Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Why don't you tell us, you're the one who brought up Israeli ordinance? I set out to show that the overwhelming majority of rockets are fired as a direct result of Israeli actions and hence Israel is not factually acting so as to reduce the rocket attacks but so as to perpetuate them.

I'm asking you what the rocket attacks against Israel being mostly during times of conflict tell us. At least you finally explained that!

I brought up the Israeli ordinance being overwhelming during times of conflict to show, that by your own reasoning and evidence, your exact same criticism of Israel applies to Hamas.

Again, I don't agree with that reasoning, but as you do you should attempt to reconcile how this criticism doesn't apply to Hamas but does to Israel. I criticize both for this.



You search for examples of actions by the state of Israel on the basis that it did a "good thing", with no further relevance to any of the actions we were considering. There is no other purpose to this other than to imbue the state of Israel with a moral quality ("it isn't so bad, it does good things too"). Apparently failing to grasp that I'm not arguing that Israel is "bad", but that its actions don't correspond to the explanation provided for them.


No, just, no. That's not what I'm doing and that is not the purpose. I'm trying to establish that you do agree that Israel has been correct in using force before so we can move on from if Israel can ever use force legitimately to establishing grounds for evaluating if any given use is legitimate.

You're making a straw man of my arguments and drawing inferences that simply aren't there.



I don't recall saying that Israel shouldn't exist. I only recall some criticism of depopulating a region against the consent of the local population and then colonizing it. Could you provide a quote?


If that action hadn't been taken, Israel wouldn't exist. That is exactly arguing that Israel shouldn't exist. You even suggested other places it should have existed if it wanted to, which is all besides the point that it exists now where it is currently. Unless you want it moved or to stop existing, what is your point? What is the utility of the criticism (besides advancing your dreaded 'Israel is bad' argument, that you don't want to advance)?



I know enough about the event and what happened subsequently with the land. I just don't feel the need to indulge in your hobby of "criticizing the Palestinians or agreeing with the Israeli just because we can".


See above. If you know enough about it, then you should know enough to have an easy example or two of justified use of force by Israel. Dang, it shouldn't be this difficult to establish this, and in the process also show you are willing to occasionally agree. If you absolutely refuse to agree clearly on anything, well, that's pretty much all one needs to show to establish that you aren't arguing in good faith.



Yeah, that must be it. Why would anyone discussing this in good faith not want to participate in "let's find things we can agree with Israel on and then claim we're so not imbuing moral qualities on a state"?



It must be a mystery.


Because you're not discussing this in good faith. Not a real mystery. There could be many reasons for this, including getting caught up in the adversarial sentiments these types of discussions foster. So why don't you have another go at it?
 
Unless you want it moved or to stop existing, what is your point? What is the utility of the criticism (besides advancing your dreaded 'Israel is bad' argument, that you don't want to advance)?

The "utility" of the criticism is quite obviously that the event is highly relevant for understanding the perspective of the Palestinian people, who didn't quite like having their lands forcibly depopulated, so one can understand why they'd be a tad pissed off. See specifically how it's relevant for understanding people?

You, on the other hand, do not seem capable to consider it other than "how bad it makes Israel look" and then see the need to respond with "good things Israel did".

If you know enough about it, then you should know enough to have an easy example or two of justified use of force by Israel.

I don't care. If you want to share examples of things you consider appropriate that Israel did, you are free to do so. If they have no other relevancy than showing that the state of Israel can also do "good things" (or "bad things" at that) I'll just consider them noise like I always do.

From where I sit, the state of Israel, like any other state, is an amoral abstract entity. Establishing "character traits" for it is pointless, it, again like any other state, simply does as much as it can get away with. If you really need to know, I personally consider the primary function of the state, of Israel or otherwise, to be to uphold class society and hence illegitimate in general. Though that's a topic for another thread.
 
The "utility" of the criticism is quite obviously that the event is highly relevant for understanding the perspective of the Palestinian people, who didn't quite like having their lands forcibly depopulated, so one can understand why they'd be a tad pissed off. See specifically how it's relevant for understanding people?

You, on the other hand, do not seem capable to consider it other than "how bad it makes Israel look" and then see the need to respond with "good things Israel did".


You're not trying to make Israel look bad, but this is important because it makes Israel look bad? Who argues that the Palestinians shouldn't be pissed, that it is not understandable why they would be upset?

But let's apply your logic to the rocket attacks again then. Again, your own logic. It's important to understand why the Israeli people would be pissed, if people are firing rockets at them. So why does your reasoning only stack against Israel and for the Palestinians again?



I don't care. If you want to share examples of things you consider appropriate that Israel did, you are free to do so. If they have no other relevancy than showing that the state of Israel can also do "good things" (or "bad things" at that) I'll just consider them noise like I always do.

From where I sit, the state of Israel, like any other state, is an amoral abstract entity. Establishing "character traits" for it is pointless, it, again like any other state, simply does as much as it can get away with. If you really need to know, I personally consider the primary function of the state, of Israel or otherwise, to be to uphold class society and hence illegitimate in general. Though that's a topic for another thread.


Your hand wave here is tedious. I've already explained why it would be important to establish what you think a legitimate use of force is and that Israel can sometimes be justified in it. We need to find where we agree and why to work out how to apply that understanding to other events. My sharing times I think they were justified wouldn't do that. You still refuse and have ignored my other points again.

Your assessment is that I'm only concerned about good guys and bad, and can only think about if something makes Israel look bad is unsupported and ridiculous. I've already criticized Israel many times including recently. This only supports my assessment that you are not interested in arguing in good faith.
 
It's important to understand why the Israeli people would be pissed, if people are firing rockets at them.

I couldn't agree more. See, now we're getting somewhere, you're talking about Israeli people rather than the state. One can then even discuss things like "is the state actually reducing those rocket attacks and hence acting in the interest of those people who are rightfully pissed?"

So why does your reasoning only stack against Israel and for the Palestinians again?

Because one is a bit of a rogue state and the other are people. Other than that, there is no stacking.

I've already explained why it would be important to establish what you think a legitimate use of force is and that Israel can sometimes be justified in it.

Unless there's a relevant point to be made here, no it is not important. Israel, like any other state, is always justified in legitimate use of force given that that's pretty much what "legitimate" means. One can argue about what constitutes legitimate force, and I'm sure that for every definition instances of Israel doing it can be found, but unless you're going to argue that the instances of use of force that were actually brought up were legitimate, it's just not all that relevant.
 
No it isn't. The overwhelming majority of rockets are fired during major hostilities. You ought to be interested in the numbers if you want a solid understanding of the situation, or even the appearance of such.

Furthermore, I am still not interested in your attempts to imbue a state, Israel or otherwise, with moral agency. It doesn't matter whether it did a "good thing" once or not. You are, in good animist tradition, confusing "understanding" with "projection".
What is an "overwhelming majority of rockets"? 51%, 60%? That still leaves a sizable amount of rockets the Palestinians fired prior to major hostilities. Is Israel supposed to just ignore them? They put up the Iron Dome for a reason. What was that reason?
 
What is an "overwhelming majority of rockets"? 51%, 60%? That still leaves a sizable amount of rockets the Palestinians fired prior to major hostilities. Is Israel supposed to just ignore them? They put up the Iron Dome for a reason. What was that reason?

Of the 4007 rockets fired at Israel in 2014, 3884 were fired during the hostilities (=97%). Of the 8 people killed by Palestinian rocket fire in 2014, 8 were killed during the hostilities (=100%).

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Palestinian_rocket_attacks_on_Israel,_2014

ETA: just to be clear, I'm only counting major Israeli assaults here (the ones that get names, "Operation this or that"). Not the semi-regular minor assaults and military incursions.
 
Last edited:
So it is like totes cool to fire over a hundred rockets at Israel just for ***s and giggles? Could I do that towards your house?
 
There are other years than 2014. A quick look suggests the Palestinians have been lobbing rockets for quite a while now. But that's cool, 'cause they suck at aiming.
 
Your statement about the "refusal to acknowledge Israel's right to exist" is right there in your post, anyone can check that. So I asked you to support this "right to exist" that, apparently, you think needs to be acknowledged. But of course only a handwave came as a response.

Yes, I certainly did reference the "right to exist." In context, it had to do with "gaining and losing land" because of war. Indeed, had the Arabs not gambled with military force repeatedly because they refused to accept Israel's "right to exist," they wouldn't have lost land via war. What's more, if they were willing in more recent days to accept it, it would have been a huge step forward towards a viable solution to the problems in the region. Not the only one necessary, sure, but a big one. Furthermore, Israel's repeatedly shown that they can be willing to "return" land to the Arabs, much as they have also shown that they're not going to just trust the Arabs blindly. Part of that involves the Arabs finally admitting that Israel has a "right to exist."

That does not equate with me actually caring whether they exist in the first place, nor does the point have pretty much anything to do with your attempts to get me to demonstrate that Israel has a "right to exist." I may as well ask you to demonstrate that Palestine has the "right to exist" for all the complete lack of relevance that tangent would have. The closest thing to a point there is that I think that, when it comes to border agreements in current times, both sides need to acknowledge that the other is a legitimate entity as one part of avoiding nearly inevitable war, with the note that Israel has demonstrated that it's overwhelmingly better at war than the Arab countries have demonstrated.


I've been responding to the literal statements you have made.

By trying to change the topic to entirely irrelevant tangents.



"trying to insinuate"? You do not seem able to distinguish between what is actually said and what your interpretation of it is. You responded to my statement about the US or Australia as a homeland with 2 things. That it is "less desirable" and that there is no "cultural connection". I've addressed both as to why they are not valid counterarguments.

Huh. Odd. It seems like your accusation of being unable to distinguish is just a pathetic smokescreen to hide your own inability. In context, you managed to make it look exactly like you were accusing me of saying what I objected to. Furthermore, your attempts at refutation are, frankly, a bit bewildering in how terrible they are. The "less desirable" for the quality of the land is such because that arose from you trying to claim that they should go somewhere where no one else was really inhabiting. Such land does, in fact, tend to be quite undesirable, or it would be being used, for the most part. Then you brought up that Israel was mostly desert, which is true, but ignores the circumstances of why it's mostly desert. At last check, the desert was, more than anything else, an opportunistic land grab during negotiations specifically because of the very low population there. In other words, trying to use that as a counter is distinctly misleading, at best, and really doesn't address the essence of the point actually made, at all. To add to that and address your "and", I didn't say that the land would necessarily be less desirable, but in context, if it also fit the rest of the qualities that you suggested for it, it probably would be, which is still true. That's just dealing with quality of the land itself, though, before getting to the rest of the relevant features. Having a country completely surrounded by and landlocked in Brazil, for example, has a number of political implications that tend to be a bit undesirable separate from the quality of the land itself. As for your strange way of trying to twist the meaning of cultural connections, cultural connections quite validly serve as a rallying point for a group of people to try to work together to accomplish some goal. Saying that Israel should exist because some book says so is a dumb argument from the start, frankly, yes, but pointing out that that is a dumb argument while ignoring the reasons why it does exist and treating that as a refutation is similarly dumb. Israel exists because a group of people banded together, worked together, and dealt with other groups well enough to make their goals a reality. The cultural connections only can really be validly considered motivation, honestly. Referencing the Arabs then, like you did, when the only valid point there is about the motivation of the Jews to accomplish their goals is irrelevant.



So not only are you interpreting a statement in a way that is not necessarily determined by that statement, you even notice the obvious problem with your interpretation yet still go with it anyway.

More like, you're failing at making valid arguments all the way through. It's uncertain, in this case, though, whether that's because you're trolling or because your immense demonstrated bias is getting in your way and forcing you to fight strawmen.


That's utter nonsense. I've provided the map progression as a quick reference point for the loss of Palestinian land, in context of the comparison between Israel and the US in terms of colonizing a region already inhabited by a native population. The moment the maps were challenged I provided the data underlying them. From that moment on the data should've been used as reference rather than the maps (which are always, by their nature, inaccurate at some level). But no, pages and pages of going on about the maps where, if you try really hard, you may even find a white spot that should be green instead.

Interestingly, I wasn't referencing that, much as your claim here is still easily demonstrated to be :rolleyes: by the fact that you brought it up as a counter to the fact that Palestine wasn't politically a country and you've utterly failed, both then and since, to justify your use of it as such... or as what you're trying to claim it was used for now... or otherwise, frankly, given that there's really been no argument at all regarding the point that the Palestinians have lost a lot of land. In particular, though, what I was referencing was when, while the point in question was about the ongoing change in land ownership after the major change at the beginning of Israel's existence and there was agreement that Israel has indeed continued taking land where Palestinians were living, you responded by giving evidence of the change in land ownership at the beginning of Israel's existence, which, frankly, was entirely irrelevant to the line of conversation, like so very many of your "points" have been.
 
Last edited:
There are other years than 2014. A quick look suggests the Palestinians have been lobbing rockets for quite a while now. But that's cool, 'cause they suck at aiming.

In similar spirit to this, though, it's worth mentioning again that Hamas, despite their other serious issues, did indeed largely stop the rockets from Gaza for a couple years prior to the recent conflict and was not endorsing their use, at least some of the time. Blaming the Palestinians in general for all of the rockets is not really reflective of reality. caveman1917 is correct on the point that the overwhelming portion of the rockets have been fired during states of conflict in recent years at last check. Still, wikipedia also has numbers for other years if you'd like to look, much as it doesn't do as good of a job at distinguishing between those fired while under normal conditions or official conflict.
 
Last edited:
Indeed, had the Arabs not gambled with military force repeatedly because they refused to accept Israel's "right to exist," they wouldn't have lost land via war.

By my count, about a million Palestinians (or "Arabs" as you call them) lost land via war. Can you show how many of these "gambled with military force repeatedly"?

Interestingly, I wasn't referencing that, much as your claim here is still easily demonstrated to be :rolleyes: by the fact that you brought it up as a counter to the fact that Palestine wasn't politically a country and you've utterly failed, both then and since, to justify your use of it as such...

If you think the map progression can be invalidated solely because it's possible to not consider Palestine a country (as a few members of the international community do), then why did you have no problem going along with the obvious interpretation that the word "occupying" in "occupying someone else's country" was the relevant one rather than "country"? You did argue against it on that basis, after all.

or as what you're trying to claim it was used for now...

:rolleyes: ->
1. They are occupying someone else's country, putting those people in refugee camps and settling their lands. Basically the story of the US and the Native Americans, so that checks out.

People have memories you know.
 
Not from the post I responded to.

No, just in the thread you responded to.

Not my job.

Reading the thread? Sure it is.

Your claims, your responsibility.

Except that's not what you did though, is it? You simply assumed a ridiculous interpretation for "overwhelming majority" (seriously, who the hell thinks "overwhelming majority" means 51-60%?) to then use that to make your own irrelevant claim about a "sizeable" number of them.
 
No it isn't. The overwhelming majority of rockets are fired during major hostilities. You ought to be interested in the numbers if you want a solid understanding of the situation, or even the appearance of such.

Furthermore, I am still not interested in your attempts to imbue a state, Israel or otherwise, with moral agency. It doesn't matter whether it did a "good thing" once or not. You are, in good animist tradition, confusing "understanding" with "projection".
The quote I responded to. Note the complete lack of citations. Why do you make things up?
 
The quote I responded to. Note the complete lack of citations.

Yes, we all know about the complete lack of citations for a known fact already established earlier in the thread.

Why do you make things up?

:rolleyes:

Let's take a look:

What is an "overwhelming majority of rockets"? 51%, 60%? That still leaves a sizable amount of rockets the Palestinians fired prior to major hostilities.

The last sentence uses the previous one as a premise. The previous one is a ridiculous interpretation of the quote in the first sentence. Note how, specifically, such an interpretation gets chosen so as to "substantiate" the claim in the last sentence. Also note how the claim in the last sentence isn't even relevant to the claim whether Israeli actions operate so as to reduce rocket attacks, it is merely trying to justify them. Lastly, no citations are provided for this claim about a "sizable amount", not is it clear what "sizable" means. Although it would indeed be interesting if you'd want to list and compare the ordinance flying both ways inbetween major hostilities. I'm not holding my breath though.
 
We already know that Hamas fires rockets at Israel indiscriminately. We also know that Israel will eventually get sick of it and fight back. Wen they do, Hamas has no choice but to launch everything they have because Israel will take out everything they can.
We also already know that Hamas has absolutely no problem firing those rockets (exactly why do they have so many rockets in the first place?) while hiding behind the skirts of their women and the playgrounds of their children, welcoming their deaths for some disgusting PR campaign.

Play whatever silly semantic games you like. You need to because your position is untenable.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom