreds of settlers in storming Joseph’s Tomb in Nablus
Prevented students from entering al Quds University, firing stun grenades and rubber bullets at those who tried to go in
Earned unknown millions on reconstruction materials for Gaza, where 100,000 people need their destroyed homes rebuilt. The total bill is estimated at $7.8 billion
 
I never said that, did I?

You are weaseling around the fact that by launching rockets from Gaza, Hamas is in effect using the citizens of Gaza as human shields.

The implication is that it's silly to point out that rockets are being fired near residential areas when all of the Gaza strip is "near residential areas".

OK, be that as it may, you are overlooking the fact that by launching rockets from residential areas, Hamas directly puts civilian lives in danger.

What you think is irrelevant, what is relevant is what you can show evidence for.

I thought we were discussing things which lack evidence, like your theory about Israel wanting Hamas to fire rockets at it.

No, that is the world you live in.

The world where Israel's military adventures do not seem to stop in totality rockets being fired at it? I guess.

The rest just goes ahead and counts the rockets and "retaliations" to find out what world they live in. Here is what it looks like week by week from the ceasefire agreement in november 2012 up to january 2014 (source).

Hand-hold me here. What are you trying to show?

No, Hamas had launched zero (zilch) rockets at Israel for over a year before the Israeli assault on Gaza.

No what? I agreed that it did not appear that Hamas launched any rockets from the Strip. Rockets were still fired from the Strip. Hamas is responsible for policing the strip. What happens when they cannot stop rockets from being fired from within their territory?

So it wasn't reacting to rocket attacks after all?

Are walking about Protective Edge, or 2015?

Not the IDF, Hamas was doing this before the Israeli assault.

Sigh. You're phrasing your questions in a very slippery way. Hamas would not bomb the neighborhood, no. They would arrest the perp, if they decided to do anything.

If a Canadian was firing rockets into the United States, and the Canadian government was unable or unwilling to do anything, the United States may take it on themselves to do something. If it persisted for decades, it'd probably get worse between the US and Canada.
 
Last edited:
:rolleyes:



As has been abundantly shown already:
1. Hamas hadn't launched any rockets at Israel for over a year before the Israeli assault on Gaza.
2. All of Hamas' rockets were launched as a direct response to the Israeli assault on Gaza.
Nevertheless, 63 rockets (average 5 per month) were launched in 36 rocket attacks in addition to various mortar attacks, all prohibited by the November 2012 ceasefire.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2014_Israel–Gaza_conflict

Hamas would never lie.
 
You are weaseling around the fact that by launching rockets from Gaza, Hamas is in effect using the citizens of Gaza as human shields.

Given an elected government of a densely populated region, which gets attacked by a foreign country, what should it do according to you?

I thought we were discussing things which lack evidence, like your theory about Israel wanting Hamas to fire rockets at it.

I never said that Israel wants to do that, merely that it is doing that.

The world where Israel's military adventures do not seem to stop in totality rockets being fired at it? I guess.

Yes, and then there's the real world where Israel's military adventures are the direct cause of almost the totality of rockets fired at it.

Hand-hold me here. What are you trying to show?

Maybe presenting the data differently will help.
picture.php


The data ranges over 54 weeks, from the beginning of the ceasefire after the 2012 conflict up to january 2014.

For each side each of those 54 weeks is put into 3 categories. "1" meaning that the last attack by the opposing side was in the same week, "2" meaning that it was the week before and "3" meaning that it was 2 weeks or more earlier.

"total weeks" means the total number of weeks, for each side, in each category. The "total weeks" for "1" then means the total number of weeks the side was attacked.
"X attacked" means, for each side and category, out of the total weeks in that category how many weeks side X attacked.
"X attacks" is the total number of attacks by X for each category.

The hypothesis is that one side is "reacting to attacks" from the opposite side. Given that, we expect this side's attacks to be concentrated in category "1" and, less so, "2". Furthermore, we expect the opposing side's attacks to be concentrated in category "3".

Can you show us for which side the evidence fits the hypothesis and for which it doesn't?

Are walking about Protective Edge, or 2015?

Talking both in general and specifically the start of the 2014 conflict, Operation Brother's Keeper.

If a Canadian was firing rockets into the United States, and the Canadian government was unable or unwilling to do anything, the United States may take it on themselves to do something. If it persisted for decades, it'd probably get worse between the US and Canada.

Your story is one-sided. Given a US-Canada ceasefire. If the US was attacking Canada 43 weeks out of 54, and Canadian individuals (not the Canadian government) fired rockets back 15 weeks out of those 54, with the Canadian government even attempting to stop it, after which the US starts a major offensive against Canada, then who can be surprised that the Canadian government launches their rocket arsenal in full in response - thereby accounting for 97% of the total number of rockets fired that year?
 
Last edited:
Care to present some evidence of Hamas, rather than individuals non-affiliated with Gaza's government, firing those rockets?

Wouldn't matter.

Allowing illegal combatants to use your territory as a base from which to lauch attacks on a neighbouring state is still contrary to international law.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom