Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
It obviously wasn't defense against either Hamas or non-Hamas rocket attacks. So you tell me, why did it?

For exactly the same reasons Palestinian militants (including Hamas) launch their operations against Israeli targets, even though those attacks have virtually no traditional defense value.
 
Did the strikes precede Hamas rocket attacks or not? Yes or no?

Why do you only care about official Hamas rocket attacks? Why do you think Israel should care only about official Hamas rocket attacks?

It obviously wasn't defense against either Hamas or non-Hamas rocket attacks. So you tell me, why did it?

I really can't imagine why Israel might strike at tunnels designed to infiltrate Israeli territory in order to capture or kill Israeli citizens. It's a total mystery to me.
 
The winner of an avatar bet gets to choose an image, which the looser must then use as their avatar (the little image under your user name) for the specified period of time.

Seems fine to me then.

ETA: here's a histogram with the red(-dotted) lines being the start of major Israeli assaults on the occupied territories. As you can see, Israeli assaults preceded the "thousands of rockets fired".
 
Last edited:
Why do you only care about official Hamas rocket attacks?

I don't. As you well know the source I linked to deconstructs Israel's argument step by step. I assume you are not conceding that Israeli attacks preceded Hamas rocket attacks so that you can keep this argument going without having to proceed to the next step where it is shown that Israeli attacks also precede non-Hamas rocket attacks.

Why do you think Israel should care only about official Hamas rocket attacks?

:rolleyes:

I really can't imagine why Israel might strike at tunnels designed to infiltrate Israeli territory in order to capture or kill Israeli citizens. It's a total mystery to me.

So nothing to do with rocket attacks as is being claimed by Israel and several posters in this thread?
 
Price-tag deterrent, domestic political advantage, and terrorizing the civilian population in an attempt to undermine your opponents political support.

You're forgetting colonization of the occupied territories.

You really weren't aware of this?

I'm aware that "Israel is defending itself from rocket attacks" is total BS.
 
Last edited:
Seems fine to me then.

ETA: here's a histogram with the red(-dotted) lines being the start of major Israeli assaults on the occupied territories. As you can see, Israeli assaults preceded the "thousands of rockets fired".
And look at those goalposts go flying!

I guess you're now admitting that rockets were fired at Israel prior to July 6, 2012?
 
:rolleyes:

You're free to show those "thousands of rockets fired at Israel before Israel struck back". In the meantime I'll think about your avatar image ;)



I never said there weren't, as well as provided sources specifically dealing with them.
Let's recap, shall we?

Yes, in 2013 the Palestinian people were overwhelmingly opposed to armed confrontation. Then they got thoroughly bombed in 2014 and afterwards they were in favour in armed resistance.
So the thousands of missiles fired at Israel before Israel struck back was what, unarmed conflict?
This may be relevant.

Now, what happened first, Hamas firing thousands of rockets into Israel or Israeli bombing in Gaza?
 
You're forgetting colonization of the occupied territories.
Israel pulls all settlements out of Gaza, then periodically attacks Gaza to re-settle Gaza? I don't think so.

I'm aware that "Israel is defending itself from rocket attacks" is total BS.
Since nearly the entire purpose of price-tags attacks from Israel is to deter further PAL rocket attacks, I'd say what you think you're aware of is wrong.
 
I think it was 2001? its a chicken and egg argument.

That's what Wikipedia says. With a list here:

List of Palestinian rocket attacks on Israel, 2001


That's a long time of pursuing a policy that has made almost all of the Palestinian people worse off. Except for the bank accounts of the top Hamas leadership of course.

As long as the Hamas leadership continue to benefit, they are happy to continue to make money off of their intentional persecution of the Palestinian people.
 
Israel pulls all settlements out of Gaza, then periodically attacks Gaza to re-settle Gaza? I don't think so.

What you think is irrelevant. What matters is evidence, such as continued expropriation of Palestinian owned land by Israel in the occupied territories.

Since nearly the entire purpose of price-tags attacks from Israel is to deter further PAL rocket attacks, I'd say what you think you're aware of is wrong.

You're just making stuff up now. Provide evidence that attacks from Israel deter further Palestinian rocket attacks.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom