tyr_13
Penultimate Amazing
- Joined
- Aug 8, 2008
- Messages
- 18,095
Why don't you tell us, you're the one who brought up Israeli ordinance? I set out to show that the overwhelming majority of rockets are fired as a direct result of Israeli actions and hence Israel is not factually acting so as to reduce the rocket attacks but so as to perpetuate them.
I'm asking you what the rocket attacks against Israel being mostly during times of conflict tell us. At least you finally explained that!
I brought up the Israeli ordinance being overwhelming during times of conflict to show, that by your own reasoning and evidence, your exact same criticism of Israel applies to Hamas.
Again, I don't agree with that reasoning, but as you do you should attempt to reconcile how this criticism doesn't apply to Hamas but does to Israel. I criticize both for this.
You search for examples of actions by the state of Israel on the basis that it did a "good thing", with no further relevance to any of the actions we were considering. There is no other purpose to this other than to imbue the state of Israel with a moral quality ("it isn't so bad, it does good things too"). Apparently failing to grasp that I'm not arguing that Israel is "bad", but that its actions don't correspond to the explanation provided for them.
No, just, no. That's not what I'm doing and that is not the purpose. I'm trying to establish that you do agree that Israel has been correct in using force before so we can move on from if Israel can ever use force legitimately to establishing grounds for evaluating if any given use is legitimate.
You're making a straw man of my arguments and drawing inferences that simply aren't there.
I don't recall saying that Israel shouldn't exist. I only recall some criticism of depopulating a region against the consent of the local population and then colonizing it. Could you provide a quote?
If that action hadn't been taken, Israel wouldn't exist. That is exactly arguing that Israel shouldn't exist. You even suggested other places it should have existed if it wanted to, which is all besides the point that it exists now where it is currently. Unless you want it moved or to stop existing, what is your point? What is the utility of the criticism (besides advancing your dreaded 'Israel is bad' argument, that you don't want to advance)?
I know enough about the event and what happened subsequently with the land. I just don't feel the need to indulge in your hobby of "criticizing the Palestinians or agreeing with the Israeli just because we can".
See above. If you know enough about it, then you should know enough to have an easy example or two of justified use of force by Israel. Dang, it shouldn't be this difficult to establish this, and in the process also show you are willing to occasionally agree. If you absolutely refuse to agree clearly on anything, well, that's pretty much all one needs to show to establish that you aren't arguing in good faith.
Yeah, that must be it. Why would anyone discussing this in good faith not want to participate in "let's find things we can agree with Israel on and then claim we're so not imbuing moral qualities on a state"?
It must be a mystery.
Because you're not discussing this in good faith. Not a real mystery. There could be many reasons for this, including getting caught up in the adversarial sentiments these types of discussions foster. So why don't you have another go at it?