Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
You refer to places that they have no cultural ties to, real or imagined, and probably would be relatively undesirable to live in?

Israel isn't particularly desirable to live in either, it's mostly desert. Furthermore, and I'm not sure how this needs arguing, "my book says it's mine" does not trump "it's where I live". Neither does "my culture says it's mine".

It's true, those likely would have led to less conflict, in the long run. The lack of cultural ties, in particular, would make such a project overwhelmingly less popular, though, and thus dramatically less likely to succeed.

This particular project hasn't seemed all that popular with those affected (the Palestinians) either.

I, at least, wouldn't mind at all if they had pursued and achieved such a plan, either way, and wouldn't care much if they had completely failed to get a homeland for themselves in the first place, for that matter.

Here's how I see it, flowchart for getting a homeland:
1. Pick a place.
2. Is it already populated? Yes, go to 3. No, go to 4.
3. Does the population consent? Yes, go to 4. No, go to 1.
4. Go ahead and take it.

Israel went wrong in step 3.

refusal to acknowledge Israel's right to exist

Could you show how you derive this particular state's "right to exist" from relevant international law? Do all existing states have this right? Do all hypothetical states have this right?

where Israel is actively suppressing the Arabs' ability to destroy Israel?

That is one way to look at it, I suppose.

There's a definite qualitative difference in how I was using "essential" and your somewhat farcical use of it, either way.

I think that if you were to ask Palestinians what they think the "essential" part of the agreement was, it would have been "I'm not leaving my home". Farcical is one way to look at it, I suppose.

I've been willing to consider you not a troll, but you keep giving me plenty of reason to consider you one with things like this.

Dito. (link added for Belz)
 
Here's how I see it, flowchart for getting a homeland:
1. Pick a place.
2. Is it already populated? Yes, go to 3. No, go to 4.
3. Does the population consent? Yes, go to 4. No, go to 1.
4. Go ahead and take it.
Why do conquerors have such a hard time with this?
 
Israel isn't particularly desirable to live in either, it's mostly desert. Furthermore, and I'm not sure how this needs arguing, "my book says it's mine" does not trump "it's where I live". Neither does "my culture says it's mine".

You seem quite intent on ignoring the point that was actually being made, in other words.

This particular project hasn't seemed all that popular with those affected (the Palestinians) either.

You seem quite intent on ignoring the point that was actually being made, in other words.

Here's how I see it, flowchart for getting a homeland:
1. Pick a place.
2. Is it already populated? Yes, go to 3. No, go to 4.
3. Does the population consent? Yes, go to 4. No, go to 1.
4. Go ahead and take it.

Israel went wrong in step 3.

You're missing the part where the political governing authority comes into play, incidentally. This isn't the Stone Age anymore.

Could you show how you derive this particular state's "right to exist" from relevant international law? Do all existing states have this right? Do all hypothetical states have this right?

Heh. In short, yet again, you're ignoring the point actually made and trying to change the topic to something not really relevant for the third time in this post, alone.

That is one way to look at it, I suppose.

It's the way relevant to the variable in question.

I think that if you were to ask Palestinians what they think the "essential" part of the agreement was, it would have been "I'm not leaving my home". Farcical is one way to look at it, I suppose.

As I was using essential, the condition applies to pretty much any and all agreements of the type. As you were trying to use it, it didn't even remotely come close to that. The Arabs losing their homes was in no way essential for an agreement of that type to work. It may have been essential for completely different goals that were in play, but not to that. Your use of essential was farcical in context.

Dito. (link added for Belz)

This might have any basis in reality, of course, had you not just demonstrated your continued intent to avoid dealing with the points actually made.
 
Last edited:
This might have any basis in reality, of course, had you not just demonstrated your continued intent to avoid dealing with the points actually made.

If all your statements which I dealt with turn out later as not actually being points made then you shouldn't have written them. If you have a point to make, then just make it.
 
If all your statements which I dealt with turn out later as not actually being points made then you shouldn't have written them. If you have a point to make, then just make it.

Oddly enough, I did make the points I intended, on review. Your responses just had remarkably little to do with them, unless you consider going off on irrelevant tangents to qualify as dealing with a point. And yet again, it seemed like that was done quite intentionally.

As a note, there's one exception. Israel is around 60% desert on a quick check. The other 40% though, was rather less undesirable, though, and much more importance was placed on it than the desert, by just about every account that I've seen. In other words, your statement was partially true, though it was, yet again, rather misleading. Then it branched off into an irrelevant tangent. That, at least, was better than usual, though still remarkably poor when it comes to being a meaningful response.

Either way, I think that's enough feeding the troll for now.
 
Last edited:
Oddly enough, I did make the points I intended, on review.

Oddly enough, I did not say otherwise. You make a set of claims, and when some of them are questioned, retroactively declare those as not having been "the point". Again, if you have a point to make, then just make it without smuggling in a bunch of other claims that you clearly have no intention of defending.
 
If I say that Israel is comparable to the United States, that leaves a lot of room for bad features.

Let me give you an example:

Several years ago when Hezbollah got Lebanon involved in a war with Israel, my opinion was that Israel's behavior was awful. They bombed the crap out of the entire country when their conflict was with Hezbollah.

At the time the online dialogue was centered around supposed war crimes and atrocities Israel was said to be committing. I particularly remember pictures of junkyard ambulances that were said to be targeted by Israeli missiles. Clearly they were not, they were just junkyard relics someone had photographed for propaganda purposes.

So even though I thought Israel was in the wrong, instead of talking about that I spent all my time discussing how those photos, and other propaganda works, were obviously fakes. The issue about if Israel should have been there to begin with never came up. All discussion was devoted to the crazy stuff.

And that's how these discussions go. It's never about what the policy should be, how to bring these people together to make peace, or even how to alleviate Palestinian suffering. It's just anti-Israel crusaders, people who have little or no real empathy for Palestinians, popping up and presenting us with reasons to hate Israel, and then being refuted by others pointing out their "facts" are not so factual.

Thank you for the summary. There seems to be plenty of anti-Palestinian people in these discussions, as well, and not a lot of middle ground.
 
Thank you for the summary.

Yes, it's a nice piece of creative writing. If only it had any relation to this thread rather than his personal recollections of "images of ambulances" etc.

Anyway, since apparently you're not supposed to criticize Israel without presenting a "solution" (no such problems when criticizing the Palestinians of course), here's one I'll endorse:

Last Warsaw Ghetto survivor calls for rebellion against the occupation.

When in need of a solution, have a rebellion - it's always a good heuristic :)
 
Last edited:
Yes, it's a nice piece of creative writing. If only it had any relation to this thread rather than his personal recollections of "images of ambulances" etc.

Anyway, since apparently you're not supposed to criticize Israel without presenting a "solution" (no such problems when criticizing the Palestinians of course), here's one I'll endorse:

Last Warsaw Ghetto survivor calls for rebellion against the occupation.

When in need of a solution, have a rebellion - it's always a good heuristic :)


So you now admit that you're alright with the Palestinians attacking Israel and against Israel using any violence in return. Good to know.

That's the logical conclusion from your postings. Palestinians, all they have to do is revolt. Israel. Just die.
 
So you now admit that you're alright with the Palestinians attacking Israel and against Israel using any violence in return. Good to know.

That's the logical conclusion from your postings. Palestinians, all they have to do is revolt. Israel. Just die.

:rolleyes:

Read the linked document first and then try again.
 
Last edited:
Oddly enough, I did not say otherwise. You make a set of claims, and when some of them are questioned, retroactively declare those as not having been "the point". Again, if you have a point to make, then just make it without smuggling in a bunch of other claims that you clearly have no intention of defending.

Very well, I'll count this as close enough to a rational sounding reply to respond.

The response, though, is quite simple. These claims that you're claiming that I made... yet again weren't really claimed. You've had some nasty and ongoing issues with trying to put words into my mouth and mostly ignoring what is actually said in my responses and the direct and actual points made.

For example, trying to insinuate things like that I believe that Israel should exist because a book says it should is actually rather insulting, quite frankly, and is not a claim that I've supported with anything that I've posted. Furthermore, it is, at the very least, already directly contradicted more than a little by the fact that I've very recently said that I wouldn't have minded if no Israel or Jewish homeland existed in the first place.

Yes, I do refuse to defend claims that I'm supposedly smuggling in... when I'm not making them. If I were, I'd deal with them, though I'd still likely point out your inability to deal with the points directly made, unless you actually decided to converse in a more honest manner. Even if I wasn't making them, I might deal with them one way or another, though, incidentally, just in case you were confused about that. I'm even sometimes kind enough not to point out the egregious errors in using them, like I did when you tried to use the "IT'S ALL STOLEN LAND" argument regarding that progression when the point in question was about the change in official possession of the land as time went on, in particular. That one was actually worse than that, but that works as a quick summation.

Either way, right back at you. If you ever feel like actually making an actual argument on, for example, topics like whether the US should or should not support Israel, feel free.
 
Last edited:
These claims that you're claiming that I made... yet again weren't really claimed.

Your statement about the "refusal to acknowledge Israel's right to exist" is right there in your post, anyone can check that. So I asked you to support this "right to exist" that, apparently, you think needs to be acknowledged. But of course only a handwave came as a response.

You've had some nasty and ongoing issues with trying to put words into my mouth and mostly ignoring what is actually said in my responses and the direct and actual points made.

I've been responding to the literal statements you have made.

For example, trying to insinuate things like that I believe that Israel should exist because a book says it should is actually rather insulting, quite frankly, and is not a claim that I've supported with anything that I've posted.

"trying to insinuate"? You do not seem able to distinguish between what is actually said and what your interpretation of it is. You responded to my statement about the US or Australia as a homeland with 2 things. That it is "less desirable" and that there is no "cultural connection". I've addressed both as to why they are not valid counterarguments.

Furthermore, it is, at the very least, already directly contradicted more than a little by the fact that I've very recently said that I wouldn't have minded if no Israel or Jewish homeland existed in the first place.

So not only are you interpreting a statement in a way that is not necessarily determined by that statement, you even notice the obvious problem with your interpretation yet still go with it anyway.

I'm even sometimes kind enough not to point out the egregious errors in using them, like I did when you tried to use the "IT'S ALL STOLEN LAND" argument regarding that progression when the point in question was about the change in official possession of the land as time went on, in particular.

That's utter nonsense. I've provided the map progression as a quick reference point for the loss of Palestinian land, in context of the comparison between Israel and the US in terms of colonizing a region already inhabited by a native population. The moment the maps were challenged I provided the data underlying them. From that moment on the data should've been used as reference rather than the maps (which are always, by their nature, inaccurate at some level). But no, pages and pages of going on about the maps where, if you try really hard, you may even find a white spot that should be green instead.
 
Last edited:
:rolleyes:

Read the linked document first and then try again.

You're right, I should have read the link first. It isn't objectionable and basically wants Israel to do better for itself.

That does seem at odds with your apparent views on Israel though. Here, I'll try to advance the discussion with a question that should clear up some other things which might be misconceptions on this page. Is there any use of force by Israel that you agree with? 'Agree with' means it was proper and just in concept and largely or entirely these in implementation.
 
That does seem at odds with your apparent views on Israel though.

And how exactly would a call for rebellion against the state of Israel re the occupation be at odds with consistent criticism of the state of Israel re the occupation? You are aware that all that stuff about "antisemitism" and "bigotry" exists only in the imagination (or rather in the bag of tricks) of some in this thread?

Is there any use of force by Israel that you agree with?

As far as I see it, the state of Israel, just like any other state, has the burden of proof for any force it uses. I'm sure you can find something that will meet that burden. That still doesn't mean that bombing the crap out of a civilian population, after driving them into a small strip of land, ostensibly because of a couple of mostly harmless rockets is anything more than nonsense. Or some other obvious examples.
 
Last edited:
And how exactly would a call for rebellion against the state of Israel re the occupation be at odds with consistent criticism of the state of Israel re the occupation? You are aware that all that stuff about "antisemitism" and "bigotry" exists only in the imagination (or rather in the bag of tricks) of some in this thread?


I don't know if you're antisemitic or a bigot and those are basically irrelevant to the validity of any given argument. Those accusations aren't what I'm talking about. You've been drumming very hard on the idea that Israel should not have existed in the first place, that it is illegitimate. They 'stole all the land' and should have existed if anywhere in Brazil or Australia or something. Believing it shouldn't exist in the first place though doesn't have much to do with solving the current problems unless one thinks it not existing is a good solution to the current problems. Therefore, the inference has been made that you don't think Israel should keep existing. Instead of clearing up what you do mean, you've been vague. In fact, you simply insult those making that inference without even specifically denying what they are accusing you of.

Your linked article operates on the assumption that the existence of Israel is legitimate but some policies should change.



As far as I see it, the state of Israel, just like any other state, has the burden of proof for any force it uses. I'm sure you can find something that will meet that burden. That still doesn't mean that bombing the crap out of a civilian population, after driving them into a small strip of land, ostensibly because of a couple of mostly harmless rockets is anything more than nonsense. Or some other obvious examples.


So you don't know of any use of force from them that you agree with? Why? Not even the Six Day War?

What solution to the rockets and violence do you believe will work? Israel should simply give back land and do nothing about the rockets correct?
 
In fact, you simply insult those making that inference without even specifically denying what they are accusing you of.

Yes, funny how that works when making flawed inferences.

Your linked article operates on the assumption that the existence of Israel is legitimate but some policies should change.

I know, I read it...

So you don't know of any use of force from them that you agree with? Why? Not even the Six Day War?

I'm just not interested in it.

Israel should simply give back land and do nothing about the rockets correct?

It isn't doing anything about the rockets now, other than making sure they keep coming. It is semi-regularly assaulting Gaza, thereby provoking a bunch of rocket attacks and renewing fading support for Hamas, other such groups, and armed resistance in general.
 
Yes, funny how that works when making flawed inferences.

Why do you refuse to clarify your position?



I know, I read it...

And...



I'm just not interested in it.


Why are you unable to agree with any use of force Israel has engaged in? Is it really that important that you don't agree with anything Israel has done?

And really, you should be interested in it if you want a solid understanding of the situation, or even the appearance of such.



It isn't doing anything about the rockets now, other than making sure they keep coming.

That's simply wrong. Destroying launchers makes them have to build new ones to keep attacking, draining their resources from other attacks or escalating them. It would be very difficult to exactly measure how effective attacking the launch sites is, but it's simply not possible that it's not doing anything.


It is semi-regularly assaulting Gaza, thereby provoking a bunch of rocket attacks and renewing fading support for Hamas, other such groups, and armed resistance in general.


That's one reason I'm for as exacting an attack as possible to stop launch sites, and waiting as long as possible for other efforts before such strikes. (Note that while Israel doesn't always show such care, they have many times taken extraordinary steps to reduce collateral damage, including things that heavily reduce the effectiveness of their own strikes.)

However, that reasoning works in reverse as well. The rocket attacks only increase support for more strikes from Israel. It would be in the Palestinians best interests to stop them. So you would agree that they should stop the rocket attacks correct? Using the same reasoning you just used against Israel? Or is not criticizing the Palestinians as important as never agreeing with Israel?
 
That's simply wrong.

No it isn't. The overwhelming majority of rockets are fired during major hostilities. You ought to be interested in the numbers if you want a solid understanding of the situation, or even the appearance of such.

Furthermore, I am still not interested in your attempts to imbue a state, Israel or otherwise, with moral agency. It doesn't matter whether it did a "good thing" once or not. You are, in good animist tradition, confusing "understanding" with "projection".
 
Last edited:
No it isn't. The overwhelming majority of rockets are fired during major hostilities. You ought to be interested in the numbers if you want a solid understanding of the situation, or even the appearance of such.

So are the overwhelming majority of Israeli ordinance. And? What does this mean? What does this tell you?

Furthermore, I am still not interested in your attempts to imbue a state, Israel or otherwise, with moral agency. It doesn't matter whether it did a "good thing" once or not. You are, in good animist tradition, confusing "understanding" with "projection".


What are you talking about? How would you agreeing that there have been instances where you have agreed with Israel employing force imbue Israel with moral agency?

You again insult me instead of meaningfully clarifying your position. You ignore my direct request to clear up what it means to the situation today when you go on about how Israel shouldn't exist, is illegitimate (conquerors etc). You don't know and don't want to know about one of the events where Israel gained some of that land you insist they shouldn't have in the first place. You are unwilling to concede any point, simply ignoring them then hand waving the rest. You are unwilling to even entertain criticizing the Palestinians or agreeing with the Israelis (neither of which makes either of them the 'good guys' or 'bad guys' or whatever your accusation to avoid answering anything will be this time).

In short, you are unwilling to discuss this in good faith. Why?
 
So are the overwhelming majority of Israeli ordinance. And? What does this mean? What does this tell you?

Why don't you tell us, you're the one who brought up Israeli ordinance? I set out to show that the overwhelming majority of rockets are fired as a direct result of Israeli actions and hence Israel is not factually acting so as to reduce the rocket attacks but so as to perpetuate them.

What are you talking about? How would you agreeing that there have been instances where you have agreed with Israel employing force imbue Israel with moral agency?

You search for examples of actions by the state of Israel on the basis that it did a "good thing", with no further relevance to any of the actions we were considering. There is no other purpose to this other than to imbue the state of Israel with a moral quality ("it isn't so bad, it does good things too"). Apparently failing to grasp that I'm not arguing that Israel is "bad", but that its actions don't correspond to the explanation provided for them.

You again insult me instead of meaningfully clarifying your position. You ignore my direct request to clear up what it means to the situation today when you go on about how Israel shouldn't exist, is illegitimate (conquerors etc).

I don't recall saying that Israel shouldn't exist. I only recall some criticism of depopulating a region against the consent of the local population and then colonizing it. Could you provide a quote?

You don't know and don't want to know about one of the events where Israel gained some of that land you insist they shouldn't have in the first place.

I know enough about the event and what happened subsequently with the land. I just don't feel the need to indulge in your hobby of "criticizing the Palestinians or agreeing with the Israeli just because we can".

In short, you are unwilling to discuss this in good faith.

Yeah, that must be it. Why would anyone discussing this in good faith not want to participate in "let's find things we can agree with Israel on and then claim we're so not imbuing moral qualities on a state"?


It must be a mystery.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom