Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
I pointed out that Israel has a serious trust issue with the UN because said international institution openly proclaimed them the new Nazi Germany while they were recovering from the Yom Kippur War. After all, if you are considered the equivalent of Nazi Germany, what's another broken resolution?

Not only are you diverting from your attempt to claim that a specific resolution was the cause of Israel's non-compliance, you're falsely representing what that resolution said in the first place. Please quote the resolution "proclaiming them the new Nazi Germany" or retract your claim.
 
And yet, they don't actually deal with the actual stated issues with the representation.

The "stated issues" have been shown to be either lies or blatant misrepresentations.

And I find the questions of "Why?" and "What are the effects?" to be of significantly more concern, given that that's the information that's actually meaningful for determining a good response.

Yes, I'm sure you can rationalize any fact so that it suits your world-view.
 
Not only are you diverting from your attempt to claim that a specific resolution was the cause of Israel's non-compliance, you're falsely representing what that resolution said in the first place. Please quote the resolution "proclaiming them the new Nazi Germany" or retract your claim.

It essentially said Zionism was inherently racist, putting it in the same category as Nazism, and by extension, the average Israeli with the Waffen SS. This, coupled with UN inaction over the Killing Fields in Cambodia, that led to many Israelis (fresh from fighting a third war for survival in 25 years) to see the UN as a joke (especially when the Khmer Rouge behaved FAR, FAR, FAR worse than Israel ever did and only got dinged for it when the leadership was on their deathbeds).

To summarise my points:
1) Israel had to fight 3 wars for survival within 25 years against enemies that wanted them DEAD.
2) Then the UN passes a resolution condemning them as racist, simply because the Arab powers were sore after being humiliated at round three.
3) This was coupled with the Khmer Rouge going happy happy fun time in Cambodia and the leadership getting away scot free.

When you brand an entire country racist, don't be surprised when they see little point in complying with UN resolutions, especially when they betray hypocrisy of instutions.
 
Last edited:
It essentially said Zionism was inherently racist, putting it in the same category as Nazism, and by extension, the average Israeli with the Waffen SS.

Did you know that someone said that Dutch nationalism is inherently Germanic? Thereby putting it in the same category as Nazism, and by extension, claiming the average Dutch person to be growing a Hitler mustache and calling himself Adolf.

1) Israel had to fight 3 wars for survival within 25 years against enemies that wanted them DEAD.

How many of these did it start?

2) Then the UN passes a resolution condemning them as racist, simply because the Arab powers were sore after being humiliated at round three.

Yes, that must be why it got passed. Did you know that the Congress of South African Trade Unions considers Israel to be practicing apartheid? How does this fit in your explanation? They are neither Arab, humiliated, or participants in round three, or any other round for that matter.

3) This was coupled with the Khmer Rouge going happy happy fun time in Cambodia and the leadership getting away scot free.

So it's the Khmer Rouge's fault?

When you brand an entire country racist

You may not have noticed, but "zionism" is a specific form of Jewish nationalism (a political ideology) whereas the country is called "Israel".

don't be surprised when they see little point in complying with UN resolutions, especially when they betray hypocrisy of instutions.

Here we go with the cause and effect thing again.
 
Last edited:
Either do or don't, Zig. Stop playing games.

You're playing games yourself, Belz. I asked you a question. You refuse to answer the question, and you refuse to even state whether or not you even know the answer.
 
3) This was coupled with the Khmer Rouge going happy happy fun time in Cambodia and the leadership getting away scot free.

Which reminds me, Khmer Rouge leaders have been jailed recently by an international court. Would you support a Palestinian bid for doing this with Israeli leaders?
 
The "stated issues" have been shown to be either lies or blatant misrepresentations.

Not really by you. You've responded, yes, but generally your responses haven't actually really done what you're claiming they did. There's that whole staying on topic issue that you seem to have some trouble with, as well as the fact that each of the pictures is representing something dramatically different, and they were cobbled together to push a distinctly biased agenda with little regard for consistency or accuracy.


Yes, I'm sure you can rationalize any fact so that it suits your world-view.

While that is exactly what it looks like you're trying to do. What, exactly, do you think "my" worldview is, though? The real world isn't as pretty and nice as just about anyone wishes it would be, though. There are, in fact, times when there are only nasty, undesirable choices to choose from. I'll ask again, do you think that having Israel just stand there and take it as the Arabs attack repeatedly until they give up or achieve their goals, racial relations continuing to spiral downwards with a rising death toll, is a viable solution?

I honestly don't consider either side to be "in the right," either way. I do think that there are better and worse solutions, though, and that Israel's largely been pursuing distinctly better solutions than the Palestinian Arabs have generally been pursuing.

Which reminds me, Khmer Rouge leaders have been jailed recently by an international court. Would you support a Palestinian bid for doing this with Israeli leaders?

To butt in a bit here, only if the same would be done for the Palestinian leaders and the court wasn't going to just be a kangaroo court. Hamas' leaders, especially. Either way, look at yourself seriously. This is really what you're trying to use as a response to having the frequently entirely political nature of the UN resolutions pointed out again? Their resolutions aren't remotely comprehensive or consistent when it comes to addressing violations, and at times, they're not exactly trustworthy.
 
Last edited:
Did you know that someone said that Dutch nationalism is inherently Germanic? Thereby putting it in the same category as Nazism, and by extension, claiming the average Dutch person to be growing a Hitler mustache and calling himself Adolf.

No, but 3379 proclaimed that Zionism, the national ideology of Israel was inherently racist. Even Jim Crow era USA didn't get that kick in the gonads politically. IOW, it said that Zionism was equivalent to Nazism.

How many of these did it start?

When your country is populated by survivors of the only industrial genocide, and surrounded by nations that REALLY want to kill you, that really doesn't matter.

Yes, that must be why it got passed. Did you know that the Congress of South African Trade Unions considers Israel to be practicing apartheid? How does this fit in your explanation? They are neither Arab, humiliated, or participants in round three, or any other round for that matter.

Cold War politics led to the Soviet Union deciding that brownie points among the Arab nations, and what opposed America was good for them.

So it's the Khmer Rouge's fault?

I was using that to point out that the UN's moral compass has been broken for a very, very, very long time.

You may not have noticed, but "zionism" is a specific form of Jewish nationalism (a political ideology) whereas the country is called "Israel".

And the resolution was intended to put Israel in the same box as Nazi Germany.

Here we go with the cause and effect thing again.

So I'm explaining how and why Israel sees the UN as a joke and you dismiss it as "cause and effect".
 
Last edited:
the fact that each of the pictures is representing something dramatically different

You seem to be having trouble with the notion of "fact". Whether the difference in representation - in as much as there is any - is "dramatically different" is an assessment, not a fact. If you want to argue this you'll have to specify exactly what they represent and how that is "dramatically different".

While that is exactly what it looks like you're trying to do.

Anyone can see that I've given facts, and when the representation was considered inaccurate I've provided the underlying data.

What, exactly, do you think "my" worldview is, though?

I don't know and I don't consider it relevant.

I'll ask again, do you think that having Israel just stand there and take it as the Arabs attack repeatedly until they give up or achieve their goals, racial relations continuing to spiral downwards with a rising death toll, is a viable solution?

1. Define "Arabs".
2. Define "attack" and show what fraction of attacks was performed by "Arabs" or Israel.
3. Provide some data on the death toll, how it is rising and what it constitutes.

See that would be the difference between providing facts and asking loaded questions.

To butt in a bit here, only if the same would be done for the Palestinian leaders and the court wasn't going to just be a kangaroo court. Hamas' leaders, especially.

That's exactly what Palestinian membership with the ICC does.

Either way, look at yourself seriously. This is really what you're trying to use as a response to having the frequently entirely political nature of the UN resolutions pointed out again?

Facts: "these are the UN resolutions"
Rationalizations: "but they're just so political"

Also, my response pointed out a factual error in the claim that Khmer Rouge leaders got away with it. It took some time, but the argument does not apply anymore in the present.

Their resolutions aren't remotely comprehensive or consistent when it comes to addressing violations, and at times, they're not exactly trustworthy.

Do those problems only pop up when they say something that contradicts your previously held beliefs or are you in some systematic way going about that?
 
Last edited:
No, but 3379 proclaimed that Zionism, the national ideology of Israel was inherently racist.

How many of the Arab Israeli adhere to that national ideology?

Cold War politics led to the Soviet Union deciding that brownie points among the Arab nations, and what opposed America was good for them.

This explains COSATU's determination how exactly?

I was using that to point out that the UN's moral compass has been broken for a very, very, very long time.

Has COSATU's?

So I'm explaining how and why Israel sees the UN as a joke and you dismiss it as "cause and effect".

Yes. You see, there are these things called causes and effects, the former ought to precede the latter in time. We have Israel ignoring UN resolutions, then 3379 saying their ideology is inherently racist, then Israel still ignoring UN resolutions, then 3379 being revoked (as a condition for Israel to join peace talks), and then Israel still ignoring UN resolutions.
 
You seem to be having trouble with the notion of "fact". Whether the difference in representation - in as much as there is any - is "dramatically different" is an assessment, not a fact. If you want to argue this you'll have to specify exactly what they represent and how that is "dramatically different".

You sure that it's me who's having trouble? The picture progression was made to push a fairly biased point of view, rather obviously. "Dramatically different" works perfectly well for what's actually being shown in each picture. That you're taking issue again with the fact that they're using significantly different criteria from each other when it's already been pointed out to you repeatedly and you've previously agreed to such is quite worthy of an :rolleyes:. That particular complaint, of course, wouldn't apply if the same criteria were being used to determine the green area in each picture. With such different criteria being shown in each panel, though, there's really nothing that it can be other than propaganda, regardless of its relation to reality.

Of course, it does look like you're trying to pick a fight against something that wasn't said, again, and all you seem to have to offer is that Israel is pure evil and the Palestinian Arabs are justified in wanting to commit genocide against them! Yes, I'm engaging in slight hyperbole there, but sadly, only slight.

Anyone can see that I've given facts, and when the representation was considered inaccurate I've provided the underlying data.

That doesn't change the nature or problems with the representation. Or how much dispute the facts that you stated have received separately from that.

I don't know and I don't consider it relevant.

You were the one who brought it up and now you suddenly don't find it relevant? Amusing. Sad, but amusing.



1. Define "Arabs".
2. Define "attack" and show what fraction of attacks was performed by "Arabs" or Israel.
3. Provide some data on the death toll, how it is rising and what it constitutes.

See that would be the difference between providing facts and asking loaded questions.

Heh. Only if one's playing dumb. And it would fairly indisputably be "playing" in this case. Still, you refused to answer the question, again. I suppose I'll just assume that you don't have a particularly viable solution to the issue, then, and just want to bash Israel, rather than engage in rational discussion about it. For that matter, from the start, you seemed far more interested in trying to bash the US and Israel than discuss the pros and cons of the US supporting Israel and whether it should or not.

That's exactly what Palestinian membership with the ICC does.

And? Like many, I don't oppose recognition of Palestine as a nation, with all the rights and privileges associated, but I do think that, if they want to benefit from international recognition as a state and things like the Partition plan in the second panel of your representation, they need do some basic and obvious things like recognize Israel's right to exist within the boundaries set by that plan. The lack of willingness to even do such basic things like that puts them in an overwhelmingly worse position in a number of ways and removes their right to benefit from that plan while they remain unable to agree with it.



Facts: "these are the UN resolutions"
Rationalizations: "but they're just so political"

In short, you were ignoring what's been said in favor of what you made up in your head and not really thinking things through anyways. Again. Oh, and misrepresenting what you said a bit on top of that. That's a problem that you should probably work on, if, of course, you have any intention of engaging in honest discussion. That so many have dealt with Israel has very much been politics, more than anything else, even if violations of international law actually were the case, which wasn't necessarily true. When touching on Khmer Rouge, for example, how many UN resolutions would they have had about them, had such been pursued as vigorously as has been pursued against Israel?


Also, my response pointed out a factual error in the claim that Khmer Rouge leaders got away with it. It took some time, but the argument does not apply anymore in the present.

Except that you ignored the relevant point made entirely. That they got away with it until practically the end (the leadership was on their deathbeds) and only then did the UN do anything at all was the relevant actual claim made in that post. That remaining leaders are being dealt with now is irrelevant to that. So, no, no points at all for your reading comprehension or counterargument.

Do those problems only pop up when they say something that contradicts your previously held beliefs or are you in some systematic way going about that?

That depends, quite honestly. As a general rule, though, I'm far more interested in the quality of an argument than the conclusion reached from it. When it came to taking a look at what was happening with the UN resolutions, back then, it was just a matter of fact checking out of mild curiosity. I've actually never been a huge supporter of Israel, at all, and I ever been a bit mystified by how much some people are such. The founders' claim on the land was weak from the start, after all, and later, when I learned that the Jews had been involved in ethnic cleansing, among other things, regardless of the justification, that didn't help, among numerous other factors. Still, though, they've not even remotely been the only side in the wrong, to put it nicely, and far, far too often, I see people who effectively take a black and white view of the events there and try to support their view with bad argument after bad argument. I mostly don't care what people believe, frankly, but I do care when bad arguments are used to try to support their position, even in cases where I've agreed with their conclusion for other reasons.
 
Last edited:
How many of the Arab Israeli adhere to that national ideology?

Does that really matter?

This explains COSATU's determination how exactly?

Because they were somewhat pro-USSR due to Apartheid government suppressing Trade Unions and being in the US camp.

Has COSATU's?

If the UN proclaims Israel the New Nazi Germany while ignoring the Killing fields in Cambodia at the same time, where does COSATU come into this?

Yes. You see, there are these things called causes and effects, the former ought to precede the latter in time. We have Israel ignoring UN resolutions, then 3379 saying their ideology is inherently racist, then Israel still ignoring UN resolutions, then 3379 being revoked (as a condition for Israel to join peace talks), and then Israel still ignoring UN resolutions.

Ok, Israel had been in a total war footing for 25 years, due to the fact that everyone around them wanted them DEAD, a few UN Resolutions were nothing more than strongly worded letters. Then you have them proclaimed as morally equivalent to Nazi Germany by the Arab League's allies in the UN, which conveniently happened to ignore what was going on in Cambodia at the same time (How many resolutions did Pol Pot get within the same time?). This led to many Israelis losing faith in the UN as a credible and impartial institution, and even the repeal of 3379 hasn't changed much of that because the damage had already been done.
 
And another thing: the icc is practically a joke (how many bigwigs has it convicted? None!). A case like Israel Palestine would break it completely.
 
:rolleyes:

Nice schoolyard debating tactics, there.



No, I asked you a question. You answered with a question. Answer with an answer instead.

First, you also asked a question, that doesn't mean I didn't ask you one, so your "No" is simply and obviously wrong. And second, I asked you what happened after Israel pulled out of Gaza before you asked me to answer my own question. That's the way it always works, absent time travel.

Answer with an answer instead. What happened after Israel pulled out of Gaza? If you don't know, then simply say you don't know. If you refuse to answer, then simply state that. It would be peculiar, but at least it would be honest. But what you're doing? It's pathetic, Belz. And your attempt to blame me for your own strange evasiveness isn't going to work.
 
First, you also asked a question, that doesn't mean I didn't ask you one, so your "No" is simply and obviously wrong. And second, I asked you what happened after Israel pulled out of Gaza before you asked me to answer my own question. That's the way it always works, absent time travel.

Answer with an answer instead. What happened after Israel pulled out of Gaza? If you don't know, then simply say you don't know. If you refuse to answer, then simply state that. It would be peculiar, but at least it would be honest. But what you're doing? It's pathetic, Belz. And your attempt to blame me for your own strange evasiveness isn't going to work.

Very well. I shall henceforth assume that you don't have an answer to your (rhetorical) question. You've had plenty of time and opportunity to educate me.

It's very clear to anyone reading this thread that you asked said question, after which I asked you to provide the answer, which you have not done, all the while having the gall to accuse _me_ of being evasive. If you don't know, yourself, you have even less justification to berate others for the same ignorance.
 
Last edited:
Very well. I shall henceforth assume that you don't have an answer to your (rhetorical) question. You've had plenty of time and opportunity to educate me.

And you've had plenty of time to either answer yourself or let me know that you don't have the answer. Yet you have done neither. You have not once indicated that you do not know the answer. This has not escaped my notice.

If you don't know, yourself, you have even less justification to berate others for the same ignorance.

Except its not your ignorance I'm berating you for. It's for your refusal to even indicate that you don't know the answer, leaving me to suspect that you're just playing games here in your refusal. I stated many posts ago that I would provide you with an answer, if you simply told me you didn't know. Yet you never did. Why?
 
And you've had plenty of time to either answer yourself or let me know that you don't have the answer. Yet you have done neither.

Your question is vague. Pull out when, at what date ? Why don't you save us both some time and give us the answer. By the same token you'll prove your superior knowledge and put me in my place, so it's a win-win for you.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom