Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
and there would still be green showing in Israel

Can you show this?

Except that I didn't claim that at any point.
->
That doesn't change the nature or problems with the representation. Or how much dispute the facts that you stated have received separately from that.

Take a peek back. You'll find that every single relevant statement made by me fits that dramatically better than your farcical claims about what I said.

*sigh* maybe you should take a peek back and see that this is already the second time you've denied making an earlier claim and just ignoring it when it is pointed out you did. No amount of hautain sighing will change the record on your modus operandi for making claims, and when they are countered to then state you never made them.
 
Close is close enough, monsieur.

My primary language isn't French actually, it's Dutch. However, where I live - to be fair a bilingual Dutch/French country - the word "hautain" is also used in Dutch, so I assumed it was one of those common French words used outside, well, French.
 
Can you show this?

That, by your very own citations, there were still significant portions of Arab owned land in Israel, even though the amount was indeed dramatically reduced, rather than none at all? I could cite your very own quotations and stated facts, sure, but why would I need to, unless you weren't paying attention to them yourself?


*sigh* maybe you should take a peek back and see that this is already the second time you've denied making an earlier claim and just ignoring it when it is pointed out you did. No amount of hautain sighing will change the record on your modus operandi for making claims, and when they are countered to then state you never made them.

Except that it didn't change how much dispute there was, exactly like I said. The point was that there wasn't any for what was pointed at and also that the facts that you've presented, in general, have been judged separately from the progression that you posted and each other. Your reading comprehension gets an F. Again. Congratulations. You still get no points for fighting straw men, like before. Nor, for that matter, for dodging point after point after point after point.
 
Last edited:
Could you support that with links ? I find it an odd claim that the UN somehow leans anti-Jew.

I know this wasn't directed at me, but I thought I would add in a link anyways.

List of the UN resolutions concerning Israel and Palestine

The following is a list of United Nations resolutions that concern both Israel and Palestine and bordering states such as Lebanon. As of 2013, Israel had been condemned in 45 resolutions by United Nations Human Rights Council since its creation in 2006—the Council had resolved almost more resolutions condemning Israel than on the rest of the world combined. The 45 resolutions comprised almost half (45.9%) of all country-specific resolutions passed by the Council...

Focusing on Israel is a great way to ignore all of the much more serious problems in the rest of the world.
 
Last edited:
That, by your very own citations, there were still significant portions of Arab owned land in Israel, even though the amount was indeed dramatically reduced, rather than none at all?

6% in total as of the third map, doesn't mean there's any region where they actually hold a majority of it.

I could cite your very own quotations and stated facts, sure, but why would I need to, unless you weren't paying attention to them yourself?

Please do so. It is generally considered the proper response to a request for evidence.

Except that it didn't change how much dispute there was, exactly like I said.

Which fact, other than the maps which are representations of facts and which you exclude anyway, would be so disputed?

Your reading comprehension gets an F. Again. Congratulations. You still get no points for fighting straw men, like before. Nor, for that matter, for dodging point after point after point after point.

:rolleyes:
 
6% in total as of the third map, doesn't mean there's any region where they actually hold a majority of it.

Depends on how big the regions considered are. There's no good reason to believe that the third map is based on anything other than political boundaries, quite frankly.

Please do so. It is generally considered the proper response to a request for evidence.

Only if the request for evidence is genuine. Yours rings rather hollow, especially given how much focus that you're putting on a largely pointless matter and completely ignoring what's stated as the real issues. Again. That's before getting to how you've tried to greatly misrepresent what I've said repeatedly, among other things.

Which fact, other than the maps which are representations of facts and which you exclude anyway, would be so disputed?

Feel free to go back through if you actually want to look. Given your conduct, no, I don't find it worth it to waste my time doing such for you.
 
Last edited:
Depends on how big the regions considered are.

It seems to be coloured as a k-nearest neighbour for a couple of settlements.

There's no good reason to believe that the third map is based on anything other than political boundaries, quite frankly.

There's also no good reason to believe anything other than that it also corresponds to land ownership as used in the first map. Doesn't stop you from persistently claiming otherwise while refusing to provide evidence, though.

Only if the request for evidence is genuine.

I don't think you get to choose which claims you provide evidence for based on how much you like it.

Yours rings rather hollow, especially given how much focus that you're putting on a largely pointless matter and completely ignoring what's stated as the real issues.

This is ridiculous, you're complaining that I am focusing too much on the largely pointless matter of the accuracy of the maps?

Feel free to go back through if you actually want to look. Given your conduct, no, I don't find it worth it to waste my time doing such for you.

This is really getting old. Persistently claiming that your opponent has presented incorrect facts and every time an example is asked handwave it away. Repetition reduces vigilance, I suppose.
 
I guess it doesn't matter that the UN is condemning Israel's actions. To some, _all_ of their actions are legitimate. I don't understand that. Can't they be wrong in some things and right in others ? It's hard to discuss this issue because of that polarized thinking.

Let me make an analogy for you.

Let's say I don't really like the Affordable Care Act, but I don't think it's Obama's attempt to introduce socialism into the United States.

In writing about it, I'm constantly refuting wing-nut claims about Obama's socialism. Someone reading my writing gets the impression that I'm totally for the ACA because I never criticize it.

It's the same with Israel. I support Israel the same way I support Canada. I understand both nations are imperfect, as is my own United States.

People who criticize Canada do so realistically. Most of them, anyway. If we have a conversation about Canada, I don't need to waste a lot of time refuting stupid bigoted statements.

It's not the same with Israel. The people who are anti-Israel are rabid. They need to make up new definitions for old words such as apartheid, occupation, and even genocide just so they can use them against Israel. Normal words that accurately describe the conflict are just not shrill or filled with enough venom for these people.

I don't support Israel any more than I support any other Western Democracy, it only seems that way because the discussion about Israel never rises to the level where reasonable discussion takes place.
 
Let me make an analogy for you.

Let's say I don't really like the Affordable Care Act, but I don't think it's Obama's attempt to introduce socialism into the United States.

In writing about it, I'm constantly refuting wing-nut claims about Obama's socialism. Someone reading my writing gets the impression that I'm totally for the ACA because I never criticize it.

It's the same with Israel. I support Israel the same way I support Canada. I understand both nations are imperfect, as is my own United States.

People who criticize Canada do so realistically. Most of them, anyway. If we have a conversation about Canada, I don't need to waste a lot of time refuting stupid bigoted statements.

It's not the same with Israel. The people who are anti-Israel are rabid. They need to make up new definitions for old words such as apartheid, occupation, and even genocide just so they can use them against Israel. Normal words that accurately describe the conflict are just not shrill or filled with enough venom for these people.

I don't support Israel any more than I support any other Western Democracy, it only seems that way because the discussion about Israel never rises to the level where reasonable discussion takes place.
It would help if their government, the Israeli police and the IDF weren't actively trying to tick all of those boxes though. Corralling the Palestinians population into a few tightly controlled areas and then bombing the crap out of them is never going to win friends and influence people. The Palestinians are ineffective as a fighting force and screwed up with internal politics and actual in-fighting. Using them as an example of the potential imminent destruction of Israel is ridiculous.
 
Let's not bother with the false accusations of holocaust denial against the author of the linked article. A common enough trope in far-right circles actually, not as common as the purported Islamic conspiracy that secretly controls the world's major powers against Israel like we had earlier in the thread, though.

Anyway, back to the hypocritical accusations of bigotry, it's always hilarious when the far-right crowd uses that one.
They need to make up new definitions for old words such as apartheid, occupation, and even genocide

Ok, so we checked the Israeli claim of a genocide of Jews by Palestinian rockets and found the claim lacking (about 30 people killed in 12 years by Palestinian rocket fire).

Some other old words such as apartheid:
Desmond Tutu said:
I have been to the Occupied Palestinian Territory, and I have witnessed the racially segregated roads and housing that reminded me so much of the conditions we experienced in South Africa under the racist system of Apartheid. I have witnessed the humiliation of Palestinian men, women, and children made to wait hours at Israeli military checkpoints routinely when trying to make the most basic of trips to visit relatives or attend school or college, and this humiliation is familiar to me and the many black South Africans who were corralled and regularly insulted by the security forces of the Apartheid government.

Desmond Tutu is
wiki said:
a South African social rights activist and retired Anglican bishop who rose to worldwide fame during the 1980s as an opponent of apartheid.
He is so bigoted that he
has campaigned to fight HIV/AIDS, tuberculosis, poverty, racism, sexism, the imprisonment of Chelsea Manning, homophobia and transphobia.

Luckily Israeli officials have pointed out that Tutu just doesn't understand what apartheid is.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom