Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Let me make an analogy for you.

Let's say I don't really like the Affordable Care Act, but I don't think it's Obama's attempt to introduce socialism into the United States.

In writing about it, I'm constantly refuting wing-nut claims about Obama's socialism. Someone reading my writing gets the impression that I'm totally for the ACA because I never criticize it.

It's the same with Israel. I support Israel the same way I support Canada. I understand both nations are imperfect, as is my own United States.

People who criticize Canada do so realistically. Most of them, anyway. If we have a conversation about Canada, I don't need to waste a lot of time refuting stupid bigoted statements.

It's not the same with Israel. The people who are anti-Israel are rabid. They need to make up new definitions for old words such as apartheid, occupation, and even genocide just so they can use them against Israel. Normal words that accurately describe the conflict are just not shrill or filled with enough venom for these people.

I don't support Israel any more than I support any other Western Democracy, it only seems that way because the discussion about Israel never rises to the level where reasonable discussion takes place.

Might be the best summary of Israel-Palestine discussions yet.
 
Yet for all the depictions of Israel as a demon, I'm perplexed as to why Evil!Israel haven't deployed Nerve Gas in Gaza when it's well within their capabilities.

Exactly. Clearly apartheid in South Africa never existed either, as there was no nerve gas deployed against black people even though it was possible.
 
It would help if their government, the Israeli police and the IDF weren't actively trying to tick all of those boxes though. Corralling the Palestinians population into a few tightly controlled areas and then bombing the crap out of them is never going to win friends and influence people. The Palestinians are ineffective as a fighting force and screwed up with internal politics and actual in-fighting. Using them as an example of the potential imminent destruction of Israel is ridiculous.

There are a lot of "supporters" of the Palestinians who do want the destruction of Israel though, and also have the means. The problem for the Palestinians is that their plight is a lot more useful to these countries as a political tool, and the actions of these countries show that they have every intention of keeping it that way.

Israel has been used as the catch-all scapegoat for just about every known problem around the world. A great way to forgo solving your own internal problems is to focus on something completely unrelated that keeps the people distracted. Hamas makes money off of purposefully causing the deaths of Palestinian kids, and the countries that pay them for it are well compensated for their blood money. All while the normal everyday Palestinian and Israeli citizens pay the cost in lives.

Israelis for the most part just want a way to live in peace where their neighbors are not constantly launching bombs at them. So do most Palestinians. However, there are a lot of people, mostly people who live thousands of miles away, who are only interested in using the situation for their own purposes in a way that perpetuates the problem. Many times it is a distorted one-sided demonization for a dishonest personal gratification that creates a market and political pressure for large pocketed countries like Iran and Qatar who are incentivized to keep the situation negatively impactful for the Palestinians.

There are reasonable steps that can be taken towards a long lasting peace deal, but not nearly enough reasonable people who actually want to see that happen.
 
Interview with an Israeli soldier on the opening stages of the conflict in 1948

Q: Did you let the [Palestinians] residents get away?

YK: At first, yes. The intention was to expel them, these were the orders of the bosses, Yigal Alon and Yitzhak Sadeh. Sometimes we had to shot one or two, and then the rest got the message and left on their own. You need to understand: if you didn’t destroy the Arab’s home, he will always want to come back. When there is no home, no village, there is nowhere to return.

Q: Do you remember the battle for Lod and Ramleh?

YK: I don’t like to remember this so much… we shot shells into a mosque where many people were hiding. There was no choice.

Q: We shot?

YK: I shot with the PIAT [anti-tank weapon]. It has an enormous shock wave.

Q: And what were the results?

YK: Not pretty. They were all scattered on the walls.

Q: How many?

YK: I don’t know. Many. I didn’t count. I opened the door, saw what I saw, and closed [it].

Q: What did you feel?

YK: What can you feel after a thing like that? But if we didn’t do it, we might have been fighting to this very day. Then I stood with the Browning [machine gun] over the creek through which the remaining residents escaped. Anyone who strayed off track, got a shot.

Q: From you as well?

YK: From me too. I felt really bad but I was a good marksman, and there were times when they only asked me to fire a single bullet. At the village next to Ramleh, two shots were enough. In 45 minutes the village was empty. They got the message.

This was after the Palestinians rejected a UN proposal refusing to leave voluntarily.
 
Exactly. Clearly apartheid in South Africa never existed either, as there was no nerve gas deployed against black people even though it was possible.

Oh please, Israel is outright depicted as the new Nazi Germany, right down to the Gaza = Auschwitz comparison. And if Israel was out to grab clay and completely stomp on the Palestinians, Nerve Gas would do the job much more effectively than what policy they are pursuing now. And besides, I can't help but feel that a lot of Israel's detractors have no idea how good they've got it. It's good to grow up in a country where the last existential crisis was 70 years ago. It's good to not have your country's founders be survivors of an industrial scale extinction attempt. It's good to not have to right tooth and nail just to survive for 25 years. It's good to not live in a country whose neighbours wanted it dead for decades.

And let's look at who Israel has been surrounded by: The house of Assad in Syria. Saddam's Iraq. Mubarak/Junta Egypt. Saudi Arabia. Qatar. Yemen. And it's a damned saint in comparison to those lot.
 
Last edited:
Oh please, Israel is outright depicted as the new Nazi Germany, right down to the Gaza = Auschwitz comparison.

What utter bollocks. For say the last 10 or so pages of this thread, list:
1. Each post that depicts Israeli as nazis.
2. Each post that depicts Palestinians as nazis.
3. Each post that depicts Israeli as evil.
4. Each post that depicts Palestinians as evil.
 
Last edited:
What utter bollocks. For say the last 10 or so pages of this thread, list:
1. Each post that depicts Israeli as nazis.
2. Each post that depicts Palestinians as nazis.
3. Each post that depicts Israeli as evil.
4. Each post that depicts Palestinians as evil.

Google Israel is Nazi Germany.
 
It's good to not have your country's founders be survivors of an industrial scale extinction attempt.

You mean under Nazi Germany? An event that is not part of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, but is part of the policies of Nazi Germany during WW2, that always gets brought up in response to criticism of Israel? That's already one post bringing up Nazi Germany then.

It's indeed interesting how that works. You see, a counterargument to an article analyzing the numbers underlying current events is apparently that there exist people, who did not write the article, whose beliefs may include denial of this event under Nazi Germany. So two posts bringing up Nazi Germany in defense of criticism of Israel that has nothing to do with it.

Anyway, since you seem to think it relevant. Nazi Germany implemented, first domestically and then over the territory it controlled during WW2, an industrial scale extinction attempt against Jews, communists, gypsies, anarchists, socialists, LGBTs, trade union leaders, Jehovah's witnesses, the disabled, and several other "undesirable" groups.

On 10 may 1941, the first anniversary of the occupation of Belgium, a strike broke out against the Nazi occupation and demanding a wage increase, led by the communist party. 8 days later the strike had spread and the Germans were forced to give in and increase wages. Of course the leaders got sent to concentration camps but still, we kicked the Nazis' butt and won. I'm sure a lot of interesting things could be said about Europe under Nazi occupation, but what was your point again for bringing it up here?
 
Considering how Iraq was an axis power and the Arab world was highly influenced by Nazi Germany (FFS the Grand Mufti of Jerusalem was a Waffen SS recruiting Sergeant. How he escaped the gallows is beyond me), it does set the stage for Israeli perception of the rest of the world.

As for Israel being conflated with Nazi Germany: http://lmgtfy.com/?q=Israel+is+like+Nazi+Germany

Lastly, my comment was about the popular depiction of Israel as an evil entity on the level of Nazi Germany. Yet why has it operated with far more restraint than Saddam Hussein and Bashir Al Assad ever did, when they would have had no qualms using nerve gas?
 
Last edited:
Considering how Iraq was an axis power and the Arab world was highly influenced by Nazi Germany (FFS the Grand Mufti of Jerusalem was a Waffen SS recruiting Sergeant. How he escaped the gallows is beyond me), it does set the stage for Israeli perception of the rest of the world.

What is that supposed to mean?

As for Israel being conflated with Nazi Germany: http://lmgtfy.com/?q=Israel+is+like+Nazi+Germany

Not arguing anything in this thread, just arguing an unstated random opinion that can be found somewhere on the internet, to bring up the Nazis...
 
Last edited:
I have never posted on this thread before.

This is because I just happened to read some pages of this discussion, and I wanted to express my admiration for caveman1917. I agree with his views, and I am admired by his duly making precise and simple points, and pinning arguments with exact quotes from so many sources.

I am rather acquainted with the Israeli-Palestinian conflict and have very structured ideas on the matter, both on historical, legal and political (=solution) levels.

The core of my viewpoint, what I think matters in history and will matter in politics, is a conclusion of radical objection to Zionism. This belief is of mine is about seeing the ideological element - Zionism as the cause of problems - as probably the most important factor in the historical genesis of the conflict, and a determinant one to its solution if ever there will be one during our lives.

By this I am trying to say that my view is different from those who talk about "perspective and understanding" in terms of historical actions, "winning" or "losing land". I think I also reached a very clear understanding about the sequence of historical events where I can place the blame, basically see it as the only cause of the evolution of the conflict, on the very roots of the ideology of Zionism. That one, and that one alone is the original "sin" and hybris at the root of the conflicts. I also think that a historical event such as the destruction of 1948 Palestine and the ethnic cleansing of the land, still is an aspect less interesting and with less implications compared to the subsequent denial of the Right to Return enshrined by res. 194 (the refusal to allow refugees back is more revealing and more important than the act of cleansing the country itself, while previous history can also be read and interpreted through the prism of the subsequent events).

I am an Italian. I don't have ties to any of the religions and ethnicities involved or invoked in the conflict.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom