Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Your question is vague.

Yet you never objected to the vagueness before. So I do not honestly believe that this was your objection, I think you're just searching for excuses.

Pull out when, at what date ?

Israel only pulled out of Gaza once, in August 2005. Did you not know this?

Why don't you save us both some time and give us the answer.

If saving trouble was my only objective, I'd simply stop posting.

And why don't you save us both some time and either answer my question or admit that you don't know the answer. Why is it so hard to admit that you don't know?

By the same token you'll prove your superior knowledge and put me in my place, so it's a win-win for you.

Except that since you can pretend you knew all along, that's not really going to be what happens.
 
Yet you never objected to the vagueness before.

I didn't think it was necessary. I assumed you would simply explain the whole deal to me/us so that we could move forward.

Israel only pulled out of Gaza once, in August 2005.

Are we going to do this baby step thing ? Now I have the date but still no answer to your question. Is this how you usually converse ?

If saving trouble was my only objective, I'd simply stop posting.

You flatter me.

And why don't you save us both some time and either answer my question or admit that you don't know the answer. Why is it so hard to admit that you don't know?

I thought that me asking you to educate me WAS an admission that I propably didn't know.
 
I didn't think it was necessary.

It was, if that's what your objection was.

I assumed you would simply explain the whole deal to me/us so that we could move forward.

And how'd that work out for you?

Are we going to do this baby step thing ? Now I have the date but still no answer to your question. Is this how you usually converse ?

If you don't know the answer to a question, do you usually refuse to indicate that you don't know the answer?

I thought that me asking you to educate me WAS an admission that I propably didn't know.

Why would you think that even after multiple instances of me pointing out that you never said you didn't know the answer, and that I was waiting for you to say that you didn't know the answer?

Israel pulled out of Gaza completely in 2005. They left behind functioning farms, too, providing an opportunity for Palestinians to use those farms to earn income.

The Palestinians destroyed the farms, then engaged in increased rocket attacks against Israel.

Is there any reason, and reason at all, to believe that an Israeli withdrawl from the west bank would be met with peace rather than increased hostility?

Since you don't like answering my questions, I'll answer this one too: no, there is no reason to think that at all.
 
And how'd that work out for you?

So-so. I guess I gave you too much credit.

Israel pulled out of Gaza completely in 2005. They left behind functioning farms, too, providing an opportunity for Palestinians to use those farms to earn income.

The Palestinians destroyed the farms, then engaged in increased rocket attacks against Israel.

Is there any reason, and reason at all, to believe that an Israeli withdrawl from the west bank would be met with peace rather than increased hostility?

Depends. The significant difference between that and the scenario I mentioned is that Palestine is now a sovereign state.
 
So-so. I guess I gave you too much credit.

Likewise, I thought you knew, since it's such recent history, hardly obscure, and just about everyone interested in the topic of Israel and Palestinians should know about it. I also thought that when I asked you a question, you would either answer or simply state that you didn't know.

Oh well, no more asking questions of you, I've learned my lesson.

Depends. The significant difference between that and the scenario I mentioned is that Palestine is now a sovereign state.

It's cute that you think that would change how they behave. It wouldn't.
 
Because statehood doesn't change human nature, and the basic incentives would remain the same.

Well that's true, but then they couldn't claim that they were oppressed since they are sovereign. Hamas might still say they want to destroy Israel (which is ridiculous, they are not an existential threat to Israel), but why would regular Palestinians not think "hey, now we've got this land for ourselves, stop shelling our neighbors" ?

If you're saying that such a change is impossible (which I would disagree with because Palestinians are people, not evil monsters), then there is no point in negociating anything, is there ?
 
Well that's true, but then they couldn't claim that they were oppressed since they are sovereign.

That simply doesn't matter. Israel has no reason to give Palestinians an increased ability to kill Israelis, in return for keeping them from claiming oppression (which, honestly, they would still do). There's no benefit there.

Hamas might still say they want to destroy Israel (which is ridiculous, they are not an existential threat to Israel), but why would regular Palestinians not think "hey, now we've got this land for ourselves, stop shelling our neighbors" ?

Two things: first, regular Palestinians are fed a steady diet of disinformation. Second, Hamas doesn't care what regular Palestinians think.

If you're saying that such a change is impossible (which I would disagree with because Palestinians are people, not evil monsters), then there is no point in negociating anything, is there ?

I'm not saying such a change is impossible, only that statehood won't help make it happen. The change must precede statehood. So yes, at the moment, there is no point in negotiating. Maybe there will be in the future, but not now.

I'm sure you're familiar with the old saying that the definition of insanity is repeating the same actions and expecting different results.
 
That simply doesn't matter. Israel has no reason to give Palestinians an increased ability to kill Israelis

Who said anything about that ?

Two things: first, regular Palestinians are fed a steady diet of disinformation.

So are Americans, but I don't rule out change.

Second, Hamas doesn't care what regular Palestinians think.

They might if they come to think different.

I'm not saying such a change is impossible, only that statehood won't help make it happen. The change must precede statehood.

A fair assessment. How do you think such a change could be brought about ?
 
Who said anything about that ?

I did.

A fair assessment. How do you think such a change could be brought about ?

There is only one way I feel confident could produce such a change, and that's extreme violence and mass death. It worked with Germany and Japan, for instance. But I don't think this path is currently justified, and obviously neither does Israel. Absent that, I do not know, except that concessions are sure to fail.
 

Ok, why would that give them an increased ability to kill Israelis ?

There is only one way I feel confident could produce such a change, and that's extreme violence and mass death. It worked with Germany and Japan, for instance. But I don't think this path is currently justified, and obviously neither does Israel. Absent that, I do not know, except that concessions are sure to fail.

Can't say I completely disagree, unfortunately.
 
Israel pulled out of Gaza completely in 2005. They left behind functioning farms, too, providing an opportunity for Palestinians to use those farms to earn income.

The Palestinians destroyed the farms, then engaged in increased rocket attacks against Israel.

Israeli Settlers Demolish Greenhouses and Gaza Jobs, 7/15/05

About half the greenhouses in the Israeli settlements in Gaza have already been dismantled by their owners, who have given up waiting to see if the government was going to come up with extra payment as an inducement to leave them behind, say senior officials working on the coordination of this summer's Israeli pullout from Gaza.

Under international pressure to save what is left for Palestinian economic development, Israeli and international officials are working on a plan to pay settlers to hand over the remaining greenhouses and a dairy to Palestinians, to preserve jobs and production. These businesses provide thousands of jobs to Gazans.

Of the roughly 1,000 acres of agricultural land that were under greenhouses in the 21 Israeli settlements in Gaza, only 500 acres remain - creating significant doubts that the greenhouses could be handed over to the Palestinians as "a living business," the goal cited by the Israeli coordinator of the pullout, Eival Giladi.

Looters strip Gaza greenhouses, 9/13/05

Palestinian police stood by helplessly Tuesday as looters carted off materials from greenhouses in several settlements, and commanders complained they did not have enough manpower to protect the prized assets. In some instances, there was no security and in others, police even joined the looters, witnesses said.

“We need at least another 70 soldiers. This is just a joke,” said Taysir Haddad, one of 22 security guards assigned to Neve Dekalim, formerly the largest Jewish settlement in Gaza. “We’ve tried to stop as many people as we can, but they’re like locusts.”

[...]

During a tour of Neve Dekalim, Palestinian Prime Minister Ahmed Qureia implored Palestinians to leave the structures intact. “These greenhouses are for the Palestinian people,” he said. “We don’t want anyone to touch or harm anything that can be useful for our people.”

Jihad al-Wazir, the deputy Palestinian finance minister, said roughly 30 percent of the greenhouses suffered various degrees of damage. He said that after a “very heated meeting” with Qureia and other Palestinian leaders, the security forces appeared to be getting the situation under control.

“We expect the security to protect the assets properly,” he said.

Al-Wazir said the greenhouses did not suffer structural damage, but that looters got away with irrigation pipes, plastic sheeting and most troublesome, water pumps. He said authorities were trying to recover the expensive pumps.

Gaza Gets Ready for a Harvest of Produce and Promise, 11/28/05

Amid the rubble of the former Jewish settlements, Palestinians have sown the first seeds of a modest economic revival.

Less than three months after the Israelis departed, Palestinians have repaired scores of greenhouses left by the settlers and planted a fall crop, and they are preparing to harvest an estimated $20 million worth of strawberries, cherry tomatoes, sweet peppers and herbs and spices. The produce is intended mostly for export to Europe, but some will also be headed to Israel, Arab countries and the United States.

After overcoming numerous obstacles, the Palestinians said their main worry now was the Karni border crossing between the Gaza Strip and Israel, critical to moving the produce to the markets.

After intense negotiations this month, Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice brokered an agreement on the Gaza crossings that says Palestinian agricultural exports are to pass through Karni "on an urgent basis." But the Palestinians say they remain worried about possible delays at the crossing.

Still, the harvest, which begins in about 10 days, will be the first tangible measure of development in Gaza, which has been in an economic free fall for most of the past five years.

"I think we have made this a success in a very short period," said Bassil Jabir, director of the Palestine Economic Development Company, a government group that works with the private sector and is overseeing greenhouse rehabilitation.

"We are employing thousands of people in these greenhouses," Mr. Jabir said during an interview in the former settlement of Gadid, in the southwest corner of Gaza, as he visited the flourishing greenhouses. "We kept the growing cycle intact. We have pumped a lot of money into the Gaza economy."

The Israeli military demolished the settlers' homes before leaving in September, and piles of smashed concrete have yet to be removed. Some greenhouses were looted by Palestinians in the chaotic days after the Israeli withdrawal, but today they are hives of activity, filled with the sounds of power saws and hammers at work.

Palestinians export first crop from ex-Gush Katif greenhouses, 12/11/05

Palestinian farmers who took over the greenhouses of Jewish settlers after the disengagement have harvested and exported their first crop, sending eight tons of peppers by truck to Israeli wholesalers on Sunday, the head of the Palestinian agency managing the project said. The chairman of the Palestine Economic Development Company, Basil Jaber, said that Sunday's shipment was a trial run and by the end of the year growers expected to export an unspecified quantity of peppers, cherry tomatoes and strawberries to European and other markets.

[...]

The departing settlers stripped the greenhouses of irrigation equipment and other operating gear, which had to replaced quickly after the September pullout to catch the remainder of the 2005 growing season. "We have 2,700 greenhouses and we already started harvesting in 2,000 of them for this season," Jaber said. "It makes us proud. This land was a symbol of occupation and many people were doubting our ability to rehabilitate this land, but now we have proven that we, as Palestinians, are able to manage our lives, to farm our land and to do our own business."

Gaza: Karni closures a 'catastrophe', 2/27/06

While many of the Gush Katif farmers have yet to plant their crops in new soil, the great hope that the greenhouses they left in Gaza would provide a boon to the Palestinian economy is withering on its own vine. The closure of the Karni goods crossing from Gaza to Israel for three weeks in January and now for ten days and counting in February has led to immense financial loss for the Palestinian farmers and the corporation that took over the greenhouses in August. Additionally, the Israeli export firm which signed on to ship the Gaza-grown produce to Europe, the US and other international markets, has also taken a financial hit from the closing. According to Dr. Bassil Jabir, the CEO of the Palestinian Economic Development Company which is overseeing the production and exports of the produce grown in the former Gush Katif greenhouses, his corporation has lost over $1 million due to the closures and is losing between $40,000 and $100,000 more each day Karni remains closed. "What we are seeing is a real catastrophe," Jabir said. "There is also indirect loss because we haven't been harvesting every day. Therefore the produce stays on the vine and the growth of the seedlings and stems are damaged," he added. As part of the deal brokered by Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice in November, the Karni crossing was to remain open as much as possible to allow for Palestinian exports from Gaza - such as the greenhouse produce - to make it to the Israeli and international markets.

In Gaza, there's no milk, no sugar and tomatoes are rotting on the vines, 3/9/06

In addition to the critical shortage of staple groceries, the closure has caused significant economic damage to Gaza farmers and businessmen. Cement and steel cannot come into the Strip, and neither can fertilizers. Greenhouse owners, for example, are losing about $500,000 a day during the peak of the harvest season for peppers, cucumbers and cherry tomatoes.

The prime vegetables that were intended for export are being sold in the Gaza markets for 50 agorot a kilo, or are left to rot on the vine.

[...]

The Israel Defense Forces confirmed that the head of the Southern Command, Yoav Galant, and Aviv Kochavi, commander of the Gaza Division, recently recommended the reopening of Karni and said there was no security-related reason for its closure. But Defense Minister Shaul Mofaz ordered the closure to continue.

Several different reasons have been given for the closure, including the upcoming Israeli elections and the recent Hamas victory in the PA elections.

Israelis Are Gone, but Gaza Rebuilding Is Slow, 2/18/07

The Israeli departure raised the prospect of land-hungry Palestinians flooding into the former settlements. But while many Palestinians are impatient for new housing, security guards have kept out would-be squatters in most, but not all, cases. The settlements also came with greenhouses that offered the prospect of thousands of agricultural jobs. Yet the greenhouses sit idle.

The Palestinians invested millions of dollars to repair the greenhouses shortly after the Israelis left, and had an excellent crop in the winter of 2005 and 2006. But they were unable to export their produce to Europe, the main market, because Israel kept Gaza’s main crossing for goods closed for weeks at a time, citing security concerns.

Short of money and fearing a similar fate this year, the Palestinians did not plant a winter crop in the greenhouses. But the goods crossing has been mostly open in recent weeks, when the crops would have been ready for export.

The Palestinian Agriculture Ministry says it will soon start renting the greenhouses to private farmers and will encourage them to grow for the local market, since there are no guarantees that fruits, vegetables and flowers can be exported in a timely manner.

Gaza's greenhouses become hot property in Egypt, 1/31/08

As Palestinians trudged across the Rafah border to stock up, Yahya Salama had another mission -- to sell Israeli-style greenhouses in Egypt.

Salama, 30, carted metal bars and poles, and translucent plastic sheeting to sell to Egyptians after Hamas militants blasted open the border last week to ease the Israeli-led blockade of Gaza.

Palestinians with years of experience working in Israeli greenhouses say this equipment was unavailable in Egypt.

"The Egyptian greenhouses aren't as strong and can collapse in the wind ... The material they use to keep the viruses off the plants also isn't as good," Salama told Reuters.

Gazans are busy dismantling greenhouses to sell in Egypt because it had been nearly impossible to export produce recently, he said.
 
You sure that it's me who's having trouble?

Quite sure.

The picture progression was made to push a fairly biased point of view, rather obviously.

In as much as that is a fact rather than your opinion, it is also a genetic fallacy.

"Dramatically different" works perfectly well for what's actually being shown in each picture.

Here is what is actually being shown in each picture:
If an area is green then it means that there is more Palestinian owned than Jewish/Israeli owned land. If it is white the opposite is true.
In the areas that turned from green to white the following sequence of events has, in general, occurred:
1. There were X Palestinian and Y Jewish/Israeli settlements, X > Y.
2. The Palestinians either fled or were expelled, and A of their settlements taken over.
3. There are now (X - A) Palestinian and (Y + A) Jewish/Israeli settlements, (X - A) < (Y + A)

(Other than the second picture)

That particular complaint, of course, wouldn't apply if the same criteria were being used to determine the green area in each picture. With such different criteria being shown in each panel, though, there's really nothing that it can be other than propaganda, regardless of its relation to reality.

I've asked you to support that opinion with facts, you just repeat it.

Of course, it does look like you're trying to pick a fight against something that wasn't said, again, and all you seem to have to offer is that Israel is pure evil and the Palestinian Arabs are justified in wanting to commit genocide against them! Yes, I'm engaging in slight hyperbole there, but sadly, only slight.

:rolleyes:

Or how much dispute the facts that you stated have received separately from that.

Care to present an example?

You were the one who brought it up and now you suddenly don't find it relevant?

I never considered it relevant, nor did I ever have to. I can find it relevant that you're providing rationalizations rather than facts without finding your specific world-view relevant.

Amusing. Sad, but amusing.

What is? Your errors in logic?

Heh. Only if one's playing dumb.

Have you stopped beating your wife?

I most surely can take you to task for establishing the implicit statement in a loaded question before answering it.


It provides relevant information to what you said.

Except that you ignored the relevant point made entirely.

This is something I consider amusing given your problems with the panel and the comparisons made in my first post.

That depends, quite honestly. As a general rule, though, I'm far more interested in the quality of an argument than the conclusion reached from it. When it came to taking a look at what was happening with the UN resolutions, back then, it was just a matter of fact checking out of mild curiosity. I've actually never been a huge supporter of Israel, at all, and I ever been a bit mystified by how much some people are such. The founders' claim on the land was weak from the start, after all, and later, when I learned that the Jews had been involved in ethnic cleansing, among other things, regardless of the justification, that didn't help, among numerous other factors. Still, though, they've not even remotely been the only side in the wrong, to put it nicely, and far, far too often, I see people who effectively take a black and white view of the events there and try to support their view with bad argument after bad argument. I mostly don't care what people believe, frankly, but I do care when bad arguments are used to try to support their position, even in cases where I've agreed with their conclusion for other reasons.

That's quite reasonable.
 
Does that really matter?

If the question is whether their national ideology is inherently racist then those things seem relevant. How many Zionist Muslims would you think there are?

Because they were somewhat pro-USSR due to Apartheid government suppressing Trade Unions and being in the US camp.

:rolleyes:

If the UN proclaims Israel the New Nazi Germany while ignoring the Killing fields in Cambodia at the same time, where does COSATU come into this?

COSATU's claim is stronger (apartheid > inherently racist).
 
If the question is whether their national ideology is inherently racist then those things seem relevant. How many Zionist Muslims would you think there are?

When most Muslim powers were fighting war to the knife against Israel for 25 years, that makes things polarised. When you have the recruiting Sergeant for the Waffen-SS as Grand Mufti, that makes this a hell of a lot worse.


Cold War Politics were massively messy

COSATU's claim is stronger (apartheid > inherently racist).

So if Israel was subject to all these resolutions, why did the UN ignore the Khmer Rouge turning Cambodia into a charnel house despite being FAR worse?
 
When most Muslim powers were fighting war to the knife against Israel for 25 years, that makes things polarised.

I'll ask you again, how many of the military conflicts did it initiate?

When you have the recruiting Sergeant for the Waffen-SS as Grand Mufti, that makes this a hell of a lot worse.

Do you have anything else besides ignoring the question by judicious use of Godwin's law?

Cold War Politics were massively messy

So COSATU was feeling nostalgic about the Soviet Union and decided "we hate America so much that we're going to claim that Israel is practicing Apartheid"?

So if Israel was subject to all these resolutions, why did the UN ignore the Khmer Rouge turning Cambodia into a charnel house despite being FAR worse?

I don't know, nor do I consider it relevant.
 
1) 1948 was initiated by the Arab League as a War of Extermination, 1967 was to stop Egypt and Syria from trying to attack them, while Yom Kippur was started by the Arab League as a last gasp in destroying Israel. "who fired first" in that situation is an academic matter, up there with the Mexican Standoff.

2) I'm pointing out WHY Israel has a lot of hardened hearts on the issue, and this guy is a big factor. When you go from hobnobbing with Hitler as Grand Mufti of Jerusalem, you are going to piss off a lot of Jews in the process

3) 3379 was passed during the cold war, and the USSR was seeking to curry favour with the Arab Powers, and the COSATU were seeking to curry favour with the Soviet Union in turn due to the fact that Apartheid Era South Africa was in the Western Camp.

4) It is Relevant because 3379 was passed after Phnom Penh, yet there were very few resolutions condemning the Khmer Rouge in comparison to Israel, who is seen as the devil of the Middle East.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom