Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
1) 1948 was initiated by the Arab League as a War of Extermination

The British withdrew during a civil war. Israel declared statehood within this war, and then the surrounding powers intervened in it.

1967 was to stop Egypt and Syria from trying to attack them

Israel attacked Egypt.

while Yom Kippur was started by the Arab League as a last gasp in destroying Israel

Syria and Egypt attacked Israel.

So that's 1.5 out of 3

Are these 3 the only military engagements Israel has performed?

"who fired first" in that situation is an academic matter

It is also a fact. Whether it was right or wrong is an opinion.

3) 3379 was passed during the cold war, and the USSR was seeking to curry favour with the Arab Powers, and the COSATU were seeking to curry favour with the Soviet Union in turn due to the fact that Apartheid Era South Africa was in the Western Camp.

A determination made in 2008 is explained as caused by seeking to curry favour with the Soviet Union?

4) It is Relevant because 3379 was passed after Phnom Penh, yet there were very few resolutions condemning the Khmer Rouge in comparison to Israel, who is seen as the devil of the Middle East.

There is one variable (Israel's failure to comply with UN resolutions) that stays constant as you turn another (UN resolution considering Zionism as inherently racist) on and then off again. Your case for relevance of either that resolution or the Khmer Rouge is weak at best.
 
It worked for Israel. When it declared statehood it changed from throwing homemade bombs at markets to using real military forces.

There's a superficial similarity in methods, but a rather critical difference in goals. Israel never aspired to genocide. Hamas does. Giving Hamas statehood will not change its aspirations.
 
They're just an evil people, aren't they?
I can't speak for anyone else, but IMHO a people that repeatedly and by overwhelming margins elects political parties into power which openly espouse genocide are, in fact, evil.

You may have a different definition of evil than I do.
 
The British withdrew during a civil war. Israel declared statehood within this war, and then the surrounding powers intervened in it.

Largely because Britain had made a binding promise to both the Arabs and the Jews for their homeland in the Middle East if they helped the British fight the dying Ottoman Empire.

Israel attacked Egypt.

Who were about to attack them. I know Iraq **** the bed on this, but Pre-emptive strikes can be legal.

Are these 3 the only military engagements Israel has performed?

Barring Suez (and Israel had accomplices in Britain and France), these were the only major campaigns Israel undertook until 1975.

It is also a fact. Whether it was right or wrong is an opinion.

Courts recognise "imminent danger" as a valid defence.

A determination made in 2008 is explained as caused by seeking to curry favour with the Soviet Union?

A lot of the COSATU political machinery was established with Soviet help during the Cold War, so the higher ups are going to have an anti-Israel bias, even after 1991.

There is one variable (Israel's failure to comply with UN resolutions) that stays constant as you turn another (UN resolution considering Zionism as inherently racist) on and then off again. Your case for relevance of either that resolution or the Khmer Rouge is weak at best.

My comparison was to show why Israel lost faith in the UN (getting all the flak for fighting to survive, while the Khmer Rouge were behaving far worse and not getting anywhere near as much condemnation.
 
Last edited:
Perhaps there's consequences for electing to power a genocidal terrorist group which then proceeds to launch thousands of missiles at civilian targets in Israel?

I know that's a difficult concept for the Israel-bashers to understand, apparently the Palestinians should be allowed to attack Israel with impunity and Israel is obligated to assist the Gazan economy so they have more resources to devote to their genocidal aspirations.
 
There's a superficial similarity in methods, but a rather critical difference in goals. Israel never aspired to genocide. Hamas does. Giving Hamas statehood will not change its aspirations.

Article 33 of its Charter
Under the wing of Islam, it is possible for the followers of the three religions—Islam, Christianity and Judaism—to coexist in peace and quiet with each other.

Its electoral platform
True Islam with its civilized achievements and political, economic, social, and legal aspects is our frame of reference and our way of life.
Historic Palestine is part of the Arab and Islamic land and its ownership by the Palestinian people is a right that does not diminish over time. No military or legal measures will change that right.
The Palestinian people, wherever they reside, constitute a single and united people and form an integral part of the Arab and Muslim nation ... [Quranic verse]. Our Palestinian people are still living a phase of national liberation, and thus they have the right to strive to recover their own rights and end the occupation using all means, including armed struggle. We have to make all our resources available to support our people and defeat the occupation and establish a Palestinian state with Jerusalem as its capital.
The right of return of all Palestinian refugees and displaced persons to their land and properties, and the right to self-determination and all other national rights, are inalienable and cannot be bargained away for any political concessions.
We uphold the indigenous and inalienable rights of our people to our land, Jerusalem, our holy places, our water resources, borders, and a fully sovereign independent Palestinian state with Jerusalem as its capital.
Reinforcing and protecting Palestinian national unity is one of the priorities of the Palestinian national action.
The issue of the prisoners is at the top of the Palestinian agenda.
 
Perhaps there's consequences for electing to power a genocidal terrorist group which then proceeds to launch thousands of missiles at civilian targets in Israel?

Yes, indeed there is.

I know that's a difficult concept for the Israel-bashers to understand

I hope you're not refering to me, here. Otherwise you have a tendency to mistake me for someone else.

apparently the Palestinians should be allowed to attack Israel with impunity and Israel is obligated to assist the Gazan economy so they have more resources to devote to their genocidal aspirations.

Strawman.
 
Barring Suez (and Israel had accomplices in Britain and France), these were the only major campaigns Israel undertook until 1975.

But there were many more "minor" ones. Could you provide the full list, as well as who attacked who each time, to provide some basis for your claims that Israel just stands there as the Arabs attack repeatedly.
 
I just wondered if you had any comments on Aisha's links.

As Wildcat already alluded to, the border controls which made exporting good difficult (which, it should be noted, were also imposed by Egypt) were a direct result of Hamas' terrorist attacks against Israel.

The residents of Gaza were given an opportunity, and they pissed it all away.
 
As Wildcat already alluded to, the border controls which made exporting good difficult (which, it should be noted, were also imposed by Egypt) were a direct result of Hamas' terrorist attacks against Israel.

The residents of Gaza were given an opportunity, and they pissed it all away.

"The Palestinians initially successfully operated the farms that the Israelis left them, but the owners were unable to earn enough income to keep them open when extended border closings caused by security concerns due to Hamas attacks prevented the produce from being exported for sale and so the farms ceased operation after several years" isn't anywhere close to "[The Israelis] left behind functioning farms, too, providing an opportunity for Palestinians to use those farms to earn income. The Palestinians destroyed the farms, then engaged in increased rocket attacks against Israel."

Caveman1917's maps were misleading enough to border on falsehood. Your statement was simply straight-up ********. It's not even original ********, either:

http://www.washingtonpost.com/opini...dabe0c-0de4-11e4-8c9a-923ecc0c7d23_story.html

And there was no blockade. On the contrary. Israel wanted this new Palestinian state to succeed. To help the Gaza economy, Israel gave the Palestinians its 3,000 greenhouses that had produced fruit and flowers for export. It opened border crossings and encouraged commerce.

[...]

And how did the Gaza Palestinians react to being granted by the Israelis what no previous ruler, neither Egyptian, nor British, nor Turkish, had ever given them — an independent territory? First, they demolished the greenhouses. Then they elected Hamas.

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/richard-z-chesnoff/gaza-and-palestinian-leadership_b_5589766.html

In August, 2005, almost 32 years later, I was there when Israeli Premier Ariel Sharon, finally withdrew Israel's troops from Gaza and evacuated Israeli settlers from the rich fruit and vegetable producing settlements they had established along the strip. The corrupt Palestinian Authority took over full control of Gaza. Even the network of miraculously flourishing greenhouses that Israeli settlers had built became Palestinian, something Israel hoped would help convince the Gaza leadership to keep peaceful borders with the Jewish state.

That didn't happen. The chain of greenhouses was soon looted and all but completely destroyed.

http://www.theatlantic.com/internat...what-exactly-is-hamas-trying-to-prove/374342/

In 2005, the Palestinians of Gaza, free from their Israeli occupiers, could have taken a lesson from the Kurds—and from David Ben-Gurion, the principal Israeli state-builder—and created the necessary infrastructure for eventual freedom. Gaza is centrally located between two large economies, those of Israel and Egypt. Europe is just across the Mediterranean. Gaza could have easily attracted untold billions in economic aid.

The Israelis did not impose a blockade on Gaza right away. That came later, when it became clear that Palestinian groups were considering using their newly liberated territory as a launching pad for attacks. In the days after withdrawal, the Israelis encouraged Gaza’s development. A group of American Jewish donors paid $14 million for 3,000 greenhouses left behind by expelled Jewish settlers and donated them to the Palestinian Authority. The greenhouses were soon looted and destroyed, serving, until today, as a perfect metaphor for Gaza’s wasted opportunity.

http://tabletmag.com/jewish-news-and-politics/187071/land-for-death

If only Ariel Sharon’s 2005 disengagement from Gaza had led to the peace and co-existence between Israel and Gazans that the international community’s peace advocates promised! If only the greenhouses left by Israeli settlers had became the foundation for Gazan agriculture, producing world famous oranges and tomatoes, prized by Brooklyn’s top chefs! But that’s not what happened. Palestinians laid waste to the greenhouses.
 
"The Palestinians initially successfully operated the farms that the Israelis left them, but the owners were unable to earn enough income to keep them open when extended border closings caused by security concerns due to Hamas attacks prevented the produce from being exported for sale and so the farms ceased operation after several years" isn't anywhere close to "[The Israelis] left behind functioning farms, too, providing an opportunity for Palestinians to use those farms to earn income. The Palestinians destroyed the farms, then engaged in increased rocket attacks against Israel."

First, I didn't say all the farms were functioning, but some were. And your own links show that they were heavily looted, including of critical parts (like water pumps) absolutely necessary to keep them functioning. And the bit about rocket attacks? Well, you just confirmed that too. So what, exactly, are you saying is wrong about what I said?

Caveman1917's maps were misleading enough to border on falsehood. Your statement was simply straight-up ********. It's not even original ********, either:

Usually, when you're trying to disprove someone, you link to sources which contradict what the poster you're trying to disprove said.

But you've taken a novel approach. Quite bold, even.
 
First, I didn't say all the farms were functioning, but some were.

You said they were destroyed.

And your own links show that they were heavily looted, including of critical parts (like water pumps) absolutely necessary to keep them functioning.

And within a few months they were up and running and producing exportable goods.

And the bit about rocket attacks? Well, you just confirmed that too. So what, exactly, are you saying is wrong about what I said?

The part where you said the Palestinians destroyed them rather than use them to try and create a functioning economy.

Usually, when you're trying to disprove someone, you link to sources which contradict what the poster you're trying to disprove said.

The difference is that all the sources containing the false assertion that you parroted were opinion pieces from mostly right-wing hacks like Charles Krauthammer, published years after the fact. While the sources which show that assertion to be false are from actual news articles from when the events themselves actually happened.

You do know the difference between opinion pieces and actual news, right?
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom