Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
It is an honest assessment. You were making an implication from the choice not to answer.

It's dishonest obviously. Your ability to obfuscate is noted. It doesn't produce a tactical advantage so one should consider alternative approaches towards the subject matter.
 
Consequently, the idea of pushing out Palestinians as part of a settlement enterprise was a founding part of the Israeli nationalist concept.

Yes, something that always gets forgotten in this "well, they should have accepted the UN proposal" is that Zionist leaders were quite open about what the Palestinians' acceptance of it would mean (ie their expulsion from their homes).
 
Yes, something that always gets forgotten in this "well, they should have accepted the UN proposal" is that Zionist leaders were quite open about what the Palestinians' acceptance of it would mean (ie their expulsion from their homes).

I don't recall that. Do you have some documentation for it?
 
It would help if their government, the Israeli police and the IDF weren't actively trying to tick all of those boxes though. Corralling the Palestinians population into a few tightly controlled areas and then bombing the crap out of them is never going to win friends and influence people. The Palestinians are ineffective as a fighting force and screwed up with internal politics and actual in-fighting. Using them as an example of the potential imminent destruction of Israel is ridiculous.

I don't see that Israel is trying to tick any boxes. They are participating in a conflict with the Palestinians. It will take effort from both the Israelis and the Palestinians to end the conflict; it is not something Israel is doing to Palestinians.

They bombed the crap out of Gaza because the government of Gaza was firing a bunch of missiles into Israel. The Palestinians living in the West Bank were not bombed.
 
Ok, so we checked the Israeli claim of a genocide of Jews by Palestinian rockets and found the claim lacking (about 30 people killed in 12 years by Palestinian rocket fire).

Where did anyone claim Palestinians were committing genocide?

Someone may have claimed they would if given the chance, or that their rhetoric indicates it's a long-term goal, but to claim they're actually doing it? That smells of straw to me.

Some other old words such as apartheid:

True to form, rather than try to engage in reasoned discussion, you defend the use of incendiary rhetoric.
 
I don't recall that. Do you have some documentation for it?

Plan Dalet
4. Mounting operations against enemy population centers located inside or near our defensive system in order to prevent them from being used as bases by an active armed force. These operations can be divided into the following categories:



Destruction of villages (setting fire to, blowing up, and planting mines in the debris), especially those population centers which are difficult to control continuously.

Mounting search and control operations according to the following guidelines: encirclement of the village and conducting a search7 inside it. In the event of resistance, the. armed force must be destroyed and the population must be expelled outside the borders of the state.

The villages which are emptied in the manner described above must be included in the fixed defensive system and must be fortified as necessary.

In the absence of resistance, garrison troops will enter the village and take up positions in it or in locations which enable complete tactical control. The officer in command of the unit will confiscate all weapons, wireless devices, and motor vehicles in the village. In addition, he will detain all politically suspect individuals. After consultation with the [Jewish] political authorities, bodies will be appointed consisting of people from the village to administer the internal affairs of the village. In every region, a [Jewish] person will be appointed to be responsible for arranging the political and administrative affairs of all [Arab] villages and population centers which are occupied within that region.
 
I don't see that Israel is trying to tick any boxes. They are participating in a conflict with the Palestinians. It will take effort from both the Israelis and the Palestinians to end the conflict; it is not something Israel is doing to Palestinians.

They bombed the crap out of Gaza because the government of Gaza was firing a bunch of missiles into Israel. The Palestinians living in the West Bank were not bombed.

Mike and Mycroft,

I understand the claim that the Israelis are abusing Gaza or some occupied villages because Hamas shoots rockets from Gaza leading to almost no Israeli casualties.

The problem though is that the Israelis are also abusing peaceful Christian villages like those around Bethlehem. Jerusalem has been "pacified" under Israeli rule for decades, yet the number of Christians there has steadily decreased due to discriminatory Israeli policies. When I found these kinds of things out from American Christian volunteers to the occupied territories, it radically changed my understanding of the conflict.

Previously I envisioned the conflict as simply one of good democratic Israelis fighting bad Muslim terrorism. However, the abuse of Christian villages totally violated this image I had.

60 Minutes ran a TV program generally outlining what the Christians there are subjected to:
www.cbsnews.com/news/christians-of-the-holy-land

There are many more videos though by American protestants about the human rights violations imposed on them, like the removal of water or deadly military curfews.
 
I think that description applies to both sides. Both sides seem to refuse to even allow the possibility that Israel may have some good (or some bad) features.

If I say that Israel is comparable to the United States, that leaves a lot of room for bad features.

Let me give you an example:

Several years ago when Hezbollah got Lebanon involved in a war with Israel, my opinion was that Israel's behavior was awful. They bombed the crap out of the entire country when their conflict was with Hezbollah.

At the time the online dialogue was centered around supposed war crimes and atrocities Israel was said to be committing. I particularly remember pictures of junkyard ambulances that were said to be targeted by Israeli missiles. Clearly they were not, they were just junkyard relics someone had photographed for propaganda purposes.

So even though I thought Israel was in the wrong, instead of talking about that I spent all my time discussing how those photos, and other propaganda works, were obviously fakes. The issue about if Israel should have been there to begin with never came up. All discussion was devoted to the crazy stuff.

And that's how these discussions go. It's never about what the policy should be, how to bring these people together to make peace, or even how to alleviate Palestinian suffering. It's just anti-Israel crusaders, people who have little or no real empathy for Palestinians, popping up and presenting us with reasons to hate Israel, and then being refuted by others pointing out their "facts" are not so factual.
 
Mike and Mycroft,

I understand the claim that the Israelis are abusing Gaza or some occupied villages because Hamas shoots rockets from Gaza leading to almost no Israeli casualties.

The problem though is that the Israelis are also abusing peaceful Christian villages like those around Bethlehem. Jerusalem has been "pacified" under Israeli rule for decades, yet the number of Christians there has steadily decreased due to discriminatory Israeli policies. When I found these kinds of things out from American Christian volunteers to the occupied territories, it radically changed my understanding of the conflict.

Previously I envisioned the conflict as simply one of good democratic Israelis fighting bad Muslim terrorism. However, the abuse of Christian villages totally violated this image I had.

60 Minutes ran a TV program generally outlining what the Christians there are subjected to:
www.cbsnews.com/news/christians-of-the-holy-land

There are many more videos though by American protestants about the human rights violations imposed on them, like the removal of water or deadly military curfews.

My understanding is that the Christian population of Bethlehem and other cities under Palestinian control has been going down precisely because Christians have been facing persecution and discrimination under the predominantly Muslim Palestinian Authority.
 
I've read that page before. Nowhere does it say, as you claimed, that if Arabs had accepted the UN Partition Plan that they would have been expelled from their homes.
I think you are right. In that document he talks about destroying villages, but doesn't say whether things would have been different if the Arab governments accepted the UN plan.

Nonetheless, there is plenty of information suggesting that they planned on enacting population transfer away.

FIRST: QUOTES:

Benny Morris, an Israeli historian, quotes Ben Gurion as saying on August 7, 1937 at an Assembly of co-thinkers:
". . . In many parts of the country new settlement will not be possible without transferring the [Palestinian] Arab fellahin. . . it is important that this plan comes from the [British Peel] Commission and not from us. . . . Jewish power, which grows steadily, will also increase our possibilities to carry out the transfer on a large scale. You must remember, that this system embodies an important humane and Zionist idea, to transfer parts of a people to their country and to settle empty lands. We believe that this action will also bring us closer to an agreement with the Arabs." (Righteous Victims, p. 143)

For more quotes like this that preceded the UN plan:
http://www.palestineremembered.com/Acre/Famous-Zionist-Quotes/Story694.html

SECOND: Actions
Israeli expulsions began at least in early ( I think February) 1947 before the Arab governments invaded that May.

THIRD: DEMOGRAPHIC REALITY
If most people in the Israeli territory were Palestinian in 1947, how else were the Israelis expecting to achieve a demographic majority for their group in 1947 when they announced their democratic state for their group only?

At this point it's just a simple matter of math. Ben Gurion was aware of this, which is why they proposed mandatory population transfer, AKA ethnic cleansing.
 
My understanding is that the Christian population of Bethlehem and other cities under Palestinian control has been going down precisely because Christians have been facing persecution and discrimination under the predominantly Muslim Palestinian Authority.
That's not the reasons those Christians give when they get to the US. They say it's because they don't like living under Israeli military rule and things like getting killed for violating curfews.

If Muslims are the problem and the Israeli army is so beneficial to the Christian villages they occupy, then why have the numbers of Christians in Jordan, Egypt, and Lebanon gone up?

Finally, it's a pretty big hole in the Israeli blaming of Muslims that the numbers of Christians in Israeli-pacified Jerusalem are actually decreasing while the numbers of Israelis there are increasing. Are you aware that it's practically impossible for Christians to get permits to build additions or houses there, and that when they do their homes get bulldozed? Meanwhile, if Palestinian Christians from East Jerusalem go abroad for 7 years they get their residency revoked so they can't return to live there again.

700+ Christians gather in Jerusalem for unprecedented demonstration of Christian Schools against discriminatory policies

For years, the Ministry of Education has tried to reduce the budget of Christian Schools , and this has forced Christian schools to increase the cost at the expense of families. The cut in funding mainly affects parents of the Israeli Arab population where the average family income is below the national average.

For years, the Ministry of Education has been consistently cutting the budget of Christian schools (45% in the last 10 years).

A committee appointed by Christian Schools in Israel led the negotiations for eight months with the Ministry and the Ministry proposed that schools become public schools. This proposal is interpreted by the owners of schools as the end of Christian educational enterprise, based on Christian values, and a serious blow to the Christian minority in Holy Land. In the light of these facts, Christian schools have stopped the talks.
40839.jpg
from the Franciscan Website
http://www.ffhl.org/holy-land-franc...tian-schools-against-discriminatory-policies/


Basically, I grew up imagining that the Israeli government was running a tolerant democratic society, since it's a US ally (USS Liberty incident notwithstanding), and that it was fighting Muslim terrorism as its main enemy. However, when I found out about the treatment of Christians under Israeli rule from American Christian volunteers there it totally changed my perception. This includes of course discriminatory policies both in the Israeli state proper and their villages under harsh military rule in the territories. It turns out that they are running a political and social structure designed to drastically benefit their own group to the detriment of other religious groups under their rule.
 
Last edited:
I'm sure they could've found a homeland where people weren't already living. Parts of Australia or the US come to mind.

You refer to places that they have no cultural ties to, real or imagined, and probably would be relatively undesirable to live in?

It's true, those likely would have led to less conflict, in the long run. The lack of cultural ties, in particular, would make such a project overwhelmingly less popular, though, and thus dramatically less likely to succeed.

I, at least, wouldn't mind at all if they had pursued and achieved such a plan, either way, and wouldn't care much if they had completely failed to get a homeland for themselves in the first place, for that matter.

The essential parts of the original partition plan required them to pack up voluntarily and leave their homes behind. Are you seriously putting a population's refusal to do that against them?

And are you seriously saying that the stubborn refusal to acknowledge Israel's right to exist in the first place is a situation that could reasonably have lead anywhere other than... Israel's destruction, the Arabs' destruction, or the current situation, where Israel is actively suppressing the Arabs' ability to destroy Israel? There's a definite qualitative difference in how I was using "essential" and your somewhat farcical use of it, either way.

As it stands, though, is there some particular reason why you insist on trying to claim or insinuate that I've said things that I haven't even remotely said and, given what I've actually said, cannot reasonably be considered to support anyways? I've been willing to consider you not a troll, but you keep giving me plenty of reason to consider you one with things like this.
 
Last edited:
They bombed the crap out of Gaza because the government of Gaza was firing a bunch of missiles into Israel. The Palestinians living in the West Bank were not bombed.

In response to the rockets from Gaza, yes. Separately, the West Bank was bombed for other reasons before the rockets, though, at last check, and not necessarily reasons that were particularly validly justified.
 
THIRD: DEMOGRAPHIC REALITY
If most people in the Israeli territory were Palestinian in 1947, how else were the Israelis expecting to achieve a demographic majority for their group in 1947 when they announced their democratic state for their group only?

Last I checked, Israel's part of the partition plan was set up so that there was a slight Jewish majority. It was only slight, though, which meant that it could have been overtaken in relatively short order, potentially, even if they could trust their fellow Jews to vote as a block. Either way, given the racial tensions of the time alone, before touching on the rest, the Jews trying to significantly reduce the number of Arabs in territory they expected to be controlling should have been a very predictable and entirely expected action, even if it wasn't necessarily explicit on publicly available documents.
 
Actually it is to the one making silly claims like that to prove his case. But just one thing that comes to mind, deforestation in Brazil is about 30000 km^2 per year, which is about equal to the land area of Belgium (population 10 million, same as Israel). So in Brazil alone you could do one of these each year.

Your numbers are wrong.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deforestation_of_the_Amazon_rainforest
In addition, the amazon forest is not void of people, and that deforestation does not come from a contiguous area. And of course, none of it solves the problem that Brazil wouldn't be (and wasn't) interested. It's an ahistorical fantasy to believe that creating Israel somewhere else was an option.

Do you have a notion of how big the Earth actually is?

Do you have a notion of how many people there are on Earth?

I don't have to tell you anything. The point that forcibly depopulating an area after the people there refused to consent, rather than finding a new homeland elsewhere, is an idea with obvious problems is valid independent of what you may want to make of it.

Which has **** all to do with the fact that the creation of Israel cannot be undone now.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom