Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
As Wildcat already alluded to, the border controls which made exporting good difficult (which, it should be noted, were also imposed by Egypt) were a direct result of Hamas' terrorist attacks against Israel.

The residents of Gaza were given an opportunity, and they pissed it all away.

I think A'isha's version of the greenhouse transfers has been well established. The story promulgated that the Gazans alone pissed away the tremendous economic potential of that advanced technology is incomplete and essentially false.
 
You said they were destroyed.

So you feel this word overstates the damage done to the greenhouses. But you don't contest that looting took place, and that this looting made some of the greenhouses inoperable, at least for a period of time.

And within a few months they were up and running and producing exportable goods.

And then what happened?

You can quibble all you want to about how I characterized events, but even your own links back up my basic point: the Palestinians are the architects of their own misery. They were given an opportunity by Israel, and they squandered it in pursuit of their quest to kill more Jews. Israel has no incentive to repeat that process on a larger scale in the West Bank.
 
I think A'isha's version of the greenhouse transfers has been well established. The story promulgated that the Gazans alone pissed away the tremendous economic potential of that advanced technology is incomplete and essentially false.

I never said anything about "advanced technology", nor did I ever categorize the opportunity as "tremendous". So you are (ironically) giving an "essentially false" representation of my argument. But it was an opportunity, they pretty much DID piss it away on their own, and A'isha's links don't actually contradict that.
 
So you feel this word overstates the damage done to the greenhouses.

Yes, because they weren't destroyed. That is what's known as a "lie", Ziggurat.

But you don't contest that looting took place, and that this looting made some of the greenhouses inoperable, at least for a period of time.

A period of time covering something like two months, after which 60-80% of the greenhouse acreage left behind by the Israelis were back in operation by the Palestinians.

And then what happened?

almost all the food the Palestinians were growing was unable to be sold for export because the border crossing was closed.

You can quibble all you want to about how I characterized events, but even your own links back up my basic point: the Palestinians are the architects of their own misery. They were given an opportunity by Israel, and they squandered it in pursuit of their quest to kill more Jews. Israel has no incentive to repeat that process on a larger scale in the West Bank.

If that "basic point" was all you were trying to get across, then why the need to falsely characterize events as worse than they actually were?

You're no better than caveman1917 and his maps in that regard.
 
And why was it closed, A'isha?

2/27/06:

As part of the deal brokered by Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice in November, the Karni crossing was to remain open as much as possible to allow for Palestinian exports from Gaza - such as the greenhouse produce - to make it to the Israeli and international markets. Closing Karni was only to be ordered by Israel in the event of imminent security threats. However, a series of attempted attacks by Palestinian terrorists near Karni and the discovery of what the IDF thinks may be smuggling tunnels underneath the terminal have prompted the long closures, the IDF said.

3/9/06:

The Israel Defense Forces confirmed that the head of the Southern Command, Yoav Galant, and Aviv Kochavi, commander of the Gaza Division, recently recommended the reopening of Karni and said there was no security-related reason for its closure. But Defense Minister Shaul Mofaz ordered the closure to continue.

Several different reasons have been given for the closure, including the upcoming Israeli elections and the recent Hamas victory in the PA elections.

7/19/07:

The Karni crossing has been shut since June 12 because the Palestinians who operated it were affiliated with Fatah and fled after Hamas took over Gaza in bloody fighting. But both Israel and the Fatah leader, President Mahmoud Abbas, have been in no hurry to help Hamas by working to regularize Gaza’s economic life.

[...]

In security terms, bringing items into Gaza is not a big problem for Israel. Exports are a different matter. Without Karni, with its sophisticated scanners, every item would have to be gone over carefully, if not by hand then with smaller scanners, to ensure that no explosives or weapons are being smuggled.

Having no Palestinians on the Gaza side of Karni whom Israel trusts has so far been an insurmountable problem for exports. Israel refuses to have any relationship with Hamas. Hamas has offered to bring Fatah back to Karni or to hire a Turkish company to operate the Palestinian side, but Israel says the Palestinians must resolve that issue.

For now political considerations seem most important, with Mr. Abbas trying to consolidate the West Bank with the help of Israel and the United States. Asked if Israel and Egypt were keeping Karni and the Rafah crossing from Egypt shut in part because Mr. Abbas asked them to, Miri Eisin, the spokeswoman for Prime Minister Ehud Olmert of Israel, said: “Our clear-cut policy is to do it in coordination with President Abbas. We’re not doing anything Abbas opposes, and we’ve opposed nothing he’s asked us to do. We both agree on the complete sidelining of Hamas.”

EDIT: It looks to me like the farmers in Gaza got caught between Hamas and Israel on one side, and Hamas and Fatah on the other. Lumping all this together as "the Palestinians", as if they were some single entity or collective hive mind or something, is just as false as the story that the greenhouses were "destroyed".
 
Last edited:
I never said anything about "advanced technology", nor did I ever categorize the opportunity as "tremendous". So you are (ironically) giving an "essentially false" representation of my argument. But it was an opportunity, they pretty much DID piss it away on their own, and A'isha's links don't actually contradict that.

I never said you mentioned anything about advanced technology or tremendous economic opportunity. I mentioned those terms, because I believe they accurately describe the amazing accomplishment represented by the Gush Katif greenhouse complex. I wasn't being sarcastic.

I agree that those greenhouses represented a vital opportunity for the Gazan economy. I disagree that the Gazans pretty much pissed it away on their own. There were forces on both sides contributing to that particular tragedy.
 
What a fun thread....


Palestinians are just EEEEEEEvil, thats the whole issue in a nutshell.


Looks like Palestinians are the new JOOOOOS for racists seeking a new target.
 
What a fun thread....


Palestinians are just EEEEEEEvil, thats the whole issue in a nutshell.


Looks like Palestinians are the new JOOOOOS for racists seeking a new target.

From what I see on Stormfront, many racists seem to be sticking with ol' reliable.
 
From what I see on Stormfront, many racists seem to be sticking with ol' reliable.

Absolutely. Its difficult for thick people to change direction.

Anyway..... Back to the Evil Palestinians.

Maybe I can ask Zig and Wildcat to suggest what is to be done with these Evil people? What have we done with Evil people in the Past?
 
Absolutely. Its difficult for thick people to change direction.

Anyway..... Back to the Evil Palestinians.

Maybe I can ask Zig and Wildcat to suggest what is to be done with these Evil people?

For the most part, nothing.

Oooo, I bet I sound just like a Nazi, don't I!

What have we done with Evil people in the Past?

Who do you presume is the "we" in this question? And why should I care what this "we" has done in the past?
 
You've left out the second part, show that both of those organizations "openly espouse genocide".

Hamas is easy, it's in their charter.

A few choice quotes:

"Israel will rise and will remain erect until Islam eliminates it as it had eliminated its predecessors."

"[Peace] initiatives, the so-called peaceful solutions, and the international conferences to resolve the Palestinian problem, are all contrary to the beliefs of the Islamic Resistance Movement."

"The prophet, prayer and peace be upon him, said: The time will not come until Muslims will fight the Jews (and kill them); until the Jews hide behind rocks and trees, which will cry: O Muslim! there is a Jew hiding behind me, come on and kill him!"

"Israel, by virtue of its being Jewish and of having a Jewish population, defies Islam and the Muslims."

But I've saved my favorite for last. It's not really about genocide, but it gives you some insight into how bat-***********-**** crazy Hamas really is:

"The Muslim women have a no lesser role than that of men in the war of liberation; they manufacture men and play a great role in guiding and educating the [new] generation. The enemies have understood that role, therefore they realize that if they can guide and educate [the Muslim women] in a way that would distance them from Islam, they would have won that war. Therefore, you can see them making consistent efforts [in that direction] by way of publicity and movies, curricula of education and culture, using as their intermediaries their craftsmen who are part of the various Zionist Organizations which take on all sorts of names and shapes such as: the Freemasons, Rotary Clubs, gangs of spies and the like. All of them are nests of saboteurs and sabotage."

I get the whole Freemasons thing. That's been a mainstay of conspiracy theorists since pretty much forever. But Rotary Clubs? They're scared of the threat from Rotary Clubs? Yeah, these people are nuts.

Enjoy their company, caveman.
 
Did I not say both?

You also asked Wildcat, not me. Should that have stopped me? I provided a partial answer. Do you prefer no answer at all to a partial answer? Why?

And do you concede the point that Hamas has genocidal ambitions? Or will you continue to bury your head in the sand with your fingers in your ears?
 
If the Israeli peace process is to work, respect must be shown by each side for the other. It's just like this thread. Bickering, insults, unfair characterizations, and incivility will cause this thread to fail. So, in the words of William Jefferson Clinton, knock it off. Disagree without being disagreeable and show some basic courtesy to each other.

Further breaches of Rules 0, 12 and/or any other rule will result in unpleasant UN sanctions Moderator action. Thank you.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Loss Leader
 
It is no answer at all unless it's both, that's the point.

Well, no. If Wildcat answers regarding Fatah, or if I decide to bother later with another post, then you will have a full answer, even though no single post contains it.

And it makes no sense to prefer no answer to a partial answer, even if a partial answer does not satisfy.

Yes. Did I ever not?

When you asked Wildcat to show that Hamas openly espoused genocide. This question may not amount to denying that Hamas openly espoused genocide, but it sure as hell isn't conceding that they did. But I'm glad that we're now in agreement: Hamas openly espouses genocide.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom