Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Wouldn't matter.

Of course it would. And even if it didn't matter from a legal perspective, which it does, it still matters from a factual one.

Allowing illegal combatants to use your territory as a base from which to lauch attacks on a neighbouring state is still contrary to international law.

1. You require evidence that they were "allowing" it. Evidence was earlier presented that they were actively preventing it. Barring counter-evidence, and given that rocket attacks by individuals or groups were likely (due to continued Palestinian casualties) and rare over the time period considered, I'll assume they were not "allowing" it. At least not to a degree such that establishing who fired the rockets wouldn't matter.

2. Even if you can show this, if you are interested in violations of international law, why don't you present a timed list of them by both sides?
 
Of course it would. And even if it didn't matter from a legal perspective, which it does, it still matters from a factual one.



1. You require evidence that they were "allowing" it. Evidence was earlier presented that they were actively preventing it. Barring counter-evidence, and given that rocket attacks by individuals or groups were likely (due to continued Palestinian casualties) and rare over the time period considered, I'll assume they were not "allowing" it. At least not to a degree such that establishing who fired the rockets wouldn't matter.

2. Even if you can show this, if you are interested in violations of international law, why don't you present a timed list of them by both sides?


To 'allow' (why the quotes?) something like that, Hamas need simply do nothing. It's hard to cite something like that. 'Here is a picture of Hamas doing nothing.' Would that suffice as evidence? Because of that little problem, one would have to show what they are doing to prevent the rocket attacks. Otherwise the default assumption is they are doing nothing, or nothing that could be noticed.

So what would Hamas trying to prevent rocket attacks look like? Well, as for Hamas trying to prevent things, they do round up people and execute them without trial for protesting against Hamas, or being 'collaborators' (despite being held for more than two years, they somehow 'collaborate' with Israel offensives weeks old...), then dump the bodies in hospitals to be counted as civilians killed by Israel, so that's a good base line for Hamas trying to prevent something. As demonstrating against Hamas must be a much lesser crime than firing rockets, where are those executed for firing rockets?

(For those actually interested, Hamas has at times tried to prevent rocket attacks, you know, when they aren't carrying them out themselves, justifying them or making statues honoring them.)
 
To 'allow' (why the quotes?)

Because it's a stretchable concept without a clear definition.

Because of that little problem, one would have to show what they are doing to prevent the rocket attacks.

This was already provided long ago, but here is some of it again:

IDF source: Hamas working to stop Gaza rockets

Otherwise the default assumption is they are doing nothing, or nothing that could be noticed

Refusing to update your "default assumption" in light of contradictory evidence is not a valid line of reasoning.

So what would Hamas trying to prevent rocket attacks look like?

Let's take a look, shall we? From the source above:
jpost said:
A Salafi official told the newspaper that his group refused to comply with the cease-fire agreement and would continue firing rockets at Israel. The Hamas government arrested Salafi jihadists who claimed responsibility for rocket fire at Israel, the paper reported.

The rest of your claims all require evidence.
 
Self evident? As in, "Camping at Marine World is fun for all in tents and porpoises."?
 
Self evident and contradicted by the evidence that is. About as "self evident" as 2+2=5
 
Last edited:
Because it's a stretchable concept without a clear definition.



This was already provided long ago, but here is some of it again:

IDF source: Hamas working to stop Gaza rockets



Refusing to update your "default assumption" in light of contradictory evidence is not a valid line of reasoning.



Let's take a look, shall we? From the source above:


The rest of your claims all require evidence.


You didn't read my entire post or click the links did you?

At any rate, this link should cover all the claims that weren't directly covered in the previous links.
 
You didn't read my entire post or click the links did you?

I did. There was nothing there to suggest that Hamas wasn't preventing rocket attacks, which they - being Gaza's government - were required to do.

At any rate, this link should cover all the claims that weren't directly covered in the previous links.

Not quite. For instance, you claimed that Hamas (after public executions of some people) put bodies in hospitals to be counted as civilians killed by Israel. Your source doesn't suggest this claim to be true. Nor is there any a priori reason to need an alternative explanation for why bodies get put in the morgue. Furthermore the claim seems pointless as we're talking about less than 1% of the civilians who got killed in the conflict. So again, can you provide evidence?
 
Last edited:
I did. There was nothing there to suggest that Hamas wasn't preventing rocket attacks, which they - being Gaza's government - were required to do.

Apart from the ones they carried out, and built monuments for? And the force they sent to prevent attacks during a month long 'crackdown' walking off the job?

If they are earnestly trying to prevent more rocket attacks, their efforts are both out of line with their other enforcement methods and failing badly.



Not quite. For instance, you claimed that Hamas (after public executions of some people) put bodies in hospitals to be counted as civilians killed by Israel.

Well here you go. This should help with more sources too. But to clarify, not all were publicly executed. Many were tortured in a hospital used by Hamas for military purposes before being killed, then added to the numbers of civilians killed by Israeli attacks.

Your source doesn't suggest this claim to be true. Nor is there any a priori reason to need an alternative explanation for why bodies get put in the morgue. Furthermore the claim seems pointless as we're talking about less than 1% of the civilians who got killed in the conflict. So again, can you provide evidence?

Oh, well, less than 1%, that makes it alright to torture and murder then and does not indicate the type of preventative measures Hamas uses. This handwave is unconvincing and your characterization of them simply being 'taken to the morgue' ridiculous.
 
Apart from the ones they carried out

Evidence?

Well here you go. This should help with more sources too. But to clarify, not all were publicly executed. Many were tortured in a hospital used by Hamas for military purposes before being killed, then added to the numbers of civilians killed by Israeli attacks.

Your source is to a newspaper article behind a paywall. Again: evidence?

Oh, well, less than 1%, that makes it alright to torture and murder then and does not indicate the type of preventative measures Hamas uses.

:rolleyes:
Just stop that nonsense already.

This handwave is unconvincing and your characterization of them simply being 'taken to the morgue' ridiculous.

Fine, where were they taken to? The stairwell? The balcony? Simply left where they were lying?
 
Evidence?



Your source is to a newspaper article behind a paywall. Again: evidence?

I've already linked to it. Try the second link now.



:rolleyes:
Just stop that nonsense already.

You first. Stop straw manning my points and stop bringing your straw man statements back in line with my points. What does the deaths being 1% of the civilians killed have to do with what I was saying? How does it negate what I was saying. It doesn't unless you were arguing what I said, that it's alright that they do it and not indicative of how far they will go to stop something. If you're not trying to argue that, then explain how your hand wave should be taken any other way.

As of now my point stands. Hamas doesn't do enough to stop rocket attacks, justifies rocket attacks, glorifies rocket attacks, and commits rocket attacks. Their efforts to stop the attacks are completely out of line with their other enforcement methods of far lesser offenses. Their efforts are incompetent, disingenuous, or both.



Fine, where were they taken to? The stairwell? The balcony? Simply left where they were lying?


What are you talking about? My objection wasn't they they weren't or shouldn't be taken to the morgue. Them being taken to the morgue isn't part of any point I was making, and your spinning it as just 'being taken to the morgue' was bad enough. Now you're going to double down and take your straw man of my post even further by pretending I was objecting to location.

As a side note, your care for the Palestinian people suddenly dries up when it's Hamas killing protestors, as indicated by your flippant dismissal of those rounded up, tortured, and shot. At least say it's a horrible thing before calling it 'pointless' to talk about.
 
And in other news, daesh are vying for control of Gaza with Hamas. Ouch.

Crap, really? A new move in that direction?

EDIT: Damnit, yup. A new video from them threatening to overthrow Hamas because they haven't fully implemented Islamic law, oppress the people of Gaza, and having killed the Jews and secularist fast enough. If support rises enough with for Daesh (Isis), then the troubles between Hamas and Fatah could look like a cakewalk. Oh, and Daesh hates Fatah too. Interesting times.
 
Last edited:
Crap, really? A new move in that direction?

EDIT: Damnit, yup. A new video from them threatening to overthrow Hamas because they haven't fully implemented Islamic law, oppress the people of Gaza, and having killed the Jews and secularist fast enough. If support rises enough with for Daesh (Isis), then the troubles between Hamas and Fatah could look like a cakewalk. Oh, and Daesh hates Fatah too. Interesting times.

Don't worry, someone will figure out a way to blame this on the Jews.
 
I've already linked to it.

Ok then, please quote the relevant part of the article where this is claimed.

Try the second link now.

Stop pretending as if that is a separate source, it simply links back to your first link.

You first. Stop straw manning my points and stop bringing your straw man statements back in line with my points. What does the deaths being 1% of the civilians killed have to do with what I was saying? How does it negate what I was saying.

It negates one of the two reasons they may have for getting the deaths "counted as Israeli victims", namely that they were trying to get the death toll up (the number is too insignificant to have much effect on the total death toll of the conflict). The other reason they may have, to hide what they did, is negated by them publicly admitting to it and sometimes even announcing it.

All in all, there does not seem much to support your contention that they were trying to get them counted as Israeli victims.

and commits rocket attacks

You've yet to provide any evidence for this (during the ceasefire, which was the scope under consideration) even after being asked several times.

What are you talking about?

Isn't it obvious? There's a much simpler explanation for why these bodies were dumped at the hospital's morgue than your unsupported notion about "wanting them to get counted as Israeli victims". The simple explanation being "have body" & "funeral services not operating during military conflict" -> "body taken to morgue".

As a side note, your care for the Palestinian people suddenly dries up when it's Hamas killing protestors, as indicated by your flippant dismissal of those rounded up, tortured, and shot.

Whether you're doing it subconsciously or deliberately, I don't know, but it's seriously getting annoying. It's exactly the same tactic used by Monbiot in his debate with Chomsky.

At least say it's a horrible thing before calling it 'pointless' to talk about.

:rolleyes:
 
Antisemitism is your specialty, haven't come up with anything yet?

Bwahahahahahaha!

Yes, caveman, *I'm* the antisemite. I think Israel should be allowed to protect itself against genocidal terrorists, but you don't. That obviously means that I hate the Jews, and you love them.

What a sad, strange place the inside of your head must be.
 
Yes, caveman, *I'm* the antisemite.

Of course you are. You hand wave away any valid criticism of a certain state by crying "antisemitism!". By this obvious abuse of the term you lead people reading it to associate Jews with these sort of tactics. You're ensuring that people will leave with more negative connotations associated with Jews than they came in with. Yes, zig, you are the antisemite.
 
Last edited:
Of course you are. You hand wave away any valid criticism of a certain state by crying "antisemitism!".

First, the claim that misuse of the term "antisemitism" makes me antisemitic is logically nonsensical. It makes no bloody sense. That's like saying that if you call people fat who aren't fat, that means that you're fat. No.

Second, I most certainly haven't hand waved away any valid criticism of Israel by crying "antisemitism!" I've largely stuck to pointing out the flaws in your criticism, which brings up the third point: your criticism is, for the most part, NOT valid.

By this obvious abuse of the term you lead people reading it to associate Jews with these sort of tactics. You're ensuring that people will leave with more negative connotations associated with Jews than they came in with. Yes, zig, you are the antisemite.

Next you'll be telling us all about the invisible lesbian Israeli robots.
 
First, the claim that misuse of the term "antisemitism" makes me antisemitic is logically nonsensical. It makes no bloody sense. That's like saying that if you call people fat who aren't fat, that means that you're fat. No.

No, it's like saying that if you call people fat who aren't fat, that means people will think you're a liar. Doing this in the name of Jews then makes people associate Jews with liars. Even if you don't self-identify as antisemitical, you're sure doing their job for them.

Second, I most certainly haven't hand waved away any valid criticism of Israel by crying "antisemitism!"

->
The fact that I can't convince antisemites to not be antisemitic is not an argument in favor of being antisemitic.

your criticism is, for the most part, NOT valid.

Well no criticism of Israel could ever be valid, right? It's all antisemitism after all.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom