Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Basically as a US Citizen who doesn't really pay much attention to this, I keep getting bombarded with the notion that I should be on Israel's side.

Why's that? Why should I care about them MORE than Palestine?
 
Basically as a US Citizen who doesn't really pay much attention to this, I keep getting bombarded with the notion that I should be on Israel's side.

Why's that? Why should I care about them MORE than Palestine?

Because the Elders of Zion command it. Now get with the program.
 
Basically as a US Citizen who doesn't really pay much attention to this, I keep getting bombarded with the notion that I should be on Israel's side.

Why's that? Why should I care about them MORE than Palestine?

Because the Israelis like us and share our basic values, and the Palestinians hate us and oppose our basic values.

It's actually pretty simple.
 
But but but ... Isn't Netanyahu the problem we should be focusing on?!

False dichotomy.

Really, everyone should be WELL aware that there is more than one problem in this situation.
 
Interesting article on tactics used by pre-Israel Zionist militants:

Seventy years ago it was the Zionist militias who dug underground tunnels and hid weapon caches among the civilian population. So why is it so difficult for Israelis to understand when Hamas does the same today?

It's a legitimate question.
 
It's a stupid question. We all understand why they do it. Nobody is honestly in doubt about that.

Cmon, you know what the author means. He's asking why Israelis consider tactics used by Hamas to be illegitimate, while considering similar tactics used be the founding generation to have been heroic. I'm the type of guy he's directing that question at, and I've been thinking about how I would answer.
 
Cmon, you know what the author means. He's asking why Israelis consider tactics used by Hamas to be illegitimate, while considering similar tactics used be the founding generation to have been heroic. I'm the type of guy he's directing that question at, and I've been thinking about how I would answer.

Do they actually consider such heroic? Reading the article, it's actually not entirely clear whether the evidence stated is actually considered heroic or has more to do with trying not to erase the past, both good and bad. Going beyond that, it looks like there's some rather questionable equivalence in the article. Yes, groups that feel oppressed certainly tend to resort to questionable tactics, and some of what the Palestinians do is certainly justifiable and excusable in the light of the oppression they suffer, such as it is. Still, it's worth asking two questions for starters, to give some perspective.

First of all, did the Zionists ever cross the lines as flagrantly and stupidly as Hamas has been crossing them? For example, did the Zionists ever execute their own grieving people simply for the suggestion that more peaceful alternatives should have been sought? Yes, the Zionists of the time did a number of nasty things and the Arabs did a number of nasty things, too. That doesn't automatically make them reasonable to consider to be equivalent or excuse either side for what was done, but, just like anyone claiming that assault and murder are equivalent, it's a good idea to take a step back and actually consider what's being said.

Second of all, governments like Israel's are *supposed* to act in the best interest of their own people, first and foremost, are they not? When a group of people openly declares themselves to be enemies of Israel and both loudly proclaims that they desire to murder all the Jews and repeatedly takes action with that intent in mind, it really doesn't matter how legitimate they might consider the actions or whether they committed somewhat similar actions in the past. Their concern is their people, now and in the future.
 
Last edited:
you describing something as something would have little effect on my opinions of anything...


Mybe you could clarify what you are talking about?


If you are asking if I am comfortable with a nation describing itself as the home of a subset of its citizens then I do have issues......but it appears you don't?

We've been over this countless times before, so I guess one time more won't hurt.

What a nation calls itself is a lot less important than what it does. In fact often what a nation calls itself is the opposite of what it does. Think of all the nations that have "democratic", "people's" or "republic" in their name. The name itself doesn't mean anything.

Before claiming "home of ...." is somehow detrimental to whoever is not named, it's contingent on you to show how it's detrimental, and not just imply that it is.
 
It seems to me the I/P quietness started before ISIS stormed on the scene.

Yes, I think it's more that the conspiritards willing to dump their propaganda on a skeptic's board have shrunk to a number where it's no longer sustainable.
 
Interesting article on tactics used by pre-Israel Zionist militants:



It's a legitimate question.

The way I would answer it is to point out that if someone had bombed those tunnels and weapons caches, nobody would have the right to complain about civilian casualties as a result.

Weapons cache in a synagogue? Why it's there is no mystery. If the British or Arabs had bombed it when hostilities had broken out, the responsibility for any dead civilians would have been on the people who made it a target by hiding weapons there.
 
The way I would answer it is to point out that if someone had bombed those tunnels and weapons caches, nobody would have the right to complain about civilian casualties as a result.

Weapons cache in a synagogue? Why it's there is no mystery. If the British or Arabs had bombed it when hostilities had broken out, the responsibility for any dead civilians would have been on the people who made it a target by hiding weapons there.

Actually, I've been thinking it over for a few days now, and my best response centers around this point as well. I would have added that the proto-Israeli's weren't using children to dig the tunnels, and weren't using children and other civilians as shields to protect their weapons and ammo.
 
Cmon, you know what the author means. He's asking why Israelis consider tactics used by Hamas to be illegitimate, while considering similar tactics used be the founding generation to have been heroic.

Because goals matter, not just actions, i.e. people boo the invasion of France in 1940 but cheer the invasion of 1944. Or, more middle easty; because the founding generation of Israelis wanted to set up a modern democracy and Hamas want to set up a medieval theocracy?
 
Because goals matter, not just actions, i.e. people boo the invasion of France in 1940 but cheer the invasion of 1944. Or, more middle easty; because the founding generation of Israelis wanted to set up a modern democracy and Hamas want to set up a medieval theocracy?

Of course, I'm the type of guy who's sympathetic to this pov, but i'm sure you're intelligent enough to see that's pretty much the entire point of the article.
 
Of course, I'm the type of guy who's sympathetic to this pov, but i'm sure you're intelligent enough to see that's pretty much the entire point of the article.

To me, it looked like the article ignored my pov by treating the two sides as morally equivalent. (But I'm currently sleep deprived so I may have missed it)
 
Actually, I've been thinking it over for a few days now, and my best response centers around this point as well. I would have added that the proto-Israeli's weren't using children to dig the tunnels, and weren't using children and other civilians as shields to protect their weapons and ammo.

If they were hiding weapons caches in synagogues, that actually is using civilians as shields, in similar manner to one of the ways the Palestinians do. Or, in other words, that turns a civilian target into a military target. As Mycroft said, the blame falls on the group that put them there. It is likely true, however, that they weren't using kids to dig tunnels, though, among numerous other things.
 
If they were hiding weapons caches in synagogues, that actually is using civilians as shields, in similar manner to one of the ways the Palestinians do. Or, in other words, that turns a civilian target into a military target. As Mycroft said, the blame falls on the group that put them there. It is likely true, however, that they weren't using kids to dig tunnels, though, among numerous other things.

No. Not the way I am using the term. It does turn civilians into potential targets, but not as a tactical opprutunity. From what I understand, the decision to dig a network of tunnels connecting civilan areas and store munitions in those areas by the early Zionist militants was to hide them. Hamas, in addition to hiding material, also uses civilians to shield stockpiles, so that if the IDF locates these stores, they will have to pay a heavy price in image on the international stage, by slaughtering defenseless, unarmed civilians, particularly children. In fact, part of the reason Hamas uses child labor to help construct their tunnel network is to have useful images of mangled children being pulled out of rubble if the IDF locates and destroys a series of tunnel work. (Obviously, kids are also used because of their ability to work in tight spaces.)

A convincing argument can be made that Hamas's primary tactical objective in deploying weapons isn't direct damage to the enemy; it's in provoking retribution, yielding horrifying images and reports in order to cause domestic and international outrage, which can then be used to pressure Israel from within and without... which is probably the most logical (but clearly not the most ethical) strategic approach given the massive military disparity involved. Not to mention the recent proliferation of powerful social media and cheap communication devices now available.

That's what I mean by using civilians as human shields, not just to hide assets... but to protect them by presenting a no-win situation to the enemy.
 
To me, it looked like the article ignored my pov by treating the two sides as morally equivalent. (But I'm currently sleep deprived so I may have missed it)

I believe the writer is attempting to examine considerations of which tactics are and are not morally acceptable (in and of themselves) by looking at them isolated from the objectives of those who wield them.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom