Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Well, no. If Wildcat answers regarding Fatah, or if I decide to bother later with another post, then you will have a full answer, even though no single post contains it.

I already know the answer.

And it makes no sense to prefer no answer to a partial answer, even if a partial answer does not satisfy.

I am not preferring no answer to a partial answer, I'm just not preferring a partial answer for Hamas to no answer.

Here is how it makes sense:

The claim is made that the Palestinian people are evil. Evidence is them "repeatedly and by large majority electing parties that openly espouse genocide". If this were true then it would still not mean that Palestinians vote for them because they openly espouse genocide, but at least there would be some claim here.

So is it true? Elections are about 50-50 between Hamas and Fatah, sometimes one winning and sometimes the other. Both have to openly espouse genocide for that claim to be true.

When you asked Wildcat to show that Hamas openly espoused genocide.

I asked him/her to show both, a point which you continuously fail to notice.

This question may not amount to denying that Hamas openly espoused genocide, but it sure as hell isn't conceding that they did.

It isn't conceding that "repeatedly and by large majority voting for parties openly espousing genocide" is accurate for saying the Palestinian people are evil.

Also, I am free to ask for evidence for any claim made.

But I'm glad that we're now in agreement: Hamas openly espouses genocide.

We never were in disagreement on that point. Stop pretending as if you've won some kind of argument.
 
I am not preferring no answer to a partial answer, I'm just not preferring a partial answer for Hamas to no answer.

What is this I don't even....

The claim is made that the Palestinian people are evil. Evidence is them "repeatedly and by large majority electing parties that openly espouse genocide". If this were true then it would still not mean that Palestinians vote for them because they openly espouse genocide, but at least there would be some claim here.

But Wildcat didn't say they were elected because they espoused genocide, so this is a straw man. And you seem to be suggesting that voting for a party that espouses genocide because you like their position on sugar tariffs or some such is somehow acceptable. Because if you're NOT saying this, then your straw man is completely irrelevant.

So is it true? Elections are about 50-50 between Hamas and Fatah, sometimes one winning and sometimes the other. Both have to openly espouse genocide for that claim to be true.

Yes. And because I've proven that Hamas openly espouses genocide (you didn't ask only about Fatah), less work remains to be done to determine the truth of the claim.

I asked him/her to show both, a point which you continuously fail to notice.

I haven't failed to notice at all. But so what?

Also, I am free to ask for evidence for any claim made.

Yes, you are. And when you do so, I am free to conclude that you are probably unconvinced of the truth of the claim.

We never were in disagreement on that point. Stop pretending as if you've won some kind of argument.

Whether or not you ever disagreed, it was only after my challenge that you actually stated your position on the matter. And that has accomplished something.
 
I'm showing that it got elected on the basis of an anti-occupation platform rather than a genocidal one.

By quoting a carefully selected segment of it's charter?

Frankly, I doubt present-day Hamas maintains any serious genocidal ambitions.
 
What is this I don't even....

no answer = partial Hamas < partial Fatah = both

And you seem to be suggesting that voting for a party that espouses genocide because you like their position on sugar tariffs or some such is somehow acceptable.

Did you know that a solid majority of Palestinians is opposed to military operations against Israeli targets?

Yes. And because I've proven that Hamas openly espouses genocide (you didn't ask only about Fatah), less work remains to be done to determine the truth of the claim.

I'm waiting.
 
no answer = partial Hamas < partial Fatah = both

So in other words, you only ever wanted to know about Fatah. In which case, well, you should have saved everyone some time and only asked about Fatah. But you didn't. Who knows why.

Did you know that a solid majority of Palestinians is opposed to military operations against Israeli targets?

Do you think maybe the fact that Israel retaliates against attacks might have something to do with this?

I'm waiting.

Yes, you are.
 
The point of which quoting it would be to challenge the assertion of genocidal character...exactly as I said.

It is to challenge the implicit assumption that the genocidal thing holds for the Palestinian population based on specific quotes of Hamas' charter, when other specific quotes of its charter contradict it and its electoral platform (which it got elected on) doesn't mention any of it.
 
So in other words, you only ever wanted to know about Fatah. In which case, well, you should have saved everyone some time and only asked about Fatah. But you didn't. Who knows why.

I asked for both for obvious reasons (both were used to support he claim)..

Do you think maybe the fact that Israel retaliates against attacks might have something to do with this?

Almost nothing to do with it.

Yes, you are.

And in the meantime I'm going to classify the claim as being false.
 
Quite sure.

Alright. Bored with this bit of meaningless back and forth.

In as much as that is a fact rather than your opinion, it is also a genetic fallacy.

Nice try.

Here is what is actually being shown in each picture:
If an area is green then it means that there is more Palestinian owned than Jewish/Israeli owned land. If it is white the opposite is true.
In the areas that turned from green to white the following sequence of events has, in general, occurred:
1. There were X Palestinian and Y Jewish/Israeli settlements, X > Y.
2. The Palestinians either fled or were expelled, and A of their settlements taken over.
3. There are now (X - A) Palestinian and (Y + A) Jewish/Israeli settlements, (X - A) < (Y + A)

(Other than the second picture)

As you just admitted, why the second panel, if what you say was what was in mind? And why would the progression itself say that it's using criteria in all the panels that are irrelevant to what you're trying to claim is the case, rather than directly showing the loss of land? Yes, obviously, the Palestinian Arabs control a whole lot less land, one way or another, than they used to control. That can, in fact, be shown just fine without needing to toss in a planned partitioning that the Arabs didn't show the least bit of interest in upholding or by using country borders. That's before noting that you tried to use the progression in response to the point that Palestine wasn't a country, much less an Arab one, which is a remarkably irrelevant use of it, on top of the other problems.

I've asked you to support that opinion with facts, you just repeat it.

It's been supported just fine, previously. That you're trying to ignore that, while already admitting that even your claimed proper interpretation doesn't quite work really should be good reason for you to take a step back and rethink your position.


Care to present an example?

Like what the response to -

The state of Israel seized the property of the Palestinian refugees (about 80% of the pre-exodus Palestinian population in Israel) and passed a law preventing the return of the refugees. These properties were then destroyed and/or given to Jewish settlers. Of the about 20% of Palestinians remaining inside Israel, about a third were declared "Present Absentees", who technically still own the property but the state of Israel holds all ownership rights.

Was?



I never considered it relevant, nor did I ever have to. I can find it relevant that you're providing rationalizations rather than facts without finding your specific world-view relevant.

Nice try, but that logic doesn't work. To be rationalizing my world view, my world view would actually have to be such that rationalization was required for the facts in question, which in turn makes what the world view actually is relevant. It wasn't challenged at all, though. Separately from that, your argument was simply deeply flawed in multiple ways. Not necessarily fatally flawed for the specific argument that you were making at that moment, but its irrelevance to everything preceding it is a fatal flaw with how it was used. That the resolutions that you cited were made for political reasons instead of legal or moral reasons and were demonstrably inconsistently applied from country to country is a serious flaw for the immediate argument, though.



What is? Your errors in logic?

Bored with this sad attempt at a cheap shot.

Have you stopped beating your wife?

I most surely can take you to task for establishing the implicit statement in a loaded question before answering it.

You could try. You also could have made any attempt to address the issue instead of trying to change the subject, yet again, though. Feel free to point out what compelling reason you have to think that I was wrong, either way. Chances seem really good that you won't, sadly.


This is something I consider amusing given your problems with the panel and the comparisons made in my first post.

And yet, you completely fail to address the points actually made, yet again. Seems par for the course with you, unfortunately. If you were actually interested in a serious and honest discussion, I suspect that it could probably get interesting. You haven't been showing much sign of wanting such, though, so I may stop responding to you sometime soon because of the difficulties that you've been having there.

That's quite reasonable.

Thank you.
 
Last edited:
I asked for both for obvious reasons (both were used to support he claim)..

No, the obvious reason to ask for both is because you were unconvinced of both. If you were convinced of one but not the other, then the obvious thing to do is ask about the one you're not convinced of.

Almost nothing to do with it.

Well, you're wrong, it's got everything to do with it.

And in the meantime I'm going to classify the claim as being false.

I'm sure Wildcat will be all broken up about your classification.
 
Incidentally, on a quick search with the words "Fatah" and "genocide," it wasn't hard to find articles relating to such.

http://www.algemeiner.com/2015/01/01/abbass-fatah-movement-marks-fiftieth-anniversary-with-image-inciting-genocide-against-israelis/

Barely 24 hours after the Palestinian Authority submitted its application to join the International Criminal Court (ICC,) the Fatah movement of PA President Mahmoud Abbas has published a gruesome image on its Facebook page inciting genocide against Israeli Jews.

The image, by Arab artist Ali Faour, was published to coincide with the fiftieth anniversary of Fatah’s founding on the terrorist organization’s Facebook page. The anniversary was celebrated at a ceremony in Ramallah on Wednesday morning, the Palestinian Ma’an news agency reported.

Faour’s image shows a Fatah flag attached to a gun emerging from a pile of skulls, several of which are marked with a Star of David. The image conjures up memories of the corpses which Nazi execution squads dumped into mass graves during the Holocaust.

Palestinian Media Watch (PMW,) an Israeli monitoring group, noted that incitement against Israel’s very existence has been a key theme in Fatah’s celebration of its anniversary. “Central to the visual images is the map of ‘Palestine,’ used by both the Palestinian Authority and Fatah, which includes both the PA areas and all of Israel, thus denying Israel’s existence in any borders,” the group said.

http://www.gatestoneinstitute.org/2759/fatah-religious-authority-genocide

Last week, the principal Palestinian Authority religious leader, the Mufti Muhammad Hussein, presented the killing of Jews by Muslims as a religious Islamic goal. At an event celebrating the 47th anniversary of the founding of Fatah, he cited the Hadith (Islamic tradition attributed to Muhammad) saying that the Hour of Resurrection will not come until Muslims fight the Jews and kill them:

"The Hour [of Resurrection] will not come until you fight the Jews.

The Jew will hide behind stones or trees.

Then the stones or trees will call:

'Oh Muslim, servant of Allah, there is a Jew behind me, come and kill him.'"

Click to view

Palestinian Media Watch reported regularly during the PA terror campaign (Intifada, 2000-2005) on the repeated use of this Hadith by PA clerics on official PA TV to motivate Palestinians to terror attacks, preaching that Muslims had an Islamic obligation to kill Jews. The fact that the Mufti quotes this now indicates that this may have remained part of the PA's religious establishment's teachings, even though it is less frequently promoted on PA TV.

The last time official PA TV broadcast a sermon during which this Hadith calling to kill Jews was quoted was in 2010.

The years of PA promotion of killing Jews and PA religious leaders' citing this Hadith to justify it, may have contributed to the high acceptance of it in PA society. A poll sponsored by the Israel Project last year found that 73% of Palestinians "believe" this Hadith. [July 2011, Greenberg Quinlan Rosner.]

I could likely find better without much issue and have seen better, but Fatah hasn't really shown that they're particularly interested in a peaceful coexistence either. Closer than Hamas, though, however marginally, and I don't recall any stories of them brutally slaughtering Arab civilians for absurdly terrible reasons off the top of my head, unlike Hamas, which is a small point in their favor.
 
Last edited:
It is to challenge the implicit assumption that the genocidal thing holds for the Palestinian population based on specific quotes of Hamas' charter, when other specific quotes of its charter contradict it and its electoral platform (which it got elected on) doesn't mention any of it.

The "Palestinian people" combed a lengthy charter full of genocidal references and militant anti-Jewish racist sentiment, cherry picked some lonely, barely mumbled words on "tolerance" and concluded Hamas wasn't really genocidal? I don't think so.
 
Nice try.

It's still true.

As you just admitted, why the second panel, if what you say what was in mind?

Because that's the land Israel laid claim to as it declared statehood. Meaning it declared that was the territory its laws applied to.

And why would the progression itself use say that it's using criteria in all the panels that is irrelevant to what you're trying to claim is the case, rather than directly showing the loss of land?

It is the same criterium being used.

That's before noting that you tried to use the progression in response to the point that Palestine wasn't a country, much less an Arab one, which is a remarkably irrelevant use of it, on top of the other problems.

They don't have to be a country to be a people, and hence having the right to self-determination.

It's been supported just fine, previously.

The claims about it have been much more misleading than the maps are.

The first claim that it should show land owned by neither in a different colour leads one to think that Israel has been building new settlements in previously unclaimed land, thereby getting relatively more land. The reality is that Israel has been building new settlements on top of the Palestinian privately owned land.

The second claim is something about some Palestinians getting Israeli citizenship. This leads one to think that the progression is because the people changed from being "Palestinian" to "Arab-Israeli". So person X inhabits land plot A and X gets counted as "Palestinian" first and then as "Israeli", making A go from green to white. The reality is that X found himself in a refugee camp in another country after a civil war, and his land plot A was hence vacant. Israel, at that point controlling the region where A is located, then passed a law preventing the return of X to A. It then passed another law stating that properties for which the owner could not present himself by a specific date would belong to the state of Israel. It noticed that X was not present at A on that date so A now belongs to the state of Israel, which it usually builds a new settlement on, and then rents it out to Jewish settlers.

It also misleads in that it fails to mention that the citizenship awarded to Arab Israeli excludes the right to use or occupy their property, which is exactly the topic under discussion.

That you're trying to ignore that

Every claim made about it is not only fairly irrelevant but misleading on its own. You're ignoring that even if you think a different criterium should be used for unowned land, the criterium is still being applied consistently throughout all maps, contrary to your claims.

Even if you restrict the green to Palestinians' land and white to Jewish/Israeli land and use something like blue for unowned land, you'd still see the green parts becoming white, with next to no change for the blue parts.

Like what the response to -

Was?

There was none.

That the resolutions that you cited were made for political reasons instead of legal or moral reasons and were demonstrably inconsistently applied from country to country is a serious flaw for the immediate argument, though.

P: There exist political resolutions.
Q: These resolutions exist.
R: These resolutions are political.

(P AND Q) -> R?

You also could have make any attempt to address the issue instead of trying to change the subject, yet again, though.

Ok, the answer to your original question is no.

And yet, you completely fail to address the points actually made, yet again.

Ok, the Khmer Rouge and general observation that political resolutions exist are used to argue that the UN is unreliable on this issue. First of all this fails to makes the distinction between the general assembly and the security council, but more importantly fails to mention that some of the determinations in the resolutions have also been reached by many other institutions such as the ICJ. But then after "the UN is bought for" point that I will fail to address we'll have "but it's a kangaroo court" point that I'll also fail to address.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom