Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
No, it's like saying that if you call people fat who aren't fat, that means people will think you're a liar. Doing this in the name of Jews

I'm not doing this in the name of Jews. I never claimed to be doing it in the name of Jews. This is your own weird obsessive invention, and gives us insight into the sort of person you are (paranoid, conspiratorial, prone to accusations of guilt by association - I wonder where we see that sort of behavior?). I've said consistently from the start that I'm arguing from a perspective of American interests.

Even if you don't self-identify as antisemitical, you're sure doing their job for them.

Again, the irony of this accusation coming from a defender of Hamas is quite the spectacle.

Well no criticism of Israel could ever be valid, right? It's all antisemitism after all.

Not at all. But the existence of valid criticism doesn't make YOUR criticism valid.
 
Ok then, please quote the relevant part of the article where this is claimed.



Stop pretending as if that is a separate source, it simply links back to your first link.

Sorry, I didn't check to see that it was another one.



It negates one of the two reasons they may have for getting the deaths "counted as Israeli victims", namely that they were trying to get the death toll up (the number is too insignificant to have much effect on the total death toll of the conflict). The other reason they may have, to hide what they did, is negated by them publicly admitting to it and sometimes even announcing it.

All in all, there does not seem much to support your contention that they were trying to get them counted as Israeli victims.

Your reasoning is faulty in the top paragraph. This assumes that Hamas officials are all on the same page, that their actions would appear rational from an outside observer (even though internal factors might mean their actions are rational, but appear irrational from the outside), and that their actions would actually be rational. Besides that, it would mean they could know ahead of time that the 30-40 people they murdered would be insignificant to the total number for some people. I doubt you would call 30-40 killed by Israel during the same conflict to be 'insignificant' and in fact others defending Hamas have made a great deal out of a smaller number of deaths.

If you don't want to accept the claim that they were added to the war dead because of a lack of a site you can read, that's fine though and not bad reasoning. However, it doesn't change the fact that that specific detail is immaterial to my point.



You've yet to provide any evidence for this (during the ceasefire, which was the scope under consideration) even after being asked several times.

Well you could always read the Wikipedia page I linked to, but here you go.



Isn't it obvious? There's a much simpler explanation for why these bodies were dumped at the hospital's morgue than your unsupported notion about "wanting them to get counted as Israeli victims". The simple explanation being "have body" & "funeral services not operating during military conflict" -> "body taken to morgue".


I take your ignoring and cutting out my main point to mean that you concede it then?



Whether you're doing it subconsciously or deliberately, I don't know, but it's seriously getting annoying. It's exactly the same tactic used by Monbiot in his debate with Chomsky.

If he so flippantly handwaved the murders, then he should expect to be right called out for it. I don't care to investigate your accusation.





You refuse to even obliquely criticize these murders or even allow others in passing to do so. It should not surprise you that others take umbrage at this and question the strength of your caring for the Palestinians. If that was your main motivation, you would not behave so. Perhaps it once was and you've become lost along the way, but you should reflect on it in any case.
 
Sorry, I didn't check to see that it was another one.

Can you provide the requested quote or not?

Your reasoning is faulty in the top paragraph. This assumes that Hamas officials are all on the same page, that their actions would appear rational from an outside observer (even though internal factors might mean their actions are rational, but appear irrational from the outside), and that their actions would actually be rational.

Actually you are the one claiming that the reason for their actions was so as to get them counted as Israeli victims.

If you don't want to accept the claim that they were added to the war dead because of a lack of a site you can read, that's fine though and not bad reasoning.

Why are you changing your claim? Your claim wasn't that they were added to the war dead but that this was the reason for dropping them at the hospital's morgue.

However, it doesn't change the fact that that specific detail is immaterial to my point.

You make a set of claims, some of which unsupported and/or false. You associate all of these claims with Hamas, thereby leaving anyone with two options. Either let the unsupported/false claims stand, or put themselves in a position so that you can paint them as "Hamas defenders". You then try to get this fallacious interpretation to be accepted by directly stating it and implicitly assuming it in further claims, choosing your terms so as to have that effect. Such as:

I take your ignoring and cutting out my main point to mean that you concede it then?

Your use of the term "concede" implies that there ever was debate about any of those other points, which I had to be "convinced" about and initially didn't support. This again reinforces your notion that the source of my stance was "defense of Hamas" (ie I had objected to all your claims but had to "concede" all but one of them).

Furthermore, there is nothing to "concede" since your "main point" was irrelevant. As such:

Well you could always read the Wikipedia page I linked to, but here you go.

We all know Hamas fired rockets during the conflict, the question was whether they fired them before the conflict.

If he so flippantly handwaved the murders, then he should expect to be right called out for it.

It wasn't about these murders specifically.

I don't care to investigate your accusation.

What accusation? About employing a debating tactic? I didn't even claim you were doing it consciously, not much of an accusation, no?

You refuse to even obliquely criticize these murders

Maybe you should go ahead and read that Monbiot-Chomsky debate after all.

or even allow others in passing to do so.

You mean smuggling in unsupported and false claims by abusing people's unwillingness to be painted as "Hamas defenders"?

It should not surprise you that others take umbrage at this and question the strength of your caring for the Palestinians.

Nothing much surprises me anymore around here :)
 
Last edited:
I'm not doing this in the name of Jews.

Then why did you bring them into it?

paranoid, conspiratorial, prone to accusations of guilt by association - I wonder where we see that sort of behavior?

Your posts for instance. Really want me to point them out?

But the existence of valid criticism doesn't make YOUR criticism valid.

Do you have any criticism for the 3 things you raised the "Antisemitism!" defense to?
1. The depopulation and colonization of the natives living there.
2. Racial segregation in the occupied territories.
3. Israel's record with respect to international law.

If not, do you have any criticism of Israel at all?
 
Gee, I wonder why Jews might have something to do with a thread about Israel... :confused:

Weren't you the one claiming that Israel was a "multicultural society"? Also, only half of the Jewish population lives in Israel. Furthermore, even of those that live in Israel, several will be critical of their state just like in any other country. Yet, when a criticism of Israel is made you turn it into a criticism of Jews specifically (ie against the group defined by this particular religion, rather than the group defined by support for the actions of Israel that were criticized, a group that may - and likely does - include people of various religions, nationalities, gender, dexterity, hair color, or whatever else you may think is a relevant attribute).

In doing this, you change the debate by pretending that it is a criticism of Jews, you thereby then implicitly, if not explicitly, position yourself as "defending Jews" simply by framing the debate in that fashion. This not only cheapens the concept of antisemitism, which otherwise is a real problem, you are associating these - quite deplorable - debating tricks with Jews by that choice of framing the debate.
 
Last edited:
Weren't you the one claiming that Israel was a "multicultural society"?

Not that I recall.

Also, only half of the Jewish population lives in Israel.

And the relevance of that statement to anything I've said is... ????

Furthermore, even of those that live in Israel, several will be critical of their state just like in any other country.

Again, so?

Yet, when a criticism of Israel is made you turn it into a criticism of Jews specifically

No, actually, I don't. I brought up antisemitism in regards to global opinion about Israel, because antisemitism is in fact prevalent in many places, and does in fact have a lot to do with global opinions of Israel. I did not bring it up as a generic defense against any and all criticism of Israel. That's your own peculiar obsession.

In doing this, you change the debate by pretending that it is a criticism of Jews, you thereby then implicitly, if not explicitly, position yourself as "defending Jews" simply by framing the debate in that fashion.

Except that "this" isn't what I'm actually doing, and you're being deeply dishonest about it.

This not only cheapens the concept of antisemitism, which otherwise is a real problem, you are associating these - quite deplorable - debating tricks with Jews by that choice of framing the debate.

You're the only person here trying to make that connection, caveman. And your priorities are seriously ****** up. You find debate tactics deplorable, but not actual terrorism and genocidal aspirations.
 
Can you provide the requested quote or not?

Not that will satisfy you, no.



Actually you are the one claiming that the reason for their actions was so as to get them counted as Israeli victims.

Um, no. You're misreading my claims and forgetting the entire point that I was bringing up and have restated twice now. More on that below.



Why are you changing your claim? Your claim wasn't that they were added to the war dead but that this was the reason for dropping them at the hospital's morgue.

You're focusing on a small section with inexact wording. I don't know if you're confused or doing this to avoid the main point. The people were not murdered simply to add to the body count, and that was never my claim. That they were added to the body count was never my main point, and doesn't change my main point. It also doesn't change the other objectionable things, such as them being killed without due processes, tortured, the hospital they were tortured in being used for military purposes, etc.



You make a set of claims, some of which unsupported and/or false. You associate all of these claims with Hamas, thereby leaving anyone with two options. Either let the unsupported/false claims stand, or put themselves in a position so that you can paint them as "Hamas defenders". You then try to get this fallacious interpretation to be accepted by directly stating it and implicitly assuming it in further claims, choosing your terms so as to have that effect. Such as:

Simply put, no. You seem very, very confused. Furthermore, those are not the only options in any case. Challenging part of what I said doesn't mean you have to reject all of it, and obviously because much of what I've said is well evidenced and cited, and of course very objectionable acts on the part of Hamas, one could easily agree with those criticisms of Hamas while still disagreeing with others. Notably, this is exactly what I do with criticism of Israel. Some are valid and I both don't object to them, and tend to agree and explain why. I've at least mentioned them. I certainly don't pointedly avoid answering them when directly asked and go off accusing those asking of trying to paint them in a bad light.



Your use of the term "concede" implies that there ever was debate about any of those other points, which I had to be "convinced" about and initially didn't support. This again reinforces your notion that the source of my stance was "defense of Hamas" (ie I had objected to all your claims but had to "concede" all but one of them).

Furthermore, there is nothing to "concede" since your "main point" was irrelevant. As such:

As I said, you are confused. You previously objected to my main point, which as I've stated at least twice is that Hamas' measures to prevent rocket attacks are incompetent, disingenuous, or both. If they torture and murder people who aren't even collaborators, where are the arrests for rockets fired? There have been enough. No, we have the troops sent to prevent the rockets, and we have them walking off the job.



We all know Hamas fired rockets during the conflict, the question was whether they fired them before the conflict.

Wait, please be specific. Before you said during the ceasefire, which is why I then found and linked to them then. Now you mean from before the conflict? Which conflict? Which dates are you saying are the start?

Of course I could here claim you're trying to put me in a trap like you claimed I was doing before, but I'm just assuming you're using inexact language and it's confusing things.



It wasn't about these murders specifically.



What accusation? About employing a debating tactic? I didn't even claim you were doing it consciously, not much of an accusation, no?

That still constitutes an accusation, and I'm not sure why you think it doesn't.



Maybe you should go ahead and read that Monbiot-Chomsky debate after all.

Why?



You mean smuggling in unsupported and false claims by abusing people's unwillingness to be painted as "Hamas defenders"?



Nothing much surprises me anymore around here :)


You're not willing to be painted as a Hamas defender? Why? You can't even acknowledge that the torture and murder of 30-40 people is a bad thing, even if you don't believe it's important to what I was trying to support, but being a Hamas defender is such a slur? I've 'defended' Hamas before, and I've defended Israel. I'd say you are far more supportive of Hamas than Israel, and I don't much care if you'd rather say you support the Palestinian people than any government. It's not an inaccurate label, and neither is it a slur.
 
On the contrary, international law makes a clear distinction between combatants and civilians. Your persistent attempts at using the vague term "Arabs" to muddy the distinction is quite transparent and obvious. Again, you claimed the "Arabs" (ie the Palestinian civilian population) lost their land because they repeatedly used military force. No wonder you refuse to support such ridiculous notions.

Again, war isn't about individuals, either military or civilian. It's about political powers and the conditions between them. I use "Arabs" as a generality, yes, given that a number of different Arab political powers are the ones in question. Your persistent attempts to redefine things to that which would be convenient for your desired conclusions, rather than what they are, is mildly annoying, but expected at this point.

It demonstrated quite well the original claim.

If your original claim was merely that the Jews are inhabiting lands formerly controlled by Arabs, sure. It wasn't.

He said that it is because they have the same values as the US, I presented some obvious values that correspond well between the US and Israel.

You were trolling. Incredibly blatantly. You still are, with comments like this, though. All the more reason to not take you seriously.

You do realize that was not the claim made? I even quoted the claim again just a couple of posts ago, it shouldn't be that hard to find. It is just the usual copy-pasting of long-debunked Israeli propaganda that you get from people who refuse to fact check claims.

About that, could you show, on a map of the Gaza strip, where you think it should be done instead? Let's not forget that the Gaza strip is one of the regions with the highest population density in the world - 5000/km^2 - just behind Hong Kong (and without the high-rise buildings).

So, you're saying that they're not doing it... And then you ask where else they even could do it? That's a fine and coherent refutation there. So fine that there's no point even treating it seriously at all.
 
:rolleyes:

I'd just like to see the non-residential areas where Aridas thinks they should return fire from instead.

Your question is fundamentally disingenuous, given that you're assuming that military sites and bases could not be made or employed. I have no need to play such an idiotic game with you as to try to point fingers at specific areas.

As has been abundantly shown already:
1. Hamas hadn't launched any rockets at Israel for over a year before the Israeli assault on Gaza.

If you're talking about the relatively recent events, I seem to recall that the Israeli assault on Gaza happened after Hamas started launching large numbers of rockets. The West Bank was where the unjustified Israeli operation had been taking place which was used as justification for the rockets.

If you mean homemade rockets launched by individuals not affiliated with Hamas (aka the elected government of Gaza, which was party to the earlier ceasefire agreement), then consider the following. If someone in the US launches a rocket, you could either arrest this person or go bomb his neighborhood, what option is usually taken?

How many of the non-affiliated rockets actually earned a bombing in response? How many of those who fired non-affiliated rockets were arrested by Hamas?

I'm aware of a few of the latter, not so many of the former. Going beyond that, you're also trying to ignore quite a few important political aspects of the situation with your question. Again, though, that's no surprise, since you've insisted on trying to consistently ignore numerous aspects to fit your narrative the whole time you've been in the thread.
 
Last edited:
That's not the reasons those Christians give when they get to the US. They say it's because they don't like living under Israeli military rule and things like getting killed for violating curfews.

They suffer hardships that are equally suffered by Palestinian-Muslims. Unless someone is claiming Israel specifically targets Palestinian-Christians somehow, and I see nobody claiming that, then this narrative doesn't explain why the number of Palestinian-Christians is dropping in relation to the number of Palestinian-Muslims.

It’s not surprising that many of them repeat a narrative they are fed from birth; that all problems are caused by Israel, but that doesn’t make it a rational conclusion.

If Muslims are the problem and the Israeli army is so beneficial to the Christian villages they occupy, then why have the numbers of Christians in Jordan, Egypt, and Lebanon gone up?

The numbers of Christians in Jordan, Egypt and Lebanon have not gone up. That you proclaim this tells me you know very little.

Lebanon, in particular, was set up as a Christian majority nation. It’s constitution proclaims that its president must be a Christian, and it’s vice president must be Muslim. Over the last few decades it’s demographics have been changing and today it is majority Muslim.

http://www.bbc.com/news/world-middle-east-15239529

The highest share reported in the past century was in 1927, when the census found that 8.3% of Egyptians were Christians. In each of seven subsequent censuses, the Christian share of the population gradually shrank, ending at 5.7% in 1996. Religion data has not been made available from Egypt’s most recent census, conducted in 2006. But in a large, nationally representative 2008 survey — the Egyptian Demographic and Health Survey, conducted among 16,527 women ages 15 to 49 — about 5% of the respondents were Christian. Thus, the best available census and survey data indicate that Christians now number roughly 5% of the Egyptian population, or about 4 million people.

http://www.pewresearch.org/2011/02/16/how-many-christians-are-there-in-egypt/


Finally, it's a pretty big hole in the Israeli blaming of Muslims that the numbers of Christians in Israeli-pacified Jerusalem are actually decreasing while the numbers of Israelis there are increasing. Are you aware that it's practically impossible for Christians to get permits to build additions or houses there, and that when they do their homes get bulldozed? Meanwhile, if Palestinian Christians from East Jerusalem go abroad for 7 years they get their residency revoked so they can't return to live there again.

The homes that get bulldozed are the ones built without permits, and Christian Arabs are often the victims of Muslim Arabs building on their land when they are away. Arab residents of Jerusalem can apply to become Israeli citizens, which would eliminate the problem of losing residency after 7 years (how long should you be away before losing residency status?) but few take advantage of this because of political reasons.

from the Franciscan Website
http://www.ffhl.org/holy-land-franc...tian-schools-against-discriminatory-policies/

From the same Franciscan Website:

http://www.ffhl.org/holy-land-catho...-to-end-christian-persecution-in-middle-east/

http://www.ffhl.org/holy-land-franc...-east-and-stave-off-a-clash-of-civilizations/

http://www.ffhl.org/holy-land-franciscans-bbc-finally-awakens-to-war-on-middle-east-christians/

See? Looking just a little closer that the information that is available to you destroys the narrative you’re trying to push. You have to keep the blinders on and focus very carefully to maintain your narrative.

Basically, I grew up imagining that the Israeli government was running a tolerant democratic society, since it's a US ally (USS Liberty incident notwithstanding), and that it was fighting Muslim terrorism as its main enemy. However, when I found out about the treatment of Christians under Israeli rule from American Christian volunteers there it totally changed my perception. This includes of course discriminatory policies both in the Israeli state proper and their villages under harsh military rule in the territories. It turns out that they are running a political and social structure designed to drastically benefit their own group to the detriment of other religious groups under their rule.

The think about the internet is anyone can claim anything about their background. I think your statements about your own background are probably just as reliable as the “facts” you bring to the discussion.
 
Thank you for the summary. There seems to be plenty of anti-Palestinian people in these discussions, as well, and not a lot of middle ground.

I consider myself to be pro-Palestinian. I have noticed that those who are anti-Israel may talk a lot about Palestinian grievances, but they are not pro-Palestinian. That is, they are only interested in Palestinian suffering so long as it can be used as a political weapon against Israel.

Palestinians need peace. They need to be allowed to look forward to a future they can create for themselves rather than to be constantly forced to look backwards.
 
If you're talking about the relatively recent events, I seem to recall that the Israeli assault on Gaza happened after Hamas started launching large numbers of rockets.

Then you recall incorrectly.

I'm aware of a few of the latter, not so many of the former.

Then your awareness is off.

Again, though, that's no surprise, since you've insisted on trying to consistently ignore numerous aspects to fit your narrative the whole time you've been in the thread.

Sure, whatever.
 
I consider myself to be pro-Palestinian.

:rolleyes:

I can consider myself a Martian, doesn't make me so. You've specifically associated the use of the term "occupation" for an actual Israeli military occupation of Palestinian territories to be only by "rabid and venomous bigots". These would presumably include the judges of the Israeli supreme court, which has ordered the Israeli government to end its illegal occupation more than once?

Palestinians need peace. They need to be allowed to look forward to a future they can create for themselves rather than to be constantly forced to look backwards.

Bomb them regularly, killing thousands and destroying their homes, colonizing more pieces of their land, and when they complain say that they "shouldn't look backwards but forwards". The cynicism here is simply staggering.
 
Last edited:
:rolleyes:

I can consider myself a Martian, doesn't make me so. You've specifically associated the use of the term "occupation" for an actual Israeli military occupation of Palestinian territories to be only by "rabid and venomous bigots".

I did wut? I don't think so. You need better straw-men.


Bomb them regularly, killing thousands and destroying their homes, colonizing more pieces of their land, and when they complain say that they "shouldn't look backwards but forwards". The cynicism here is simply staggering.


If you portray the conflict as something Israel is doing to Palestinians, then you're wrong. There is a conflict between these two peoples, it will take efforts from both of them to resolve it.
 
I did wut? I don't think so. You need better straw-men.
->
They need to make up new definitions for old words such as apartheid, occupation, and even genocide just so they can use them against Israel.

That's called whitewashing.

If you portray the conflict as something Israel is doing to Palestinians, then you're wrong.

Not quite.

There is a conflict between these two peoples, it will take efforts from both of them to resolve it.

Except that one of these "two peoples" is under military occupation by the other.
 
Then you recall incorrectly.

On July 7th, 2014, Hamas assumed responsibility for 40 rockets fired into Israel (out of a total 100 rockets that came from Gaza at Israeli territory; other factions were also engaged in the rocketing)
HAMAS blamed Israel for an explosion that had occurred in a tunnel, although the IDF rejected categorically that it was a result of any military action on their part, and was a 'work accident' caused by the Palestinians who were using the tunnel to relay weaponry and IED's.

From 12 June through 5 July, 117 rockets had been launched from Gaza and there were approximately 80 Israeli retaliatory airstrikes on Gaza. (Just between 4 and 6 July, a total of 62 rockets were fired from Gaza, with the IAF attacking targets in Gaza to try and stop the barrage). Officially, the IDF was not undertaking a full-scale operation at that point -- only after July 7th did the upper echelons decide to go to war in an organized manner and Operation Protective Edge started.
 
Last edited:
HAMAS blamed Israel for an explosion that had occurred in a tunnel, although the IDF rejected categorically that it was a result of any military action on their part, and was a 'work accident' caused by the Palestinians who were using the tunnel to relay weaponry and IED's.

How many airstrikes did Israel perform that day (6 july) on Gaza? Does the IDF also deny their airstrikes on 29 june against Hamas?

From 12 June through 5 July, 117 rockets had been launched from Gaza and there were approximately 80 Israeli retaliatory airstrikes on Gaza.

So an average of 4 airstrikes per day? While Hamas was still arresting the perpetrators, before Israel decided to strike at Hamas directly?

Officially, the IDF was not undertaking a full-scale operation at that point -- only after July 7th did the upper echelons decide to go to war in an organized manner and Operation Protective Edge started.

It can say officially whatever it wants, its airstrikes on Hamas in Gaza precede Hamas rocket attacks on Israel, only naming a military operation from after retaliatory rocket fire occurred does not change that fact.
 
Last edited:
->


That's called whitewashing.

Based on that, I conclude that you don't know what "whitewashing" means.


Gaza is routinely referred to as "occupied" and this designation is rationalized by using an altered definition of "occupied" that applies only to Gaza and nowhere else. That's a fact, nothing is being whitewashed.


Except that one of these "two peoples" is under military occupation by the other.

And there are reasons for that, and those reasons involve Arab violence against Israel. Ignoring that is probably closer to what you meant by "whitewashing".
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom