Can you provide the requested quote or not?
Not that will satisfy you, no.
Actually you are the one claiming that the reason for their actions was so as to get them counted as Israeli victims.
Um, no. You're misreading my claims and forgetting the entire point that I was bringing up and have restated twice now. More on that below.
Why are you changing your claim? Your claim wasn't that they were added to the war dead but that this was the reason for dropping them at the hospital's morgue.
You're focusing on a small section with inexact wording. I don't know if you're confused or doing this to avoid the main point. The people were not murdered simply to add to the body count, and that was never my claim. That they were added to the body count was never my main point, and doesn't change my main point. It also doesn't change the other objectionable things, such as them being killed without due processes, tortured, the hospital they were tortured in being used for military purposes, etc.
You make a set of claims, some of which unsupported and/or false. You associate all of these claims with Hamas, thereby leaving anyone with two options. Either let the unsupported/false claims stand, or put themselves in a position so that you can paint them as "Hamas defenders". You then try to get this fallacious interpretation to be accepted by directly stating it and implicitly assuming it in further claims, choosing your terms so as to have that effect. Such as:
Simply put, no. You seem very, very confused. Furthermore, those are not the only options in any case. Challenging part of what I said doesn't mean you have to reject all of it, and obviously because much of what I've said is well evidenced and cited, and of course very objectionable acts on the part of Hamas, one could easily agree with those criticisms of Hamas while still disagreeing with others. Notably, this is
exactly what I do with criticism of Israel. Some are valid and I both don't object to them, and tend to agree and explain why. I've at least mentioned them. I certainly don't pointedly avoid answering them when directly asked and go off accusing those asking of trying to paint them in a bad light.
Your use of the term "concede" implies that there ever was debate about any of those other points, which I had to be "convinced" about and initially didn't support. This again reinforces your notion that the source of my stance was "defense of Hamas" (ie I had objected to all your claims but had to "concede" all but one of them).
Furthermore, there is nothing to "concede" since your "main point" was irrelevant. As such:
As I said, you are confused. You previously objected to my main point, which as I've stated at least twice is that Hamas' measures to prevent rocket attacks are incompetent, disingenuous, or both. If they torture and murder people who aren't even collaborators, where are the
arrests for rockets fired? There have been enough. No, we have the troops sent to prevent the rockets, and we have them walking off the job.
We all know Hamas fired rockets during the conflict, the question was whether they fired them before the conflict.
Wait, please be specific. Before you said during the ceasefire, which is why I then found and linked to them then. Now you mean from before the conflict? Which conflict? Which dates are you saying are the start?
Of course I could here claim you're trying to put me in a trap like you claimed I was doing before, but I'm just assuming you're using inexact language and it's confusing things.
It wasn't about these murders specifically.
What accusation? About employing a debating tactic? I didn't even claim you were doing it consciously, not much of an accusation, no?
That still constitutes an accusation, and I'm not sure why you think it doesn't.
Maybe you should go ahead and read that Monbiot-Chomsky debate after all.
Why?
You mean smuggling in unsupported and false claims by abusing people's unwillingness to be painted as "Hamas defenders"?
Nothing much surprises me anymore around here
You're not willing to be painted as a Hamas defender? Why? You can't even acknowledge that the torture and murder of 30-40 people is a bad thing, even if you don't believe it's important to what I was trying to support, but being a Hamas defender is such a slur? I've 'defended' Hamas before, and I've defended Israel. I'd say you are far more supportive of Hamas than Israel, and I don't much care if you'd rather say you support the Palestinian people than any government. It's not an inaccurate label, and neither is it a slur.