Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
It's not irrelevant if the Israeli airstrikes which supposedly hit the tunnel never actually happened.

Evidence?

That's already been done multiple times on this thread. One more time won't convince you.

:rolleyes:

I think I get the game you're playing now. Rocket attacks from Gaza against Israel were ongoing even before this. When such attacks were met with Israeli retaliation, Hamas officially started launching attacks against Israel. You want to blame it all on Israel because the prior attacks weren't officially Hamas attacks, as if other attacks simply don't matter.

For bonus points: which Israeli attack on Gaza a month earlier led to other groups performing rocket strikes?

Yeah, doesn't work that way.

No it doesn't. Besides, even if the order of events was reversed, that still doesn't change that self-defense does not apply to an occupying power over its occupied territories.
 
Has someone posted facts from an unbiased source so we can stop this back-and-forth ?

I have. It is an outright lie that this is "claimed by Hamas", as I have shown multiple times, and you can read for yourself on page 14 of the document.
 
Ziggurat's contention that the airstrikes never happened requires that Israel is somehow "in on it". So we have, for no apparent reason, both sides of a conflict, as well as independent observers, falsely claiming that airstrikes happened on a specific date. And that's supposed to be good enough (as always, without presenting any source whatsoever) to consider that my source is biased? Because it didn't consider that theory?
 
Given the recent bickering, could you just provide the link again, please ? I haven't followed the thread closely in the last few days.

https://www.nlg.org/sites/default/files/Attack First Kill thousands Claim Self-Defense FINAL.pdf

Page 14:
The Israeli newspaper, Haaretz reported on July 8:
Israel launched air strikes across the Gaza Strip overnight Sunday [July 6]. Nine Palestinian militants were killed over the course of the night, but Israel claims at least six of them died when a tunnel collapsed.

As I have already quoted above. Hamas does not in any way come into the sourcing of this fact.
 
Ziggurat's contention that the airstrikes never happened requires that Israel is somehow "in on it".

Well, no. I'm not claiming that there were no airstrikes anywhere. I'm claiming that there was no airstrike on the Hamas tunnel that exploded. Both sides are NOT claiming that this happened.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2014_Israel–Gaza_conflict

"On 7 July, after seven Hamas militants died in a tunnel explosion in Khan Yunis which was caused by an Israeli airstrike (per Hamas, Nathan Thrall and BBC) or an accidental explosion of their own munitions (per the IDF), Hamas assumed responsibility for rockets fired into Israel and launched 40 rockets towards Israel."
 
Well, no.

So you concede that Israel's airstrikes preceded Hamas rocket attacks?

I'm not claiming that there were no airstrikes anywhere. I'm claiming that there was no airstrike on the Hamas tunnel that exploded.

So during an airstrike by Israel a tunnel of Hamas accidentally collapsed. And this should be believed because the most neutral source in your own quote states differently?

Both sides are NOT claiming that this happened.

It's fairly irrelevant too.
 
So you concede that Israel's airstrikes preceded Hamas rocket attacks?

Do you concede that Palestinian rocket attacks preceded those airstrikes?

So during an airstrike by Israel a tunnel of Hamas accidentally collapsed. And this should be believed because the most neutral source in your own quote states differently?

What, Hamas is a neutral source?
 
How can your links possibly tell me what YOU do or do not concede?

I don't know, how does it work when you take me to task for other statements made in the links I provide?

Answer my question, caveman.

How about you answer mine?


You are aware that people can see your post containing 4 sources for the claims, with you highlighting "Hamas" and "IDF", and then we have the BBC and another? Just because you don't highlight them doesn't mean they're not there.

Let's take a look at what the BBC had to say:
"Israel hit by Hamas rocket salvo". BBC News. 7 July 2014. Retrieved 17 December 2014. "A Hamas spokesman had earlier accused Israel of killing the five militants during air strikes on Sunday and called it a "grave escalation". He promised Israel would "pay a tremendous price". But Israeli military spokesman Lt Col Peter Lerner denied the claims, saying the men had died on Sunday in a tunnel that had been bombarded by Israel on Thursday. He said the militants went into the tunnel to assess the damage from the air strike and meddled with some explosives, which were apparently detonated accidentally."
So on thursday Israel conducts an airstrike on the tunnel. Then on sunday it conducts more airstrikes, but not on that tunnel, during which some Hamas members found it convenient to go look at the tunnel that was already bombed, and which at that moment accidentally exploded thereby killing them.

This is supposed to dispute that the Israeli airstrikes precede Hamas rocket fire how exactly?
 
Last edited:
You are aware that people can see your post containing 4 sources for the claims, with you highlighting "Hamas" and "IDF", and then we have the BBC and another? Just because you don't highlight them doesn't mean they're not there.

Let's take a look at what the BBC had to say:

"Israel hit by Hamas rocket salvo". BBC News. 7 July 2014. Retrieved 17 December 2014. "A Hamas spokesman had earlier accused Israel of killing the five militants during air strikes on Sunday and called it a "grave escalation". He promised Israel would "pay a tremendous price". But Israeli military spokesman Lt Col Peter Lerner denied the claims, saying the men had died on Sunday in a tunnel that had been bombarded by Israel on Thursday. He said the militants went into the tunnel to assess the damage from the air strike and meddled with some explosives, which were apparently detonated accidentally."

Oh, look at that: the BBC repeats Hamas's claim, but does not itself ever make the claim. Huh. I wonder why I didn't highlight the BBC as being a source of that claim.

Oops, I lied: it's obvious why I didn't.

This is supposed to dispute that the Israeli airstrikes precede Hamas rocket fire how exactly?

I note you continue to ignore rockets that Hamas did not officially take responsibility for. I wonder why you think Israel should have ignored such rockets as well.

Oops, I lied again. I know exactly why.

You're right, I just keep lying.
 
Oh, look at that: the BBC repeats Hamas's claim, but does not itself ever make the claim.

Even more lies, it sources the strikes to the Israeli military.
bbc said:
"Israel hit by Hamas rocket salvo". BBC News. 7 July 2014. Retrieved 17 December 2014. "A Hamas spokesman had earlier accused Israel of killing the five militants during air strikes on Sunday and called it a "grave escalation". He promised Israel would "pay a tremendous price". But Israeli military spokesman Lt Col Peter Lerner denied the claims, saying the men had died on Sunday in a tunnel that had been bombarded by Israel on Thursday. He said the militants went into the tunnel to assess the damage from the air strike and meddled with some explosives, which were apparently detonated accidentally."

You're right, I just keep lying.

The sequence of events:
Israel attacks Gaza
Non-Hamas groups fire rockets at Israel.
Israel performs airstrikes on Hamas tunnel networks
Hamas fires rockets at Israel

No matter how much you try to lie and distort things, it won't change the facts.
 
Last edited:
Even more lies, it sources the strikes to the Israeli military.

Even more lies. The strike wasn't what killed those Hamas members. The claim that it did comes from Hamas, and Hamas alone, not the IDF, and not the BBC.

The sequence of events:
Israel attacks Gaza
Non-Hamas groups fire rockets at Israel.
Israel performs airstrikes on Hamas tunnel networks
Hamas fires rockets at Israel

No matter how much you try to lie and distort things, it won't change the facts.

And why did Israel attack Gaza? Did they just decide they needed to kill them some towelheads?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom