Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
I used the obvious interpretation.

Well, yeah, most people think their interpretation is obvious, I know.

You are free to clarify that you meant something that was not only totally different

I did, and you still don't believe me.

1) You make a statement.
2) I commented on it under the assumption that the obvious interpretation was the intended one.
3) You said my interpretation was wrong, but did not explain why.
4) I reasserted my interpretation.
5) You claim I am wrong, and make a statement which looks radically different from your original statement. You do not indicate that you intended your original statement to mean this new statement.

Stop trying to act as if you've got something to teach people in terms of rational thinking and stick to the topic, will you, Zig ?

Now you're mad at me

Mad ? Seems you're _really_ bad at interpreting written conversations.

because I thought you moved the goalpost, rather than understanding that your writing is so atrocious that your meaning was completely opaque in its original expression. It's not my fault, Belz.

When you're done stroking your own back, can we get back in topic ?

Damn, Belz, if you're going to go full moral relativism, why did you even challenge my statement about international law in the first place?

I see, it's ok when _you_ do it.

Security for Israel.

How does the settlements fit into this grand scheme ?

Why are you even participating in this discussion if you don't already know?

Oh, I'm sorry. I wasn't told that this thread was for middle-east knowledge grandmasters only.

It's not exactly ancient history. Do you honestly not know?

Still waiting...

Yes. You advocated that Israel respond to Palestinian attacks as if they were the actions of an enemy nation waging war against Israel.

That is a lie. I never did such a thing. Just because I write up a scenario doesn't mean I "advocate" it. Come on, Zig. You've been here long enough to know this. Stop acting.
 
In what way?

The displacement of Palestinian Arab landowners in favor of Israeli Jewish landowners. The first map shows the distribution of Palestinian Arab-owned land vs. Jewish-owned land. The second map shows the proposed division between a Jewish state and an Arab state in the UN Partition Plan of 1947.

The third and fourth maps, though, show the borders encompassed by the state of Israel, with no regard to whether the land within those borders was owned by Jewish citizens or Arab citizens (or non-citizens), as compared to the land inhabited by stateless Palestinian Arabs living in areas occupied by Egypt and Jordan. The first two maps and the second two maps really don't belong together.
 
I don't dismiss it because I don't like it, I dismiss it because they're easily debunked lies.

You are aware what fraud is, right? That progression of pictures was made with blatantly obvious intent to deceive. Yes, the labels are there and that makes it slightly better, even if, like Ziggarut's been pointing out, the first picture is rather inaccurate. With that said, I don't think I've ever seen it used to try to make a point while taking in account either the labels or the reasons why things changed, and your use didn't change that observation in the least.


Obvious enough. Just because something isn't officially legal doesn't mean it doesn't exist, nor is it very relevant in a comparison of de facto situations.

In short, you were being combative about nothing and for no good reason. Either way, this point still doesn't and wouldn't support your attempt to compare the US before the Civil Rights movement and present day Israel, given that the fact that there was or is significant racial issues present in both was never in question.

You claimed to have a long list of countries to which that argument could be equally applied. I've shown, by giving actual data, that to be false. If anyone is playing dumb it's you.

That actually wasn't quite my claim, but whatever. Number of violations matters very little, and only indirectly, to your original statement and does not really support your attempt to link the US and Israel.

An assembly resolution affirming the Palestinian right to sovereignty and self-determination has been passed every year since 1974. This has been confirmed, again and again, by the International Court of Justice and the UN security council. You trying to deflect that point by going "maybe there were some really bad countries voting for that" is disingenuous at best.

Heh. That wasn't what I said. Again.

Prove or retract.

Pick a post. Ziggarut did have a point, though, with the "playing" dispute. I cannot verify whether it's playing or not.
 
The third and fourth maps, though, show the borders encompassed by the state of Israel, with no regard to whether the land within those borders was owned by Jewish citizens or Arab citizens (or non-citizens), as compared to the land inhabited by stateless Palestinian Arabs living in areas occupied by Egypt and Jordan. The first two maps and the second two maps really don't belong together.

The state of Israel seized the property of the Palestinian refugees (about 80% of the pre-exodus Palestinian population in Israel) and passed a law preventing the return of the refugees. These properties were then destroyed and/or given to Jewish settlers. Of the about 20% of Palestinians remaining inside Israel, about a third were declared "Present Absentees", who technically still own the property but the state of Israel holds all ownership rights. In as much as the panel denotes de facto ownership it seems fair enough to me, given the numbers and the central message it conveys.
 
like Ziggarut's been pointing out, the first picture is rather inaccurate.

Fine, the authors of the picture had the audacity to label a region with say 50 Palestinian and 2 Jewish villages [numbers made up but indicative] as "Palestinian land" rather than "Desert" or whatever. And after Israel took over those 50 Palestinian villages they even had the audacity to now label it "Israel" and still not "Desert" or whatever.

In short, you were being combative about nothing and for no good reason.

I was being argumentative for very good reason.

Either way, this point still doesn't and wouldn't support your attempt to compare the US before the Civil Rights movement and present day Israel, given that the fact that there was or is significant racial issues present in both was never in question.

Suppose country X has segregated restaurants while country Y has segregated public transport. Would you say these would be incomparable on account of institutional racism because one is about restaurants and the other about public transport?

That actually wasn't quite my claim, but whatever.

That's before touching the long list of other countries that that complaint also applies to.

Number of violations matters very little, and only indirectly, to your original statement and does not really support your attempt to link the US and Israel.

I never said it does.

Pick a post.

:rolleyes:

Ziggarut did have a point, though, with the "playing" dispute. I cannot verify whether it's playing or not.

Funny he never figured out that is exactly why that one point he made deserved a :rolleyes:, since even if we assume the claims to be true, he was only showing that it was mistaken rather than fraudulent.
 
Well, yeah, most people think their interpretation is obvious, I know.

Looking back at your original wording, are you actually still of the opinion that your meaning was obvious?

I did, and you still don't believe me.

I do believe you. I just don't accept fault for what you didn't make in the least bit clear.

When you're done stroking your own back, can we get back in topic ?

I've been willing to for quite some time.

I see, it's ok when _you_ do it.

No, Belz, it's not OK when I do it. But I don't do it. Moral relativism has never been my thing. My position from the start has been premised on the idea that some things are better and some things are worse, in regards to morality. That is, in fact, the entire basis of my argument for why Israel deserves support. And my dismisal of international law with my quote "international law has no particular moral legitimacy" only makes sense if moral legitimacy is something I value. If I didn't value moral legitimacy (which you can't if you're a moral relativist), then logically my statement about the lack of moral legitimacy for international law would be irrelevant.

So you're really pulling this accusation out of your ass, Belz.

How does the settlements fit into this grand scheme ?

If you had paid attention, you would have noticed that I don't really think there is a "grand scheme". There are immediate concerns. Settlements help provide a buffer between dense Israeli population areas and Israel's enemies, and they put pressure on the Palestinians to make peace sooner rather than later.

Oh, I'm sorry. I wasn't told that this thread was for middle-east knowledge grandmasters only.

This isn't obscure knowledge either, Belz. I'll tell you if you honestly don't know what happened, but if you already do know, then you shouldn't need me to. And this isn't actually an indication of whether or not you know.

That is a lie. I never did such a thing. Just because I write up a scenario doesn't mean I "advocate" it.

It sure as hell sounded like you were advocating it to me. But then, of course, you also contradicted yourself (you originally said that the Palestinians would "presumably" deal with the terrorists if Israel withdrew, but more recently said you thought it probably wouldn't work), so who the hell knows what you really think.

Come on, Zig. You've been here long enough to know this. Stop acting.

Oh please. You've misrepresented me plenty in this recent discussion. You're hardly in a position to denounce me because I don't accurately represent your beliefs, when you won't actually make those beliefs clear. For example, you've never even said whether or not the US should be supporting Israel. You've also said both sides have behaved badly, but you've never said which side behaves worse. So you're being very far from clear in any of this.
 
The state of Israel seized the property of the Palestinian refugees (about 80% of the pre-exodus Palestinian population in Israel) and passed a law preventing the return of the refugees. These properties were then destroyed and/or given to Jewish settlers. Of the about 20% of Palestinians remaining inside Israel, about a third were declared "Present Absentees", who technically still own the property but the state of Israel holds all ownership rights.

This point would be one that's worth keeping on the table, certainly, when the issue at hand is Israel's misdeeds. It was quite understandable and predictable, sure. That's not much of a defense morally, though, for the ethnic cleansing that occurred.

In as much as the panel denotes de facto ownership it seems fair enough to me, given the numbers and the central message it conveys.

Fair enough? Heh. If you want to convey an overwhelmingly incomplete and biased version of events, sure. The Arabs dug themselves deeper and deeper into a hole when it came to their use of military force and repeated losses. As I recall, the partition plan in the second panel is disproportionately skewed towards Israel in fair part because of a failed Arab uprising or few that soured the governing authorities to them. In the third, it's more because the Arabs refused to accept the plan, ganged up, lost, and ended up making things worse for the Palestinian Arabs. In the fourth, the same can be said as the third. Frankly, war has consequences that are distinctly unpleasant for the losers. Maintaining rhetoric calling for the destruction of and funding terrorist actions against militarily superior foes has consequences as well, especially for the groups that actually engage directly in the terrorism and spout similar rhetoric, but also for all those associated with those groups. It's not a pretty situation today for the Palestinian Arabs, certainly, but a whole lot of the blame for that lays on them. Not even close to all, of course, but they've made decisions that make things worse for themselves over and over and over, and that should not be ignored.
 
I was being argumentative for very good reason.

Very good reason? That reason couldn't have much directly to do with the actual points that had been made before, though, and was presented as if it did.

Suppose country X has segregated restaurants while country Y has segregated public transport. Would you say these would be incomparable on account of institutional racism because one is about restaurants and the other about public transport?

No, and yet again, at no point did I disagree that both cases do involve a fair bit of discrimination, which is all that you've really been able to support. The underlying factors and history of the racism, motivations both past and present, official rhetoric, legal situation, interference of outside interests, and so on are all different enough that the comparison is still remarkably poor, once you get past the superficial similarities.

ETA: And again, all of this started with you trying to twist Ziggarut's easily defensible statement in ways that really don't work. At all. The current interests, attitudes, and values in the US are not, in fact, the same as what they were before the Civil Rights movement or when terrible things were done to Native Americans. That alone negates any and all value from your first two tries to distort what he said, before touching the rest of the fatal issues. Nor does any of what you said have anything to do with how good the current political relationships are between the US and various countries in the region... or, to go on a complete tangent to his statement, that the US has, in fact, supported Palestinian Arabs in numerous and rather significant ways, regardless. Very probably more than any other single country... and they still seem to hate us because the US also supports Israel.

ETA2: Well, I suppose that this could potentially go a bit of a middle ground, though, if you can validly back up your attempt to claim that the current overriding, or even notable, values behind the US' support and interest in supporting Israel are, in fact, approval of "occupying someone else's country, putting those people in refugee camps and settling their lands," support for institutional racial segregation, and support of flaunting international law at will. Seriously, go ahead. That's what you'd actually need to do to have any chance to support your original post at this point in any meaningful way.

I never said it does.

You actually did, by how and where you used it. Context matters. Hence why I called you out for trying to move the goalposts and change the subject.
 
Last edited:
This point would be one that's worth keeping on the table, certainly, when the issue at hand is Israel's misdeeds. It was quite understandable and predictable, sure. That's not much of a defense morally, though, for the ethnic cleansing that occurred.

Oh please, they are factual statements supporting the last two maps in response to the criticism directed at them. Stop this diversion about morality.

If you want to convey an overwhelmingly incomplete and biased version of events, sure.

If you want to convey a central fact. I consider the fact "who's occupying who here" interesting outside of any spin you'd like to put on it.

The Arabs dug themselves deeper and deeper into a hole when it came to their use of military force and repeated losses.

They're just an evil people, aren't they? One can even wonder whether they're a real people in the first place, given Ziggurat's scare quotes around "Palestinian".

As I recall, the partition plan in the second panel is disproportionately skewed towards Israel in fair part because of a failed Arab uprising or few that soured the governing authorities to them.

So what? It is relevant since it was the border Israel declared statehood over, and internationally asked to be, and has been, recognized within.

Frankly, war has consequences that are distinctly unpleasant for the losers.

Does that include having their lands seized and colonized?
 
Well, I suppose that this could potentially go a bit of a middle ground, though, if you can validly back up your attempt to claim that the current overriding, or even notable, values behind the US' support and interest in supporting Israel are, in fact, approval of "occupying someone else's country, putting those people in refugee camps and settling their lands," support for institutional racial segregation, and support of flaunting international law at will.

I made no such claim. In fact, my claim contains exclusively values that have passed in the US - as was indicated.

That's what you'd actually need to do to have any chance to support your original post at this point in any meaningful way.

That's an error in logic. What I actually have to do, and have done, is show that they exist in Israel and the occupied territories and correspond with the earlier US values.

You actually did, by how and where you used it. Context matters.

Why should I trust your memory on context when your memory on actual statements is shown wrong?

Hence why I called you out for trying to move the goalposts and change the subject.

Incorrectly.
 
Oh please, they are factual statements supporting the last two maps in response to the criticism directed at them. Stop this diversion about morality.

And yet, they don't actually deal with the actual stated issues with the representation.

If you want to convey a central fact. I consider the fact "who's occupying who here" interesting outside of any spin you'd like to put on it.

And I find the questions of "Why?" and "What are the effects?" to be of significantly more concern, given that that's the information that's actually meaningful for determining a good response.


They're just an evil people, aren't they?

Nice attempt at a common straw man. No, I don't think that they're just an evil people. Nor have I argued in favor of that, though I have no doubt that I could make a fine rhetorical case in favor of it. I do think that they've been making numerous decisions that have worked against them for a long time, though, as a group, and culturally hold values that encourage poor decision making.

One can even wonder whether they're a real people in the first place, given Ziggurat's scare quotes around "Palestinian".

Scare quotes? "Palestinian" is what the Arabs of the area were renamed in more of an effort to try to increase the legitimacy of their claim to the land than anything else, after the nearby Arab countries tried and failed to take the land for themselves, at last check. It serves just fine as a name for them, regardless, as questionably accurate as it's become for many.

So what? It is relevant since it was the border Israel declared statehood over, and internationally asked to be, and has been, recognized within.

I'll have to ask, then. Are you intentionally being dense enough to ignore the context that that statement was made within and what was actually said, again, or is it unintentional?

Does that include having their lands seized and colonized?

Wouldn't be a first, by a long shot. As it stands, though, Israel has had ample reason to believe that the Arabs in question would turn around and try to destroy them, yet again, in fairly short order, given the opportunity, which would lead to Israeli citizens dying and probably a heck of a lot more Arabs dying, yet again, before getting to the rest of the collateral damage, material and otherwise, that would be done. Along the lines of your complaint, and in reference to this, though, your statements are leaving out a bit of important information. More than a few Palestinian Arabs have repeatedly made their desire to commit genocide against the Jews of Israel, or what became Israel, clear since before the Holocaust and take their lands for themselves. Even more recently, a popular position seems to be that they'd happily take all the land that they would originally have had if they had agreed to the land divisions in that second panel, of course, and still refuse to accept Israel's legitimacy to exist and try to take the rest as soon as possible.

It's worth asking, do you really think that having Israel just stand there and take it as the Arabs attack repeated until they give up or achieve their goals, racial relations continuing to spiral downwards, is a viable solution?
 
I made no such claim. In fact, my claim contains exclusively values that have passed in the US - as was indicated.

So, you admit that your post was trolling. Good for you.

That's an error in logic. What I actually have to do, and have done, is show that they exist in Israel and the occupied territories and correspond with the earlier US values.

To make it a relevant response to what you quoted of Ziggarut's post, you would have to do exactly what I said, if you wanted to avoid the relevant errors in logic that currently make it seem quite worthless. So no, it's not an error of logic on my part.

Why should I trust your memory on context when your memory on actual statements is shown wrong?

You've yet to demonstrate that, by the look of it.

Incorrectly.

Back that up, then. You've already admitted that your response wasn't directly relevant to the line of argument being dealt with in what you quoted it to be in response to and your purpose still seems to be quite obviously to be exactly what I pointed out.
 
You've said so twice, but have you performed the basic check of your theory that cause should precede effect?

Let's see:

1) Israel has just fought the third existential war within a generation, and is understandably exhausted
2) Then it has to put up with a new UN resolution putting it on the level of Nazism and branding every Israeli soldier as the moral equivalent of the SS.
3) It was only repealed in 1991 after political chicanery on behalf of the US and Saddam's humiliation. Despite this, Israel has a deep mistrust of the UN, especially when the Durban conferences become more like Stormfront.

It was just like prohibition: When Americans were being criminalised by the state on a "moral" basis, it destroyed the sanctity of law.
 
Looking back at your original wording, are you actually still of the opinion that your meaning was obvious?

You're the one who said it was obvious, not me. I clarified it for you already.

I do believe you. I just don't accept fault for what you didn't make in the least bit clear.

Who gives a damn ? Now that you understand it, move on.

No, Belz, it's not OK when I do it. But I don't do it.

Yep. Never happened.

Moral relativism has never been my thing. My position from the start has been premised on the idea that some things are better and some things are worse, in regards to morality.

Not to derail onto another topic, but it's a fact that different people have different morals at different times in different places. It's also a fact that morals aren't a physical law, so how can they not be relative ?

That is, in fact, the entire basis of my argument for why Israel deserves support. And my dismisal of international law with my quote "international law has no particular moral legitimacy" only makes sense if moral legitimacy is something I value. If I didn't value moral legitimacy (which you can't if you're a moral relativist), then logically my statement about the lack of moral legitimacy for international law would be irrelevant.

Understood.

So you're really pulling this accusation out of your ass, Belz.

You were doing so well right up to that part, Zig.

Is this the way you talk to people in real life ?

Settlements help provide a buffer between dense Israeli population areas and Israel's enemies, and they put pressure on the Palestinians to make peace sooner rather than later.

So it is a political tool and not a means to provide Israelis with lodging. At least we agree on that.

This isn't obscure knowledge either, Belz.

Who said it was ? I am allowed to ask questions about topics in which I participate, and expect answers rather than "You don't know that ? Boy, you're so dumb" ?

It sure as hell sounded like you were advocating it to me.

Of course it did. That's what black-and-white thinking does.

For example, you've never even said whether or not the US should be supporting Israel.

Yes, because that's irrelevant to what I was saying.

You've also said both sides have behaved badly, but you've never said which side behaves worse.

I also have not said if I like vegetarian pizza or not. Why would I even mention this, since it is, again, irrelevant to what I said ? Unless, of course, I _must_ stand somewhere on this.
 

What about article 33 of the 4th Geneva convention?
Article 33. No persons may be punished for an offense he or she has not personally committed. Collective penalties and likewise all measures of intimidation or of terrorism are prohibited.
Pillage is prohibited.
Reprisals against persons and their property are prohibited.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom