Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
its a chicken and egg argument.

No it is not, though I'm sure some here would like to pretend it is. The evidence clearly and consistently shows that escalations in Israeli attacks provoke escalations in rocket attacks, not the other way around. It has nothing to do with a chicken and egg argument and everything to do with consistently attacking first and then claiming self-defense.
 
No it is not, though I'm sure some here would like to pretend it is. The evidence clearly and consistently shows that escalations in Israeli attacks provoke escalations in rocket attacks, not the other way around. It has nothing to do with a chicken and egg argument and everything to do with consistently attacking first and then claiming self-defense.

Well, wouldn't that imply that Israel attacked first ?
 
What you think is irrelevant. What matters is evidence, such as continued expropriation of Palestinian owned land by Israel in the occupied territories.
There is absolutely no evidence of of continued expropriation of Palestinian land in Gaza, which is where the threat of continued rocket attacks exists.

You're just making stuff up now. Provide evidence that attacks from Israel deter further Palestinian rocket attacks.
How well the tactic works is entirely irrelevant. The intention of attaching a price tag to launching rockets at Israel is clear to anyone outside of those whose political agenda requires it not to be clear.
 
Last edited:
Well, wouldn't that imply that Israel attacked first ?

Literally? Yes. But there's a difference between "who started it" and "who is re-igniting it".

It is unknown who attacked first, it started the day the British mandate of Palestine ended in 1948, hence its army withdrawing, and civil war broke out between the two groups.

We were talking about the 2014 events and the claim that Israel was acting after and in response to the thousands of rocket attacks that year. That WildCat now brings up the "very first rocket in 2001" is:
1. Irrelevant, since he claimed "thousands of rockets before Israel struck back".
2. A diversion to make this seem to be a "chicken and egg" question.

While the question "who attacked first in that far distant past" may be interesting, it is still distinct from "who is escalating the ongoing conflict now". As well as completely irrelevant to the specific events in 2014.
 
There is absolutely no evidence of of continued expropriation of Palestinian land in Gaza, which is where the threat of continued rocket attacks exists.

I said the occupied territories, which includes the West Bank where Israel does expropriate Palestinian land.

How well the tactic works is entirely irrelevant.

It's not like every time a lot of people get killed, so who cares about whether it actually works, right?

The intention of attaching a price tag to launching rockets at Israel is clear to anyone outside of those whose political agenda requires it not to be clear.

If it is so clear then provide some evidence.
 
It's not like every time a lot of people get killed, so who cares about whether it actually works, right?

Do you ever ask this question of Hamas?

No, of course not. They get a pass. I wonder why.

Oops! I keep lying. I know exactly why.
 
Do you ever ask this question of Hamas?

Yes I do. The respective figures for the latest conflict are 66 soldiers and 6 civilians killed on the Israeli side and 605 militants and 1492 civilians killed on the Palestinian side.

Oops! I keep lying. I know exactly why.

So do I. Do you consider a Palestinian civilian life to be worth less than 6/1492 of an Israeli civilian one? If not, do you have any other reason why, when considering civilian loss of life, I should not focus on the IDF's actions?
 
Yes I do. The respective figures for the latest conflict are 66 soldiers and 6 civilians killed on the Israeli side and 605 militants and 1492 civilians killed on the Palestinian side.



So do I. Do you consider a Palestinian civilian life to be worth less than 6/1492 of an Israeli civilian one? If not, do you have any other reason why, when considering civilian loss of life, I should not focus on the IDF's actions?

It's almost as if Hamas should stop attacking Israel.

One side incurring a huge cost doesn't make the side that incurs the huge cost in the right or the victims. I'm a six foot tall 237 pound martial artist. If a five one 200 pound out of shape football fan charges me, am I really the attacker because he ends up with a concussion or broken nose, and I end up with no injuries?

Your reasoning here is nonsesne at a very basic level. Palestinian agency is not reduced because they're losing. Your argument considering civilian loss of life is putting the blame, the agency, for those costs totally on Israel. Hamas is responsible for many of those Palestinian deaths with their own actions. They need to own up to their mistakes.

Losses don't have to be equal for moral considerations either. The JDF and Israel have done a lot of bad, wrong, immoral things, but Hamas currently has to be responsible for their own actions. They should stop attacking. They should have stopped when they were given back land.
 
Last edited:
Yes I do. The respective figures for the latest conflict are 66 soldiers and 6 civilians killed on the Israeli side and 605 militants and 1492 civilians killed on the Palestinian side.

And what, exactly, do you think this tells us? Certainly it tells us that Israel is much more powerful than the Palestinians. But does it tell us anything more than that? No, it does not.

So do I. Do you consider a Palestinian civilian life to be worth less than 6/1492 of an Israeli civilian one? If not, do you have any other reason why, when considering civilian loss of life, I should not focus on the IDF's actions?

First off, Israel prioritizes Israeli lives over Palestinian lives. This is not only inevitable, it is also proper. Second, Hamas and other Palestinian fighters deliberately endanger Palestinian lives as a matter of policy. Dead Palestinian civilians is an actual goal for them. So when they achieve their goal through deliberate action, why should they be considered blameless, as you apparently believe they should be?

Israel takes action to minimize Palestinian civilian deaths. Hamas takes action to maximize Palestinian civilian deaths. You want to side with Hamas, because it's their own people that they're managing to kill. This is not a moral attitude.
 
And what, exactly, do you think this tells us? Certainly it tells us that Israel is much more powerful than the Palestinians. But does it tell us anything more than that? No, it does not.

:rolleyes:

What it exactly tells us is that Israel is much more lethal than the Palestinians.

First off, Israel prioritizes Israeli lives over Palestinian lives.

Obviously.

This is not only inevitable, it is also proper.

I'm not sure if it's proper for an occupying power, but it is certainly historical.

Second, Hamas and other Palestinian fighters deliberately endanger Palestinian lives as a matter of policy. Dead Palestinian civilians is an actual goal for them.

Wait a second. The argument used to be that the Palestinians want to kill Jews with rocket attacks, and Israel defends against that. Now it is that the Palestinians want to kill themselves and their method is through provoking Israel to do it for them?

So when they achieve their goal through deliberate action, why should they be considered blameless, as you apparently believe they should be?

:rolleyes:

Israel takes action to minimize Palestinian civilian deaths. Hamas takes action to maximize Palestinian civilian deaths.

Even if you were to provide evidence that Hamas action is the main reason for the overwhelmingly large casualty rate discrepancy, that still doesn't change the fact that it is still Israel doing the shooting.

You want to side with Hamas, because it's their own people that they're managing to kill. This is not a moral attitude.

:rolleyes:
 

:bunpan

What it exactly tells us is that Israel is much more lethal than the Palestinians.

Because they're much more powerful. Which is what I said.

I'm not sure if it's proper for an occupying power, but it is certainly historical.

We're talking about Gaza, remember? Israel isn't occupying Gaza, and the targets of Hamas's missile attacks are not in Gaza or the West Bank. And it will always be proper for a government to prioritize the safety of its own citizens. That is its primary legitimate purpose.

Wait a second. The argument used to be that the Palestinians want to kill Jews with rocket attacks, and Israel defends against that. Now it is that the Palestinians want to kill themselves and their method is through provoking Israel to do it for them?

You say that like these are mutually exclusive goals. They most certainly are not.


:bunpan

Even if you were to provide evidence that Hamas action is the main reason for the overwhelmingly large casualty rate discrepancy, that still doesn't change the fact that it is still Israel doing the shooting.

And? What's your point?


:bunpan
 
Because they're much more powerful. Which is what I said.

Not only do the two categories not necessarily coincide, you even explicitly excluded that it said anything but "more powerful".

We're talking about Gaza, remember? Israel isn't occupying Gaza

Nice try. Its blockade ensures its continued control, making it is still the occupying power.

and the targets of Hamas's missile attacks are not in Gaza or the West Bank.

Israeli targets aren't in Israel either, what's your point? Also, when are you going to stop getting your Hamas talking points in? Weren't you the one going on about how we shouldn't ignore non-Hamas rockets?

And it will always be proper for a government to prioritize the safety of its own citizens. That is its primary legitimate purpose.

Do you support the practice during WW2 of German assaults on French villages in retaliation for terrorist attacks by French fighters?

You say that like these are mutually exclusive goals. They most certainly are not.

So you just add claims on top as required.

And? What's your point?

Provide evidence.
 
Nice try. Its blockade ensures its continued control, making it is still the occupying power.
Blockades and sieges are actually quite distinct from occupations. The most obvious difference is the total absence of any occupying force in the first two.

Do you support the practice during WW2 of German assaults on French villages in retaliation for terrorist attacks by French fighters?
Is there a difference between attacking a village in retaliation for terrorism, and attacking a village because you want to fight and defeat the terrorists and they are in that village?
 
Blockades and sieges are actually quite distinct from occupations. The most obvious difference is the total absence of any occupying force in the first two.

One also starts with a b and the other with an o.

In any case, the Gaza strip.

wiki said:
The territory is still considered to be "occupied" by the United Nations, International human rights organisations, and the majority of governments and legal commentators, despite the 2005 Israeli disengagement from Gaza.

Is there a difference between attacking a village in retaliation for terrorism, and attacking a village because you want to fight and defeat the terrorists and they are in that village?

Yes.
 
Not only do the two categories not necessarily coincide, you even explicitly excluded that it said anything but "more powerful".

If a nation is not more lethal, then it isn't more powerful.

Israeli targets aren't in Israel either, what's your point?

That the "occupying" status is irrelevant.

Also, when are you going to stop getting your Hamas talking points in? Weren't you the one going on about how we shouldn't ignore non-Hamas rockets?

Now you're making a rather massive logical error. There is a difference between excluding something from a category and including something in a category. You have done the former, I am doing the latter.

Do you support the practice during WW2 of German assaults on French villages in retaliation for terrorist attacks by French fighters?

Congratulations, your first full-scale Godwin for this thread!

Tell me, caveman, what was the actual target of Israeli retaliation? Was it Gaza villages? Or was it terrorist targets who were hiding in Gaza villages?

So you just add claims on top as required.

When they're all true, why not?
 
Stop moving the goalposts. Show the thousands of rockets fired at Israel before Israel attacked or concede the bet.
A Wikipedia link was already provided a few posts ago... :rolleyes:

When do you think the first missiles were launched at Israel from Gaza, 2012?
 
Yes I do. The respective figures for the latest conflict are 66 soldiers and 6 civilians killed on the Israeli side and 605 militants and 1492 civilians killed on the Palestinian side.



So do I. Do you consider a Palestinian civilian life to be worth less than 6/1492 of an Israeli civilian one? If not, do you have any other reason why, when considering civilian loss of life, I should not focus on the IDF's actions?
Perhaps the Palestinians should stop attacking Israel? I mean, if I went up to an MMA champion and punched him in the nose I'm pretty certain I would get my ass kicked badly... but to keep doing it even after getting my ass kicked badly would be a sign I'm not quite right in the head, wouldn't it?

And just to be clear, in your opinion who is right and who is wrong in any given armed conflict is directly related to the casualties on each side, correct? If not, what is the relevance of you posting casualty figures?
 
A Wikipedia link was already provided a few posts ago... :rolleyes:

When do you think the first missiles were launched at Israel from Gaza, 2012?

Stop blatantly lying. Again, show the thousands of rockets fired before Israel attacked Gaza or concede the bet. If you do not do so in your next response then don't expect me to pay any further attention to your posts.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom