caveman1917
Philosopher
- Joined
- Feb 26, 2015
- Messages
- 8,143
You refer to places that they have no cultural ties to, real or imagined, and probably would be relatively undesirable to live in?
Israel isn't particularly desirable to live in either, it's mostly desert. Furthermore, and I'm not sure how this needs arguing, "my book says it's mine" does not trump "it's where I live". Neither does "my culture says it's mine".
It's true, those likely would have led to less conflict, in the long run. The lack of cultural ties, in particular, would make such a project overwhelmingly less popular, though, and thus dramatically less likely to succeed.
This particular project hasn't seemed all that popular with those affected (the Palestinians) either.
I, at least, wouldn't mind at all if they had pursued and achieved such a plan, either way, and wouldn't care much if they had completely failed to get a homeland for themselves in the first place, for that matter.
Here's how I see it, flowchart for getting a homeland:
1. Pick a place.
2. Is it already populated? Yes, go to 3. No, go to 4.
3. Does the population consent? Yes, go to 4. No, go to 1.
4. Go ahead and take it.
Israel went wrong in step 3.
refusal to acknowledge Israel's right to exist
Could you show how you derive this particular state's "right to exist" from relevant international law? Do all existing states have this right? Do all hypothetical states have this right?
where Israel is actively suppressing the Arabs' ability to destroy Israel?
That is one way to look at it, I suppose.
There's a definite qualitative difference in how I was using "essential" and your somewhat farcical use of it, either way.
I think that if you were to ask Palestinians what they think the "essential" part of the agreement was, it would have been "I'm not leaving my home". Farcical is one way to look at it, I suppose.
I've been willing to consider you not a troll, but you keep giving me plenty of reason to consider you one with things like this.
Dito. (link added for Belz)