Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Do they actually consider such heroic? Reading the article, it's actually not entirely clear whether the evidence stated is actually considered heroic or has more to do with trying not to erase the past, both good and bad...

Just to let you know I'm not ignoring this interesting post, just getting my thoughts together and re-reading some stuff.
 
Cmon, you know what the author means. He's asking why Israelis consider tactics used by Hamas to be illegitimate, while considering similar tactics used be the founding generation to have been heroic. I'm the type of guy he's directing that question at, and I've been thinking about how I would answer.

If that's what he meant, that's what he should have said. But OK, I'll go with that. It's still not a very good question, because it makes some assumptions. The biggest is that these superficially similar actions are really the same. But they're not.

1) Hamas doesn't simply hide munitions among civilians because they don't want those munitions to be found. They hide them among civilians because they want civilian casualties, among their own population.

2) Even if we choose to excuse it on the grounds that they're going to fight however they can manage, the more relevant point is that Israel is entitled to strike at these munitions caches, even if there is civilian collateral.

3) Regardless of the sins of the past, this is where we are now. And right now, Israel is protecting its civilians and Hamas is feeding its civilians into a metaphorical wood chipper.

4) And lastly, a point which usually gets overlooked but shouldn't: what the two sides fought for is radically different. If Hamas got what it wanted, even if it was magically granted its wishes through non-violent means, the product would be bad. The society they hope to create is an evil one. Israeli society, by contrast, is not. The results of Israel's foundation have been the only democratic, stable, productive society in the middle east.
 
The main gulf between Israel and Europe/USA when it comes to negotiations, AFAIU, is that a large chunk the Israeli electorate remembers a time (25 years TBP) when it had to fight tooth and nail to survive, and fought 3 existential wars within that space of time, compounded by everyone under 40 in the latter literally can't remember a time when such a threat was right on their doorstep (and also explains why countries such as Poland and South Korea are hawkish compared to Sweden or France). That's the basis of the rift between Israel and Europe/USA.
 
Because the Israelis like us and share our basic values

1. They are occupying someone else's country, putting those people in refugee camps and settling their lands. Basically the story of the US and the Native Americans, so that checks out.

2. They have institutional racial segregation, like the US before the civil rights movement. So that checks out too.

3. They ignore international law at will, so this checks out as well.

While I'll then go along with your statement, how is it supposed to convince anyone else? Say like outside your military alliance? Going "we did it to the Native and African Americans too, they're so like us" is not going to convince any of the following states who recognize Palestine.
400px-Palestine_recognition_only.svg.png
 
An example of the real difficulty in getting a workable peace (aka both sides must want peace), the "moderate" Palestinian party

Would that particular point (publishing despicable images) still be an issue after Netanyahu's appearance in the "Je suis Charlie" photo-op?
 
Would that particular point (publishing despicable images) still be an issue after Netanyahu's appearance in the "Je suis Charlie" photo-op?

Why wouldn't it be? Bibi's jackassery means nothing either way to thezionistentity's motley crew of blood enemies, outside of a few cheap propaganda points. Fatah's willingness to publish Nazi/like imagery until the kitchen got too hot is more than fair game, regardless of the PM's photo opportunities.
 
Why wouldn't it be? Bibi's jackassery means nothing either way to thezionistentity's motley crew of blood enemies, outside of a few cheap propaganda points. Fatah's willingness to publish Nazi/like imagery until the kitchen got too hot is more than fair game, regardless of the PM's photo opportunities.

Fair game for what exactly?
 
1. They are occupying someone else's country, putting those people in refugee camps and settling their lands. Basically the story of the US and the Native Americans, so that checks out.

Not entirely accurate. Or a particularly good comparison. The nearby Arabs have made war (or were just about to make war, going by their troop and equipment movements combined with their rhetoric) repeatedly and lost repeatedly and had to make concessions related to that. "Palestinian" is better described as an attempt to rename the Arabs that happened to live in those areas to manufacture legitimacy for getting those lands away from the Israelis by any means possible. There would, with little doubt, be no distinct Palestine if the Arabs had won any of those wars. The Israelis have been open to returning occupied lands, when they have reasonable basis to believe that it will achieve peace, and have done so repeatedly, for that matter. I don't recall the US doing anything similar with the Native Americans or even being willing to do so, regardless. More could be said, but, frankly, there's little need. Your characterization of the situation is quite poor, to be kind.

2. They have institutional racial segregation, like the US before the civil rights movement. So that checks out too.

Unfortunately, yes, they do have racial issues. There are at least three points that need to be taken into account here, though. First, and most important, Israel is officially working to try to reduce and remove the racism within Israel and has taken a number of steps to try to do so, including non-discrimination laws. It is certainly true that they're not good on that front, but they have been making efforts. For the second, it's really not tu quoque to point out that the Palestinians have not made similar or comparable attempts and, in fact, fairly openly make existential threats to Israel and the Jews, in addition to putting their animosity into practice. Third, it's worth noting that, in cases like the checkpoints that had been set up, that was fairly certainly temporary backlash against a group of people that kept producing terrorists and advocating terrorism. Much of the rest that I've heard of has also been backlash against terrorists being brought in. It's a bad situation, yes. The comparison with the US before the civil rights movements is again remarkably poor, though.

3. They ignore international law at will, so this checks out as well.

Yes and no, much as if you're going to try that line of argument, it would be much more credible and effective if the Palestinians weren't flagrantly ignoring international law at will, as well. That's before touching the long list of other countries that that complaint also applies to.

While I'll then go along with your statement, how is it supposed to convince anyone else? Say like outside your military alliance? Going "we did it to the Native and African Americans too, they're so like us" is not going to convince any of the following states who recognize Palestine.

So, you'll go along with his statement only if you try to twist it in horrible and remarkably inaccurate ways? Good for you. Ziggurat's point stands perfectly well, when taken as he's made clear that he intended it. Your way, though, fails on even a basic actual evaluation. Seriously, there's lots of low hanging fruit when it comes to Israeli-Arab relations. Resorting to stunts like what you just tried, though, is relying on your audience to be stupid, ignorant, or too biased to care. While much of your audience could, in fact, potentially qualify, that doesn't make your arguments at all better.
 
Last edited:
1. They are occupying someone else's country

No they aren't. The West Bank previously belonged to Jordan, Gaza previously belonged to Egypt, but neither of those countries want that land back. Israel proper used to belong to the Ottoman Empire, which no longer even exists. And there is no country of Palestine. You can pretend all you want to, but it's still just make believe.

putting those people in refugee camps

Clue for the clueless: they aren't camps. They're just called camps for propaganda purposes. Seriously, they still call actual cities and towns, composed exclusively of permanent buildings and structures, "camps". It's a complete farce.

and settling their lands.

So... one group builds houses. The other group blows up buses.

And it's the group building houses that you've got a problem with.

Basically the story of the US and the Native Americans, so that checks out.

Yeah, no. Not even close.

2. They have institutional racial segregation, like the US before the civil rights movement. So that checks out too.

No, they don't. They really, really don't.

3. They ignore international law at will, so this checks out as well.

What exactly do you think "international law" is, and why do you grant it any moral authority?

While I'll then go along with your statement, how is it supposed to convince anyone else? Say like outside your military alliance?

The fact that I can't convince antisemites to not be antisemitic is not an argument in favor of being antisemitic.

Going "we did it to the Native and African Americans too, they're so like us" is not going to convince any of the following states who recognize Palestine.
[qimg]https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/0/08/Palestine_recognition_only.svg/400px-Palestine_recognition_only.svg.png[/qimg]

Oh, hey, look! You've got every single dictatorship on the side of the Palestinians! Quite the achievement there. You say I'm not convincing anyone else, but do you really think you're convincing me?
 
So... one group builds houses. The other group blows up buses.

And it's the group building houses that you've got a problem with.

First of all, are the two mutually exclusive ? Can't we have a problem with both ?

And speaking of propaganda, do you really think that calling it "building houses" is going to fool anyone ? Pretty much the world agrees that what they are doing is illegal, but you don't see a problem with it ?
 
First of all, are the two mutually exclusive ? Can't we have a problem with both ?

You can have a problem with both, but you had better be able to prioritize.

And speaking of propaganda, do you really think that calling it "building houses" is going to fool anyone ? Pretty much the world agrees that what they are doing is illegal, but you don't see a problem with it ?

Argument ad populum holds no sway with me, international law has no particular moral legitimacy, and frankly, I see it as a much better way for Israel to put pressure on the Palestinians to come to the bargaining table than many of the alternatives.
 
You can have a problem with both, but you had better be able to prioritize.

Why ?

Argument ad populum holds no sway with me

It wasn't one.

international law has no particular moral legitimacy

Might makes right, then ?

I see it as a much better way for Israel to put pressure on the Palestinians to come to the bargaining table than many of the alternatives.

I think neither side really wants to negociate.
 

Seriously, Belz? You can't figure out on your own why one should be able to distinguish something very bad from something that's a little bad, and consider the very bad thing to be more important to address?

It wasn't one.

Yes, Belz, it was.

Might makes right, then ?

Irrelevant straw man. Try again.

I think neither side really wants to negociate.

What is there to negotiate? The Palestinians want to destroy Israel. This is not a goal that negotiations can dissuade them from. Should Israel haggle over the timeline for their own destruction?

It seems that you've taken the rather common position of moral equivalency between the two sides (nothing in these recent posts indicates otherwise). If so, then just like caveman1917, and countless others in this thread, you haven't come to terms with the reality that Israel's Gaza withdrawl has proven: Israel is willing to give land to the Palestinians, and it is willing to dismantle settlements. But why should it, when such moves will not be met with any improvement in relations, but only used as an opportunity to escalate hostilities?
 
No they aren't. The West Bank previously belonged to Jordan, Gaza previously belonged to Egypt, but neither of those countries want that land back. Israel proper used to belong to the Ottoman Empire, which no longer even exists. And there is no country of Palestine. You can pretend all you want to, but it's still just make believe.

For reference:
palestine-map.bmp


Clue for the clueless: they aren't camps. They're just called camps for propaganda purposes. Seriously, they still call actual cities and towns, composed exclusively of permanent buildings and structures, "camps". It's a complete farce.

Ridiculous. The tents over time got replaced with prefabs provided by the UN and later concrete shelters. It's not like they haven't been living in refugee camps for decades after all.

Yeah, no. Not even close.

Quite accurate in fact.

No, they don't. They really, really don't.

And then there is also a thing called reality.

The fact that I can't convince antisemites to not be antisemitic is not an argument in favor of being antisemitic.

:dl:

Do you seriously think that's going to work?

Oh, hey, look! You've got every single dictatorship on the side of the Palestinians! Quite the achievement there. You say I'm not convincing anyone else, but do you really think you're convincing me?

Why would I want to convince you?
 
The comparison with the US before the civil rights movements is again remarkably poor, though.

I'm talking about things like segregated public transportation. Wasn't that one of the things in the US as well?

Yes and no, much as if you're going to try that line of argument, it would be much more credible and effective if the Palestinians weren't flagrantly ignoring international law at will, as well. That's before touching the long list of other countries that that complaint also applies to.

Could you provide some of those other countries that are also, by a wide margin, the country which ignores UN resolutions the most?

So, you'll go along with his statement only if you try to twist it in horrible and remarkably inaccurate ways?

It's far from being as inaccurate as you make it.
 
For reference:

Your reference is a fraud. The definitions for what counts as "Palestinian" versus "Jewish" land changes from panel to panel. Hell, it's not even consistent within each panel.

The first panel, for example, shows "Jewish land" as land privately owned by Jews. Land owned by the British government (which should properly not be considered as Jewish or Palestinian) is classified as Palestinian.

The second panel is likewise a fraud. Those partitions never actually existed. They were only proposed. Who rejected them? The Palestinians. Why should I feel bad that they ended up with less because they decided to go to war to try to keep the Jews from getting anything?

The third panel is, again, a fraud (see the pattern yet?). The green areas are not "Palestinian". They are Egyptian and Jordanian. Why do Egypt and Jordan no longer own that land? Why do they no longer even want that land?

The ONLY land that was EVER "Palestinian" is the green land in the very last panel. There is now more "Palestinian" land than there has ever been before.
 
I'm talking about things like segregated public transportation. Wasn't that one of the things in the US as well?

Please, tell me all about how inclusive and tolerant Palestinians are. I'm all ears.

You're a hypocrite, caveman1917. You don't care about Israel's behavior in any objective sense, or you'd be far more concerned with how every other state in the region acts even worse. You only care about whatever you can say that will make Israel look bad, even if (as with your map) it's a lie.
 
I'm talking about things like segregated public transportation. Wasn't that one of the things in the US as well?



Could you provide some of those other countries that are also, by a wide margin, the country which ignores UN resolutions the most?



It's far from being as inaccurate as you make it.

Remember the "Zionism as Racism" resolution that set the peace process back by decades? It was from the UN, and oh boy did it shred Israeli faith in the institution, like how Prohibition gutted American faith in the law.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom