Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Closer than Hamas, though, however marginally, and I don't recall any stories of them brutally slaughtering Arab civilians for absurdly terrible reasons off the top of my head, unlike Hamas

With one critical difference, Fatah doesn't openly espouse genocide. If you had checked closer you'd see that it distanced itself from that picture. It is no different from using statements by individual politicians such as Ben-Ari saying "There are no innocents in Gaza, don’t let any diplomats who want to look good in the world endanger your lives—mow them down!" to claim that Israel openly espouses genocide and Israeli citizens as being "evil".

which is a small point in their favor.

:rolleyes:
 
The "Palestinian people" combed a lengthy charter full of genocidal references and militant anti-Jewish racist sentiment, cherry picked some lonely, barely mumbled words on "tolerance" and concluded Hamas wasn't really genocidal? I don't think so.

The Palestinian people, being under military occupation, most likely voted for the guy who promised to stop it.
 
The claim is made that the Palestinian people are evil. Evidence is them "repeatedly and by large majority electing parties that openly espouse genocide". If this were true then it would still not mean that Palestinians vote for them because they openly espouse genocide, but at least there would be some claim here.

So is it true? Elections are about 50-50 between Hamas and Fatah, sometimes one winning and sometimes the other. Both have to openly espouse genocide for that claim to be true.
Hamas openly calls for the genocide of the Jews, Fatah calls openly for the destruction of Israel and refuses to disavow that goal. Fatah leaders regularly spout anti-Semitic ideas, and financially reward those who kill Israeli civilians, even those who kill children.

What exactly is your point caveman? You don't even think the 50% of Palestinians who vote for the party openly espousing genocide of the Jews (as opposed to the other 50% who vote for the openly anti-Semitic party calling for the destruction of Israel) are evil? What does "evil" mean to you? If there was a US political party that called for all blacks to be killed would you think that it and the people who voted for them are evil, or would you say that maybe it was that party's other policies people were voting for?

The Palestinians find themselves in their current position because of their barbaric, uncivilized, viscerally abhorrent behavior. It's not Israel's fault that the Palestinians live in a [feces]hole, along with most of the rest of the Arab world. It's their own fault for being uncivilized barbaric backwards jackasses who can't even get along with each other, and only unite under the banner of anti-Semitism.

It's astonishing to me that anyone in the west defends this sick barbaric death culture, but then again lots of people in the west hate Jews just as much I guess.
 
Last edited:
So the thousands of missiles fired at Israel before Israel struck back was what, unarmed conflict?

This may be relevant.

ref said:
This submission to the ICC prosecutor:

Presents facts showing that Israeli air and ground attacks preceded Hamas rocket fire.
Because Israeli armed forces launched large-scale attacks on the West Bank and Gaza during a period when a cease-fire with Hamas was in place and while Hamas continued to observe the cease-fire, before any Hamas rockets were launched from Gaza and while no non-Hamas rockets were being fired at Israel, Israeli forces could not have been defending Israeli citizens from rocket fire.
 
The Palestinian people, being under military occupation, most likely voted for the guy who promised to stop it.
Clearly. Nothing to do with an obscure, lip-service remark in an otherwise racist militant charter, though.

Yes, in 2013 the Palestinian people were overwhelmingly opposed to armed confrontation. Then they got thoroughly bombed in 2014 and afterwards they were in favour in armed resistance.
That's correct. The PAL's were in favor of a non-violent approach, and now they are overwhelmingly in favor of a violent approach. Which is why I corrected your earlier erroneous statement.
 
Last edited:
That's correct. The PAL's were in favor of a non-violent approach, and now they are overwhelmingly in favor of a violent approach. Which is why I corrected your earlier erroneous statement.

The point is still that the PALs are not inherently violent or evil, even with a Hamas government. So while you are correct that their favour changed, it is still the correct poll to make the point.
 
Last edited:
It's still true.

*sigh* Very well. That very much shortened version can qualify as a genetic fallacy, if you ignore the rest of the preceding information and points. Moving on.

Because that's the land Israel laid claim to as it declared statehood. Meaning it declared that was the territory its laws applied to.

So, you're changing your claim to one where you're claiming that the progression is mislabeled for the intent. In short, you're still admitting that the progression that you showed is distinctly flawed, at best.

It is the same criterium being used.

Again, not according to the progression itself, no matter how much you try to squirm.

They don't have to be a country to be a people, and hence having the right to self-determination.

While that may well be true, that doesn't affect the veracity of the actual point that had been made, nor does it make your response any less irrelevant, as it was made. It is certainly true that you could have even tried to work the picture into a valid and meaningful response that would also not have provoked anywhere near the controversy that it did. You didn't, instead opting for an irrelevant gotcha attempt.


The claims about it have been much more misleading than the maps are.

Some, perhaps.

The first claim that it should show land owned by neither in a different colour leads one to think that Israel has been building new settlements in previously unclaimed land, thereby getting relatively more land. The reality is that Israel has been building new settlements on top of the Palestinian privately owned land.

That complaint is somewhat bewildering. If Israel would be taking the Palestinian's privately owned land, rather than land owned by neither, the picture would reflect that directly in such a case, meaning that the case that Palestinians were losing land (for strongly implied nefarious reasons) would be strengthened if it validly and directly showed such, rather than what it does.

Separately, yes, I've read of a case or two of Israel kicking out Palestinians from their homes and co-opted their homes for their settling, at last check.

The second claim is something about some Palestinians getting Israeli citizenship. This leads one to think that the progression is because the people changed from being "Palestinian" to "Arab-Israeli". So person X inhabits land plot A and X gets counted as "Palestinian" first and then as "Israeli", making A go from green to white. The reality is that X found himself in a refugee camp in another country after a civil war, and his land plot A was hence vacant. Israel, at that point controlling the region where A is located, then passed a law preventing the return of X to A. It then passed another law stating that properties for which the owner could not present himself by a specific date would belong to the state of Israel. It noticed that X was not present at A on that date so A now belongs to the state of Israel, which it usually builds a new settlement on, and then rents it out to Jewish settlers.

Again, your complaint doesn't work particularly well. By your own admittance, some of the Palestinians *are* officially Israelis and do still own land. Even if it is only about 13-14% of the previous number, going by the numbers you claimed, there should still be patches of green inside Israel, unless you have significant information that you hadn't presented before. Instead, there's none, in part because multiple panels were using criteria that couldn't show the Palestinian-owned land at the time in Israel or Israeli controlled territory, regardless of whether there was any.

It also misleads in that it fails to mention that the citizenship awarded to Arab Israeli excludes the right to use or occupy their property, which is exactly the topic under discussion.

This is a new claim for you. Just since I'm getting tired of you dancing around, feel free to back it up.

Every claim made about it is not only fairly irrelevant but misleading on its own. You're ignoring that even if you think a different criterium should be used for unowned land, the criterium is still being applied consistently throughout all maps, contrary to your claims.

Except that you've consistently failed to back that up properly. Of course, my direct issues with it have far more to do with the usage of it that I've seen you and others engage than the specific issues with accuracy, given that it's consistently used in a rather context free and irrelevant way to what it's used in response to.

Even if you restrict the green to Palestinians' land and white to Jewish/Israeli land and use something like blue for unowned land, you'd still see the green parts becoming white, with next to no change for the blue parts.

And that could support the case that you've been pushing far better than what you actually used. So why not use better arguments preferentially?

There was none.

Only if you completely ignored what I said. You seem to do that a fair bit, though.

P: There exist political resolutions.
Q: These resolutions exist.
R: These resolutions are political.

(P AND Q) -> R?

No. But then, you've been making distinct efforts to ignore or misrepresent what's been said, so I'm not surprised that you're trying this. At this point, I cannot reasonably consider your failure to understand on this to be anything other than trolling, so I will cease responding to it.

Ok, the answer to your original question is no.

Alright.

Ok, the Khmer Rouge and general observation that political resolutions exist are used to argue that the UN is unreliable on this issue. First of all this fails to makes the distinction between the general assembly and the security council, but more importantly fails to mention that some of the determinations in the resolutions have also been reached by many other institutions such as the ICJ. But then after "the UN is bought for" point that I will fail to address we'll have "but it's a kangaroo court" point that I'll also fail to address.

Incidentally, it may be worth repeating, yet again, that there's been no argument that Israel has, in fact, broken international law when it has found reason to do so and that the UN has fairly certainly correctly identified at least some of the violations. The relevant claim when it comes to raw numbers, though, is that Israel has received significantly more attention from quite a few countries who have actively sought to condemn them for whatever they think they can get away with condemning them for and that no other country receives similar levels of attention and treatment. The "UN is bought for" and "but it's a kangaroo court" are not claims that I had any intention to use, though there have, in fact, been kangaroo courts used to condemn Israel. Likely the Palestinians, too.
 
With one critical difference, Fatah doesn't openly espouse genocide. If you had checked closer you'd see that it distanced itself from that picture. It is no different from using statements by individual politicians such as Ben-Ari saying "There are no innocents in Gaza, don’t let any diplomats who want to look good in the world endanger your lives—mow them down!" to claim that Israel openly espouses genocide and Israeli citizens as being "evil".

Not as openly, yes, which is why Israel has been working with them, politically. Incidentally, that's part of the reason why I included the 73% of Palestinians think that it's their religious duty to kill Jews poll mention. Fatah still celebrates terrorist actions against the Jews, beyond that, among other similar things. Either way, as before, I'm actually not making the claims that most of the Palestinians are evil, though I certainly could. I was getting a little tired of the pointless back and forth, though. Fatah's not even remotely far away from going back to openly advocating genocide again, but they seem to be much, much smarter than Hamas politically, when it comes to relations with Israel, so they're much less likely to actually go back to openly pushing for it soon.
 
Last edited:
This may be relevant.

WildCat is right, it's not relevant. One of Hamas tunnels collapsed and a few workers in it died due to poor ventilation. Hamas declared, without providing any evidence, it is due to Israeli bombardment (which is difficult to hide) and "retalliated".

Source: the link you posted.

Filing blatantly false charges like these will get you sued for slander in most jurdistictions.

McHrozni
 
Again, not according to the progression itself, no matter how much you try to squirm.

Yes it does. It shows the relative proportion of Palestinian vs Jewish/Israeli land in each map, how hard can this be to understand?

Separately, yes, I've read of a case or two of Israel kicking out Palestinians from their homes and co-opted their homes for their settling, at last check.

Try about 700 000 cases:

In 1945, of the 26.4 million dunams (26,400 km²) of land in Mandatory Palestine, 12.8 million was owned by Arabs, 1.5 million by Jews, 1.5 million was public land and 10.6 million constituted the desertic Beersheba district (Negev). Of the 9.2 million dunams of land that was arable, 7.8 million dunams was owned by Arabs, 1.2 million by Jews and 0.2 million was public land. By 1949, some 700,000 Palestinians had fled or been expelled from their lands and villages. Israel was now in control of some 20.5 million dunams (approx. 20,500 km²) or 78% of lands in what had been Mandatory Palestine: 8% (approx. 1,650 km²) were privately controlled by Jews, 6% (approx. 1,300 km²) by Arabs, with the remaining 86% being public land. Land laws were passed to legalize changes to land ownership.

And that could support the case that you've been pushing far better than what you actually used. So why not use better arguments preferentially?

Because what I actually used was available and a perfectly valid representation for the facts it chooses to present. Those facts don't go away no matter how much Israeli propaganda whines about the color of the desert.

Only if you completely ignored what I said. You seem to do that a fair bit, though.

Nonsense, as anyone can see you claimed there to be responses disputing the facts I brought up in that post. When I correctly pointed out that this has not happened you claim I forgot your response where you did not dispute any of those facts but rationalized and moralized them.

This is presumably due to your continued failure to separate fact from opinion. That their land got taken is a fact, whether they "brought it on themselves" is an opinion. Presenting such an opinion does not constitute disputing the facts.

No. But then, you've been making distinct efforts to ignore or misrepresent what's been said, so I'm not surprised that you're trying this.

:rolleyes:

At this point, I cannot reasonably consider your failure to understand on this to be anything other than trolling, so I will cease responding to it.

trolling = not accepting some random guy on a forum claiming "it was all political, the Soviet Union's fault" without specific evidence better than "don't you know the UN is political?".

The relevant claim when it comes to raw numbers, though, is that Israel has received significantly more attention from quite a few countries who have actively sought to condemn them for whatever they think they can get away with condemning them for and that no other country receives similar levels of attention and treatment.

Evidence?
 
WildCat is right, it's not relevant. One of Hamas tunnels collapsed and a few workers in it died due to poor ventilation. Hamas declared, without providing any evidence, it is due to Israeli bombardment (which is difficult to hide) and "retalliated".

Source: the link you posted.

Filing blatantly false charges like these will get you sued for slander in most jurdistictions.

McHrozni

:rolleyes:

link I posted said:
The Israeli newspaper, Haaretz reported on July 8:
Israel launched air strikes across the Gaza Strip overnight Sunday [July 6]. Nine Palestinian militants were killed over the course of the night, but Israel claims at least six of them died when a tunnel collapsed.
 
Last edited:

What exactly is this supposed to convey? Your disdain for having your argument ripped to shreds? Your indifference to being proven completely wrong? I really can't figure it out, but it doesn't appear to accomplish anything.
 
What exactly is this supposed to convey? Your disdain for having your argument ripped to shreds? Your indifference to being proven completely wrong? I really can't figure it out, but it doesn't appear to accomplish anything.

:rolleyes:

If you really want to know, my disdain for blatant lies and propaganda. You know, the thing the two of you specialize in.
 
Last edited:

:bunpan

If you really want to know, my disdain for blatant lies and propaganda. You know, the thing the two of you specialize in.

Except what he said wasn't a lie, nor was it propaganda. And you don't have disdain for blatant lies and propaganda, you regularly post lies and propaganda yourself. Your only criteria is that it be anti-Israeli.

Plus, nobody cares about what you have disdain for. If these were the lies you claim them to be, then people might be interested in evidence, but you won't post that. I wonder why.

Oops, I just proved you right by lying myself: I don't wonder why, I know exactly why.
 
Except what he said wasn't a lie, nor was it propaganda.

Of course it is. The relevant facts are that Israel claims to have been defending itself from Hamas' rocket attacks whereas the Israeli airstrikes precede the rocket attacks. The question whether the tunnel collapsed on its own or due to the Israeli airstrikes on the tunnels is irrelevant for establishing which precedes which. It's that cause and effect thing again.

And you don't have disdain for blatant lies and propaganda, you regularly post lies and propaganda yourself.

Quote one and prove it.

Plus, nobody cares about what you have disdain for.

:rolleyes: [I'll even explain this one to you: you yourself just asked me about my disdain for something]

If these were the lies you claim them to be, then people might be interested in evidence, but you won't post that. I wonder why.

I already did when I first posted the link, I suggest you actually read it. The airstrikes (July 6) precede the Hamas rocket attacks (July 7), and this is not "claimed by Hamas" but by Haaretz which sources it to an IDF spokesman.
 
Of course it is. The relevant facts are that Israel claims to have been defending itself from Hamas' rocket attacks whereas the Israeli airstrikes precede the rocket attacks.

That's what Hamas claims. And you accept that claim uncritically.

The question whether the tunnel collapsed on its own or due to the Israeli airstrikes on the tunnels is irrelevant for establishing which precedes which. It's that cause and effect thing again.

It's not irrelevant if the Israeli airstrikes which supposedly hit the tunnel never actually happened.

Quote one and prove it.

That's already been done multiple times on this thread. One more time won't convince you.


:bunpan

[I'll even explain this one to you: you yourself just asked me about my disdain for something]

I didn't ask you what you had disdain for. I asked if disdain was all you were trying to express. I don't care about your disdain, but I was mildly curious if you were trying to express anything more than that.

I already did when I first posted the link, I suggest you actually read it. The airstrikes (July 6) precede the Hamas rocket attacks (July 7), and this is not "claimed by Hamas" but by Haaretz which sources it to an IDF spokesman.

I think I get the game you're playing now. Rocket attacks from Gaza against Israel were ongoing even before this. When such attacks were met with Israeli retaliation, Hamas officially started launching attacks against Israel. You want to blame it all on Israel because the prior attacks weren't officially Hamas attacks, as if other attacks simply don't matter. Yeah, doesn't work that way.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom