Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
You know what I find the most hilarious about Israel/Palestine?

The main critics of Israel are all pampered middle class university students who have the privilege of not having to fear extinction. The privilege to not have been descended from Holocaust survivors and being kicked out of their home continent and then finally set foot on what was possibly the last sanctuary for jews. The privilege to not have to fight three wars for survival within a generation, while their opponents espoused Nazi ideology. The Privilege to not have to face constant warfare, and be branded as the demon in western media by sheltered ideologues who (to quote Raiden) never had to fight and steal and kill just to survive. Now, times have changed, and Israel is no longer at immediate risk of extinction, but the threat still lingers in Israeli national memory.
 
Yeah, the production of dead Palestinian children is one of the main sources of funding for the Hamas leadership.

I don't think Hamas's sole purpose is to kill kids for money while repressing the rest of the Palestinians in the areas the control, but it certainly is a large portion of it.

I think that is why I don't find that a large portion of the Palestinian supporters actually care at all about the Palestinians themselves. If they did, the very first thing they would do is address this terrible tactic from Hamas. Instead I find that they just want to demonize Israel to make themselves feel better.

Hamas spend very much on military systems for defense. They dig tunnels, not ditches. They try to build a missile tracking station. They don't build
walls or fences to keep Israeli soldiers out. They do place missile lunching systems in the middle of their cities.

Hamas does not have an exit strategy that ends in peace and prosperity. One would think that they weren't really afraid of Israeli aggression. They just keep shelling. Their entire charter is devoted to the annihilation of Jews. They have a rather brutal idea of what they are going to do after they win.

Many protesters in this country are claiming that the Arabs just want their land back. However, that is not even what they say. Hamas very openly pursues another agenda. I would love to see protesters in this country present the rest of us with the Hamas exit strategy.

All money that Israel, or any other country gives, goes straight to Hamas. They themselves have sealed off their cities to supplies. They insist on a tax on commodities to go to Hamas.

They don't seem to spend much on entertainment or education. They carefully control the TV and radio. It must get very boring in Gaza. No development, no museums, not much in the way of TV or movies. Nothing to educate them on other cultures. Oh yes, they can make babies.

They have been offered money and supplies to develop their economy. They plow every last dollar into the resistance. There is nothing material that could appease them. They don't want 'human rights', they want 'justice'. One can use money and resources to give everyone 'human rights'. The only 'justice' they could live with is killing.

Hamas has no plans contingent on their success. Suppose Hamas drives every Jew out, ashkenazic and sephardic. Suppose they drive every European out. They will be almost as poor as they are now.

Many readers will claim that I am wrong. If you think that I am wrong, then you have a hypothesis of what happens after Hamas 'wins'.

Maybe everybody would be better off if Israel surrenders to Hamas. However, it seems many Israelis and Israel sympathizers are afraid of what happens afterward. So lets find out what the exit strategy of Hamas is is the Hamas exit. Tell us what most Palestinians, including Hamas, considers the conditions on Israel for surrender.

Inquiring Minds Want to Know !-)
 
As I said before, if Israel really wanted to, Gaza would be nothing but a pyramid of skulls while there road to Jerusalem would be adorned with impaled Palestinians.
 
As I said before, if Israel really wanted to, Gaza would be nothing but a pyramid of skulls while there road to Jerusalem would be adorned with impaled Palestinians.

Very true. Israel has the ability to destroy the Palestinians but not the desire, while the Palestinians have the desire to destroy Israel but not the ability.
 
Hi folks, new in this thread, haven't read anything... just throwing in a bit of trivia:

I have an incognito Facebook account which I use to browse, befriend, debate, disrupt conspiracy theorists. One "friend", who is into pretty much every CT there is (particularly chemtrails, 9/11...) also is very much siding with everything Palestinian and reflexively suspects Israeli involvement in every evil on earth. Some days ago, he posted a video that revealed him as a holocaust denier too. One of his friends chimed in, commenting that there is now a "holocaust" going on against the Palestinians. Now while it can't be disputed that Palestinians die at the hands of Israelis, there is obviously an ocean of difference in order of magnitude between the two, and I suspected that this alleged "holocaust" doesn't show in any significant way on Palestian population statistics.

Found some interesting stats:
Wiki: Demographics of the Palestinian territories

  • The Palestinian territories suffer some 14,000 deaths per year, so military conflicts like those in 2014 (ca. 2,200 killed) and 2008/09 (1,200-1,400 killed) do cause a significant proportion of deaths in a year.
  • BUT still the mortality rate, at about 4 deaths / 1000 people (person-years, to be more precise) is lower than that of Israel (a bit over 5) and only half that of the USA (ca. 8)! Sounds surprising, but is explained by the much younger mean and median age of the population - fewer people die of old age in Palestine because fewer are old.
  • Life expectancy is around 75 years according to the CIA World Factbook - about median in the world. Slightly more than Turkey, Brazil, Jordan; about the same as Hungary, China, Mexico; slightly less than Croatia, Morocco, Ecuador.

Obviously, living conditions leave a lot to be desired, and wars with Israel take a real toll; but the situation isn't out-and-out murderous. "Holocaust" comparisons... yikes!

Said FB-"friend" blocked me after I provided those stats. Apparently, facts are not welcome in anti-semitic circles. ;)

It is almost universally the case that whenever a conspiracy theory involves a group of people referred to as "them", said group precisely equals "the Jews".

It is a feature of conspiracy theories many do not realize the extent of.
 
By "one state solution" are you referring to annexations?

I could not support annexation because it would impose enforced citizenship of a non democratic state. I would not be a supporter of black people being made citizens of a state that defines inself as the home of white people either.

So if I described your country as "Home of the Aborigines", you would stop wanting to live there?
 
A little propaganda video from Banksy

It never ceases to amaze me how those who highlight the suffering of the Palestinian people in Gaza just refuse to consider that maybe the solution is for Hamas to make peace with Israel.

It has been a long time since I weighed-in here.
Today, it seemed worthwhile to add a few comments to the thread.

That posted video above simply distorts the true picture of Gaza.

I thought it would be useful to take the video, frame by frame, and critique the artist known as Banksy.

0:34 -- Inserted scene of IDF troops (apparently filmed in Bethlehem, on the West Bank, not Gaza border) --- In reality, no Israeli troops are in Gaza.

"They are not allowed to (leave)" -- Untrue. Gazans can leave, and they do.
Some exit through Israel, some through Egypt.

0:42 "surrounded by a wall..." --- Not really. The characterization of being 'walled-in' is more powerful imagery, but the Gaza Strip is surrounded by standard border fencing, mostly. And part of that border is with Egypt, not Israel.


0:48 "no cement has been allowed into Gaza since the bombing (summer 2014)" -- This statement is just an outright falsehood.
While Israel is rightfully concerned about the diversion of cement material into the hands of HAMAS for reinforcing and rebuilding their tunnels, the fact is that thousands of tons of cement has been transferred into Gaza by Israel.
http://www.jpost.com/Middle-East/De...w-limited-building-materials-into-Gaza-339435
And the Jihadists are continuing to build tunnels.
http://www.news24.com/World/News/After-Gaza-war-losses-Islamic-Jihad-bounces-back-20150306-4

1:38 - the pink bow kitty "Our children have nothing to play with" ----
Nonsense.
The markets of Gaza are filled with consumer goods, including soccer balls, toys, sports-shoes and electronics (video games).
Kids in Gaza also go to school regularly and they play with their friends out in the streets, with the same energy and enthusiasm as kids in other underdeveloped places (Pakistan, Philippines, Peru, Mexico, etc.)


Ends with the quote (as if to justify why the artist known as Banksy produced this lopsided and obfuscating video) -- "If we wash our hands in conflict between the powerful and the powerless, we side with the powerful. It's not neutral... It's complicit"

The scenes of destruction in Gaza were the RESULT of the powerful HAMAS which controls the enclave, bringing war unto the people there.

https://robertldeak.wordpress.com/2...zas-residents-want-to-leave-because-of-hamas/
 
Last edited:
It's worth pointing out a couple things in response, then.

"They are not allowed to (leave)" -- Untrue. Gazans can leave, and they do.
Some exit through Israel, some through Egypt.

Many of them are effectively prevented from leaving, at last check. Hardly surprising or unreasonable, though, especially when far too many of them seem to want to get into Israel for more nefarious reasons. Few countries would respond with less than what Israel's responded with when it comes to how they've dealt with a people that keeps sending government-encouraged terrorists to attack them.

0:42 "surrounded by a wall..." --- Not really. The characterization of being 'walled-in' is more powerful imagery, but the Gaza Strip is surrounded by standard border fencing, mostly. And part of that border is with Egypt, not Israel.

They are effectively walled in, though. Again, with reason, but that doesn't change that it's the case. One of the actually reasonable complaints that I've heard about the wall, for the record, is that the wall was built right on the border and the Israeli will and have opened fire on those who approach too closely, despite that land supposedly being Palestinian property, by Israeli policy. That it tends to be rubber bullets does make that better, but it would still be quite out of line, if the claim is true.
 
So if I described your country as "Home of the Aborigines", you would stop wanting to live there?

you describing something as something would have little effect on my opinions of anything...


Mybe you could clarify what you are talking about?


If you are asking if I am comfortable with a nation describing itself as the home of a subset of its citizens then I do have issues......but it appears you don't?
 
It has been a long time since I weighed-in here.
Today, it seemed worthwhile to add a few comments to the thread.

That posted video above simply distorts the true picture of Gaza.

I thought it would be useful to take the video, frame by frame, and critique the artist known as Banksy.

0:34 -- Inserted scene of IDF troops (apparently filmed in Bethlehem, on the West Bank, not Gaza border) --- In reality, no Israeli troops are in Gaza.

"They are not allowed to (leave)" -- Untrue. Gazans can leave, and they do.
Some exit through Israel, some through Egypt.

0:42 "surrounded by a wall..." --- Not really. The characterization of being 'walled-in' is more powerful imagery, but the Gaza Strip is surrounded by standard border fencing, mostly. And part of that border is with Egypt, not Israel.


0:48 "no cement has been allowed into Gaza since the bombing (summer 2014)" -- This statement is just an outright falsehood.
While Israel is rightfully concerned about the diversion of cement material into the hands of HAMAS for reinforcing and rebuilding their tunnels, the fact is that thousands of tons of cement has been transferred into Gaza by Israel.
http://www.jpost.com/Middle-East/De...w-limited-building-materials-into-Gaza-339435
And the Jihadists are continuing to build tunnels.
http://www.news24.com/World/News/After-Gaza-war-losses-Islamic-Jihad-bounces-back-20150306-4

1:38 - the pink bow kitty "Our children have nothing to play with" ----
Nonsense.
The markets of Gaza are filled with consumer goods, including soccer balls, toys, sports-shoes and electronics (video games).
Kids in Gaza also go to school regularly and they play with their friends out in the streets, with the same energy and enthusiasm as kids in other underdeveloped places (Pakistan, Philippines, Peru, Mexico, etc.)


Ends with the quote (as if to justify why the artist known as Banksy produced this lopsided and obfuscating video) -- "If we wash our hands in conflict between the powerful and the powerless, we side with the powerful. It's not neutral... It's complicit"

The scenes of destruction in Gaza were the RESULT of the powerful HAMAS which controls the enclave, bringing war unto the people there.

https://robertldeak.wordpress.com/2...zas-residents-want-to-leave-because-of-hamas/

Hi Web.....great to see you back..

all the ISIS stuff has seen Palestinian issues somewhat pushed into the background, this thread is fairly quiet nowdays.
 
If you are asking if I am comfortable with a nation describing itself as the home of a subset of its citizens then I do have issues......but it appears you don't?

Israel is a special situation in that she was founded specifically by a homeland movement.

Personally, I have no problem with a future Palestine describing itself as an ethnic Palestinian homeland, a future Kurdistan describing itself as a Kurdish homeland, and so forth.
 
Hi Web.....great to see you back..

all the ISIS stuff has seen Palestinian issues somewhat pushed into the background, this thread is fairly quiet nowdays.

It seems to me the I/P quietness started before ISIS stormed on the scene.
 
Israel is a special situation in that she was founded specifically by a homeland movement.

Personally, I have no problem with a future Palestine describing itself as an ethnic Palestinian homeland, a future Kurdistan describing itself as a Kurdish homeland, and so forth.

One of the qualifiers I have for a modern democracy is that the nation is the "home" of its citizens, all of them.
 
U.S. vows to push for two-state solution to Israeli-Palestinian conflict

"As difficult as it is, the United States will never stop working for a two-state solution and the lasting peace that Israelis and Palestinians so richly deserve," McDonough declared in his address to J Street, a nonprofit liberal group advocating for a U.S.-led end to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.

"We continue to believe that the best way to safeguard Israel's long-term security is to bring about a comprehensive peace between Israelis and Palestinians -- two states for two peoples, living side-by-side in security and peace," he said.

"Like every administration since President Johnson, we will continue to oppose Israeli settlement activity since it undermines the prospects for peace," he said.
 
Has McDonough got the Palestinians on board for this? I doubt it, since one of the major parties calls for the destruction of Israel and the genocide of the Jews while the other calls for the destruction of Israel but would allow Jews to remain as dhimmi. Maybe.

The peaceful coexistence Palestinian parties combine for about 1% of the vote, or they might if they actually held an election once in a while and the members weren't accused of being Jew-lovers and killed.
 
Has McDonough got the Palestinians on board for this? I doubt it, since one of the major parties calls for the destruction of Israel and the genocide of the Jews while the other calls for the destruction of Israel but would allow Jews to remain as dhimmi. Maybe.

The peaceful coexistence Palestinian parties combine for about 1% of the vote, or they might if they actually held an election once in a while and the members weren't accused of being Jew-lovers and killed.

But but but ... Isn't Netanyahu the problem we should be focusing on?!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom