Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
I'm talking about things like segregated public transportation. Wasn't that one of the things in the US as well?

Looking into it, the nature of the discrimination and regarding that are only comparable in a very superficial way, specifically, that there is/was discrimination occuring. Comparisons break down quickly after that point, by the look of it, especially when it comes to how officially legal the discrimination apparently is. As I agreed previously, there are definite racial issues in Israel, but the comparison to the US before the Civil Rights movement is still terrible, at best.


Could you provide some of those other countries that are also, by a wide margin, the country which ignores UN resolutions the most?

Why should I play along with your attempt to move the goalposts and change the subject? That's before touching on how the things that you're citing are not international law in the first place.

It's far from being as inaccurate as you make it.

Then demonstrate such. So far, you've failed to do so rather horribly. Instead of validly supporting your position, you've offered up false statements and half-truths. That's really not helping your case.
 
Comparisons break down quickly after that point, by the look of it, especially when it comes to how officially legal the discrimination apparently is.

Israel's own supreme court finds, on a regular basis for about four decades now, its government to be belligerently occupying territory and being in violation of international law, yet you'd hardly argue that made the occupation non-existent.

Why should I play along with your attempt to move the goalposts and change the subject?

You shouldn't, though you should explain why you consider a relevant answer to be "moving the goalposts and changing the subject". You argued that there was a lack of specificity concerning basing a comparison on international law. I showed you that, by at least one objective measure, it is specific.

That's before touching on how the things that you're citing are not international law in the first place.

Oh please. Those resolutions generally affirm violations of international law.

you've offered up false statements

Care to provide an example?

and half-truths

And of this?
 
Last edited:

I note that you can't actually refute anything I said. Hell, you apparently don't even have a response to my argument. Such is the low quality of your own reasoning. You believe the anti-Israel propaganda because that's the ideological bubble you live in, so you can parrot it endlessly, but when confronted by facts, you just don't know what to do. But you certainly can't question your own premise, so instead you just express disdain, because that's all you've got left.

It's almost sad, really.
 
as I said before, UN resolution 3379 (aka Zionism as racism) probably did a lot to gut their credibility in Israel to the extent that UN resolutions are seen as a joke (especially when Israel was fresh from Yom Kippur.)
 
I note that you can't actually refute anything I said.

Actually, all you could note was that I didn't refute anything you said, not that I can't. If I were trying to hide that I can't refute anything you say, don't you think I would be better off by not responding at all?

The first panel shows the private ownership of Palestinian and Jewish land before the civil war.

I'll leave you to discover the other refutations of your points yourself.

It's almost sad, really.

Yes it is.
 
Actually, all you could note was that I didn't refute anything you said, not that I can't. If I were trying to hide that I can't refute anything you say, don't you think I would be better off by not responding at all?

Given your propensity for posting easily debunked lies, I'm not about to assume that you're going to take the most logical and rational course of action.

The first panel shows the private ownership of Palestinian and Jewish land before the civil war.

No it doesn't. I already told you why. There was a hell of a lot of land that wasn't privately owned by anyone at all, yet it's marked on the map as if it was owned by the Palestinians. That's a lie. You have been told why it's a lie, yet your only response is to merely repeat the lie.
 
Seriously, Belz? You can't figure out on your own why one should be able to distinguish something very bad from something that's a little bad, and consider the very bad thing to be more important to address?

Interesting bait and switch, but it would only work on me if I had the memory of a mole rat and forgot that this isn't the statement I was answering.

Yes, Belz, it was.

It really wasn't. It's not an appeal to "popularity", but to the legal opinion of international experts.

Irrelevant straw man. Try again.

So if it's a straw man, you can clarify what you mean. If international law is meaningless, I assume it's because we can violate it willy-nilly.

The Palestinians want to destroy Israel.

Correction: some Palestinians want this. Regardless, this isn't a reason to wipe out a whole people, and I wager the Palestinians would be pretty happy if Israel just out of the blue pulled out of the west bank and declared Palestine a sovereign country.

Then they'd deal with the terrorists themselves, presumably, and if they didn't, then it'd be an act of war.

Should Israel haggle over the timeline for their own destruction?

You seem to think that if rhetoric is convincing, it somehow shapes reality.

It seems that you've taken the rather common position of moral equivalency between the two sides

Nope. Try again.
 

That's quite the sad attempt to dismiss a point that you don't like. It would, admittedly, be reasonably used in response to -

So... one group builds houses. The other group blows up buses.

And it's the group building houses that you've got a problem with.

Given that that statement oversimplifies the situation rather overwhelmingly and obviously enough to ignore a lot of relevant points. However, what you chose to :rolleyes: at was, quite frankly, truth. That claimed progression is fraudulent... and it's very much the Arabs' fault both that the second picture didn't become the case and that the third ceased to be the case, much as Palestinian land in the third only applies to the region there and not at all a particular country. The other countries holding the land didn't seem all that interested in giving it up, either. Jordan, for example, gave out Jordanian citizenship en masse in the West Bank.

Israel's own supreme court finds, on a regular basis for about four decades now, its government to be belligerently occupying territory and being in violation of international law, yet you'd hardly argue that made the occupation non-existent.

And your point is? At no point did I disagree that there are significant racial issues present. In fact, I repeatedly agreed that there are. Your comparison of it to the racial issues in the US before the Civil Rights movement is still both remarkably poor on it's own merits, once you start going past the fact that both cases do indeed involve significant racial issues, and is an obvious attempt to twist Ziggarut's statement into a mockery of how it was clearly intended.

You shouldn't, though you should explain why you consider a relevant answer to be "moving the goalposts and changing the subject". You argued that there was a lack of specificity concerning basing a comparison on international law. I showed you that, by at least one objective measure, it is specific.

Playing dumb? Can't say I'm surprised, honestly, given your arguments so far.

Let's see, though. Can you in fact, spot the obvious differences between making a statement that Israel and the US break international law at will, which I didn't dispute anyways, though I did add perspective, and making the statement that Israel ignores more UN resolutions than any other country? The latter really doesn't help your previous attempt to compare the US breaking international law and Israel breaking international law or refute what I said at all, therefore, the only viable conclusion is that you're trying to move the goalposts and change the subject to one that you think is actually defensible and claim false victory if you can defend that irrelevant point.


Oh please. Those resolutions generally affirm violations of international law.

Given the countries that made and supported more than a few of them and the actual claimed violations, the number becomes rather less trustworthy in multiple ways, last I checked. Admittedly, that was a while ago and it wasn't exactly important to me, though, so I don't remember much in the way of specifics off the top of my head. That's not at all to say that Israel's been particularly praiseworthy or undeserving of a number of the condemnations, by any means, but frankly, politics are politics.




Care to provide an example?



And of this?

Yup, playing dumb. You say this like they haven't been pointed out as things have progressed.
 
Correction: some Palestinians want this. Regardless, this isn't a reason to wipe out a whole people, and I wager the Palestinians would be pretty happy if Israel just out of the blue pulled out of the west bank and declared Palestine a sovereign country.

This is quite true.

Then they'd deal with the terrorists themselves, presumably, and if they didn't, then it'd be an act of war.

It also seems pretty obvious that Israeli leaders fully expect that it wouldn't be all that long until war broke out under those circumstances, yet again, and don't want more dead citizens, like there would be. ETA: Well, that's the nice side of things. That they'd rather certainly lose their jobs in short-order plays a part on the other side of things.
 
Last edited:
It really wasn't. It's not an appeal to "popularity", but to the legal opinion of international experts.

No, it wasn't. You said, "Pretty much the world agrees that what they are doing is illegal". That's not a reference to the legal opinions of international experts. That's an appeal to the popular opinion of everybody.

So if it's a straw man, you can clarify what you mean. If international law is meaningless, I assume it's because we can violate it willy-nilly.

You need to improve your reading comprehension. This is what I said: "international law has no particular moral legitimacy". Do you understand the difference between that statement and the statement "international law is meaningless"?

International law obviously has meaning. For many purposes it's a convenient way to set standards to facilitate smooth interactions. Many standards are arbitrary, but even arbitrary standards have use merely because they are standard. Furthermore, there are often consequences to violating international laws. These grant the laws meaning, regardless of the morality (or lack thereof) involved.

As to them not having any particular moral legitimacy, that requires a more in-depth conversation about what grants laws in general, even of the malum prohibitum variety, any moral legitimacy. Social contract, all that sort of stuff. But that stuff actually tends to be missing in regards to international law. International law often has utilitarian purpose, but there is no reason to assign any moral weight to it, and you certainly haven't put forth any argument for why it should. Even your reference to "might makes right" is ironic in this context, since that is, in fact, the actual foundation for international law. If you don't like the idea of might makes right, international law is a bad place to look for an alternative.

Correction: some Palestinians want this.

The ones in charge do.

Regardless, this isn't a reason to wipe out a whole people,

Sure, but nobody here is suggesting wiping out the Palestinians, and neither is Israel.

and I wager the Palestinians would be pretty happy if Israel just out of the blue pulled out of the west bank and declared Palestine a sovereign country.

What actually happened when Israel pulled out of Gaza?

Then they'd deal with the terrorists themselves, presumably, and if they didn't, then it'd be an act of war.

Now you're advocating Israel being even more violent than they actually were.

Nope. Try again.

To quote a great thinker, "So if it's a straw man, you can clarify what you mean."
 
Do you have rebuttals to Zig's points, though ?

Of course I do. As already pointed out, the first panel contains the relative privately owned land by Jewish and Palestinian citizens. That the green represents "British state owned land" is an outright lie, you can find the data in "Village statistics, 1945".

The second panel contains the proposal for a partition that formed the basis for the declaration of independence of Israel (and the creation of the state of Israel).

etc
 
That's quite the sad attempt to dismiss a point that you don't like.

I don't dismiss it because I don't like it, I dismiss it because they're easily debunked lies.

And your point is?

Obvious enough. Just because something isn't officially legal doesn't mean it doesn't exist, nor is it very relevant in a comparison of de facto situations.

Playing dumb?

You claimed to have a long list of countries to which that argument could be equally applied. I've shown, by giving actual data, that to be false. If anyone is playing dumb it's you.

Given the countries that made and supported more than a few of them and the actual claimed violations, the number becomes rather less trustworthy in multiple ways, last I checked. Admittedly, that was a while ago and it wasn't exactly important to me, though, so I don't remember much in the way of specifics off the top of my head. That's not at all to say that Israel's been particularly praiseworthy or undeserving of a number of the condemnations, by any means, but frankly, politics are politics.

An assembly resolution affirming the Palestinian right to sovereignty and self-determination has been passed every year since 1974. This has been confirmed, again and again, by the International Court of Justice and the UN security council. You trying to deflect that point by going "maybe there were some really bad countries voting for that" is disingenuous at best.

Yup, playing dumb.

Prove or retract.
 
Of course I do. As already pointed out, the first panel contains the relative privately owned land by Jewish and Palestinian citizens. That the green represents "British state owned land" is an outright lie, you can find the data in "Village statistics, 1945".

Bwahahahaha!

First off, I didn't say that the green represents "British state owned land". I said that it included British state owned land.

And dude, your own source just contradicted you. See that white section to all those pie charts? "Public and other". That category is completely missing from your fraudulent comparison. The public fraction is small in some districts, but in Beersheba (which is by far the largest district), it's a full 85%. But that region is almost entirely green on your fraudulent map. So quite clearly it HAS included public land in the green portions of your fraudulent map, and then labelled it fraudulently.

The second panel contains the proposal
Exactly, a proposal. Which makes labeling it as actually being owned by those respective parties a lie.


Indeed, the lies simply continue.

But thanks for debunking yourself, you should actually be pretty proud. Not many posters can pull that off.
 
Bwahahahaha!

First off, I didn't say that the green represents "British state owned land". I said that it included British state owned land.

And dude, your own source just contradicted you. See that white section to all those pie charts? "Public and other". That category is completely missing from your fraudulent comparison. The public fraction is small in some districts, but in Beersheba (which is by far the largest district), it's a full 85%. But that region is almost entirely green on your fraudulent map. So quite clearly it HAS included public land in the green portions of your fraudulent map, and then labelled it fraudulently.

The map accurately represents the relative land ownership by Palestinians and Jews on a regional level. That you don't know how to read a map is your problem.

Exactly, a proposal. Which makes labeling it as actually being owned by those respective parties a lie.

As anyone can see, it's not labeled as such.

Indeed, the lies simply continue.

Yes they do.
 
The map accurately represents the relative land ownership by Palestinians and Jews on a regional level.

Which map? The 4-panel map you first posted? Nope, that's a fraud. And your second map contradicts it.

That you don't know how to read a map is your problem.

Oh, I most certainly can.

As anyone can see, it's not labeled as such.

And what do you imagine "as such" to mean in this case?

Your first map is labelled in a manner so as to deliberately deceive, by misrepresenting what is being shown. It uses the same description across panels even though it switches what's actually being shown, and uses what superficially looks to be equivalent labels for "Jewish land" and "Palestinian land" even though what's actually being shown for the two categories have radically different definitions. And again, your own source proves this.

You're breaking the first rule of holes, caveman. Perhaps you should change your name to holeman. :dig:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom