Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Are you aware that anyone can look at the labels above the panels and see that you're lying?

<SNIP>
Edited by jsfisher: 
Rule 12 violation deleted.


I'm counting on them reading the labels above the panels. I hope they look at your second map too, since that nicely debunks your first map.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
And dude, your own source just contradicted you. See that white section to all those pie charts? "Public and other". That category is completely missing from your fraudulent comparison. The public fraction is small in some districts, but in Beersheba (which is by far the largest district), it's a full 85%. But that region is almost entirely green on your fraudulent map. So quite clearly it HAS included public land in the green portions of your fraudulent map, and then labelled it fraudulently.

According to the linked source, Beersheba, covering 12,577,000 dunums, broken down into 1,936,380 dunums (or 15.39% of the land in the district) owned by Arabs, 65,231 dunums (or 0.52%) owned by Jews, 2,279 dunums (or 0.02%) public lands, and 10,573,110 dunums (or 84.07%) of land deemed uncultivable and listed as "ownership undefined". It notes that the "uncultivable" lands were used as pasturage by bedouin tribes in the area and that "it is wrong to presume that that the figure of 10,573,110 dunums appearing in the 'Village Statistics' under the separate column of 'Uncultivable Land' is government-owned."

Beersheba, then, was a sparsely-cultivated desert district, with 2,003,890 dunums of cultivable land (by which the report seems to mean "land actually under cultivation"), 96% of which was owned by Arabs, 3.3% by Jews, and .11% designated public land.
 
Last edited:
I'm counting on them reading the labels above the panels.

Good, then they can see that the first panel clearly states "Jewish and Palestinian land" and not "Jewish, Palestinian and other land". In other words, it shows the relative ownership of private Jewish and Palestinian citizens on a regional level.

They can also see that the second panel does indeed indicate that it shows the UN partition plan, rather than "actual control" as you claim.

That it starts by showing Jewish private land and then shows Israeli land might be explained by the fact that Israel didn't exist at the time of the first panel, hence the comparison was between the two groups of citizens.
 
According to the linked source, Beersheba, covering 12,577,000 dunums, broken down into 1,936,380 dunums (or 15.39% of the land in the district) owned by Arabs, 65,231 dunums (or 0.52%) owned by Jews, 2,279 dunums (or 0.02%) public lands, and 10,573,110 dunums (or 84.07%) of land deemed uncultivable and listed as "ownership undefined". It notes that the "uncultivable" lands were used as pasturage by bedouin tribes in the area and that "it is wrong to presume that that the figure of 10,573,110 dunums appearing in the 'Village Statistics' under the separate column of 'Uncultivable Land' is government-owned."

Beersheba, then, was a sparsely-cultivated desert district, with 2,003,890 dunums of cultivable land (by which the report seems to mean "land actually under cultivation"), 96% of which was owned by Arabs, 3.3% by Jews, and .11% designated public land.

So we're just going to shuffle around between "Palestinian", "Bedouin", and "Arab", as well as between "owned" and "ownership undefined", in order to claim that that map isn't a complete farce.

Got it.

And what happened to all those Bedouin, anyways? Did they somehow magically change from being Palestinians to being Jews?
 
as I said before, UN resolution 3379 (aka Zionism as racism) probably did a lot to gut their credibility in Israel to the extent that UN resolutions are seen as a joke (especially when Israel was fresh from Yom Kippur.)

You've said so twice, but have you performed the basic check of your theory that cause should precede effect?
 
Good, then they can see that the first panel clearly states "Jewish and Palestinian land" and not "Jewish, Palestinian and other land". In other words, it shows the relative ownership of private Jewish and Palestinian citizens on a regional level.

Except that it does nothing of the sort, since without knowing how much of the land was privately owned at all on the regional level, any attempt to compare between regions will be wrong. Plus, of course, there's nothing anywhere to indicate that this is supposed to only represent private land ownership, with public lands being inexplicably factored out.

So that attempted justification can't keep it from being a lie.

They can also see that the second panel does indeed indicate that it shows the UN partition plan, rather than "actual control" as you claim.

Except that the title of the entire graph is "Palestinian loss of land". But it's not lost land if they never had it, is it?

That it starts by showing Jewish private land and then shows Israeli land might be explained by the fact that Israel didn't exist at the time of the first panel, hence the comparison was between the two groups of citizens.

If you want to go by citizenship, then it's STILL a lie. For example, that third panel? None of that green area was "Palestinian". It was all either Egyptian or Jordanian.

ETA: the other problem, of course, being that maps of the relative private ownership of land (with public/unowned land being discounted) cannot indicate if any land was actually lost. Suppose, for example, that we have two groups, each of which privately owns 10% of the land, with 80% not privately owned. If you factor out this unowned land, then it looks like land ownership is 50/50. Now let's suppose that group A privately acquires another 10% of the land, but only from the previously non-private land, with group B's land ownership not changing. Now if we factor out unowned land, it looks like land ownership is 67%/33%. It LOOKS like there was a big transfer of land from group B to group A. But of course, group B didn't lose any land at all in this scenario. Factoring out the non-privately held land (which did not remain constant over time) is intellectually dishonest. And to do so without even indicating it, well, that's an outright lie.
 
Last edited:
So we're just going to shuffle around between "Palestinian", "Bedouin", and "Arab", as well as between "owned" and "ownership undefined", in order to claim that that map isn't a complete farce.

"We" aren't doing anything. You can do whatever you want with the data. I was merely giving more details about what that data from the linked source actually is.

If you want to get all bent out of shape that that one map showed Beersheba as "Palestinian land" instead of whatever else you think it should say, by all means knock yourself out.
 
The other countries holding the land didn't seem all that interested in giving it up, either. Jordan, for example, gave out Jordanian citizenship en masse in the West Bank.

The Jordanians at the time explicitly wanted the land they invaded in the 1948 war. They're less interested in its people, having done things like revoke en masse the citizenship they gave out en masse.

See also the link in Mycroft's sig.
 

It's a joke that you think that link is about the Bedouin. Here, try this instead:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bedouin#In_Israel

One key quote:

"All of the Israeli Bedouin were granted Israeli citizenship in 1954."

Huh. So any land that was owned by Bedouin continuously from the first panel to the last panel would have had its color changed, even though ownership didn't.

Your map is a lie, caveman.
 
No, it wasn't. You said, "Pretty much the world agrees that what they are doing is illegal". That's not a reference to the legal opinions of international experts. That's an appeal to the popular opinion of everybody.

Only because you prefer your personal interpretation of what I said to my stated meaning. Why would you do that ? It's like if someone says something at the dinner table, and you take offense to it, and they say "well, I didn't mean it like that, I meant X", and you're still offended because you decide that they really meant what you initially thought.

You need to improve your reading comprehension. This is what I said: "international law has no particular moral legitimacy".

Nothing has moral legitimacy. What's your point ?

International law often has utilitarian purpose, but there is no reason to assign any moral weight to it, and you certainly haven't put forth any argument for why it should.

Why would I do that, since it has little to do with what I posted before you brought it up ?

Even your reference to "might makes right" is ironic in this context, since that is, in fact, the actual foundation for international law.

It's the foundation of law in general, but not always.

The ones in charge do.

On this we absolutely agree. I think the same can be said of Israel's leaders.

Sure, but nobody here is suggesting wiping out the Palestinians, and neither is Israel.

In that case allow me to ask you a question: what do you believe is their end goal, given their past and current actions ?

What actually happened when Israel pulled out of Gaza?

Educate me.

Now you're advocating Israel being even more violent than they actually were.

Advocating ? Did you even read what I posted ?

To quote a great thinker, "So if it's a straw man, you can clarify what you mean."

I said that I find that both sides in this issue are both right and wrong. I didn't specify to what extent each of them is, although I did propose a solution that may or may not (probably not) work.
 
Huh. So any land that was owned by Bedouin continuously from the first panel to the last panel would have had its color changed, even though ownership didn't.

Yes, the land that was continuously owned by Bedouins from before 1948 to 1954 would have had its color changed, even though ownership didn't. However, as the Wiki article you cite says,

Prior to the 1948 Israeli Declaration of Independence, when the Negev became part of Israel, an estimated 65,000–90,000 Bedouins lived in the Negev. According to Encyclopedia Judaica, 15,000 Bedouin remained in the Negev after 1948; other sources put the number as low as 11,000.[64]

In 1999, 110,000 Bedouins lived in the Negev, 50,000 in the Galilee and 10,000 in the central region of Israel.[65]

All of the Israeli Bedouin were granted Israeli citizenship in 1954.[66]

The Bedouin who remained in the Negev belonged to the Tiaha confederation[67] as well as some smaller groups such as the 'Azazme and the Jahalin. After 1948, some Negev Bedouins were displaced. The Jahalin tribe, for instance, lived in the Tel Arad region of the Negev prior to the 1950s. In the early 1950s, the Jahalin were among the tribes which, according to Emmanuel Marks, "moved or were removed by the military government."[68] They ended up in the so-called E1 area East of Jerusalem.
 
Yes, the land that was continuously owned by Bedouins from before 1948 to 1954 would have had its color changed, even though ownership didn't. However, as the Wiki article you cite says,

But they're still Israeli. And the second two graphs doesn't separate by ethnicity, but by nationality. So complaining about how Israelis lost land (actually, they just lost the ability to use land that they never legally owned) hardly backs up the assertion that Palestinians lost land, does it?

So caveman's graphs are still very much a lie.
 
One key quote

"Prior to the 1948 Israeli Declaration of Independence, when the Negev became part of Israel, an estimated 65,000–90,000 Bedouins lived in the Negev. According to Encyclopedia Judaica, 15,000 Bedouin remained in the Negev after 1948; other sources put the number as low as 11,000."
 
Only because you prefer your personal interpretation of what I said to my stated meaning.

I used the obvious interpretation. You are free to clarify that you meant something that was not only totally different, but also totally not obvious, but the fault there is yours in writing something that no reader could have been expected to understand the way you apparently meant it. Furthermore, read the history of the exchange again.

1) You make a statement.
2) I commented on it under the assumption that the obvious interpretation was the intended one.
3) You said my interpretation was wrong, but did not explain why.
4) I reasserted my interpretation.
5) You claim I am wrong, and make a statement which looks radically different from your original statement. You do not indicate that you intended your original statement to mean this new statement.

Now you're mad at me because I thought you moved the goalpost, rather than understanding that your writing is so atrocious that your meaning was completely opaque in its original expression. It's not my fault, Belz. I took your original comment to mean what it looked like. This was entirely reasonable on my part. It isn't until now that you tell me that you meant something completely different all along.

Nothing has moral legitimacy. What's your point ?

Damn, Belz, if you're going to go full moral relativism, why did you even challenge my statement about international law in the first place? If nothing has moral legitimacy in your view, then you're the one advocating might makes right, not me, and your attempt to criticize me on that front is more than a bit ironic.

Or is this another case where what you mean doesn't actually match what you say? I can never tell with you.

On this we absolutely agree. I think the same can be said of Israel's leaders.

Obviously not. Israel has the means to exterminate the Palestinians. And yet, the Palestinian population keeps growing. For supposedly aspiring genocidaires, this would be quite pathetic.

In that case allow me to ask you a question: what do you believe is their end goal, given their past and current actions ?

Security for Israel. Given their past goals and current actions, and the fact that they're a democracy with elections, I think they actually have a hard time following any consistent grand strategy in pursuit of this goal, but that's the only consistent goal I see.

Educate me.

Why are you even participating in this discussion if you don't already know? It's not exactly ancient history. Do you honestly not know?

Advocating ? Did you even read what I posted ?

Yes. You advocated that Israel respond to Palestinian attacks as if they were the actions of an enemy nation waging war against Israel. The appropriate response in such an event would be far more devastating to the Palestinians than the actual response that Israel delivered.

I said that I find that both sides in this issue are both right and wrong. I didn't specify to what extent each of them is, although I did propose a solution that may or may not (probably not) work.

If you think your own proposal probably won't work (and Israelis almost certainly think it won't), then how can you expect them to actually try? The attempt is not risk-free for Israel, you know.

You cannot expect this of them. And you cannot reasonably criticize them for not attempting it.
 
But they're still Israeli.

Yes, which is why I'm agreeing with you that the maps (EDIT: or at least the second two) are misleading in that regard (or, rather, that they're technically correct, but don't give a complete picture of what they're purporting to describe).
 
Last edited:
"Prior to the 1948 Israeli Declaration of Independence, when the Negev became part of Israel, an estimated 65,000–90,000 Bedouins lived in the Negev. According to Encyclopedia Judaica, 15,000 Bedouin remained in the Negev after 1948; other sources put the number as low as 11,000."

Keep going.

"In 1999, 110,000 Bedouins lived in the Negev, 50,000 in the Galilee and 10,000 in the central region of Israel."

Of course, none of that has much to do with land ownership. Nor does your map include the land stolen from Jews who were expelled from surrounding Arab countries.
 
Yes, the land that was continuously owned by Bedouins from before 1948 to 1954 would have had its color changed, even though ownership didn't.

All present absentees were also granted citizenship. Yet it doesn't seem clear what to do with the colour of their land either, given the laws applying to them. In a strictly legal sense they own that land but there's a military occupation force that prevents them from going there. Even so, I doubt there is a lot of Bedouin land in the first place.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom