Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
The Palestinians have no more a right to return than the Sudeten and East Prussian Germans.

Or the Jewish Holocaust survivors to apply for German citizenship. It's correct. In fact no law prevents the Sudeten from returning. They can do so if they like. And well as if the descendants from German Jewish want German citizenship, they va have it.
The point is very few, if any, Sudeten or Prussian ever demanded to live in Poland or Russia or in Chekoslovakia, and very few Italians wanted to love back to Yugoslavia.
Those communities just neve pursued a formal recognition of such rights, insofar it was not considered a national interest.
But now their descendants can move and live wherever they want if they like.
And if the Jews want German citizenship their grandparents they were strippped of, they are entitled to have it back.

The Right of Return of Palestinians is recognized by SC res. 194, is an established right. It's enshrined by Conventions. Many countries acknowledge one cannot strip citizens of citizenship or prevent them from returning home. It's an individual right, and there is little to dispute. It may be not applicable in full because of political or security reasons, but needs to be acknowledged.
 
Last edited:
I have never posted on this thread before.

This is because I just happened to read some pages of this discussion, and I wanted to express my admiration for caveman1917. I agree with his views, and I am admired by his duly making precise and simple points, and pinning arguments with exact quotes from so many sources.

I am rather acquainted with the Israeli-Palestinian conflict and have very structured ideas on the matter, both on historical, legal and political (=solution) levels.

The core of my viewpoint, what I think matters in history and will matter in politics, is a conclusion of radical objection to Zionism. This belief is of mine is about seeing the ideological element - Zionism as the cause of problems - as probably the most important factor in the historical genesis of the conflict, and a determinant one to its solution if ever there will be one during our lives.

By this I am trying to say that my view is different from those who talk about "perspective and understanding" in terms of historical actions, "winning" or "losing land". I think I also reached a very clear understanding about the sequence of historical events where I can place the blame, basically see it as the only cause of the evolution of the conflict, on the very roots of the ideology of Zionism. That one, and that one alone is the original "sin" and hybris at the root of the conflicts. I also think that a historical event such as the destruction of 1948 Palestine and the ethnic cleansing of the land, still is an aspect less interesting and with less implications compared to the subsequent denial of the Right to Return enshrined by res. 194 (the refusal to allow refugees back is more revealing and more important than the act of cleansing the country itself, while previous history can also be read and interpreted through the prism of the subsequent events).

I am an Italian. I don't have ties to any of the religions and ethnicities involved or invoked in the conflict.


The core of the problem is that Israel exists, but shouldn't? Umm, that boat has sailed.

Did you mean something else by Zionism?
 
The Right of Return of Palestinians is recognized by SC res. 194, is an established right. It's enshrined by Conventions. Many countries acknowledge one cannot strip citizens of citizenship or prevent them from returning home.

And yet many countries have done so to various people, including those loudest in their support of Palestinians, and no one whispered anything about that.

Why would Palestinians get special treatment, denied to every other community?
Without said special treatment there would be peace.

McHrozni
 
I have never posted on this thread before.

Welcome to the thread.

This is because I just happened to read some pages of this discussion, and I wanted to express my admiration for caveman1917. I agree with his views,

There's nothing necessarily wrong with agreeing with his views, but it's worth noting that you're already giving distinct reason to believe that your judgement on the matter is biased.

and I am admired by his duly making precise and simple points, and pinning arguments with exact quotes from so many sources.

Out of curiousity, which arguments and points? He threw out a lot and, when challenged, frequently ran away to some other point that really wasn't all that relevant to the prior one that he had tried to make and/or grossly misrepresented what the other party was saying, if he even deigned to claim to address it in the first place. In the end, though, it's certainly true that he was right about a few things. Generally those things met with no significant disagreement, though. The Palestinian Arabs DID lose a lot of land, for example, in a way that wasn't particularly "fair." That the Jewish people of Israel are not shining bastions of wonderfulness that all the world should look at and be amazed should be pretty obvious, regardless, as well. Neither of these were ever even remotely in dispute, though.

I am rather acquainted with the Israeli-Palestinian conflict and have very structured ideas on the matter, both on historical, legal and political (=solution) levels.

Talking about such is what this thread is for, after all.

This belief is of mine is about seeing the ideological element - Zionism as the cause of problems - as probably the most important factor in the historical genesis of the conflict,

Well... duh? If the Jewish people hadn't wanted a homeland to call their own, obviously, none of the trouble directly related to the homeland that they worked to attain would have happened. Still, as a stance, this feels like it's roughly on par with pinning the blame on the nationalistic desires of the Palestinian Arabs as the most important factor in the historical genesis of the conflict. Partially true and really not useful in and of itself, for anything other than painting a distinctly biased picture.

and a determinant one to its solution if ever there will be one during our lives.

Do you have any specific proposals that you think are reasonably achievable?

By this I am trying to say that my view is different from those who talk about "perspective and understanding" in terms of historical actions,

Bait noted. Incidentally, "perspective and understanding" is about exactly what the words mean. That's not at all the same as excusing, supporting, rejecting, hating, or whichever other thing that a people who doesn't like employing them might try to use to make a caricature of them. They're more about, surprise, understanding the situation and not letting bias or double standards get in the way of judgement. Those who disparage perspective and understanding, like those who disparage cause and effect, frequently have little to say of value, though.

"winning" or "losing land".

This would likely be much more of a moot point if the Palestinian Arabs ever seriously agreed to the essential parts of the original partition plan or an updated version of it, rather than just the parts that they liked. Parts like Israel's right to exist in the first place.

I think I also reached a very clear understanding about the sequence of historical events where I can place the blame, basically see it as the only cause of the evolution of the conflict, on the very roots of the ideology of Zionism. That one, and that one alone is the original "sin" and hybris at the root of the conflicts. I also think that a historical event such as the destruction of 1948 Palestine and the ethnic cleansing of the land, still is an aspect less interesting and with less implications compared to the subsequent denial of the Right to Return enshrined by res. 194 (the refusal to allow refugees back is more revealing and more important than the act of cleansing the country itself, while previous history can also be read and interpreted through the prism of the subsequent events).

My earlier comment about blaming it all on Zionism still seems relevant here, incidentally. Your focus on the the denial of the "Right to Return" is curious, though, given that it was openly admitted to go hand in hand with the ethnic cleansing, regardless, given that the two things were both done for the same overall purpose. Fairly specifically, it was to achieve a clear majority of Jews in the lands that would soon become Israel, rather than the slight majority of Jews that they would have had, with a very significant Arab minority that notably had different goals, desires, and already had bad blood towards the Jews even then, because of various things like the distinct favoritism that Jews had been showing Jews over Arabs when it came to jobs and resources for an extended period of time and clashing views on who should control that land that became Israel.

I am an Italian. I don't have ties to any of the religions and ethnicities involved or invoked in the conflict.

That doesn't mean that you're free from bias, though. I tend to disregard ties, myself, in favor of valid arguments, though.
 
Last edited:
If the Jewish people hadn't wanted a homeland to call their own, obviously, none of the trouble directly related to the homeland that they worked to attain would have happened.

I'm sure they could've found a homeland where people weren't already living. Parts of Australia or the US come to mind.

This would likely be much more of a moot point if the Palestinian Arabs ever seriously agreed to the essential parts of the original partition plan or an updated version of it, rather than just the parts that they liked.

The essential parts of the original partition plan required them to pack up voluntarily and leave their homes behind. Are you seriously putting a population's refusal to do that against them?
 
Last edited:
I'm sure they could've found a homeland where people weren't already living. Parts of Australia or the US come to mind.

The only parts of either country where nobody was living are parts where nobody can live. And it's irrelevant anyways: it's done, it's in the past. You cannot undo it now, no matter how much you desire it.
 
The only parts of either country where nobody was living are parts where nobody can live.

Somewhere else then, unless you're saying there's literally no more space on the Earth?

And it's irrelevant anyways: it's done, it's in the past.

Well let's hope that should anything like this happen again, that time someone will actually take a step back and think it through first.

You cannot undo it now, no matter how much you desire it.

Making stuff up again, are we?
 
Somewhere else then, unless you're saying there's literally no more space on the Earth?

There are places with low population density (usually because they can't support high densities). There are no habitable places left on Earth with zero population density.

Making stuff up again, are we?

And how would you undo the creation of the state of Israel?

Oh, that's right: let Hamas et al kill all the Jews.
 
There are places with low population density (usually because they can't support high densities). There are no habitable places left on Earth with zero population density.

Evidence?

And how would you undo the creation of the state of Israel?

Oh, that's right: let Hamas et al kill all the Jews.

Do you seriously think you pretending your own fantasies to be your opponent's position is fooling anyone?
 
The second message on the main thread said:
How to solve the Israel/Palestine problem. Nuk the entire area. Problem solved. Bonus - the number of nuclear weapons in the world will go down. Now do I win the Nobel peace prize?
The problem is that people will come back for more once the radiation goes away in maybe a few centuries.

There will still be people on both sides saying it's their ancient homeland and then they will try to act accordingly.

I suppose if the land actually flooded and went under the sea level the problem might go away. But then people would try to build a dike around it and make it like the Netherlands or they would make huge rafts and houseboats, and live over it.

There is so much intense feeling, ideology, and trillions of dollars invested into the project as it is now, why should something like radiation or sea level stop them?
 
Prove me wrong.

Actually it is to the one making silly claims like that to prove his case. But just one thing that comes to mind, deforestation in Brazil is about 30000 km^2 per year, which is about equal to the land area of Belgium (population 10 million, same as Israel). So in Brazil alone you could do one of these each year.

Do you have a notion of how big the Earth actually is?

Then tell me exactly how you think you can undo the "mistake" of creating Israel.

I don't have to tell you anything. The point that forcibly depopulating an area after the people there refused to consent, rather than finding a new homeland elsewhere, is an idea with obvious problems is valid independent of what you may want to make of it.
 
Last edited:
There will still be people on both sides saying it's their ancient homeland and then they will try to act accordingly.

This is a false equivalence. Israel (or rather Zionism) is saying it's their ancient homeland, the Palestinians are saying it's their current homeland (or rather current until the successive waves of depopulation in 1948 and 1967).
 
This is a false equivalence. Israel (or rather Zionism) is saying it's their ancient homeland, the Palestinians are saying it's their current homeland (or rather current until the successive waves of depopulation in 1948 and 1967).
Yes.

In any case, my point is that even putting the place below sea level won't solve the problem because the "enterprising Israelis" who "made the desert bloom" will still do something like build a dam around it like Holland, and then the Palestinians will want to know why they can't live in their newly-dried homeland too.

This is what happens when someone makes an ideology that they have to have the land because of an ancient alleged religious promise or other claims and then has trillions of dollars to accomplish it.
 
Back in 1937, Ben Gurion wrote that if the Israelis weren't given the Negev desert and the Palestinians didn't want them in the Negev either, then,

We must expel Arabs and take their place. Up to now, all our aspirations have been based on an assumption – one that has been vindicated throughout our activities in the country – that there is enough room in the land for the Arabs and ourselves. But if we are compelled to use force – not in order to dispossess the Arabs of the Negev or Transjordan, but in order to guarantee our right to settle there – our force will enable us to do so.
So at the end, he put a spin on it, saying it wasn't really about expelling Arabs but about settling there. But in any case, even if the main motive isn't just to pick a random population in the world to ethnically expel, but rather a motive of settlement, the idea remained of ethnic cleansing, ie. We come in, they go.

Consequently, the idea of pushing out Palestinians as part of a settlement enterprise was a founding part of the Israeli nationalist concept.
http://mondoweiss.net/2012/03/we-mu...tter-advocating-the-expulsion-of-palestinians
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom