Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Stop blatantly lying. Again, show the thousands of rockets fired before Israel attacked Gaza or concede the bet. If you do not do so in your next response then don't expect me to pay any further attention to your posts.

I wouldn't call what Wild Cat says qualifies as lying.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=10617011&postcount=3319
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=10612727&postcount=3287

If I say "A is true", and A is indeed true, I'm not lying, am I? It is more reminiscent of telling the truth. Correct me if I'm wrong.

McHrozni
 
I wouldn't call what Wild Cat says qualifies as lying.

It is exactly that. As you can see in post 3314 the scope established was between 2013 when Palestinians were opposed to armed conflict and late 2014 when they were supportive. In between they got thoroughly bombed. WildCat claimed that "thousands of Hamas rockets fired at Israel preceded the Israeli bombing" which was conclusively shown to be false. He then changed the scope to go as far back as 2001, which is not only moving the goalposts but still false, as Israel attacked Gaza long before "thousands of rockets" were fired in 2001. This doesn't change even if we include mortar attacks.

If I say "A is true", and A is indeed true, I'm not lying, am I?

If you say "A is true", and A is patently false, and then you attempt to change the subject to saying "B is true" when even B is also patently false, then you are lying.
 
If a nation is not more lethal, then it isn't more powerful.

Nonsense. Just because a nation is more powerful doesn't mean it actually goes out and kills more civilians than its enemy.

That the "occupying" status is irrelevant.

An occupying power has specific duties in international law to protect civilians. I suggest you familiarize yourself with them.

Now you're making a rather massive logical error. There is a difference between excluding something from a category and including something in a category. You have done the former, I am doing the latter.

:rolleyes:

Congratulations, your first full-scale Godwin for this thread!

Ridiculous. I gave the most well-known example of retributions against villages for terrorist attacks by an occupying power.

Tell me, caveman, what was the actual target of Israeli retaliation?

Retaliation for what? As far as I see it, Israel's main goal is perpetuation of the conflict.

Was it Gaza villages? Or was it terrorist targets who were hiding in Gaza villages?

Terrorist targets? If you mean people accused of criminal offences, then the following applies:
from earlier link said:
People accused of criminal offences shall be provided with proceedings respecting internationally recognized judicial guarantees (for example, they must be informed of the reason for their arrest, charged with a specific offence and given a fair trial as quickly as possible).

If you mean people engaged in hostilities against the occupation, then the following applies:
Civilians who take a direct part in such hostilities lose their protection
against attack for the time of their direct participation, but not their civilian
status. If they do not participate directly in hostilities or no longer do so
(for example, if they are hors de combat), they are protected against
attacks.

Indirect support for the resistance movement, such as providing infor-
mation or non-military supplies, does not constitute taking a direct part
in hostilities. Those so engaged are civilians and therefore protected
against attack. They may, however, be in contravention of security laws
passed by the occupying power. In that case, they can be tried and
sentenced or their freedom of movement restricted.

When they're all true, why not?

The first, that Israel defends from Palestinian rocket attacks, has already been shown false. The second, that civilian deaths are mainly due to Hamas using civilians as human shields, you have not provided any evidence for. The wikipedia article on "human shield" as this to say:
According to observers from The Independent and The Guardian who interviewed Gazan refugees, it was a "myth" that Hamas forced civilians to stay in areas under attack against their will; they reported that the Gazans who refused to heed the IDF's warnings did so because even areas Israel had declared safe for refugees had been shelled by its forces.[71][72] The BBC Middle East editor Jeremy Bowen likewise said he "saw no evidence of Hamas using Palestinians as human shields".[73] An Amnesty International document (dated July 25, 2014) asserts that they do "not have evidence at this point that Palestinian civilians have been intentionally used by Hamas or Palestinian armed groups during the current hostilities to “shield” specific locations or military personnel or equipment from Israeli attacks."[74] What's more, Amnesty International's assessment is that international humanitarian law was clear in that "even if officials or fighters from Hamas or Palestinian armed groups associated with other factions did in fact direct civilians to remain in a specific location in order to shield military objectives from attacks, all of Israel’s obligations to protect these civilians would still apply."[74] The human rights group, however, still found that Palestinian factions, as in previous conflicts, launched attacks from civilian areas.[74]
 
I guess it doesn't matter that the UN is condemning Israel's actions. To some, _all_ of their actions are legitimate. I don't understand that. Can't they be wrong in some things and right in others ? It's hard to discuss this issue because of that polarized thinking.
 
Congratulations, your first full-scale Godwin for this thread!

If you really want to see a full-scale Godwin comparing Israel's actions to "Hitlerism", then just read what this holocaust survivor had to say:
Suzanne Weiss said:
Yet for me, the Israeli government's actions toward the Palestinians awaken horrific memories of my family's experiences under Hitlerism: the inhuman walls, the checkpoints, the daily humiliations, killings, diseases, the systematic deprivation.
 
Last edited:
I guess it doesn't matter that the UN is condemning Israel's actions. To some, _all_ of their actions are legitimate. I don't understand that. Can't they be wrong in some things and right in others ? It's hard to discuss this issue because of that polarized thinking.

I think that many things Israel has done and is doing are wrong and harmful.

However, most all if not all of the UN condemnations are nonsense and are passed in large part because of the number of Islamic controlled countries in the general assembly that hate the Jews (and a few large powerful ones that pander to these countries like Russia). That there are legitimate criticisms of Israel does not make any given criticism valid.
 
I guess it doesn't matter that the UN is condemning Israel's actions.

It doesn't matter that the UN security council is condemning Israel's actions, even when the US used its veto power most of the time.

To some, _all_ of their actions are legitimate. I don't understand that.

It's called propaganda. Such as the post above trying to deflect that the resolutions used were security council resolutions, not general assembly ones, and that the situation would be much worse if the US hadn't used its veto on 2/3 of them.

It's hard to discuss this issue because of that polarized thinking.

It's also hard to discuss it because facts are frequently denied.
 
However, most all if not all of the UN condemnations are nonsense and are passed in large part because of the number of Islamic controlled countries in the general assembly that hate the Jews (and a few large powerful ones that pander to these countries like Russia).

Could you support that with links ? I find it an odd claim that the UN somehow leans anti-Jew.

It's also hard to discuss it because facts are frequently denied.

By both sides, it seems.
 
Last edited:
Could you support that with links ? I find it an odd claim that the UN somehow leans anti-Jew.

Why do you find that odd? The Organization of Islamic Cooperation is by far the largest voting block within the UN. They have considerable influence within the UN, antisemitism is common among many of their member states, and many nonmember states play along with them in order to curry favor.
 
Could you support that with links ? I find it an odd claim that the UN somehow leans anti-Jew.

That would be exceeding difficult because I'd have to check many, many UN resolutions to see if they deal with Israeli actions in any way, then then further check the validity of the claims therein. Which would actually be your responsibility. Which UN resolutions do you think have merit in this regard?

Ziggurat already substantially answered the other aspect. If you look at the votes, who supported them, and what they say, you'll find they are overwhelming if not entirely done by countries that have attacked Israel, support attacking Israel, or sold weapons to those countries. In turn these countries have long used religious justifications and anti-Jewish rhetoric (although there are economic/political power reasons as well).
 
Why do you find that odd? The Organization of Islamic Cooperation is by far the largest voting block within the UN. They have considerable influence within the UN, antisemitism is common among many of their member states, and many nonmember states play along with them in order to curry favor.

Well that's certainly very damning if true. But since I'm not taking your word for it, could you provide some sort of evidence for this ?
 
Well that's certainly very damning if true. But since I'm not taking your word for it, could you provide some sort of evidence for this ?

Here is the, completely irrelevant, list of general assembly resolutions on Israel. You can try sampling some of them to see how anti-semitic they are.
 
Well that's certainly very damning if true. But since I'm not taking your word for it, could you provide some sort of evidence for this ?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Israel...bias_and_disproportionate_attention_on_Israel

"In recent years, the Middle East was the subject of 76% of country-specific General Assembly resolutions, 100% of the Human Rights Council resolutions, 100% of the Commission on the Status of Women resolutions, 50% of reports from the World Food Programme, 6% of United Nations Security Council resolutions and 6 of the 10 Emergency sessions.[citation needed]

These decisions, adopted with the support of the Organisation of the Islamic Conference (OIC) countries, often criticize Israel for its "occupation of Palestinian land and its oppression of Palestinians." A number of observers have described this criticism as excessive. For example, according to the UN Association of the UK, General Assembly resolutions in the period 1990–2003 show bias against Israel, condemnation of violence against Palestinians, but only occasional discussion of violence against Israelis.[4] In addition, the UNHRC was criticized in 2007 for failing to condemn other alleged human rights abusers besides Israel."

Small note: the Organization of Islamic Cooperation was formerly named the Organization of the Islamic Conference. The acronym did not change, obviously.
 
"These decisions, adopted with the support of the Organisation of the Islamic Conference (OIC) countries, often criticize Israel for its "occupation of Palestinian land and its oppression of Palestinians." A number of observers have described this criticism as excessive. For example, according to the UN Association of the UK, General Assembly resolutions in the period 1990–2003 show bias against Israel, condemnation of violence against Palestinians, but only occasional discussion of violence against Israelis.[4] In addition, the UNHRC was criticized in 2007 for failing to condemn other alleged human rights abusers besides Israel."

Allow me to finish your quote on the part that is actually relevant to the argument that was made:

"The United States has been criticized as well by the OIC and other Arab organisations, for vetoing most Security Council decisions critical of Israel, the so-called Negroponte doctrine.[5][6] Since 1961, Israel has been barred from the Asian regional group. In 2000, it was offered limited membership in the Western European and Others Group. On 29 November 2012, the UN General Assembly adopted United Nations General Assembly resolution 67/19 changing Palestine's "entity" status to "non-member state" by a vote of 138 to 9, with 41 abstentions. This implicitly recognised its sovereignty.[7][8]"
 
Yes it does. It shows the relative proportion of Palestinian vs Jewish/Israeli land in each map, how hard can this be to understand?

And how hard can it be to understand that the progression itself used criteria that cannot reasonably be claimed to show what you say it's supposed to?


Not what I was talking about, much as I did refer to that before when I noted that the pre-Israeli's had performed ethnic cleansing, so it's really not telling me anything new. Regardless, that should be easily shown... and there would still be green showing in Israel, still directly countering your claims about the validity of multiple panels in the progression. Also, still completely irrelevant to the problems with the usage of the progression that have nothing to do with the specific accuracy of the green parts, which, again are the most serious issues, as far as I've been concerned.

Again, the Palestinian Arabs lost a lot of land. That's not been in dispute. Much of the loss was entirely unfair. That's also not in dispute. The progression is still inaccurate and blatant propaganda where none is needed, misleading about the various causes of their losses and the way things have progressed, and is consistently used in service of fallacious arguments like the way you were originally using it.

Because what I actually used was available and a perfectly valid representation for the facts it chooses to present. Those facts don't go away no matter how much Israeli propaganda whines about the color of the desert.

Heh. Except that it actually is inaccurate, misleading, and, most importantly, you were using it fallaciously. No, those facts don't go away however much you want to claim that it's Israeli propaganda.

Nonsense, as anyone can see you claimed there to be responses disputing the facts I brought up in that post.

Except that I didn't claim that at any point. Rather, I pointed out that facts and arguments are judged on their own merits. The progression you offered failed factually, as a standalone argument, and as you attempted to use it. The quoted facts in post that was in question, however, received agreement that they were worth keeping in mind.

Looks like my suspicion was entirely accurate. You really, really need to learn to step back and pay attention to what's actually been said. You've been fighting straw men a fair bit.

When I correctly pointed out that this has not happened you claim I forgot your response where you did not dispute any of those facts but rationalized and moralized them.

*sigh* There's good arguments and bad. When it comes to the situation with Israel and the Palestinians, there's a whole lot less black and white than you keep trying to imply with your entirely one-sided claims. Claims that are frequently biased enough to be considered disinformation, as was shown quite well by your attempts to omit highly relevant information when it came to major conflicts, among other things. Perspective and understanding are not the same as rationalization and moralization, as difficult as that may be for you to accept.

This is presumably due to your continued failure to separate fact from opinion. That their land got taken is a fact, whether they "brought it on themselves" is an opinion. Presenting such an opinion does not constitute disputing the facts.

Again, perspective and understanding are not the same things as rationalization and moralization, as difficult as that may be for you to accept. Quite frankly, realistically, the Arabs have, in fact "brought much of their past and current woes upon themselves" when it comes to things related to Israel, by repeatedly making war and losing, since before Israel existed. It's a fact that war has nasty consequences, especially for the losers, and the Arabs have been very sore losers. It is also true that the Jews are not at all innocent in the matter, as was demonstrated by the ethnic cleansing, though the roots of much of the enmity also stretch back to long before Israel existed and, had the Jews chosen different courses of action earlier on, tensions would likely be much less.

It's certainly true that presenting the facts along those lines does not dispute the related fact that the Arabs have lost quite a bit of land. However, it's one of multiple areas of important context that you've repeatedly tried to leave out of the picture. When important pieces are left out of a picture, a picture tends to become distinctly misleading and entirely unfit for honest use.

trolling = not accepting some random guy on a forum claiming "it was all political, the Soviet Union's fault" without specific evidence better than "don't you know the UN is political?".

Not at all. You either really haven't been paying attention at all or you're trolling if you're somehow trying to claim that that claimed position and justification has anything to do with what I've said, though, which is what you're doing. If the former, why are you here at all if you're not going to pay attention to what's being said? As it stands, though, the latter is the much more strongly indicated, given that you don't seem stupid.

Evidence?

That that's the claim being made? :eye-poppi

Take a peek back. You'll find that every single relevant statement made by me fits that dramatically better than your farcical claims about what I said.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom