*sigh* Very well. That very much shortened version can qualify as a genetic fallacy, if you ignore the rest of the preceding information and points. Moving on.
Because that's the land Israel laid claim to as it declared statehood. Meaning it declared that was the territory its laws applied to.
So, you're changing your claim to one where you're claiming that the progression is mislabeled for the intent. In short, you're still admitting that the progression that you showed is distinctly flawed, at best.
It is the same criterium being used.
Again, not according to the progression itself, no matter how much you try to squirm.
They don't have to be a country to be a people, and hence having the right to self-determination.
While that may well be true, that doesn't affect the veracity of the actual point that had been made, nor does it make your response any less irrelevant, as it was made. It is certainly true that you could have even tried to work the picture into a valid and meaningful response that would also not have provoked anywhere near the controversy that it did. You didn't, instead opting for an irrelevant gotcha attempt.
The claims about it have been much more misleading than the maps are.
Some, perhaps.
The first claim that it should show land owned by neither in a different colour leads one to think that Israel has been building new settlements in previously unclaimed land, thereby getting relatively more land. The reality is that Israel has been building new settlements on top of the Palestinian privately owned land.
That complaint is somewhat bewildering. If Israel would be taking the Palestinian's privately owned land, rather than land owned by neither, the picture would reflect that directly in such a case, meaning that the case that Palestinians were losing land (for strongly implied nefarious reasons) would be strengthened if it validly and directly showed such, rather than what it does.
Separately, yes, I've read of a case or two of Israel kicking out Palestinians from their homes and co-opted their homes for their settling, at last check.
The second claim is something about some Palestinians getting Israeli citizenship. This leads one to think that the progression is because the people changed from being "Palestinian" to "Arab-Israeli". So person X inhabits land plot A and X gets counted as "Palestinian" first and then as "Israeli", making A go from green to white. The reality is that X found himself in a refugee camp in another country after a civil war, and his land plot A was hence vacant. Israel, at that point controlling the region where A is located, then passed a law preventing the return of X to A. It then passed another law stating that properties for which the owner could not present himself by a specific date would belong to the state of Israel. It noticed that X was not present at A on that date so A now belongs to the state of Israel, which it usually builds a new settlement on, and then rents it out to Jewish settlers.
Again, your complaint doesn't work particularly well. By your own admittance, some of the Palestinians *are* officially Israelis and do still own land. Even if it is only about 13-14% of the previous number, going by the numbers you claimed, there should still be patches of green inside Israel, unless you have significant information that you hadn't presented before. Instead, there's none, in part because multiple panels were using criteria that
couldn't show the Palestinian-owned land at the time in Israel or Israeli controlled territory, regardless of whether there was any.
It also misleads in that it fails to mention that the citizenship awarded to Arab Israeli excludes the right to use or occupy their property, which is exactly the topic under discussion.
This is a new claim for you. Just since I'm getting tired of you dancing around, feel free to back it up.
Every claim made about it is not only fairly irrelevant but misleading on its own. You're ignoring that even if you think a different criterium should be used for unowned land, the criterium is still being applied consistently throughout all maps, contrary to your claims.
Except that you've consistently failed to back that up properly. Of course, my direct issues with it have far more to do with the usage of it that I've seen you and others engage than the specific issues with accuracy, given that it's consistently used in a rather context free and irrelevant way to what it's used in response to.
Even if you restrict the green to Palestinians' land and white to Jewish/Israeli land and use something like blue for unowned land, you'd still see the green parts becoming white, with next to no change for the blue parts.
And that could support the case that you've been pushing far better than what you actually used. So why not use better arguments preferentially?
Only if you completely ignored what I said. You seem to do that a fair bit, though.
P: There exist political resolutions.
Q: These resolutions exist.
R: These resolutions are political.
(P AND Q) -> R?
No. But then, you've been making distinct efforts to ignore or misrepresent what's been said, so I'm not surprised that you're trying this. At this point, I cannot reasonably consider your failure to understand on this to be anything other than trolling, so I will cease responding to it.
Ok, the answer to your original question is no.
Alright.
Ok, the Khmer Rouge and general observation that political resolutions exist are used to argue that the UN is unreliable on this issue. First of all this fails to makes the distinction between the general assembly and the security council, but more importantly fails to mention that some of the determinations in the resolutions have also been reached by many other institutions such as the ICJ. But then after "the UN is bought for" point that I will fail to address we'll have "but it's a kangaroo court" point that I'll also fail to address.
Incidentally, it may be worth repeating, yet again, that there's been no argument that Israel has, in fact, broken international law when it has found reason to do so and that the UN has fairly certainly correctly identified at least some of the violations. The relevant claim when it comes to raw numbers, though, is that Israel has received significantly more attention from quite a few countries who have actively sought to condemn them for whatever they think they can get away with condemning them for and that no other country receives similar levels of attention and treatment. The "UN is bought for" and "but it's a kangaroo court" are not claims that I had any intention to use, though there have, in fact, been kangaroo courts used to condemn Israel. Likely the Palestinians, too.